Volume 18 - Number 4 - March 2012
Pages: 375 - 499

MEMORIALS

Johnson, G. M. (2012). Andrew Brink: Attachment, mentorship, and loss [Memorial]. Clio’s Psyche, 18(4), 487-490.

https://doi.org/10.70763/a9c397afa342c368ba24e7620ee41a94

Andrew Brink: Attachment, Mentorship, and Loss

memorial

Abstract

In this memorial tribute to the literary scholar and psychobiographer Andrew Brink, the author, his former graduate student at McMaster University, recounts their relationship from their first meeting in 1984. The author describes Brink’s application of British object relations theory and Bowlby’s attachment theory to Bertrand Russell and to poets, novelists, painters, and psychoanalysts, a body of work that runs from Loss and Symbolic Repair in the 1970s to a late study of Claude Lorrain. The author recalls Brink’s graduate course “From Puritanism to Psychotherapy: Confessionalism in English Literature,” his supervision of a master’s thesis on Russell’s need for power and of a doctoral dissertation, and the latitude he gave his students. The author also recalls taking part in a fantasy analysis project in which subjects read pages from Lolita and The Collector, later incorporated in Obsession and Culture, and Brink’s introduction to John Fowles, who judged a prize-winning article in Twentieth Century Literature. The author reports that Brink located a source of cultural malaise in the disturbed fantasies of men, purveyed by idolized male creators and rooted in attachment disturbance and traumatic loss. The author is admiring of Brink as a mentor and friend, and concludes by resolving to work toward the ideals of justice, equality, and truth that Brink held.

Keywords:

Andrew W. Brink, attachment theory, Betrand Russell, British object relations, Claude Lorrain, John Bowlby, Loss and Symbolic Repair: A Psychological Study of Some English Poets, memorial, mentorship, psychoanalysis, psychobiography, psychohistory, Romanticism

An image that comes to mind from my many memories of Andrew Brink is of him striding across Central Park, his nervous energy driving him forward, with his wife Helen and me trotting behind him just to keep up. His goal: to give a psychobiographical paper on eminent philosopher Bertrand Russell at the International Psychohistorical Associations’ annual conference. Andrew typically forged a few steps ahead of others, for example, in his prescient applications of British object relations and Bowlby’s attachment theory to Russell, along with an astonishing array of culture shapers, from 17th-century and Romantic poets to 20th-century novelists, poets, painters and psychoanalysts. He began this courageous work in the 1970s with Loss and Symbolic Repair, long before I joined his trek, and he continued right up until this year, with a study of Claude Lorrain.

I well remember my first meeting with him, in an impersonal concrete-block office at McMaster University in 1984. I was just entering graduate school there, young and very shy for my age. When I sat down facing him, I soon realized that he was more nervous than I, which somehow put me at ease. I had completed a double degree with honors at the University of Western Ontario in English and psychology—in those days a rare combination—and had chosen to come to McMaster because I had heard there was a

Page 487

professor there named Brink who was actually doing psychological work in English studies! After one exuberant discussion with Andrew, I realized I had made the right choice, and I also sensed that I was exactly the sort of student that he was looking to mentor.

His graduate course, “From Puritanism to Psychotherapy: Confessionalism in English Literature,” challenged all our presuppositions. Andrew took writers off the pedestals constructed for them and explored them with compassion, as human beings. He was intensely committed and brimming with enthusiasm, and he created a rare, pioneering spirit of cooperation among his students. I was too shy to say much in class but came out of it spinning. It was unlike any other graduate class I took and had a lasting impact. I still refer to my class notes.

Professor Brink was working on the Bertrand Russell papers housed at McMaster, and I was swept up by his excitement at probing this rich archive, to the extent that I wound up writing as my master’s thesis, a psychobiographical portrait focusing on Russell’s need for power. By this time there was no question that I would remain at McMaster and work with Andrew on my PhD.

He was not a typical supervisor in that he really let me explore whatever avenues I chose, which led me to some byways, such as the unjustly neglected psychological novelists May Sinclair and J.D. Beresford, on whom I’ve continued to work, as well as into the esoteric realms of psychical research and the paranormal, which I connected with early psychoanalysis. He didn’t even mind when, five years later, I turned in a 727 page dissertation (though I heard the Graduate Studies Department set an upper page limit in its wake!). During these years I got to know Andrew and Helen on a personal level, particularly after I decided to rent one of their cottages right next door to their lovely 19th-century stone home in the hamlet of Greensville—surely an unusual set-up for supervisor and student, although there was an evergreen stand between the two houses. For some students this could have spelled disaster, but for me it was an ideal, peaceful, idyllic place to write away from the city (and to indulge my hobby for repairing cars, especially British sports cars, of which I had a few—magnanimously tolerated by Andrew).

Page 488

Andrew and Helen introduced me to group meditation with local health professionals, environmental activism, and organic gardening, which I’ve kept doing. He involved me in a fantasy analysis project in which subjects read randomly selected pages from Nabokov’s Lolita and Fowles’s The Collector. I drew on my background in statistics to design the experiment and, though it was time consuming, I knew it was groundbreaking and was proud to contribute to it. Andrew later incorporated the findings in Obsession and Culture.

Then there were the wide-ranging, tea-drenched conversations in Andrew and Helen’s parlor, over dinner in the austere candle-lit dining room, down at the brook, or beside some piece of rescued statuary in their rolling, lush gardens. No, he was not a typical supervisor. Would there were more like him in the current “client-driven” academy.

It was a sad day when I left that idyll and headed out into a very uncertain job market, eventually landing a position on the other side of the country. For Andrew, too, that phase in his career soon came to an end, when he took early retirement and a new position as Co-ordinator of the Humanities and Psychoanalytic Thought Programme at the University of Toronto, his alma mater. Luckily, we both came to enjoy our new positions, despite the challenges.

I kept in touch with Andrew through yearly visits and by e-mail. His writing about the roles played by obsession, anxiety, and avoidance in creativity only increased in frequency and incisiveness. I know he was proud of my efforts, too, as when I won a prize in Twentieth Century Literature for a reworked chapter of my dissertation on Virginia Woolf, judged by John Fowles, who was sympathetic to Andrew’s theories of creativity, and to whom Andrew introduced me in Toronto several years later.

In the past dozen years, Andrew came to know my wife, Nina, and our children. He was just as encouraging of Nina’s work on the educational and therapeutic uses of labyrinths as he had always been of my work. The children scampering about their home and grounds brought out that boyish grin of his on more than a few occasions.

Page 489

What a humane, conscientious, visionary man. Andrew sensed a source of our cultural malaise in the disturbed fantasies of men and how powerfully these fantasies were purveyed by male creators, who were then idolized. He was not afraid to probe the sources in disturbances around attachments and particularly in traumatic loss. His many-dimensional, loving bond with Helen showed that he surmounted these endemic male struggles himself; with her intense social conscience she kept him grounded and aware of threats to our physical and social environments (and she literally kept him walking through that environment).

For me he is one of those rare friends whose loss cannot be replaced but must be borne with the hope that I can strive toward the ideals of justice, equality, and truth that he held so high.

Page 490

About the author

George Johnson

George M. Johnson, PhD, is currently Professor of English at Thompson Rivers University in British Columbia. Johnson’s revised dissertation was published as Dynamic Psychology in Modernist British Fiction (2006). His current book project is Grappling with Ghosts: Mourning and Mysticism in First World War Britain, and he may be contacted at gjohnson@tru.ca.

How to cite this article

Johnson, G. M. (2012). Andrew Brink: Attachment, mentorship, and loss [Memorial]. Clio’s Psyche, 18(4), 487-490.

https://doi.org/10.70763/a9c397afa342c368ba24e7620ee41a94

PDF downloads