
Volume 26 - Number 2 - Winter 2020
Pages: 127 - 263
SYMPOSIUM ON MALE REFLECTIONS ON SEX AND POWER
Lotto, D. (2020). David Lotto responds to the commentaries. Clio’s Psyche, 26(2), 239-244.
David Lotto Responds to the Commentaries
Abstract
In this article, the author replies to the contributors to the symposium on male reflections on sex and power, which opened with his essay “A Male Perspective on Sex and Power in the Age of #MeToo.” He contends that relations between the sexes provoke partisanship marked by splitting, a forced choice between solidarity with women as victims and alignment with male perpetrators. He then discusses the charge of “blaming the victim,” which he traces to Jeffrey Masson’s attack on Freud and psychoanalysts, and argues that a later shift toward near-automatic belief in accusations led to false accusations of satanic ritual and child sexual abuse and to other moral panics. He maintains that the original essay concerned not male misconduct generally but the possible role, in Kohut’s terms, of narcissistic injury when advances are rebuffed, and he defends emphasis on sexual motivation as psychoanalytic against Paul Elovitz’s objection. He is sharply critical of Matthew Bowker’s response, disputing its reading of the research literature on gender differences in sexuality and sexual aggression. He disputes Denis O’Keefe’s account of patriarchy, arguing that political, economic, and military power explains domination better than gender does. He expresses agreement with parts of the responses by Michael Britton, Susan Kavaler-Adler, Judith Logue, Merle Molofsky, and Marcia Newton. He argues that explaining women’s support for Phyllis Schlafly or for Donald Trump in 2016 as false consciousness is more demeaning than acknowledging the benefits some women derive from the traditional order.
#MeToo movement, gender psychodynamics, intellectual partisanship, misogyny, Paul H. Elovitz, psychohistory, psychopathology, sexual aggression, splitting, toxic masculinity, victimhood
I would like to thank Paul Elovitz for organizing and publishing this symposium. I am gratified to see the number of thoughtful comments that have been made and would like to thank everyone who has taken the time and effort to respond to my paper. I will explore two issues that seem to be central to this discussion, and then address some of the specific comments made by the contributors.
The first issue is the degree to which the topic of relations between the sexes seems to bring out what we might call partisanship with its underlying quality of splitting. I am referring to the quality of choosing sides: are you in solidarity with the women who are seen to have been and continue to be the oppressed and exploited victims of what is most often called the patriarchy, or are you on the side of the sexual predators, almost always coded as male? An example of what I mean is Dr. Matthew Bowker’s statement that: “Lotto adopts a perspective that is nearly identical to that which he attributes to perpetrators of sexual and gender-based crimes (e.g. harassment, battery, rape, and more).”
Page 239
For Bowker, some of the things I speak of in the paper are seen as, at worst, aligning with the patriarchy, or at the least, undermining a full-throated fealty to defending women from the depredations of male aggression. Not an ignoble sentiment but there seems to be a good deal of hostility toward my suggestion that there might be more to say about sexual and power relations between the genders than that men are abusers and women are their victims. There is also the belief that sexual “essentialism” is a bad thing that all is culturally determined and differences between men and women are artifacts of a rigid society mired in binary thinking.
A number of the responses focus on the bad behavior of men and its sources. This is indeed the main focus of the #MeToo movement, but it is not the main focus of the paper. I do speculate that, in addition to the many well-studied motivations and characteristics of men who engage in criminal behavior directed at women, reacting to the perceived narcissistic injury experienced by some men when women are not receptive to their advances can be a motivational factor.
There is no doubt that “toxic masculinity” is real, as is misogyny, men who won’t take no for an answer, men who rape, assault, and commit sexual assaults. But there are also men who grope, grab, make inappropriate sexual remarks, and make a variety of unwanted sexual advances. As Susan Kaveler-Adler points out, there is an important difference between the actions of Harvey Weinstein and Al Franken.
Sometime after the paper was sent out to the responders I came across an article in the New York Times, which is now included in the crime and punishment section of my paper. I find this report highly disturbing. In addition to the obvious problem of the possibility that innocent people are being unjustly or overly harshly punished, it is reminiscent of other prosecutorial excesses, moral panics, and mass hysteria that we have experienced.
The second issue, which is related to the first, is that of “blaming the victim.” This accusation first gained prominence following the Jeffrey Masson led assault on Freud and psychoanalysts, who were accused of this offense when they did not believe or doubted female patients’ accounts of sexual abuse and instead viewed them as suffering from hysterical psychopathology. There was certainly at least some justification for this allegation, but, particularly among psychotherapists of many persuasions, there was a
Page 240
dramatic swing to almost always believing female accounts of sexual abuse. To not believe, or even to question, the narrative presented by the victim/patient came to be seen as a very bad thing to do as you were no doubt re-traumatizing the patient. Unfortunately, this culminated in an epidemic of false accusations of satanic ritual and cult abuse, as well as other false accusations of child sexual abuse, which led to a substantial number of innocent individuals experiencing unjust punishments, including incarceration. A prohibition on any suggestion that an allegation of sexual abuse might not be true or that its severity may be exaggerated has led to some very unfortunate consequences.
Now for some specific responses to the contributors. There is much I could say by way of response to Dr. Bowker’s broadside, but let me just respond to the section of his article citing six different references that he claims contradict what I have said. The first article he cites has the striking title: “Women, Men, and the Bedroom: Methodological and Conceptual Insights that Narrow, Reframe, and Eliminate Gender Differences in Sexuality” (2011), which he claims demonstrates that my claim men have a greater desire for sex is poppycock, and no doubt a blatant example of the belief in sexual essentialism. It is, in fact, an almost 100-page article with an extensive review of the literature on gender differences. From the abstract of this article is as follows: “Many researchers have elucidated large, well-established and reliable gender differences in sexuality… Common wisdom – as well as the research about the beliefs of many psychologists – suggests that men, simply put, like sex more than women do” (Terri D. Conley, Amy C. Moors, Jes L. Matsick, Ali Ziegler, and Brandon A. Valentine, “Women, Men, and the Bedroom: Methodological and Conceptual Insights that Narrow, Reframe, and Eliminate Gender Differences in Sexuality,” Sage Journals).
Bowker then cites three articles from the literature on the characteristics of rapists and “sexual harassers,” which allegedly show that sexual desire plays either no, or perhaps just an inconsequential, role in rapists’ motivation. The real motivations are said to be “sadism, violent impulses to dominate, and a profound hatred of women” (“Women, Men, and the Bedroom”). The second of the three articles he cites is: “Toward a Theory of Sexual Aggression: a Quadripartite Model.” From the abstract of this article: “The components of the model – physiological sexual arousal, cognitions that justify sexual aggression, affective dyscontrol, and personality
Page 241
problems – function as motivational precursors that increase the probability of sexually aggressive behavior” (Gordon C. Nagayama Hall and Richard Hirschman, “Toward a Theory of Sexual Aggression: a Quadripartite Model,” Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 1991). This seems to indicate that sexual desire may play at least some role.
I’d like to second Michael Britton’s observation that it is “not what a man feels like doing; it’s what he does with those feelings.” I would also agree with him that “the #MeToo movement has succeeded in replacing that certainty [that a sexual price could be demanded in return for career advancement] with anxiety that such behavior will in fact see the light of day.” I also applaud Susan Kavaler-Adler’s recognition that things can go too far, as with Al Franken and the dangers of a “zero tolerance for sexual harassment” policy along with the importance of maintaining perspective on the wide range of very different behaviors that have been considered to be sexual violations.
I appreciate how carefully Judith Logue read and responded to the paper, but I have one quibble regarding overestimating the power of no to protect a woman from harm. The power of no works when sex is consensual, not when it’s non-consensual. Other than the “expected censure and losses that accompany reporting,” there may also be reluctance to report from the knowledge that if she is believed, and we know that historically this has been a big if, the consequences for the perpetrator may be quite severe.
I thank Merle Molofsky for reminding us of the importance of sexual pleasure in the complex weave of sexual desire and power in relations between the sexes, and her wonderful #MeToo story along with her conclusion that “Men and women both have power.” Marcie Newton provides us with an excellent review of the history and development of Freud’s views on sex. The psychoanalytic model I am working from is Kohut’s, who emphasized the effects of narcissistic injury—its internal consequences but, more importantly for psychohistory, its external consequences—which are a desire for revenge; to get even with who or whatever was responsible for the narcissistic injury you and your people have suffered.
I’ve already addressed Denis O’Keefe’s comments in what I said about “blaming the victim.” I would also like to comment on the “cultural zeitgeist” to which he refers. I would take this to mean that he was speaking of intersectionality, where solidarity
Page 242
with the oppressed—African Americans, women, the many who have been abused and oppressed by colonial masters, refugees, immigrants, and the numerous others that have been harmed by more powerful others—is a central tenet. I applaud this view of the world and its history, or as Howard Zinn would say, a people’s history. However, there appears to be a required political correctness; a good example of which is Dr. Bowker’s comments on lynching initiated by a woman’s allegation that a black man made sexual advances, insisting that responsibility for the atrocities “belong not to women but to white persons.” According to Bowker, the world is apparently divided into perpetrators and victims, and women belong to the victim class, so they can’t possibly be perpetrators.
Although several of the commentators have discussed the evils of the patriarchy, Denis gives an account of this position in its clearest form, using phrases such as “Western history is replete with attempts to dominate every aspect of women’s lives…” and “We could fill countless volumes documenting male dominance in Western history to date whereas women’s lives, bodies, and sexuality have been overtly controlled through physical as well as ideological means, i.e. patriarchy.” I would argue that these statements are examples of the splitting I referred to earlier. Western history and the power relationships between men and women are far more complex than these sweeping generalizations allow. Western history may well be replete with domination of the weaker by the powerful. But the fact that there have been many women who have held positions of power, particularly in recent history, would suggest that political, economic, and military power, which can be wielded by members of either sex, is more central to understanding the history of domination than is gender. We had Cleopatra, Elizabeth, and Victoria, but we also had Thatcher and have Merkel, Pelosi and various female leaders around the world who are not in the public eye. Shouldn’t we consider Sheryl Sandberg more of a patriarch than a victim of the patriarchy?
Regarding Paul Elovitz’ comments that the paper is not psychoanalytic enough, I disagree. I am pointing out that an emphasis on the importance of sexual motivation is fundamentally psychoanalytic. Object relations, narcissism, and most of all, attachment theory, have been prominent in psychoanalysis since Freud’s death. Freud had much to say about infantile sexuality and its influences. But he also knew about the centrality of adult sexuality. This paper is in the spirit of going back to Freud, trying to not lose sight of his
Page 243
insights about the strength of sexual motives in driving human behavior.
Finally, I find it of interest that Judith Logue is the only one to address the feminism versus femininism section of the paper, the history of the fight for the ERA amendment, and the inconvenient fact that 52% of white women voted for Donald Trump in 2016. One could take the position that the femininists are in thrall to the patriarchy or, to use the old Marxist term, that they suffer from false consciousness, not realizing how oppressed and exploited by the patriarchy they have been. I think this kind of stance is more demeaning of women than saying that their sexual desirability gives them a certain kind of power, as Dr. Bowker would have it.
I think Judith is correct to point out, as Phyllis Schlafly and her allies contended, that women sometimes receive benefits from adherence to the patriarchal order, the largest one being that it allows them, if they wish, to be stay-at-home mothers and housekeepers while being financially supported by their spouses. For some women, providing and maintaining a nurturing home for their family is a higher priority than a career.
Page 244
How to cite this article
Lotto, D. (2020). David Lotto responds to the commentaries. Clio’s Psyche, 26(2), 239-244.



