Volume 07 - Number 3 - December 2000
Pages: 102 - 164

THE PSYCHOLOGY OF CONSPIRACY THEORIES

Lotto, D. (2000). Hofstadter revisited: How conspiracy theories and paranoia have become mainstream. [Review of the books Paranoia Within Reason: A Casebook on Conspiracy as Explanation by George Marcus (1999), Fear Itself: Enemies Real and Imagined in American Culture by Nancy Schultz (1999), and Empire of Conspiracy: The Culture of Paranoia in Postwar America by Timothy Melley (2000)]. Clio’s Psyche, 7(3), 115-117.

https://doi.org/10.70763/1592104031ceaa405b8a103c399e2633

Hofstadter Revisited: How Conspiracy Theories and Paranoia Have Become

book review

Abstract

This review considers three recent books on paranoia and conspiracy theory in contemporary Western culture: George Marcus’s edited collection Paranoia Within Reason: A Casebook on Conspiracy as Explanation (1999), Nancy Schultz’s edited collection Fear Itself: Enemies Real and Imagined in American Culture (1999), and Timothy Melley’s Empire of Conspiracy: The Culture of Paranoia in Postwar America (2000). The author notes that none is overtly psychohistorical and sets out to extend their explanations from a psychohistorical perspective. The review reports Melley’s thesis that postwar American novelists and social critics share a view of individuals as subject to external forces beyond their control, which he terms agency panic. It notes Corey Robin’s comparable account of intellectual anxiety over lost autonomy. It also reports Peter Knight’s essay “A Plague of Paranoia: Theories of Conspiracy Theory Since the 1960’s.” Knight contends that the mainstream consensus from which Richard Hofstadter wrote “The Paranoid Style in American Politics” (1965) no longer exists and that conspiracy theories have become mainstream. He and Marcus point to the Cold War and the national security state as formative. The author judges agency panic explanations incomplete and proposes analyzing the fantasy content of particular conspiracy theories, reading them as metaphorical expressions of real influence by governments, corporations, and international institutions. The author attributes the current intensity to widespread mystification through advertising, public relations, and spin, together with a tendency toward projection. The author concludes that a full explanation requires attention to both history and psyche.

Keywords:

conspiracy theories, essay review, Fear Itself: Enemies Real and Imagined in American Culture, George Marcus, Paranoia Within Reason: A Casebook on Conspiracy as Explanation, psychoanalysis, psychohistory, Richard Hofstadter, Timothy Melley, Empire of Conspiracy: The Culture of Paranoia in Postwar America

This essay will briefly review three recent books on the subject of paranoia and conspiracy theories in contemporary thought: George Marcus’ edited collection, Paranoia Within Reason: A Casebook on Conspiracy as Explanation (1999), Nancy Schultz’s edited collection, Fear Itself: Enemies Real and Imagined in American Culture (1999), and Timothy Melley’s Empire of Conspiracy: The Culture of Paranoia in Postwar America (2000). None of the books is overtly psychohistorical but they do address topics and questions which are central to the concerns of psychohistorians. What I will do is look at the explanations suggested by some of the authors represented in these books and then try to expand some of these explanations from a psychohistorical perspective.

Melley’s Empire of Conspiracy presents the thesis that since World War II there has been a boom in conspiratorial ways of viewing events in Western thought and culture. He focuses mainly on novelists and social critics. He argues that the novels of William Burroughs, Joseph Heller, Norman Mailer, Thomas Pynchon, Kurt Vonnegut, Ken Kesey, Joan Didion, Margaret Atwood, and William Gibson, among others, all share an essentially paranoid view of the world. By this he means that these novels are populated by characters who are the victims of external forces which are both beyond their control and full understanding. He does not address the more overtly conspiratorial fiction such as The Turner Diaries

Page 115

(1978), or the literature on UFOs, alien abduction, or satanic ritual abuse. [Editor’s Note: See “A Portrait of the Conspiratorial and Revenge Fantasies,” p. 138, for a discussion of The Turner Diaries.]

In the area of social criticism Melley discusses various important books that have nourished conspiratorial and paranoid ways of understanding the world, some of which include Norbert Wiener’s Cybernetics (1948), David Riesman’s The Lonely Crowd (1950), William Whyte’s The Organization Man (1956), Vance Packard’s The Hidden Persuaders (1951), Herbert Marcuse’s One Dimensional Man (1964), Charles Reich’s The Greening of America (1970), and Michel Foucault’s books of the 1970s and 1980s: Discipline and Punish (1977), The History of Sexuality, 3 vols., (1978-1986), and Madness and Civilization, (1988).

What all of these commentaries have in common is that they share an awareness of the individual’s sense of loss of control over major aspects of life. Melley calls this “agency panic” which he defines as “anxiety over the way technologies, social organizations, [chiefly government and corporate bureaucracies], and communication systems have reduced human autonomy and uniqueness” (p. 7).

Corey Robin, one of the contributors in Schultz’s Fear Itself, similarly focuses on what he calls a “near hysteria among intellectuals” over threats to and loss of the individual’s autonomy and freedom (p. 17).

From a psychohistorical perspective the most interesting article in the Schultz collection is by Peter Knight, a British academician who writes on conspiracy culture, entitled A Plague of Paranoia: Theories of Conspiracy Theory Since the 1960’s. Using Hofstatder’s classic paper, “The Paranoid Style in American Politics,” published in 1965, as a launching point, Knight argues that much has changed since that time. Whereas Hofstader could speak from a liberal, rationalist, and mainstream position about the excesses of the right-wing lunatic fringe, Knight contends that this mainstream consensus no longer exists. As he says: “No longer can the consumption of conspiracy narratives be understood simply as evidence of a paranoid mentality” (p. 28). In his view, conspiracy theories have become mainstream.

Knight, as well as George Marcus, anthropologist and editor of Paranoia Within Reason, among others, has pointed to the Cold War and the establishment of the national security state in the United States, as key historical events which have shaped the creation and acceptance of paranoid and conspiratorial consciousness in the post-World War II period.

Knight cites Frederic Jameson’s aphorism that “‘conspiracy is the poor person’s cognitive mapping in the postmodern age’” (p. 49). This is a good starting point from which to build a psychohistorical account of the phenomenon of the proliferation of “conspiracy consciousness.” [Editor’s Note: See Peter Knight’s new article in this issue, p. 106.]

As Freud has said, there is usually a kernel of truth contained in even the wildest of delusions. If we attempt to explore conspiracy theories as a psychoanalyst would look at a dream, we would want to ask: What piece of truth is being expressed metaphorically by this way of viewing the world? So, for example, theories about being manipulated and controlled by powerful external forces, be they small gray aliens, ZOG (Zionist Occupational Government), NWO (New World Order), or devil-worshipping satanists, might be seen as a symbolic expression of the fact that we are being influenced by powerful external forces including multinational corporations and the governments that act as agents for them, to say nothing of WTO, IMF, and CIA. I am suggesting that using a psychohistorical method, essentially a form of fantasy analysis of the content of any particular conspiracy theory, will give us the best understanding of the popularity of conspiracy consciousness.

The analysis presented by Melley, Robin, and others which views the expansion of conspiracy consciousness as resulting from “agency panic” or hysteria over fear of loss of autonomy is fine as far as it goes, but psychohistory needs to look deeper. Freedom and autonomy are threatened, but the crucial question is: What are the real sources of these threats and why is our anxiety about them at such a high level at this time?

In connection to the question of why now, there seems to have been a qualitative shift in the nature of the threat to our autonomy. Being subject to the influence and control of powerful forces that don’t particularly have our best interests at heart is not a new phenomenon. But in times gone by we mostly knew who the oppressors were and what they were up to. Colonialism was pretty transparent. So was slavery, the exploitative actions of the robber barons, and the military goals of Nazi Germany. What is different now is the degree

Page 116

of mystification which has become standard operating procedure. Advertising, public relations, marketing, spin, double-talk and doublethink have become far more prevalent than they have been in the past. As so many of the novelists discussed by Melley are fond of emphasizing, we are so often puzzled about who, exactly, it is and how, exactly, they are doing it to us. This is fertile ground for nurturing theories and beliefs that abolish the uncertainty and give us the answers.

We seem to have a built-in affinity for the use of projective mechanisms. When we are anxious, disturbed, fearful, or guilty, we seem to move easily into a search for something external on which to blame our discomfort. Thus, scapegoating, moral panics, hysterias, and conspiracy theories flourish.

A full psychohistorical explanation involves looking at the influence of both history (the external) and the psyche (the internal). When a particular form of conspiracy theory or hysteria captures the popular imagination it is most likely because it resonates with both powerful internal anxieties and potent external realities.

Page 117

About the author

David Lotto

David Lotto, PhD, is a veteran psychologist, psychoanalyst, and psychohistorian who is a longtime member of the Psychohistory Forum. He practices psychotherapy in Western Massachusetts, edits The Journal of Psychohistory, and may be reached at .

How to cite this article

Lotto, D. (2000). Hofstadter revisited: How conspiracy theories and paranoia have become mainstream. [Review of the books Paranoia Within Reason: A Casebook on Conspiracy as Explanation by George Marcus (1999), Fear Itself: Enemies Real and Imagined in American Culture by Nancy Schultz (1999), and Empire of Conspiracy: The Culture of Paranoia in Postwar America by Timothy Melley (2000)]. Clio’s Psyche, 7(3), 115-117.

https://doi.org/10.70763/1592104031ceaa405b8a103c399e2633

PDF downloads