
Volume 08 - Number 3 - December 2001
Pages: 105 - 164
SPECIAL ISSUE
Jazwinski, C. H. (2001). Feminist psychobiography of eminent women in a psychology of women course. Clio’s Psyche, 8(3), 148-150.
Feminist Psychobiography of Eminent Women in a Psychology of Women Course
Abstract
In this article, the author, who has taught a university Psychology of Women course for over fifteen years, describes an assignment in which students complete a feminist psychobiographical analysis of an eminent woman from any historical period. The author reports that women of achievement remain insufficiently visible and that their accomplishments are sometimes attributed to others, as with Marie Curie’s two Nobel prizes. The author cites Gerda Lerner on the consequences for women of not knowing their intellectual predecessors. The author lists the properties that distinguish feminist psychobiography from traditional biography: a focus on women valued in their own right, attention to historical and cultural context, interest in women who departed from stereotypes, and a preference for gender-neutral theories. Referring to Sophie Germain, Florence Nightingale, and Emily Dickinson, the author maintains that education, economic security, and free time are central conditions of women’s achievement. Students follow a prescribed outline and use Maslow’s theory of self-actualization as the common framework, which the author prefers because it avoids a focus on pathology. The author names as difficulties the scarcity of information about eminent women, the limited volume of high-quality scholarship, and bias in existing work, including excessive attention to sexuality. The author concludes that the assignment develops students’ critical stance toward institutionalized knowledge and a sense of pride and identification with the women studied.
Abraham Maslow, cultural differences, feminism, gender inequality, gender roles, gender stereotypes, Maslow’s Hierarchy of Needs, mental health, psychobiography, psychology of women
I have taught a university course entitled Psychology of Women for over 15 years. Mostly women enroll in the course and the focus is primarily on women (as contrasted with a gender differences course). Students complete a feminist psychobiographical analysis of an eminent woman from any historical period. Psychology of women typically includes such topics as: the social construction of gender, gender roles, stereotypes and myths, biology, development, cognitive abilities, achievement and careers, personality, mental health, communication, and friendships. Students practice critical thinking by learning about several biases (for example, male-as-normative, overuse of biological explanations for women relative to men) and evaluating mass media presentations of women. The psychobiography assignment provides students with vivid detail about an individual person with an appreciation of constants and changes in women’s lives throughout history. The lives of remarkable women, from various cultures and times, are often inspiring as examples of achievement under adversity.
Unfortunately, women who are important participants in the culture are still not sufficiently visible. Eminent female artists, writers, scientists, rulers, politicians, or social activists are relatively unknown. Sometimes eminent women’s successful performance is attributed to others’ efforts. For instance, Marie Curie Sklodowska’s two Nobel prizes, one in physics (1903, joint award with Pierre Curie) and one in chemistry (1911, awarded to
Page 148
Marie Curie only), are sometimes both attributed to her husband Pierre.
Being unaware of exceptional female role models can lead one to believe that few such women existed. As Gerda Lerner has eloquently put it: “Women who did not know that others like them had made intellectual contributions to knowledge and to creative thought were overwhelmed by the sense of their own inferiority or, conversely, the sense of the dangers of their daring to be different.” (The Creation of Feminist Consciousness: From the Middle Ages to Eighteen-seventy, 1993, p. 12) Students who learn about eminent women in my course tend to express the sentiment that they should have learned about these women earlier.
A feminist approach to psychobiography is relatively recent, having been spurred by feminist scholarship in the disciplines of history and psychology. (See The Creation and Reinharz, “Feminist Biography: The Pains, the Joys, the Dilemmas” in Amia Lieblich and Ruthellen Josselson, eds., Exploring Identity and Gender: The Narrative Study of Lives, 1994.) Traditionally, biographical analyses have focused on men. Biographies of women have typically been of persons with fame thrust upon them, who posed no threatening questions, or whose fame stemmed from their association with men as wives, mothers, sisters, mistresses, and muses.
In contrast to traditional biographical scholarship, feminist psychobiography has the following special properties: focuses on women who are valued in and of themselves rather than because of their relationships to men; views eminent women as representative of other women, rather than as rarities; considers the study of “anomalous” women—who challenged female stereotypes, belonged to the sphere of action, and existed outside typically “female spaces” such as the home—to be valuable; considers women who were feminist or proto-feminist to be particularly interesting; and considers relations among women as central to women’s stories. Gender-neutral theories, such as social learning theory (Bandura) or Maslow’s theory of self-actualization are preferred.
Feminist psychobiography acknowledges the importance of contextualizing the lives of women. The roles and opportunities afforded women within a particular historical period and culture are taken into account. For example, the profound effects of denial of education are often underestimated in examining women’s past achievements in the mainstream culture. Women were not admitted to universities between their founding in the 11th century up until the late 19th century. (The Creation) Although many a persistent woman overcame the obstacles of inadequate education, one can only speculate as to what might have been had women’s talents been nurtured. For example, brilliant mathematician Sophie Germain (1776-1831) taught herself mathematics and foreign languages through the solitary reading of books, against the wishes of her parents. Germain learned differential calculus, among other topics, in this manner and made significant contributions in number theory and the theory of elasticity. Unfortunately, her work on elasticity was hampered for many years by her lack of formal training in physics. Germain’s death certificate lists her merely as a property holder rather than a scientist or mathematician.
Women’s socio-economic status has been an extremely powerful determinant of their achievement. It is difficult for successful creative accomplishments to occur without appropriate tools (such as an education) and support (both physical and social). The women who have achieved, seemingly against many odds, usually have had some resources. Perhaps the most necessary (though not sufficient) requirements for creative, intellectual achievement are economic security and free time, which allow women access to creative space. For example, Germain, though discouraged from reading, did have access to a fine library and enjoyed economic security. Florence Nightingale was discouraged by her family from pursuing nursing but had been given a classical education and economic support by her upper-class parents. Emily Dickinson was not encouraged or even acknowledged by her parents as a poet but she was supported economically and was not coerced into marriage. What is common in the lives of these brilliant women is that though they were not celebrated by their families for their creative, intellectual achievements, at least they were allowed some space to develop their talents.
To aid the students in their selection of a subject, I provide a list of eminent women. (See <condor.stcloudstate.edu/~jaz/psy275/eminent.women.list.html>.) Popular choices have included: Joan of Arc, Margaret Sanger, Mother Theresa, Harriet Tubman, Catherine the Great, Beatrix Potter, and Emily Dickinson. (It is interesting that students in other courses rarely choose women for assignments unless instructed to do so.
Page 149
In my Theories of Personality course, only four out of thirty-one of the students spontaneously chose women for a psychobiography assignment.)
The content of student presentations is prescribed in an outline. (See <condor.stcloudstate.edu/~jaz/psy275/psybioguide.html>.) Students are required to address the following topics: historical and socio-cultural context, women’s roles (legal, economic, family, etc.), individual developmental history and mentors, adult roles and achievements, creative space, obstacles and sacrifices, and societal acknowledgement of the woman’s achievements.
Maslow’s theory of self-actualization is the common analytical framework. Its advantage is that it stresses the self-actualized person’s relative detachment from social and cultural imperatives. Maslow’s theory is well suited to the study of eminent women because Maslow himself defined optimal psychological adjustment by looking at the qualities of people such as Albert Einstein and Eleanor Roosevelt. An emphasis on positive personality characteristics and the individual’s uniqueness within their social milieu helps avoid a focus on “pathology,” for example, achievement as a form of compensation for one’s inferiority. Eminent women’s detachment from proscribed sex roles, such as motherhood, within a particular culture and historical period often can be seen as a necessary choice for gifted women who wished to fulfill their creative potential.
There are several problems in assigning a psychobiography of an eminent woman. One problem is the sheer paucity of information on eminent women. Many creative women from the past have contributed to art, science, and literature but are not well known and some may never be known. Another difficulty in feminist psychobiography is the lack of high quality scholarship on women. Research on people from past centuries requires years of work with documents. Scholars have devoted their lives to the study of such figures as Abraham Lincoln. The same, high-quality volume of work has not been done on the lives of eminent women. Further, some of the work that has been done on women is biased. One problem can be an excessive focus on women’s sexuality. In a recent presentation on Georgia O’Keefe, one of my students did a good job of covering O’Keefe’s life and work but, to my dismay, she saved all of the “gossip” on O’Keefe for the end of her talk.
A valuable consequence of the psychobiography assignment is the development of students’ critical stance towards institutionalized knowledge. The lack of awareness of eminent women is perceived as a flaw in the educational system. Biases in describing and interpreting women’s lives can be understood as resulting from particular sex role stereotypes. By working on their own presentation and listening to the presentations of others, many students hear about some brilliant women for the first time. This knowledge creates a sense of pride and identification in many of my students.
Page 150
How to cite this article
Jazwinski, C. H. (2001). Feminist psychobiography of eminent women in a psychology of women course. Clio’s Psyche, 8(3), 148-150.



