Volume 07 - Number 3 - December 2000
Pages: 102 - 164

THE PSYCHOLOGY OF CONSPIRACY THEORIES

Kalfus, M. (2000). A sceptic’s notes on presidential assassination conspiracy theories. Clio’s Psyche, 7(3), 124-127.

https://doi.org/10.70763/89db09d856d45d361982edc10ce738a2

A Sceptic’s Notes on Presidential Assassination Conspiracy Theories

article

Abstract

This article examines conspiracy theories surrounding the assassinations of American presidents, drawing on the author’s recollections, a 1992 survey of International Psychohistorical Association members, and historians’ scholarship on the Lincoln case. The author reports that more than 60 percent of respondents believed in a conspiracy to kill John F. Kennedy, most favoring versions implicating government agencies and officials, and recalls rumors about Franklin Roosevelt’s death heard in adolescence. Following William Hanchett and James McPherson, the author traces the Stanton–Radical Republican theory of the Lincoln assassination to Otto Eisenschiml’s Why Was Lincoln Murdered? (1937), reporting Hanchett’s judgment that its pattern was imposed on the evidence. The author compares the Lincoln, Roosevelt, and Kennedy theories, noting shared features: a national crisis, deep social divisions, a president loved or despised, alleged government involvement and cover-up, and a figure linked to a hostile power. The author contrasts William McKinley, whose assassination produced no comparable theory, and attributes the difference to McKinley’s public presence and to Theodore Roosevelt’s immediate succession. Using the concepts of the paranoid position, splitting, and group fantasy, the author proposes that such theories let believers idealize the slain president while demonizing his successor. The author concludes by urging skepticism, invoking Occam’s Razor against elaborate conspiratorial explanations.

Keywords:

Abraham Lincoln, American group fantasy, International Psychohistorical Association (IPhA), JFK, John F. Kennedy (JFK), movie analysis, Oliver Stone, presidential assassination, psychohistory, psychology of conspiracy theories, U.S. presidency

In the spring of 1992, I conducted a survey for the International Psychohistorical Association (IPA) newsletter in which I included some questions about the various theories related to the assassination of President Kennedy. These questions were prompted by the controversy surrounding the recent release of the movie JFK by Oliver Stone, a film that had all the earmarks of feeding a rip-roaring American group fantasy. Eight years later, I am still astonished by the fact that far more many members shared in the group fantasy as presented by JFK rather than tried to analyze it (e.g., “Unworked-through grief creates conspiracy theo-

Page 124

ries”). More than 60% of the respondents believed there was a conspiracy to assassinate President Kennedy—most of them opting for the most extreme forms of conspiracy involving the CIA, FBI, Lyndon Johnson, Richard Nixon, etc. It was the first time that I realized that I was in the minority on this issue not only among my fellow countrymen, but also within the psychohistorical community.

My own experience with conspiracy theories in relation to the assassination of Presidents dates back to my early teens. I was 14 when FDR died of a massive cerebral hemorrhage while sitting for an oil portrait in the “Little White House” at Warm Springs, Georgia. Only a few days later, I began to hear dark rumors that FDR had been poisoned by the portrait artist—alleged to be a Communist agent. The artist’s Russian surname, “Shoumatoff,” was apparently the only evidence for this theory, and I cannot remember what reasons, if any, were given for the alleged assassination or for the massive cover-up that would have been involved. Far more vivid in my mind was a similar, and far more grandiose theory, that circulated a few months later and was reported by one of my aunts. According to this theory, Shoumatoff, still the culprit, was a Nazi sympathizer and part of a conspiracy (at the highest levels of the government, up to and including Harry Truman!) that not only assassinated FDR but also spirited Adolph Hitler out of his Berlin bunker in the final days of the war and transported him to a magnificent villa atop a mountain in Argentina. My aunt assured us that she knew someone who had actually seen Hitler driving in a motorcar in Buenos Aires!

I knew better than to argue with my aunt, but in the years ahead, I did allow myself to be drawn into debates about the assassination of Abraham Lincoln. Now it was hardly a secret that there was a real conspiracy involved. However, conspiracy buffs (sometimes but not always also Civil War or Lincoln buffs) assailed the consensus historian position that the assassination was a “simple conspiracy” involving John Wilkes Booth and a small band of ne’er-do-well followers. The truth, they argued, was that only Lincoln was the target of the real conspiracy plotters—plotters who had used Booth and his friends as mere pawns. Who were these backstage plotters? None other than Edwin M. Stanton and the Radical Republicans. Their motivation, it was claimed, was that Lincoln was far too conciliatory with the South and was willing to bring the secessionists back into the Union with full political rights. In some versions, the Radicals were said to have acted on behalf of Northern industrialists, who would benefit from Republican supremacy over a weakened Democratic party. (Jim Bishop’s very popular 1955 book, The Day Lincoln Was Shot, suggested that the War Department, under Stanton, was well aware of Booth and his fellow plotters but did not interfere because the assassination of Lincoln would leave the North thirsting for revenge and in full support of military occupation of the South.) Over the next two decades, as the nation was rocked by the assassinations of JFK, Martin Luther King, Jr., and Robert Kennedy, I kept encountering various versions of the Stanton-Radical Republican conspiracy theory in magazine and newspaper articles. By the end of the 1970s, this thesis was the subject of a movie called The Lincoln Conspiracy—and similar “documentaries”—that continue to turn up on television to this day.

It was not until I encountered William Hanchett’s article on this subject that I understood the provenance of the Stanton-Radical Republican “grand conspiracy” theories. (See William Hanchett, “The Lincoln Murder Conspiracies: The Assassination in History and Historiography,” in Gabor S. Boritt, ed., The Historian’s Lincoln: Pseudohistory, Psychohistory, and History, 1988, pp. 315-338.) According to Hanchett, the Stanton-Radical Republican theory originated with a Chicago businessman named Otto Eisenschiml, who published his book, Why Was Lincoln Murdered?, in 1937. Hanchett credits Eisenschiml with engaging “in the most thorough and imaginative search for assassination materials yet undertaken.” The range of his research included War Department files, private collections of papers, newspaper and magazine articles, memoirs, government documents, etc. Hanchett argues that no fair-minded person “could possibly maintain that this pattern [a Stanton-Radical Republican conspiracy] emerged from the evidence.” In fact, Hanchett notes, this pattern was “imposed upon the evidence, which was stretched and twisted to establish the pattern” (p. 332). Hanchett then proceeds to demonstrate the way in which Eisenschimml manipulated his arguments to make his unsupported speculations seem like scientifically-proven facts. Clearly, one could make a similar comment about a great many of the books that have been produced about the assassination of JFK.

In his excellent commentary upon the Hanchett article (The Historian’s Lincoln, pp. 339-343), the Civil War historian, James R. McPherson

Page 125

 lists a dozen “grand conspiracy” theories that had been floated in the century following Lincoln’s death. The earliest maintained that Confederate and/or Copperhead (Northern sympathizers with the Confederate cause) leadership instigated the plot and aided in Booth’s flight. Some theories even had a role for Andrew Johnson in this evil conspiracy. Other theories attributed the plot to a Catholic conspiracy, or “a consortium of [Jewish] international bankers headed by the Rothschilds,” or Lincoln’s own Secret Service. Indeed, as McPherson points out, the movie mentioned earlier—The Lincoln Conspiracy—manages “without blushing to incorporate most of these theories into one superconspiracy interpretation” which includes both Northern and Southern political and business leaders. Again, similar critiques have been made about Oliver Stone’s JFK.

One thing that has intrigued me is the commonalities of popular culture in the eras that first gave rise to Lincoln, FDR, and JFK conspiracy theories. Each of these Presidents came to power in a period of great national crisis during which there were deep, emotionally-loaded divisions within the American populace—divisions that made each side believe the other was driven by the most sinister of motives. Each in his own way was a larger-than-life charismatic figure that was either greatly loved or virulently despised by opposing segments of the society. Further, in each case the “grand conspiracy theory” involved U.S. governmental leaders and agencies as well as an alleged massive cover-up. In each case also, there was at hand a representative of a power hostile to the U.S.—Booth as a Southern sympathizer, Shoumatoff as a “Nazi agent,” and Oswald as a Castro sympathizer—someone that could be employed as a pawn or a patsy.

I am not aware of similar grand conspiracy theories being floated after the assassination of the very popular William McKinley in 1901 by Leon Czolgosz, a self-described anarchist—an assassination that otherwise meets many of the above criteria. This was during a period of extended social turmoil—labor violence, vast tides of immigrants from Eastern and Southern Europe, the Populist movement, and grinding poverty in urban slums and subsistence farms. Anarchists had already been blamed for the Haymarket Square bombing in 1886. Emma Goldman’s partner and lover, Alexander Berkman, had attempted to assassinate Henry Clay Frick in the midst of the Homestead Steel strike in 1892. Moreover, monarchs in Austria and Italy had been assassinated by anarchists. Thus, when McKinley’s death touched off a wave of arrests and persecutions of American anarchists, it was what we might think of as “reality-based paranoia.” Even though the clearly unstable Czolgosz had been turned away by the anarchist groups he had tried to join, one could hardly blame the average American for subscribing to a group fantasy of a nation under anarchist attack. A similar case could be made for the theory that held Confederate leaders responsible for Lincoln’s death, or Castro’s Cuba for Kennedy’s. These, too, could be described as “reality-based paranoia.”

Why did the McKinley assassination never escalate beyond that, into the sort of “grand conspiracy theory” that involved officials and agencies of the U.S. government itself? The major reason, I think, lay in the personalities of the assassinated Presidents and the people who succeeded them. Though popular, McKinley was not in the least a charismatic or forceful presence in national life as were Lincoln, FDR, and Kennedy. Furthermore, he was the only one of the four who was succeeded in office by someone who was extremely charismatic, already well-known and greatly admired by most Americans—Theodore Roosevelt. TR’s powerfully attractive personality stands in stark contrast with Andrew Johnson, Harry Truman, and Lyndon Johnson—none of whom were considered to be the equal of the men they replaced. Thus, Teddy Roosevelt was able to step immediately into the role of delegate and allay national anxieties—establishing manic rather than depressive group fantasies. Coinciding with the turn of the century and a series of international expositions celebrating America’s growing power and the promise of the future, TR’s Presidency quickly obliterated the memory of McKinley and brought national mourning to a speedy conclusion.

It is my assumption that conspiracy theories—whether reality-based or not—are formed in the paranoid position—for some people a permanent residing place, for others a place we regress to under the impact of terrible anxieties. The belief in evil figures who plot monstrous actions against us originates in our infancy—where the monsters that the child fears are the split-off “bad” parts of its parents, leaving it free to love and idealize the “good” parents—a tendency many of us carry into adult life.

What we have done with our parents, we do with authority figures. To the degree he/she offers us group fantasies that allay our anxieties

Page 126

and fears, and offer a vent for our suppressed rage, the parent/authority figure/delegate is idealized. To the degree that he/she fails to do so (by disagreeing with our worldview/socio-political attitudes) the leader/delegate can become the target of our paranoid fantasies. We can either idealize such figures or demonize them.

The amazing thing about the “grand conspiracy theories” relative to Presidential assassination is that they fulfill both needs. We are enabled to idealize the assassinated “good father” (Lincoln, FDR, JFK) and demonize the unlovable surviving “bad father” (Stanton and Johnson, Truman, and LBJ). How comforting. No wonder even we sceptics allow ourselves a recreational wallowing in the wildest of conspiracy theories—especially when they are offered up by talented filmmakers.

The fact is that human life is fragile and contingent, and it unfolds in a messy tangle of strange coincidences and staggering improbabilities. How we hate to deal with the chaotic implications of all this. Yet Occam’s Razor should still be our guide. The more layers of complexity one adds to a conspiratorial explanation of life’s messy, sometimes tragic events, the more likely it is that the theory is false—the historic equivalents of all the complicated mathematical convolutions that medieval astronomers went through to make their observations conform to the Aristotelian universe, with the earth at its center. No matter how satisfying it would be to believe so, the earth does not stand at the center of the universe and we do not stand in the center of enormous conspiracies, with casts of thousands, covering up the “true facts” in Presidential assassinations from Lincoln to JFK.

Page 127

About the author

Melvin Kalfus

Melvin Kalfus is an adjunct professor at Lynn University in Boca Raton, Florida, and a Member of the Advisory Council of the Psychohistory Forum. He is also a past president of the International Psychohistorical Association. He was featured in the Winter, 1996, issue of The Psychohistory News.

How to cite this article

Kalfus, M. (2000). A sceptic’s notes on presidential assassination conspiracy theories. Clio’s Psyche, 7(3), 124-127.

https://doi.org/10.70763/89db09d856d45d361982edc10ce738a2

PDF downloads