
Volume 20 - Number 1 - June 2013
Pages: 1 - 125
Kaplan, K. J., & Anderson, J. W. (2013). Freud, Greek narratives, and Biblical counter-narratives: A dialogue. Clio’s Psyche, 20(1), 101-111.
Freud, Greek Narratives, and Biblical Counter-narratives: A Dialogue
Abstract
This article, presented as a dialogue between Kalman J. Kaplan and James William Anderson, brings Freud’s Oedipus complex to bear on Greek and Hebrew narratives of fathers and sons. Kaplan retells the Greek creation myth in Apollodorus, in which Sky, Cronus, and Zeus are displaced through violence and castration. He characterizes it in family-systems terms as a recurring pattern of marital estrangement, triangulation, and transgressed generational boundaries. He maintains that Freud offered no counter-narrative and questions why Freud, a Jew, favored Greek over Hebrew sources, citing Freud’s replies to Alter Druyanov and to Max Eitingon’s mention of Lev Shestov. Kaplan proposes that Genesis supplies the counter-narrative. He reads circumcision as a sign of covenant rather than symbolic castration, and the Akedah as Abraham’s trust that God, whose covenant depends on Isaac, will relent. Anderson, stating his own reservations about Freud, sets out how Freud would read the same material. In this reconstruction, the Greek myths, Sophocles’ play, circumcision, and the Akedah all evidence a universal, inborn Oedipus complex. The Akedah is read as a story restraining paternal aggression and teaching obedience to authority, which Anderson contrasts with psychoanalytic self-awareness. Kaplan replies that the Biblical family recognizes no father-son rivalry and rests on intergenerational concord, citing Malachi. Anderson concludes by agreeing that the covenant gives believers reason to overcome hostility and that Greek myth lacks such a counter-narrative. He adds that Malachi presupposes opposing inner tendencies, and proposes that God the Father offers a positive model of paternal care.
Apollodorus, counter-narratives, father-son dynamic, Greek mythology, human nature, Oedipus complex, psychohistory, Sigmund Freud
KAL KAPLAN:
The Greek myth of creation begins with Sky (the male) marrying Earth (the female) and producing, first, the hundred-handed monsters, and then the Cyclopes (Apollodorus, 1:1-2). Family pathology then immediately commences, as the father takes the children away from the mother and throws them into Tartarus, a dark and gloomy place in Hades. Sky again has children by Earth, the Titans” (Apollodorus, 1:3). Earth retaliates for the loss of her children by persuading the Titans to attack their father and gives Cronus, the leader of the Titans, a steel sickle. The Titans set upon their father, and Cronus cuts off his father’s genitals and throws them into the sea. The Furies are born from the spurting blood. Cronus becomes the new ruler (Apollodorus, 1:4).
In this myth, the Oedipal conflict is described as being ingrained through the Furies into the fabric of the natural world. Earth and Sky foretell that Cronus will lose the rule to his own son;
Page 101
so Cronus devours his offspring as they are born (Apollodorus 1:5). One of the babies, Zeus, is saved through a ruse. When Zeus reaches adulthood he makes war on Cronus and the Titans, fulfilling the prophecy of Earth and Sky (Apollodorus 2:1).
A tragic family pattern emerges from these stories. Husband and wife are estranged from each other. The husband is disengaged and hurtful. The wife is enmeshing and vengeful. Family triangulation occurs, pitting mother and son against father. Generational boundaries are blurred and transgressed. Moreover, the pattern seems a natural consequence of creation and is destined to repeat itself cyclically throughout the generations.
Sigmund Freud was aware of the power of the narratives of Greek mythology. He saw a particular complex as being central to human nature and named it after the Greek mythological figure, Oedipus. In Freud’s view, fathers see their sons as a threat, as contained in the warning of the oracle to Laius: that Oedipus “when he reached man’s estate” would kill his father Laius and marry his mother Jocasta. In Freud’s developmental scheme, the father threatens to castrate the son to prevent this from happening. As a result, the son then gives up the mother as a libidinal object and identifies with the father, the superego being heir to the Oedipus complex. Thus the superego is based on fear.
Freud had no counter-narrative for this story. It is difficult to see how, with this framework for viewing the world, there can be any resolution based on love between father and son. There is an unending conflictual pattern between father and son as foretold by Earth and Sky (Apollodorus, 1.5; 2.1). Yosef Yerushalmi puts it this way: “Like Sisyphus pushing his rock, Oedipus and Laius must contend forever. At one point in the cycle, the father must be slain by the son; at another, the return of the repressed, the father returns; the return is only illusion, for the cycle will begin again (Yerushalmi, Freud’s Moses: Judaism Terminable and Interminable, 1991, 95).
JIM ANDERSON:
Freud provided a stark and challenging view of human nature, a view that stresses the centrality of the Oedipus complex and the powerful sexual and aggressive forces that are a part of that
Page 102
complex. I have my criticisms of Freud’s view, but here I would like to consider how the material from Greek mythology discussed by Kal would be seen from Freud’s perspective.
Kal begins by describing the universe’s early history as depicted in Greek mythology. The story is saturated with murderous hatred between fathers and children, particularly sons. Fathers are afraid their sons will kill and displace them. They try to rid themselves of the sons by obliterating them or banishing them. Sons who survive indeed retaliate by killing the fathers. Castration even comes into play; Cronus cuts off the genitals of his father, Sky.
Freud would have seen the Greek myth of creation as supporting his theory of the Oedipus complex. He believed that boys are born with a desire to possess their mothers, indeed, even to have sex with them. The boy sees that his father has what he wants, a privileged relationship with the mother and an exclusive sexual bond with her. He views his father as his rival, and he wants to displace him; in fact, he wants to kill him. Realizing that his father is far more powerful than he, the boy fears his father and thinks in particular that his father will punish him by castrating him. Freud paid little attention to the father’s role, but it follows that he would have seen the father also having rivalry with his son and often fearing that his son will displace him.
To Freud, the Oedipal pattern is inborn and inevitable, though few psychoanalysts today would accept that assumption. Freud therefore expected the Oedipus complex to appear everywhere, in every culture and in every historical period. The Greek myth of early history, to Freud, would have been evidence of the existence of Oedipal patterns in the culture of the ancient Greeks. Hence, when the Greeks came to fantasize the beginning of the world, they projected these themes into the myths they made up. They imagined the early divine creatures as living out Oedipal themes: fathers and sons being in conflict, sons wanting to kill fathers, fathers being afraid of sons, and mothers having a role in all this.
Similarly, the story of Oedipus, and Sophocles’ telling of the story in his play, Oedipus Rex, would have been further evidence to Freud of the omnipresence of the Oedipus complex. Freud
Page 103
noted that the play had much the same effect on the modern audience as it did on Sophocles’ audience more than two thousand years ago (The Interpretation of Dreams, 1900, 261). In the play the oracle declares that it is the destiny of Oedipus to marry his mother and to kill his father. The “destiny” of Oedipus “moves us,” Freud wrote, “only because it might have been ours—because the oracle laid the same curse upon us before our birth as upon him. It is the fate of all of us, perhaps, to direct our first sexual impulse towards our mother and our first hatred and our first murderous wish against our father.”
Kal states that Freud did not provide a counter-narrative, and I agree. Freud believed that there was only one narrative, a universal narrative. He believed that all people are heirs to the Oedipus complex.
While Freud made use of Greek mythology, he fundamentally disagreed with the Greek doctrine of destiny. While the ancient Greeks believed that everyone is fated to live out the lives prescribed by the eternal forces, Freud thought that we have certain inborn tendencies. Such tendencies have an impact similar to that of the force of destiny. But there is a vital difference. The whole purpose of psychoanalysis and of self-knowledge in general is to become aware of these tendencies that reside in the unconscious. Hence people can become in control of their own lives rather than being in the grip of forces of which they are not aware.
KAL KAPLAN:
What is curious to me, Jim, is, although the Hebrew Scriptures in general and the book of Genesis in particular do seem to provide a counter-narrative, Freud, a Jew, albeit a “godless Jew,” seems much more partial to Greek than Hebrew narratives. A short time after the publication of The Interpretation of Dreams, the Jewish historian and folklorist, Alter Druyanov, wrote to Freud alerting him to the considerable similarity between his ideas and those of the early Hebrews. Freud answered: “‘I’m happy to learn of a competent reader of my book from so far a place. As far as I’m concerned however the similarity between my ideas and those of the early Greeks strikes me as much more salient’” (in Eran J. Rolnik, Freud in Zion: History of Psychoanalysis in Jewish Palestine/Israel 1918-1948, 34).
Page 104
The idea that the son is a threat to a father rather than an extension of him into the future is utterly foreign to the Biblical worldview. The father realizes that the son is not motivated to displace him because he knows that he will inherit from him. Indeed, he wants to see his son develop and surpass him, and is commanded to teach him thoroughly (Deuteronomy 6:7, Kiddushin 30a, Babylonian Talmud). This covenantal relationship is symbolized by circumcision of the male foreskin (b’rith hamilah) at the age of eight days (Genesis 17: 9-11). In my view as someone who has studied and written about the psychological meaning of Biblical narratives for more than 20 years (e.g., K. J. Kaplan, M. W. Schwartz, & M. Markus-Kaplan, The Family: Biblical and Psychological Foundations, 1984, and K. J. Kaplan, and M. W. Schwartz, A Psychology of Hope: A Biblical Response to Tragedy and Suicide, 2008) circumcision is not symbolic castration but the very opposite. It transforms the primordial fear on the part of the son into the assurance that the father’s own interests lie in the son’s being fit to carry on the covenant. Rather than promoting fear of the future as the Greek Oedipus narrative does, the Biblical narrative embraces the future.
The pivotal narrative that portrays the basic familial pattern is that of the Akedah—Abraham’s binding of Isaac—wherein God tells Abraham to sacrifice his son Isaac. There are several significant elements to the story. First, God calls upon Abraham to offer his son, Isaac, who, God acknowledges, is Abraham’s only son whom he loves, as a sacrifice (Genesis 22:2). Second, Abraham seems prepared to go through with the sacrifice, apparently never fully giving up hope that God will transform his command so that Isaac might be saved. Further, Isaac trusts in his father, despite his questioning with regard to the absence of a burnt offering (Genesis 22:6-8). Finally, God does relent, sending an angel at the last moment to command Abraham not to sacrifice Isaac: “Lay not thine hand upon the lad” (Genesis 22:9-12).
The central question raised by the Akedah is: Why does Abraham continue to trust in God, given that God seems to be unrelenting in His call for the sacrifice of Isaac?
Answering this question necessitates a fuller understanding of the relationship between God, Abraham, and Isaac, and the outworking of the covenant among them. Abram’s (his original and
Page 105
pre-covenant name) relationship with God begins with Him telling Abram to leave his father Terah’s house and the pagan gods (Genesis 12: 1-3). Abram’s relationship with God develops. Sarai is barren and arranges for Abram (now named Abraham) to have a son, Ishmael, with her handmaiden Hagar (Genesis 17:5). Sarai is renamed Sarah and is given the blessing of a son, Isaac, despite her advanced age of 90. God will continue the covenant with Isaac rather than Ishmael, whom He will bless but not give His covenant (Genesis 17:20-21). Abraham reluctantly sends Ishmael away at Sarah’s request after Ishmael makes sport at Isaac’s weaning (Genesis 21: 8-11).
After all these events, we are confronted with the narrative of the Akedah. The above passages begin to make comprehensible the central question of the Akedah. Abraham trusts God because he believes that God thus has a vested interest in the survival of Isaac. God must relent in His call for the sacrifice of Isaac. He has an empty covenant should Isaac die.
Underlying this episode is the paradox Abraham finds himself in—the Akedah paradox. If Abraham rejects God’s command to sacrifice Isaac, he is breaking his covenant with his monotheistic God and will likely lapse back into a paganism that allows, indeed invites, child sacrifice. By accepting God’s command, Abraham achieves a Biblical resolution that ends child sacrifice, once and for all.
The question to me, Jim, is why Freud, a Jewish man familiar with his own tradition, would have failed to see in the Hebrew Scriptures the basis for such a counter-narrative?
Max Eitingon, the only real Zionist within Freud’s inner circle of supporters, alerted Freud to the writings of Eitingon’s friend and Landsman, Lev Shestov, the Russian-Jewish philosopher and author of the landmark book, Athens and Jerusalem (1930-37). Eitingon went so far as to send Freud one of Shestov’s books. Freud’s answer gives ample evidence as to his disinterest in understanding Biblical and Hebrew thinking. “You cannot imagine how unaffected I am by these convoluted philosophical discussions” (in Rolnik, Freud in Zion, 2007, 56).
Page 106
JIM ANDERSON:
As one would expect, Freud would have had a sharply different view of these Biblical stories, particularly the story of the Akedah. Freud would see the Akedah as further evidence of the universality of the Oedipus complex. He would say that the Oedipus complex underlay Hebrew myth, just as it underlay Greek myth, and just as it underlies the psyche of human beings today.
His argument would be simple. A central factor in the Oedipus complex is the conflict between fathers and sons. The son wants to murder the father. The father, aware of his son’s intentions, has an inner urge to kill his son and take away the threat. Therefore the early Jews developed a story to try to control the father’s murderous desires. The story, directed to fathers, says in effect: “You will have a desire to kill your son. Don’t be surprised. This desire feels as if it were implanted in you by God. Even Abraham was in a position of wanting to kill his son, but he was not at fault, he was merely following God’s directive. But God has declared that you should not kill your son. He has demanded that you spare him.” In other words, the story was necessitated by the need to help fathers resist their murderous desires toward their sons.
Freud saw the custom of circumcision as buttressing his view, rather than, as Kal claims, demonstrating the pact between father and son. Freud speculates that the son has an unconscious “memory-trace from the prehistory of the human family, when the jealous father would actually rob his son of his genitals if the latter interfered with him by his rivalry for a woman.” “The primæval custom of circumcision, another symbolic substitute for castration,” he goes on, “is only intelligible if it is an expression of subjection to the father’s will” (An Outline of Psycho-Analysis, 1938, 190). In Freud’s vision, the Akedah too illustrates Abraham’s subjection to God and the son’s subjection to his father.
Within Freud’s framework, the story operates through strengthening the superego, that is, the moral code within the individual’s mind. The story, portrayed as the word of God, becomes incorporated into the superego. A believing person considers it wrong to murder his son. Freud would consider this solution to be typical of the solutions that were common before modern times. It
Page 107
is not based on self-understanding. A person does not say, “I have these murderous desires toward my son. I realize that virtually everyone has such impulses at times. But I can make the decision not to act on that desire. I am in rational control of my behavior.” Instead, humankind had to rely on a story that had the force of a commandment from God; the meaning of the story is: “Thou shalt not kill nor harm thy son.”
Freud would further claim that some fathers at times end up hurting their sons because of their unconscious hostility. In that situation, the father’s wish to hurt would bypass his superego injunctions. For example, a father might let his son engage in a dangerous activity, such as playing in a dangerous area when the son is too young to be safe. Freud would say that is why his approach, which is based on awareness, is preferable. People who are aware of unconscious desires and have a mastery over them will be in less danger of unconsciously finding ways of circumventing the conscious mind and accomplishing harmful, unconscious purposes.
Kal asks, “Why does Abraham continue to trust in God, given that God seems to be unrelenting in His call for the sacrifice of Isaac?” I think it requires tortuous reasoning to try to give an answer that sounds nice to such a question. The obvious answer is that the story was created to make a point: people are not to trust their own personal values, they are not to consider what matters most to them; rather, they are to follow the authority of God unquestionably. The story exists in the Bible to instruct people to submit to God, no matter how wrong or harmful it might seem to be to do so. Even if God’s command appears to call for the worst action imaginable—sacrificing one’s own son—one still must obey. I see the Akedah as embodying what might be called the pre-modern approach or even the pre-Freudian approach, an approach that revolves around following authority rather than relying on one’s own judgment, values, and ethics.
While it seems to me that Kal brought up the Biblical stories to claim that they are sharply different from the Greek myths, I think Freud would be struck more by the similarity. He would see the Biblical stories as further evidence of his view of human nature. Life, to Freud, is saturated with rivalry, envy, and sexuality. The stories of the Bible inevitably reflect human nature. Those who
Page 108
made up the stories projected the qualities of life onto them. Therefore we have: Abram has sex with his wife, Sara, and with his wife’s handmaiden, Hagar; it is the earliest Biblical ménage a trois. (Hagar bears Abram’s first son, Ishmael, and Sara bears his second son, Isaac.) Ishmael, envious of his favored brother, Isaac, does not join in the celebration of his weaning. Sara, wanting her son to be the special one and jealous of Hagar, demands that Hagar and Ishmael be driven away. Abram, with the same hostility toward a son that he would later feel toward Isaac, agrees to banish Ishmael.
In summary, Freud would see Biblical stories as illustrating his conception of human nature: people are lustful, selfish, and aggressive. Left to their own devices, people would be endlessly destructive to others and to themselves; there would be unremitting strife. Therefore, the superego has developed, the internal moral code that people carry within themselves. The Bible reinforces the superego in two main ways. First, by providing many of the guidelines that have become encoded in the superegos of most people, such as the Ten Commandments. Second, by teaching people, in stories such as the Akedah, that they should obey God unquestionably. Freud had an implied critique of this second factor, the principle of blind obedience. He favored self-awareness; he preferred to have people know what is in the unconscious and to make decisions based on the greatest familiarity possible with what is inside them.
KAL KAPLAN:
Despite Jim’s claim of similarities between the Greek and Biblical narratives, two sharp differences remain. The Greek narrative provides no respite from unremitting rivalry between father and son. The Biblical narrative recognizes no such rivalry.
The Biblical family, in contrast to the family of Greek mythology, has a purpose, the passing down of a covenant. There is an intergenerational bond wherein each generation has a vested interest in the well-being of the other. The son does not desire to possess his mother or displace his father. Instead he accepts protection and nurturance from his parents and learns from them. The Biblical message is not one of strife between father and son but rather one of concord and mutual love. It is expressed most directly in the words of the prophet Malachi: “And He shall turn the heart of the fathers to the children, And the heart of the children to their fa-
Page 109
thers…” (Malachi 3: 22-24).
JIM ANDERSON:
Because Kal had the first word, the last word falls to me. But it will not be one of contention; rather, I hope we can reach some accord.
I think by this point Kal has accepted my argument—I really should say Freud’s argument—that people by nature have powerful, often unruly forces within them. Even the last, beautiful statement from “Malachi” seems to support that point. Why would God have to encourage fathers and sons to turn their hearts toward each other if they did not have a strong internal tendency toward the opposite?
My impression is that Kal also would agree with me—or again, I should say, with Freud—about the value of self-understanding. Given the powerful forces within us, forces that often push us toward behavior that would harm others or ourselves, we are best off to the extent that we understand and manage those forces. The Greeks emphasized destiny because it seemed to them that uncontrollable forces outside themselves determined their lives. Our view today is that those forces are within us, and, once we are aware of them, we can master them.
Kal’s overarching point is one with which I agree. He argues convincingly that the Biblical narrative provides for believers a powerful argument, organized around the meaning of the covenant, as to why fathers and sons should overcome any inner hostility they might have toward each other. A father would want to facilitate his son’s growth, and a son would have love and gratitude toward his father. I see too that there is no central dynamic in the Greek stories that provides what Kal calls a counter-narrative to the Oedipal story, with its vicious antagonism between father and son. I would even go farther and expand on Kal’s interpretation of the meaning of the covenant. He says in effect that fathers and sons share in the covenant, hence it is in the interest of fathers to nurture their sons, and the sons, in turn, feel grateful to their fathers and pass on their fathers’ legacy. One could also see the story of the covenant as providing a positive model of father-son interaction. God the Father cares for the well-being of His sons and provides
Page 110
for them, and the sons carry on God’s life-affirming purposes.
Page 111
How to cite this article
Kaplan, K. J., & Anderson, J. W. (2013). Freud, Greek narratives, and Biblical counter-narratives: A dialogue. Clio’s Psyche, 20(1), 101-111.



