Volume 19 - Number 3 - December 2012
Pages: 249 - 368

MEMORIALS OF FORUM MEMBERS

Kobrin, N. (2012). Remembering my mentor Sander Breiner [Memorial]. Clio’s Psyche, 19(3), 356-359.

https://doi.org/10.70763/000871c1fc726f0b52dc86a4eeb027de

Remembering My Mentor Sander Breiner

memorial

Abstract

In this memorial tribute, the author remembers Sander J. Breiner (1925–2012), a psychiatrist, psychoanalyst, and contributor to the Psychohistory Forum, whom she calls her mentor. She recounts encountering his essay “Some Interesting Child Rearing Practices in the Arab Moslem World” in Historical and Psychological Inquiry and his book Slaughter of the Innocents, and then corresponding with him while developing her work on suicide terrorism, which appeared in Clio’s Psyche and grew into The Banality of Suicide Terrorism. She reports that his writings on the mother-infant bond were critical to her argument linking suicide terrorism to the devalued female in Arab Muslim shame/honor culture, and she states that neuroscience now supports that argument. She notes his U.S. Army service in World War II, including the Battle of the Bulge, and his encouragement that she teach military and law enforcement audiences. She attributes her exclusion from a Human Terrain Team to anti-Semitism and says he described a comparable experience in the army. She summarizes his view, expressed in an email, that maternal well-being shapes early brain development and that a traumatized mother may transmit psychological abandonment to her children. He concluded that moderate Muslims must lead in opposing suicide terrorism and in raising the value of women. She closes by crediting him with teaching those around him how to say goodbye, by contacting each patient, colleague, and friend before his death. Throughout, she admires him personally and professionally.

Keywords:

Arab Muslim culture, The Banality of Suicide Terrorism, Clio’s Psyche, memorial, mother-infant bond, psychohistory, Psychohistory Forum, radical Islam, Sander Breiner, Slaughter of the Innocents

Sander J. Breiner (1925-2012) was, without a doubt, an extraordinary human being. He was also my most exemplary mentor. My connection to him was made possible by the Psychohistory Forum and its journal, Clio’s Psyche, and therefore, I am doubly

Page 356

honored to have been asked by his family as well as by Paul Elovitz to write these brief words.

I first came across a reference to his work “Some Interesting Child Rearing Practices in the Arab Moslem World,” in Historical and Psychological Inquiry (1990), edited by Paul Elovitz. I immediately sought out his book Slaughter of the Innocents: Child Abuse through the Ages and Today (1990). I read it in one sitting and immediately contacted Dr. Breiner with a series of questions; he answered everyone.

During this same time frame, I had the good fortune to publish several essays in Clio’s Psyche which morphed into The Banality of Suicide Terrorism, where I drew a link to the devalued female in the shame/honor Arab Muslim culture. Dr. Breiner’s writings were critical to my argument, which is now receiving support from neuroscience. He always took time out of his busy schedule to provide important insights, and thought provoking comments and questions. He was tough yet kept me on track, encouraging me most especially to reach out to moderate Muslims.

I learned the most from him about the significance of the mother-infant bond. While I never actually asked Dr. Breiner directly, I sensed that he knew a lot about Arab Muslim culture from living and practicing in Detroit, which has a significant diaspora. He was peripatetic and yet extremely practical. I have always felt that the best psychoanalysts writing about aggression and violence were those who knew war first-hand, such as Wilfred Bion, who was a World War I tank commander. During World War II, Dr. Breiner enlisted in the U.S. Army and fought in the Battle of the Bulge. His daughter Linda said that he was awarded the Bronze Star before his death. His granddaughter Zena served in the Israel Defense Force with distinction. Zena’s brother, Noah, studied at Haifa University. I had the opportunity to meet both Linda and Zena here in Tel Aviv, and as the saying goes, the apples do not fall far from the tree.

By now, we were on a first name basis. Sandy encouraged me to teach the military and law enforcement about the psychology of radical Islam. I had wanted to go into Afghanistan on a Human Terrain Team but was not permitted due to anti-Semitism. Linda

Page 357

told me that her father had wanted me to know that he had undergone a similar experience in the army and that he had completely believed me when I had told him that I had been hazed quite horribly. In his case, his life had been threatened by a sergeant who didn’t like Jews, so our work and life experience took similar paths. (Like Sandy, I too grew up in Chicago.)

His last request was that I write something short that would demonstrate links between our work. Just days ago, I had completed an essay in his memory to be translated into German when Paul contacted me for this remembrance. I had sent the essay to Linda, who wrote me back saying that the essay had arrived uncannily on the last day of the Shloshim, the thirty-day period of mourning. She said her Dad would always ask, “What have you done for the Jewish people today?”

Sandy wrote about the devalued female in Arab Muslim culture, that it was not just that abuse of the female would affect the development of the brain, but that when the female baby became a mother, she would inevitably communicate a kind of psychological abandonment to her children because of her own trauma. This, to him as well as to me, was common sense. He wrote in an email that “genetic expression can be affected by external events” because “Mothers-to-be emotional and physical well-being will affect the beginning neural tube and primitive heart,” and “In the first two years of life the brain quadruples in size.” Furthermore, “between 9 to 22 years of age 50% of the gray matter is lost, and the white matter increases enormously.” He concluded that the key to solving Islamic suicide terrorism would require the intervention of moderate Muslims to stand up against terror-suicide and “enhance the value and importance of the female (childhood through motherhood).” He considered the little girl to be the most important person in the world. Therefore, she merited better treatment than the male—not equal but better! I do not know of any other scholar who has ever stated this with such authority.

Yet, Sandy did something even more remarkable, something that few of us are actually able to do—he taught us how to say goodbye when we face death. He contacted each of his patients, colleagues and friends and he communicated to each one of them what we meant to him and what we must now do as we face life in

Page 358

a new way, without him in his physical presence. He gave us this special gift of love. Sandy lives on through this gifting.

Page 359

About the author

Nancy Hartevelt Kobrin

Nancy Hartevelt Kobrin, PhD, a psychoanalyst who supervises psychiatry residents in the Hennepin-Regions Psychiatry Training Program, maintains a private practice in St. Paul, Minnesota. She is a clinical member and supervisor in the Israeli Association of Marriage and Family Therapy and was a contributor to Effective Treatments for PTSD (Edna Foa, Terence Keane, and Matthew Friedman, eds., 2000), considered to be the international guidelines for Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder. Dr. Kobrin does most of her research in Arabic, English, and Hebrew but also has competence, to varying degrees, in six other languages. She may be contacted at .

How to cite this article

Kobrin, N. (2012). Remembering my mentor Sander Breiner [Memorial]. Clio’s Psyche, 19(3), 356-359.

https://doi.org/10.70763/000871c1fc726f0b52dc86a4eeb027de

PDF downloads