
Volume 02 - Number 4 - March 1996
Pages: 73 - 100
Lentz, B. (1996). The environmental psychohistory of J. Donald Hughes [Interview]. Clio’s Psyche, 2(4), 85-88.
The Environmental Psychohistory of J. Donald Hughes
Abstract
This interview with J. Donald Hughes, John Evans Professor of History at the University of Denver, covers his work in psychohistory and environmental history. Hughes defines psychohistory as understanding history through psychological insight. He recounts coming to it through Jungian analysis and his article “The Dreams of Alexander the Great,” for which he selected six dreams from reliable ancient sources. He maintains that human nature has changed little over the millennia. He cautions that interpreting Native American dreams and visions is difficult because the material usually reaches readers through non-Indian sources, and says the widely quoted Chief Seattle letter was written around 1970 by a film scriptwriter. He defines environmental history as the study of human interaction with nature, argues that humans are part of nature rather than apart from it, and reports finding little correlation between professed attitudes toward nature and actual behavior. He describes his path into the field through forestry, a history doctorate, the founding of the American Society for Environmental History, and his editorship of Environmental History Review, and he discusses his book Pan’s Travail. He surveys environmental attitudes and damage in ancient Egypt, China, the Judeo-Christian and European tradition, and Native American societies, proposing that Lynn White’s medieval thesis does not go back far enough. Hughes concludes that understanding of humanity’s relation to nature has lagged behind technology, and suggests psychology may be needed alongside ethical and religious teaching.
Alexander the Great, Charles Darwin, Ecological Consciousness, ecology, Environmental History Review, environmental psychohistory, human-environment relationships, interview, J. Donald Hughes, Journal of Psychohistory (JOP), Jungian psychology, North American Indian Ecology, Pan’s Travail: Environmental Problems of the Ancient Greeks and Romans, Sequoia National Park, sustainable agriculture
J. Donald Hughes was born in 1932 in Santa Monica, California. He is John Evans Professor of History at the University of Denver where he teaches ancient and environmental history. He is the author of Pan’s Travail: Environmental Problems of the Ancient Greeks and Romans (Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press, 1994), North American Indian Ecology, rev. 2d ed., (El Paso: Texas Western Press, 1996), “The Dreams of Alexander the Great,” Journal of Psychohistory 12(2) (Fall 1984): 168-192, and co-editor with Robert C. Schultz of the anthology Ecological Consciousness (Washington: University Press of America, 1981). He is past editor of Environmental History Review, past president of the C.G. Jung Society of Colorado, and a frequent contributor to this publication. He was interviewed in his office at the University of Denver.
Clio’s Psyche (CP): How do you define psychohistory?
J. Donald Hughes (JDH): It’s the endeavor to understand history with the insights that come from psychology. There are some who would say that in studying psychology you’re moving inward, and in studying history, outward. But I see it the other way around. Psychology helps me to think about the problem of motivation in history, and history helps me understand who I am.
CP: How did you come to psychohistory?
JDH: Mainly through my work in Jungian psychology. In 1978 I went into personal analysis for two years and read everything I could on the subject. It enabled me to discover an immense treasure of nature that’s in the inner life.
I had a colleague whose field was the American West, but his particular interest was alcoholism. He had been an alcoholic and became interested in tracing examples of alcoholism in history. He showed me an article on it that had appeared in the Journal of Psychohistory and said, “Look, this journal is interesting.” I decided that was where I could send my article on the dreams of Alexander the Great, the first psychohistorical paper that I had written. I sent it and got a letter back from Paul Elovitz saying he was interested in the article, and would I give it at the 1984 International Psychohistorical Association (IPA) Convention in New York City. I was very honored by that and did present, and found the other papers and sessions so relevant, so alive.
CP: Of which of your psychohistorical works are you most proud?
JDH: The article, “The Dreams of Alexander the Great.” It’s a historical paper about dreams that are recorded for Alexander. It required my finding all the dreams ascribed to him — a great number, and winnowing out the ones he might actually have had, that come from reliable sources. I ended up with six dreams for which I thought one could make a good case. They’re recorded in the same way as his other actions, often in more than one source, and they use images and symbols that we could expect in ancient dreams. I tried to see what those images and symbols would have meant to someone growing up in his time and community.
CP: Can we here in the 20th century be empathic with people who lived millennia ago?
JDH: Yes. I don’t think that human nature has changed all that much. I judge that because, being an ancient historian, I read a lot of ancient literature, and find the authors reflecting the same emotions, talking about many of the same issues as we still do today
CP: Why should historians study dreams?
JDH: Because we are interested in why people do things in history; what their motivation is. Dreams are a way of getting at that because people often make decisions not by rationally thinking things through but from unconscious motivation. And Freud said it right, didn’t he?: “Dreams are the royal road to the unconscious.”
CP: How do you feel about attempts to take archival North American Indian dreams or visions and interpret them as having meaning for today?
JDH: I have written some books on American Indian history and I have read a lot
Page 85
of American Indian mythology. It seems extremely difficult for anyone who has not carefully studied the culture of the particular tribal group where the dream or vision occurs to put him- or herself into that way of thought and to see what these images mean. A further problem with American Indian mythology is that it almost always comes to us through a non-Indian source because Indians didn’t ordinarily write these things down. So, it’s already been put through a cultural filter that takes away some of the original meaning. Even worse, sometimes the texts weren’t really given by Indians at all. One of the most famous cases is the supposed letter of Chief Seattle to the President in Washington, DC. It’s quoted everywhere — even Joseph Campbell quotes it. But it wasn’t written by an Indian at all! It was written about 1970 by a nature film scriptwriter.
CP: How do you define environmental history?
JDH: Generally, it’s the investigation of human interaction with nature in history.
CP: Do we need to distinguish between “environment” and “ecology”?
JDH: Yes, we do. Ecology is a scientific discipline. Environment means nature in general, everything that is around us. I do have an argument with the way the word “environment” is commonly used to make a distinction between the human and the nonhuman. I don’t like to do that; I see us as part of nature. Someone told me this joke at a recent IPA meeting, “You know what the Buddhist said to the hot dog vendor? ‘Make me one with everything!”‘ But we are one with everything. We don’t get made one — we are. So, environment as something separate, as something that we can treat as people do — as a set of natural resources, as “out there”, as the non-self — I have a problem with.
Our attitudes, if they were functional, would be developing in relation to the whole earth. We can have a dinner tonight that has food from five continents. If local production is not sufficient we can get it from somewhere else. We have fruit all year because we get it from Chile. So, our relationship is to the biosphere — to the whole earth. We have to realize that we are part of that. I think Darwin once said it: We are a branch of the tree. We’re connected with the rest of it and we’re in competition with other nearby branches for survival. But, if the tree dies, we and all the other branches die. Everything that we have has to be drawn from the totality of the tree. Some realization of that — some identification of ourselves with all of nature, with the earth — has to be made.
CP: Is there a psychological component to environmental history?
JDH: There certainly is — our attitudes and values and behavior toward nature. Is there a relationship between the way people regard nature — or at least the way they say they regard it — and what they actually do? I have found less correlation between the two than I would like to have thought. Major religions, for instance, have rather strong views about how we ought to treat nature. Yet, when you look at the way their followers treat the environment, you see they cause a lot of damage.
Ecologists know that if certain things happen it’s going to be very bad for some of the species in the ecosystem. One danger is overpopulation. If we have one species zooming forward numerically, ecologists tell us that a crash is coming down the road. It’s a simple ecological principle. We can apply it to rabbits, foxes, and ants. But, of course, we dare not apply it to human beings! A lot of the things we do are not ecologically functional. They are not in our own self-interest. I agree with Socrates who, when he was accused of corrupting the youth of Athens, said, “No, I can’t corrupt the youth because if I did I would be making my city a worse place in which to live.” This is the way I feel about the community of the ecosystem. If we do something to make it a worse place, we harm ourselves.
CP: Of which of your environmental history books are you most proud?
JDH: The most recent one, Pan’s Travail. It deals with what happened in terms of human-environment relationships in Greece and Rome.
CP: What are you working on now?
JDH: A book that will deal with specific human-environmental problems in all periods of world history, how they evolved, and the lack of care societies have given to ecological process and balance. Hopefully it’ll be finished sometime late in 1996 and published by Routledge.
CP: Of which of your other
Page 86
environmental history achievements are you most proud?
JDH: I was editor for three years of what was then Environmental Review, now Environmental History Review. I inherited it from John Opie, now at the New Jersey Institute of Technology, and added several artistic touches. I tried to make it less exclusively an American historical publication and to add more on world history.
CP: What brought you to environmental history?
JDH: I think it was my checkered academic career. After studying forestry and botanical genetics, I went on and got my PhD in history at Boston University. But I decided that I wanted to try to bridge my interests in history and biology, and my interest in teaching eventually came to the ancient world.
Just at the time that my first article came out in 1975, a few historians held an informal meeting at a conference in Denver to talk about this very thing: environmental history. Maybe the most important voice at the time was Will Jacobs, who had just published a comment in the American Historical Association Newsletter [November, 1970, 5-11]: “Frontiersmen, Fur Traders and Other Varmints.” It critiqued the environmental effects of the westward movement in American history. And there were Don Worster, John Opie, Rod Nash, and Carolyn Merchant. In 1976 we founded the American Society for Environmental History and started publishing Environmental Review.
CP: Was there anything in your family background that put you on the road to environmental history?
JDH: Yes — the Boy Scouts, and my father. He was scoutmaster of Troop 8 during the Second World War. Because of the nature of the group’s activities, he got permission to buy gasoline to take us up to Sequoia National Park at a time when virtually no Americans were traveling. We spent eighteen days that first summer among the big trees. I really got a feeling for a part of nature that had been preserved for coming generations. And that fed my interest in working for the Forest Service and the National Park Service, which I later did for twelve, maybe fifteen, summers. That trip was definitely a psychological, even a spiritual, experience.
CP: Were there other individuals who were important to your development?
JDH: There were a number of writers whom I found influential. For example, John Muir, the early conservationist. I remember his books on his experiences in the Sierra Nevada well; I read them after my first summer in the Sierra. Wonderful 19th century prose! Also, John Wesley Powell and Aldo Leopold — and Robert Frost, whom I did meet one time. I had read all of his books — there’s a lot of nature in his poetry. It’s not, strictly speaking, environmentalist, but it relates to the American landscape in an important way.
CP: How do you view environmental education?
JDH: I teach classes in environmental history, a subject that is not part of the typical environmental studies programs which are made up of biologists and geographers. I think environmental education ought to start as soon as possible so that children can form an appreciation of nature that will help them to make the right decisions. I see the destructive attitudes that occur in people who see an animal and want to shoot it. Those come from childhood experiences and attitudes, whether in the city, the suburbs, or rural places.
CP: How would you describe the environmental psychohistory of the ancient Egyptians?
JDH: The Egyptians were what I would call a bioregional people. They found a niche for themselves within their own dependable environment. The agriculture that they practiced cooperated with the regime that they found in their environment, so we have one of the cases in history of sustainable agriculture. They connected this with their gods who are all nature figures of one sort or another, mostly birds and other animals. At the same time, they had environmental problems, in a pattern that we can trace over the years. They gradually drained all the marshes and removed the forests. By the end of the ancient world both the crocodile and the hippopotamus were extinct in Egypt. And they were worshipping both of those animals — Sobek the crocodile god and Taweret the hippopotamus goddess. They continued to worship sacred trees; they planted them in the temples next to sacred lakes. It’s a problem, isn’t it? How can you have such an affirmative attitude toward the environment and still do things that bring animals to extinction?
Page 87
CP: What about ancient China?
JDH: They had some very interesting ethical teachings. The Taoists felt that nature should be untouched and the wise man will live simply in nature. The Confucian idea is that of civilized society, of relating to other human beings in the proper way. I find Mencius combines both, and it’s an attractive pairing. The Chinese do seem to have a pragmatic way of relating to the world. It’s not so strongly religious, it’s more like a way of life. But Chinese devastation of their own environment, even in early times, is quite noticeable. Mencius himself talks about it: The Ox Mountain was deforested by people who lived in the city nearby and Mencius said, “People say, ‘Look at this mountain. It’s a bare mountain. The nature of the mountain is bare.’ But if they knew the whole story, they would know that it isn’t — that its nature is to bear forests. And it’s because of the human use of it that it has been deforested.” What is the conclusion of that argument? That human nature is basically good, and that when human nature appears to be evil, it’s because it has been somehow perverted away from its true self. So, Mencius reaches a psychological conclusion: You always have hope of making people better because they are basically good. In modern China there’s probably a legacy from this thought of Mencius, although the officials might not acknowledge it. Certainly that attitude doesn’t go against Marxism, which believes human beings can be educated to be economically good.
CP: And the Judeo-Christian, European legacy? Lynn White wrote an article in the mid-seventies on Europeans’ taking the “dominion over” concept too far.
JDH: Lynn White was the grand old man of the Medievalist school, so he wanted to claim for the Middle Ages the responsibility for the bad attitudes that caused our present environmental crisis. Medieval Christendom taught that God is not in nature, it desacralized the natural world and left human beings free to do anything they wanted to it. That idea encouraged the growth of the modern scientific attitude. So, today, whether we are market capitalists or socialists, we are still treating the world as a Medieval philosopher would have. Maybe White was right as far as he went, but he didn’t go back far enough because you can find the roots of the same attitudes in Aristotle. And one might even trace the divorce of nature from the spiritual back to early monotheistic groups. In the Old Testament, when you go into a foreign land, you burn down its sacred groves because you ought not to confuse God with nature.
CP: And the environmental psychohistory of the American Indians?
JDH: They had incredible respect for various elements of nature they had come into contact with, and that reflects itself in the unspoiled condition of the North American continent when it was discovered by Europeans. But when you look at those Indians who achieved a level of urban civilization, such as the Aztecs and the Mayas, you do see environmental damage, things getting out of balance, not in accord with the announced religious or ethical ideas of the people.
So, there’s something about the inherent logic of technology: when we get to the level of urban concentrations of people and a certain level of use of the elements that are within nature, we do seem to cross some sort of line. Non-urban Indians were on one side, and we’re on the other. The line is between the world where humans feel they belong and the world where they don’t, where they adopt a hostile approach and feel they have to conquer.
CP: We’ve crossed the technology threshold? The more technology we have, the more “advanced” and “developed” we become, the farther away we get from nature?
JDH: Yes. And our ability to see ourselves in relation to nature has not kept up with our technological advancement. It’s in the balancing of technology with nature, and in the ecological process. We are so terribly out of balance. We may need something other than just ethical or religious teachings to get us on the right track — something from the field of psychology. I’m just not sure what.
Page 88
How to cite this article
Lentz, B. (1996). The environmental psychohistory of J. Donald Hughes [Interview]. Clio’s Psyche, 2(4), 85-88.



