Volume 21 - Number 1 - June 2014
Pages: 1 - 121

MEMORIALS

Lawton, H. (2014). Doing psychohistory. Clio’s Psyche, 21(1), 83-88.

https://doi.org/10.70763/e0c7ccc47b2613c82d1073a4214deecc

Doing Psychohistory

posthumously published article

Abstract

In this article, published posthumously, the author sets out his view of what psychohistory is and what it asks of those who practice it. He defines psychohistory as the interdisciplinary study of why human beings have acted as they have in history, prominently using psychoanalytic principles. He places its antecedents in Freud and Dilthey and names Erik Erikson, Bruce Mazlish, Peter Loewenberg, George Kren, Lloyd deMause, David Beisel, and Charles Strozier among its pioneers. He maintains that the field is more interpretive than narrative and that it addresses why events happened rather than what happened. He disputes the charge of reductionism, contending that political, social, economic, and cultural factors derive from emotion and fantasy. Drawing on his own experience, he proposes that the psychohistorian’s disciplined subjectivity, or countertransference, serves as a major interpretive tool, likening history to a patient, while insisting that facts remain essential. He reports that training is informal and largely self-directed, and refers to his The Psychohistorian’s Handbook (1988). He argues that a personal analysis likely improves the work. He lists the qualities he considers necessary: curiosity, open-mindedness, introspection, tolerance of anxiety, willingness to move beyond disciplinary norms, trust in one’s own authority, and research skill in libraries and on the Internet. He concludes by encouraging scholars to take up psychohistory.

Keywords:

Bruce Mazlish, Charles Strozier, countertransference, David Beisel, Erik Erikson, George Kren, Henry Lawton, interdisciplinary, Lloyd deMause, methodology, Peter Loewenberg, psychoanalysis, The Psychohistorian’s Handbook, psychohistory, scholarship, subjectivity

Interest in psychohistory remains alive and well despite its somewhat uneven track record. Some scholars shrink from endeavoring to do psychohistory due to uncertainty about its emotional and intellectual requirements. It is my hope that what I offer here will help ease this uncertainty.

People read what we psychohistories write and listen to what we say. They wonder whether we are select practitioners of some arcane art or if psychohistory is a field that is easily accessible. The truth lies somewhere in between. There are those intrigued by what we do, who view psychohistory as the harbinger of new and better understanding about man’s historical motivations, and others who would be happy to see us gone. Some psychohistorians fantasize that this latter group is all around us, seeking our destruction. As with any fantasy, there is an element of truth, but

Page 83

most people are just not all that concerned about what we do or have to offer. Some of our work certainly provokes anxiety, but the best of our work is challenging and stimulating.

Psychohistory remains one of the great emotional and intellectual adventures open to modern scholars. It is an exciting field, full of growth and vitality. We have been busy doing psychohistory, trying to make the field viable, learning, and understanding. We have not paid enough attention to what it takes to do psychohistorical work. It is time to do otherwise.

Though we are able to trace our antecedents as far back as Freud and Dilthey, psychohistory is a relatively new field, pioneered by such scholars as Erik Erikson, Bruce Mazlish, Peter Loewenberg, George Kren, Lloyd deMause, David Beisel, Charles Strozier, and many others. Nonetheless, confusion about what psychohistory is still persists today. I define psychohistory as the interdisciplinary study of why human beings have acted as they have in history, prominently utilizing psychoanalytic principles. We do psychohistory because it offers new, deeper ways to understand historical motivation ways that go beyond what more traditional disciplines can offer. The interdisciplinary approach is needed so that we can utilize insights and evidence from all fields (especially psychoanalysis, history, anthropology, family systems theory, small and large group psychology) in our work. Many practitioners, including me, make strong use of psychoanalysis in our work because, despite all the efforts to question its tenets, it still offers the best way to understand human beings and what they are about.

Psychohistory is more interpretive than narrative, utilizing methods from varied fields to understand reasons why. It is built on the traditional disciplines; their insights are the building blocks with which we work. A psychohistorical approach is necessary because history has long been more concerned with questions of what happened rather than why it happened. Thus, psychohistory was born as a new field, independent of the limits and denials of traditional disciplinary thinking, to make the jump to the fuller understanding that we seek to achieve.

Our field is often accused of reductionism because we emphasize the primacy of emotion and fantasy, while our more tradi-

Page 84

tional colleagues still tend to focus on other factors such as political, social, intellectual, cultural, or economic events. More accurately, we seek explanatory bedrock. All of these other factors can be said to derive from emotion; denying this reality is essentially a defense to deny the reality of emotion in history, which can often be rather intense and anxiety-provoking. Taking these other factors into consideration is not wrong if we realize that they stem from emotion and do not use them in the service of denying that basic fact. Motives are exhibited by persons, either as individuals or acting together. Behaviors and motives are also essentially caused by emotions individually felt and/or experienced in shared contexts such as the family or a social group. Human beings are their own agents; motives are the expressions of their feelings.

Psychohistorians try to use the materials of traditional scholarship in new ways, plus material ignored or inadequately used. Data that we especially need, such as that about childhood or intimate emotional life, is often not as readily available as we would like it to be. We must be tenacious researchers, but this is not always enough. Like therapists with their patients, we must carefully use our own disciplined subjectivity our own countertransference as a major interpretive tool to understand the emotional meaning of our material.

In a sense, history is like our patient, but we seek to understand rather than to cure. Also, of course, we do not have a patient/therapist relationship. We cannot have a dialogue with the patient but, as Peter Loewenberg has noted, we do immerse ourselves in our data so that we can listen with as much sensitivity as we can muster to what the voice of history is trying to tell us. This is not simple and can be an emotionally draining enterprise.

For the psychohistorian, comprehension is an intellectual and emotional act. Traditional disciplines tend to intellectually comprehend and deny or downplay the importance of emotion, feeling, and fantasy as tools of understanding. All this said, what are the emotional/intellectual requirements for psychohistorical work? What does it take to be a psychohistorian?

Even after almost 50 years, there is still little training available for psychohistorians. What does exist is essentially informal,

Page 85

mainly consisting of scholars who meet together in study groups (e.g. The Psychohistory Forum and the online psychohistory discussion groups) or conferences (e.g. those offered by the International Psychohistorical Association) to present and discuss their work. We remain basically self-trained, often working in isolation; each of us reads the literature in accordance with his/her own needs or the dictates of whatever research we may be doing. This is one reason for the highly variable quality of psychohistorical scholarship. The literature that we need for our work is taken from many disciplines and may be difficult to locate. One reason I wrote The Psychohistorian’s Handbook (1988) was to help the aspiring scholar get some grounding in the literature of many fields and the principles of interdisciplinary research. It helps to have a sound background in one or more traditional disciplines e.g. history, psychoanalysis, anthropology, political science, etc. In psychohistory, it is crucial that the scholar be willing and able to make the jump beyond traditional disciplinary norms. This might be an act of considerable emotional and intellectual courage for some of us, but the dividend of a better quality of understanding is, in my experience at least, worth any price that might be involved.

People still ask if being psychoanalyzed is necessary for psychohistorical work. Some have argued, as I once did when I relied on self-analysis, that having an analysis is no guarantee of superior insight and not having one a guarantee of inferior work. Since psychohistory involves both intellectual and emotional comprehension, an analytic experience, if it is done well, helps us be more attuned to the importance of emotion, fantasy, dreams, etc. as motivating issues. Thus, if one has been analyzed it is likely that s/he will do higher quality psychohistorical work.

The psychohistorian must have a healthy, well-developed sense of curiosity. It must be intense enough to help us push beyond traditional disciplinary limits. Open-mindedness must stand with our curiosity. We should be aware of and respect the insights of traditional scholarship, but be comfortable with thinking for ourselves. It helps if the psychohistorian is something of a revolutionary, in the sense that the authority for what we seek to achieve comes not only from traditional thinking (our data) but, more importantly, from within ourselves in essence, from our own subjec-

Page 86

tivity/countertransference. Indeed, some complain that psychohistory embodies extreme subjectivity, ignoring the supposedly objective standards of traditional disciplines. Yet all scholars’ theories and explanations are significantly influenced by their life experiences. This is as important, if not more so, than supposedly objective frameworks. Psychohistorians know this and use our countertransference to what we study as a tool for enhanced comprehension. It would be an error to think that facts, insofar as they are ascertainable, do not matter to the psychohistorian. Quite the contrary! If we do not have a solid base of information, we have nothing to work from and build upon.

We must have the ability for deep introspection and the strength to tolerate anxiety. The subjects that we seek to study can often prove more complex and/or terrifying than originally expected or anticipated. Our material can evoke fearful emotions in both scholar and reader (this is one reason that Lloyd deMause’s work is so controversial to many). Some may feel provoked to run away from psychohistorical work due to anxiety and/or denial. This is unfortunate, and should be resisted as much as possible. It is important not to be easily intimidated. The more self-aware and disciplined the scholar can be, the better.

One can never expect to know everything necessary when doing interdisciplinary work. When confronted by something unknown in his/her research, the psychohistorian cannot give up. You must learn what you need to know to solve your problem. This is one reason why I have always felt that psychohistorical work should not be deadline driven. You need time to do this work. Still, it can also be easy to fall into the trap of perpetual study, because it seems like there is always something new. It is important to know when to draw the line in order to bring your project to a conclusion. Accept that you will never be able to be definitive.

Anyone wanting to do psychohistorical work must be a skilled researcher. You must be able to get around in a library on your own. Unfortunately, you cannot always count on the help of the librarian because, if for no other reason, most of them know little of our field and what it is about. Also, in today’s world, knowledge of the Internet is crucial. You need to know about search engines and how to use them. It is essential to have the imagination

Page 87

to vary the search terms. You may need to try a number of different ones before you get useful information. Due to the fact that the quality of Internet information can be highly variable, it is often necessary to check the material against other sources for accuracy. However, the Internet can also be a veritable treasure trove of primary source material. There are a number of vast digital libraries of primary material that can be downloaded for free by the enterprising scholar. Both in the library and on the Internet, the important thing is to have the imagination and tenacity to seek out what you want to know. If you can do this, you will find there is virtually nothing that you cannot find out something about.

In conclusion, I encourage people to study psychohistory because it is one of the great emotional and intellectual adventures open to modern scholars. It is underappreciated despite the important work done by pioneers in our field that is more interpretive than narrative. We use the materials of traditional scholarship differently; mostly with a greater emphasis on emotion, fantasy, and the researchers’ own feelings. Very important for psychohistorical work is a healthy, a well-developed sense of curiosity, deep introspection, the ability to tolerate anxiety, an openness to different ideas, good research skills, an ability to work on your own, and trusting one’s own authority. When done well, our scholarship is as good as any other field while providing unique insights. What we offer is one of the great emotional and intellectual adventures still open to those interested in the pursuit of the life of the mind.

[Editor’s Note: Jason Lawton provided this and the following file, last accessed by Henry on June 20, 2012, for publication.]

Page 88

About the author

Henry Lawton

Henry Lawton, M A, MLS (1941-2014), spent his paid career  (from 1971-2002) as a Family Service Specialist with the New Jersey Division of Youth and Family Services,  but psychohistory was his passion. He served as founding co-director of the Psychohistory Forum until he decided to devote his time to the Group for the Psychohistorical Study of Film as its founder. Henry was also the extraordinarily devoted secretary and then president of the International Psychohistorical Association (now the IPhA) carrying out the duties of secretary, even when in enormous pain and confined to a wheelchair. Lawton was a prolific scholar who also wrote The Psychohistorian’s Handbook (1988).

How to cite this article

Lawton, H. (2014). Doing psychohistory. Clio’s Psyche, 21(1), 83-88.

https://doi.org/10.70763/e0c7ccc47b2613c82d1073a4214deecc

PDF downloads