
Volume 14 - Number 4 - March 2008
Pages: 105 - 159
Lotto, D. (2008). Rejoinder to Elovitz. Clio’s Psyche, 14(4), 144-146.
Rejoinder to Elovitz
Abstract
In this response article in the journal’s Presidential Election Dialogue, on whether presidential elections and the personalities of leaders make a difference, the author replies to Paul H. Elovitz’s “Leaders and Psychobiographical Studies Make a Difference,” which answered the author’s lead essay, “Tweedledum and Tweedledee: Why Presidential Elections are Irrelevant.” He disputes Elovitz’s belief that a Gore administration would have differed markedly from Bush’s on the environment. He points to Bill Clinton’s leadership of the Democratic Leadership Council and its market-based approach, and to Al Gore’s record as senator and vice president, which he says environmental groups largely opposed. He maintains that campaign finance makes officeholders dependent on corporate donors, that the requirements of getting elected matter more than a candidate’s personality or character, and that the best-funded candidate usually wins. He reads Nixon’s 1968 nomination victory over Rockefeller as a contest between rival groups of financial backers, and says this view is common in left-leaning and progressive periodicals. He clarifies that he does not claim leaders are irrelevant. In his account, they act within limits set by a mainstream consensus on corporate capitalism, American conduct abroad, and the role of government. He also questions the democratizing effect of internet communication, citing an article in The Nation on e-mail rumors about Obama in the 2008 campaign and the 2004 Swift Boat campaign, and concludes that such technology weakens democracy.
Al Gore, Bill Clinton, Buckley v. Valeo, Democratic Leadership Council (DLC), free-market capitalism, globalization, market-based solutions, Paul Elovitz, political process, privatized healthcare, psychohistory, Social Security, U.S. presidency
Actually, Paul Elovitz is wrong. He appears to be suffering from an all too common case of optimistic naivete: too much seeing the glass half-full when it is really just about empty. Bill Clinton, the man from Hope, who opened an office in Harlem after the ignominious end of his administration, was the president of the Democratic Leadership Council (DLC) in 1990 and 1991. He was consistently loyal to one of the cornerstones of the DLC credo: the belief in and reliance on “market-based solutions” in all things. Clinton (and his vice president, Al Gore) were always supporters of free-trade agreements and globalization, charter schools, a privatized healthcare system, and even the partial privatization of Social Security. Free-market capitalism and its corollary that money must be given its say in the political proc-
Page 144
ess (supported by the Supreme Court’s Buckley v. Valeo decision in 1976), is as much a position of the centrist DLC, and of all the current front-running Democratic candidates, as it is of the Republicans.
With regard to Dr. Elovitz’s “considered belief’ that things would have been so much better under a Gore administration compared to Bush’s, for example, that there would not be the current “blatant disregard for the environment,” Google “Al Gore, Record on the Environment” and explore the Websites that come up which show the actual positions Gore took when he was in power as a senator and vice president. Most were vehemently opposed by the environmental community and many of which have increased greenhouse gas-fed global warming.
The fact that Gore can take the positions he now does on the environment, which are so different from those he took when he was in office, is no accident. Gore’s personality and character matter much less than the requirements of getting elected and remaining in office. The euphemistic spin put on this kind of political behavior is that politicians must compromise and settle for a little bit of what they want or get nothing at all. I would prefer to call it what it is, that office holders are virtually totally beholden and subservient to the interests of their corporate sponsors, who may toss a few scraps to the non-rich to prevent them from getting too restive in the face of their exploitation.
In our current political system in the United States, money rules. To not acknowledge this reality is to be in serious denial. As long as candidates require the massive amounts of cash that they do to effectively influence elections, they need to accede to the wishes of the corporations which are making the donations. And their wishes are straightforward: they are obligated to seek to maximize their profits thereby satisfying their fiduciary responsibility to their shareholders.
I am not alone in taking this position. It is the accepted wisdom of virtually all Left-leaning and Progressive elements in this country. The pages of the Left periodicals The Nation, Mother Jones, The Progressive, In These Times, and even Public Citizen are filled with articles on the corrupting influence of money in U.S. politics. Newspaper columnists, op-ed writers, and a slew of authors bombard us with information about the central role campaign contributions and lobbyists play in influencing political decisions. We live in an oligarchy, not a democracy. The fact that middle-class Richard Nixon defeated the wealthier Nelson Rockefeller for the Republican nomination in 1968 simply means that the West Coast moneyed elites who financed Nixon’s campaign were able to beat Rockefeller’s East Coast financial backers. It is not the candidate’s wealth that matters it’s how much financial clout his, or her, supporters have along with how good their advertising and PR people, campaign managers, speech writers, and host of other highly paid support staff are at their jobs. The candidate that spends the most does not always win but does most of the time. A candidate who spends ten million compared to his opponent’s fifteen million could well win, but a candidate who spends one million is virtually guaranteed to lose.
I never said that leaders are irrelevant. My argument is not that there are no differences between Tweedledum and Tweedledee it is that they both have one very important thing in common: they have learned how to serve their masters, the rich and powerful, the captains of industry and the corporations they run, our modern-day aristocrats. The elected leaders, including the president, have a certain range for freedom of thought and action, but it is limited. It must remain within the bounds of the mainstream consensus: corporate capitalism and privatization are the only possible economic system; Americans are basically good and just, their motives are noble, and they have the right and even the obligation to coerce the rest of the world into complying with their way of seeing and doing things; and the proper role of government is to promote the health and growth of the market rather than to take care of people in need.
As for the “democratizing influence of the rapid communications made possible by modem technological innovation,” the latest issue of The Nation (November 19, 2007) has an article devoted to the recent explosion of the Right’s use of disinformation, spread in the form of rumors by means of forwarded e-mails and blogs with regard to the 2008 presidential campaign, for example, the widely circulated e-mail which falsely claims that Obama is Moslem and attended a Madrassa in Indonesia when he was young. As in the Swift Boat campaign during the 2004 presidential race, the rapid communication made possible by the spread of the Internet can quite easily be adapted to the needs of unscrupulous cam-
Page 145
paign operatives. I see this as an example of the increased sophistication and effectiveness that modem communication technology grants to those engaged in manufacturing consent, whatever their political goals. I characterize this as weakening rather than strengthening real democracy.
Page 146
How to cite this article
Lotto, D. (2008). Rejoinder to Elovitz. Clio’s Psyche, 14(4), 144-146.



