Volume 14 - Number 3 - December 2007
Pages: 41 - 104

THE PSYCHOLOGY OF PRESIDENTIAL CANDIDATES 2008

Konrath, S. (2007). Reflections on the power of virgins and martyrs. Clio’s Psyche, 14(3), 54-55.

https://doi.org/10.70763/81cacbb44ce8bf874ef92e1a73432c7f

Reflections on the Power of Virgins and Martyrs

article

Abstract

This article considers why women remain underrepresented in American politics, noting that they hold sixteen percent of the seats in both the U.S. Senate and the House of Representatives. The author argues that, in male-centric societies, women are viewed through the male gaze and grouped into four familiar symbolic roles, the Virgin, the Whore, the Mother, and the Martyr, each with strong religious associations. The author contends that women who present as ambitious or intelligent are seen as cold and aggressive, while women who present as warm are seen as nonthreatening but not competent, and that men do not face a comparable bind. The author proposes that, until women hold equal political and economic power, the best option is strategic self-presentation within these roles. Queen Elizabeth I is offered as an example of a ruler who took the place of the Virgin Mary in her people’s religious imagination. The author describes George W. Bush’s conversion narrative and post-9/11 rhetoric as an appeal to the religious psyche of Americans, one that in the author’s view omits martyrdom. The author maintains that Hillary Rodham Clinton’s decision to stay with Bill Clinton during the Lewinsky scandal fits the Martyr role, and that she will remain successful as long as she stays in it. The author concludes that these roles limit equal power for women and hopes that future political daughters of the Bush and Clinton families will have more individual roles.

Keywords:

2008 U.S. presidential election, American politics, Barack Obama, feminism, gender dynamics in politics, male-centric societies, Martyr role, Mitt Romney, political narrative, psychohistory, religious psyche, symbolic roles

Three decades after second-wave feminism, women are still significantly underrepresented in American politics. They currently hold only sixteen percent of the seats in both the U.S. Senate and the House of Representatives. It has been historically very difficult for women to gain power, in large part, because in male-centric societies women are viewed through the male gaze, which wears only a limited spectrum of lenses. Thus women are grouped into one of a few compelling and familiar mythical symbolic roles: the Virgin, the Whore, the Mother, and the Martyr.

Until women have equal political and economic power as men, smart and ambitious women might do very well to pattern themselves after these roles. That these roles are compelling yet constraining can be demonstrated in considering any woman who dares try to break out from one of them. Women who present themselves as too ambitious or intelligent are seen as cold and aggressive, perhaps because intelligence is seen as antithetical to each one of these symbolic roles. Women who present themselves as too warm in accordance with these roles, however, are seen as intellectually nonthreatening and passive, and are not respected as competent equals. These interpretations are magnified in the public spotlight, making it difficult for women first to choose to run for office and then to be elected. (Men, on the other hand, while often pressured to be more “manly,” can be seen as both warm and competent, both of which are important in politics.)

What is a woman with political ambitions to do? It seems as though the best option at present for women who want to gain political power is to do so by strategic self-presentation, like any other politician, except within the limits of these roles. The most powerful females will be the ones who can at least outwardly become one (or more) of these roles, as a study of history will confirm. (Although the Whore is often limited to behind-the-scenes political power, this role is not to be underestimated.)

Each of these roles has very strong religious associations as well and the religious unconscious of the masses is just as important in winning popular political favor. Queen Elizabeth I, one of the most powerful female political figures in history, was popularly known as the “Virgin Queen.” Although the literal truth to the first part of that title is debated, she did remain single and transformed her sexual “inexperience” into the power of political independence. Elizabeth strategically tapped into the religious psyche of her people. She first removed their powerful Mother figure, the Virgin Mary, by reestablishing the Protestant Anglican Church of England, and then she became its replacement in her people’s psychological imaginations. Hillary Rodham Clinton would be wise to follow in Elizabeth’s footsteps in reading the religiously themed psyche of her people and restructuring it to her advantage.

President Bush has also attempted to use the religious psyche of his people to his advantage. Part of his appeal to Americans in the pre-9/11 world was that he had had a dramatic religious conversion to a literal version of Christianity coinciding with the rise of evangelical Protestantism. He tapped into the common people by mirroring them as “fully human,” echoing words of redemption from his former alcoholism (“God saved me and I had no desire to drink anymore”) and a life of waywardness. People stee-

Page 54

ped in the culture of Christianity need to also identify with someone “fully divine.” In the post-9/11 world Bush has attempted to become this, for example, in his denials of ever making mistakes and in his black-and-white us-versus-them “war on terror.” He even descended from the clouds in an airplane in the divine moment just before his infamous “Mission Accomplished” speech. This strategy seemed to be working at first, however, now his God complex seems to be believed only by him, and his approval ratings have dropped to near historic lows.

One problem with Bush’s ego ascension is that he is forgetting a key component of the Christian cultural psyche—that resurrection Sunday can only come after Good Friday. Bush may have successfully tapped into many of the elements of his country’s most popular religion, but he is missing one of the most important ones, that of martyrdom. And that’s where Hillary Clinton can step in. Hillary has an advantage to Bush’s attempt to echo the divine in that the very roles that at first may appear to be limitations can be extremely compelling in the hands of a skilled leader. Right in the middle of the public humiliation of the Lewinsky scandal, Hillary Clinton’s approval ratings were the highest they had ever been (https://abcnews.go.com/images/pdf/927a1HillaryClinton.pdf). Before she seemed to know the truth herself, she publicly spoke in defense of her husband, and when the truth came, it did not set her free of Bill. Instead, like many long-suffering wives, she chose to stay with him because of her deep devotion to and unfailing love for him. This was not the first time that Bill had publicly humiliated her by having an affair (and it probably won’t be the last), but like an eternally loving Christ figure, every time Bill sinned, she forgave, even “seven times seventy” times. Cynical commentators have suggested that she was staying with him in order to gain political power; however, the psychological route to this power might be more complex than at first appears. While Hillary will never be the Virgin Queen, in the religious and political landscape of the U.S. today, she will continue to be successful as long as she remains the Martyr.

I hope I have not overstated the case for women’s strategic maneuvering of these roles as they do, overall, present huge limitations to equal power for women. If the recent “First Daughters,” Chelsea, Jenna, and Barbara, should ever choose to continue in the Bush or Clinton political dynasty, they will hopefully do so in a time period that allows them more individual roles.

Page 55

About the author

Sara Konrath

Sara Konrath is an assistant professor at the Institute for Social Research, University of Michigan, and the director of the Interdisciplinary Program for Empathy and Altruism Research. Konrath may be contacted at .

How to cite this article

Konrath, S. (2007). Reflections on the power of virgins and martyrs. Clio’s Psyche, 14(3), 54-55.

https://doi.org/10.70763/81cacbb44ce8bf874ef92e1a73432c7f

PDF downloads