
Volume 26 - Number 2 - Winter 2020
Pages: 127 - 263
SYMPOSIUM ON MALE REFLECTIONS ON SEX AND POWER
Logue, J. (2020). A female perspective on sex and power. Clio’s Psyche, 26(2), 222-225.
A Female Perspective on Sex and Power
Abstract
This response article, part of the symposium on male reflections on sex and power, replies to David Lotto’s opening essay, “A Male Perspective on Sex and Power in the Age of #MeToo.” Writing from her clinical practice and personal experience, the author agrees with Lotto on several points. She maintains that #MeToo is progress toward gender equality, that research on dominance, authoritarianism, and belief in traditional sex roles bears on motives for sexual assault, that many women are ambivalent about using sexual power, and that punishing men without due process is a harmful consequence. She notes that the #HimToo movement has been revived in response. She adds that money, status, and political connections increase male impunity, and she cites Brett Kavanaugh, Clarence Thomas, Donald Trump, Bill Clinton, and Jeffrey Epstein as men whose institutional support makes change unlikely. She disagrees with Lotto on the power of refusal, contending that he overestimates how far a woman’s “no” protects her, given threats to livelihood and family that deter reporting. She argues that girls and women need education in setting limits and voicing refusal, and that men need to learn to respect them. She proposes that American group psychology denies loss and skips over grieving. She concludes that gender equality stalls unless the losses it entails are acknowledged, as she says Phyllis Schlafly understood in opposing the Equal Rights Amendment, and protections are established.
#HimToo movement, #MeToo movement, feminism, feminist psychoanalysis, gender dynamics, gender equality, Harvey Weinstein, manhood, psychohistory, sexual assault, sexual predator
#MeToo
The #MeToo movement disrupts previous perspectives and displaces our earlier understanding and behavior regarding gender relations in America. It promotes awareness of sexual harassment and sexual assault. Its popularization occurred after the allegations of sexual abuse against Harvey Weinstein in the fall of 2017.
The thought-provoking introduction highlights the important controversy: does the #MeToo ideology value victimization and puritanical American sexual mores? Does it de-emphasize women’s agency and autonomy?
The #MeToo movement is progress because it exposes the real fears and harmful consequences of the sexual harassment and assault of girls and women. It attempts to further gender equality. It highlights female ambivalence and ignorance about sexuality, which requires education and cultural change. It heightens awareness of male victims of sexual harassment and leads us to urge we separate male perpetrators from good men. The intense media attention in 2019 to how to define and promote positive manhood might not have occurred without the #MeToo movement.
Why Do They Do It?
Dr. Lotto supports his ideas with research on motivation for sexual assault. Research demonstrates the relevance of the personality characteristics of dominance and authoritarianism, lack of empathy, and a belief in traditional sex roles combined with impunity for masculine sexual assault. Lotto insightfully adds the psychological dynamic of anger, resentment, and hostility because of lack of sexual power in the initiation of the sexual relationship. He emphasizes the impulse to “turn the tables” on women for revenge at being rebuffed.
I would add that money, social status, and political connections contribute to increased male impunity. Sociocultural factors intersect with emotional and mental conflicts. Drug and alcohol abuse, economic pressures (e.g. impoverishment or job failure), and
Page 222
domestic conflict may be both cause and effect. Pain and suffering, physical and family illness, and chronic anxiety and depression may lead a man (or a woman) to seek relief and distraction with sexual predatory behavior.
Female Power
The sexual power of women “has always been well-known.” In the past 50 years, it has been socially acceptable if not mandated for women to use their sexually-based power to get ahead in the workplace, whether in the professions, educational institutions, manufacturing companies and factories, or small businesses.
What is new—and concurrent with the depathologizing of homosexuality and increased acceptance of all genders and LGBTQ communities—is that this is now questioned. “Slut-shaming” has increased against girls and women who make use of their sexual power for opportunistic goals. Dr. Lotto’s most valuable contribution is his recognition that “many women do have a great deal of ambivalence and reluctance to make use of this power.”
The changes in actual practice, in the larger political system, in psychoanalysis, and in individual psychology have been a disappointment. Girls and women—of any sexual orientation—remain too ambivalent, insufficiently educated, and uncertain about how to take responsibility for their sexuality. Until we educate girls and women, and change our culture, gender equality remains elusive.
Progress requires we encourage girls and women of all races and classes to be more confident; we teach them how to set limits without shame or shaming; we ensure they are listened to and heard by family and authorities; and we support them in effecting consequences and punishment when appropriate.
So long as rich and well-connected predators, like Brett Kavanaugh, Clarence Thomas, President Trump, former President Clinton, and Jeffrey Epstein have the support of the Justice Department, politicians, and celebrities, there is no reason to believe much will change. Even if the sociocultural pendulum expectably swings—and whether unconscious group aggression is on the surface or beneath the surface—human nature and sexuality will still ensure conflict, controversy, and gender wars!
Feminism vs. Femininism
David Lotto calls it an “inconvenient fact” that many women are complicit with patriarchy. As a professional woman, wife,
Page 223
mother, and grandmother, I can attest to the benefits of patriarchy. I can also detail the costs of women’s liberation. When feminists acknowledge the losses—not just the gains—inherent in the fight for gender equality, we have a greater chance of achieving it.
I have argued for decades that we need to be emotionally honest about the costs of gender equality. We need to empathize with contemporary women like Phyllis Schlafly, who derailed and defeated the Equal Rights Amendment (ERA) for which I have fought strongly. When we join our sisters, “pussy power” has a chance to promote positive human values for all genders.
The Power of No
Dr. Lotto is right that women are often in control of what does or does not happen. It is unfair to expect him to have the experience of a young inexperienced woman who is threatened that her life, or the life of her family, or her job that supports her family, or her dream career will be in jeopardy if she reports her rape or assault.
Almost every woman in my life knows personally of such a female experience, if she herself has not endured them. I have decades of experience with both patients and strong women professionals who have had to debate whether to report a predator or pedophile or face the expected censure and losses that accompany reporting. Dr. Lotto overestimates the power of “no” from a girl or woman to keep her safe from emotional or actual harm.
Crime and Punishment
Dr. Lotto is incisive and accurate about crime and punishment. Extremism in the direction of punishment of men without due process is an unintended and harmful consequence. Fortunately, the #HimToo movement from 2015 has been revived to address the valid concerns about male victims, the inappropriate loss of jobs and careers, public humiliation, and unfair criminal prosecution.
On Ambivalence
To my dismay, girls and women—of any sexual orientation—today still appear too ambivalent about their sexuality, insufficiently educated about sexuality, and uncertain about how to take responsibility for their sexuality. Boys and men are also uncertain about whether to be protective and caring of girls and women or to treat them as competitors. Increasingly, young men discuss concerns about aggressive and predatory women and how to protect themselves from them.
Page 224
In my clinical practice, I continue to be surprised, though no longer shocked, when many girls and women do not know their feelings about lust, sex, and love, and how to responsibly set limits. This too often leads to traumatizing encounters with psychological and physiological effects. It hurts men, too.
It is a difficult challenge to teach women and girls how to firmly say “yes” or “no” without shaming others. We need to learn how to teach women and girls to respond in sexual encounters without frozen immobility. We also need to instill confidence and assertiveness that prevents them from deferring inappropriately. It is essential that we teach women how to explain in words—and how to set limits—when their erotic excitement has turned to ambivalence and refusal. At the same time, we need to teach men how to respect and abide by what a woman says she does not want.
Psychoanalytic Contributions
A psychoanalytic perspective can be helpful. I most appreciate Dr. Lotto’s emphasis on contemporary adult fantasies and motives, not only on the “developmental tilt” or the power of the nurturing caretaker, who is usually the mother.
An additional observation is that denial of loss and skipping or jumping quickly to solutions—without attention to grieving—are typical of our American group psychology. When women—and men too—address the individual, social, and cultural losses that accompany the shifts required for gender equality, we have a better chance of maximizing the upsides, while acknowledging the downsides.
Conclusion
When Phyllis Schlafly fought against the ERA, she understood well the loss of protections for women in a patriarchal society. Unless or until we understand, acknowledge, and accept the losses caused by these changes—and establish protections—we risk unintentional consequences if not harm. We also stall progress for gender equality, soul and mental health, and civil rights.
Page 225
How to cite this article
Logue, J. (2020). A female perspective on sex and power. Clio’s Psyche, 26(2), 222-225.



