Volume 32 - Number 3 - Summer 2025
Pages: 261 - 389

PSYCHOANALYTIC REFLECTIONS ON ANIMALS AND PETS IN OUR LIVES

Maldonado-Salcedo, M. (2025). Losing my best friend: The perils of animal bereavement and grief. Clio’s Psyche, 32(3), 271-276.

https://doi.org/10.70763/342285bb2a8cadef22f667eeb6a63732

Losing My Best Friend: The Perils of Animal Bereavement and Grief

article

Abstract

Losing an animal companion is tough, particularly for individuals who live with mental health challenges and depend on these special relationships as a way to navigate the difficulties of everyday life. However, the ensuing grief from losing a beloved pet remains underexplored in research that seeks to understand human-animal relationships further. In this essay, I reflect on my experience with active grief after the death of my dog and best friend, Bailey. I engage with scientific and cultural considerations surrounding pet loss and bereavement while highlighting the need for more social support and understanding for those who experience pet loss. I advocate for this grief to be centered and not treated as “disenfranchised,” as this can result in adverse outcomes and deter post-traumatic growth because of the severe pain of separation and impaired social support. I intentionally offer my experience as evidence as to why it is essential to change attitudes surrounding pet companionship so that individuals who suffer from their loss can share their experiences, find support, cope, and recover confidently.

Keywords:

active grief, animal bereavement, animal grief, attachment, emotional support animals, human-animal relationships, memorialization rituals, mental health issues, pet loss, psychobiography, psychohistory, social support

Despite the popular euphemism of good grief, there is nothing good about grief. While it is a natural response to losing a loved one and a part of life, it remains complicated due to its subjectivity. Grief alters feelings, physical sensations, cognitions, and behaviors. Unfortunately, people can suffer in silence when their loss is unrecognized, unsupported, or invalidated by social norms. This oversight can lead to the pathologization of grief, which further complicates recovery. Such is the case when humans lose their animal companions. Despite the deep physical and emotional bonds, society can perceive it as inferior and dismiss the salience of the relationship.

Mourning a pet can engender overwhelming emotions, such as remorse, regret, and resentment, making it inherently traumatic. Animals enhance human health, but few studies focus on the impact of losing them. The limited professional interest of this grief overlooks how and why human-animal relationships can be therapeutic and profoundly meaningful to their caretakers. For example, dogs in the Western world are often considered family members and even work in service to humans. They are frequently trained to help people cope with adversity, thus improving health outcomes, as seen in dog-assisted therapy interventions. Court services using canines have proven successful in aiding domestic abuse survivors in testifying against their abusers, offering terrified victims comfort, protection, and strength to confront them within the judiciary. With all the added value dogs offer

Page 271

humans, conducting more empirical research on human-animal interactions and individuals who struggle with mental health remains lacking.

Dogs positively impact our lives by offering stress relief, companionship, physical activity, and countless other benefits. However, when our furry friends die, it can feel disorienting, overwhelming, and lonely because of the prevailing belief that it is easier to move on from a non-human loss. Culturally, we must normalize pet bereavement to support individuals in processing and centering their grief without judgment or stigma. This undertaking can feel impractical when social support is inadequate—an attempt to better understand the (clinically) significant psychological distress after pet loss is urgent.

Grief, with no exception, can undermine our ability to express ourselves. It has a muting effect, so coping with it can be confusing and disordered. Pet loss affects our ability to articulate our feelings because of the invalidating assumption that a non-human loss is somehow less fraught or remarkable. However, losing a beloved animal companion can feel as catastrophic as any other tragedy because of the intense, unique animal-human bond and the shared unconditional love. In this essay, I offer my experience as evidence to synthesize my grief after losing my best friend, my dog Bailey. My experience can serve as an entry point for further exploring pet bereavement and grief. I also put it in conversation with the scientific and cultural attitudes surrounding pet loss. In this age of modern medicine, I question why I still struggle with the untimely loss of my dog, a miniature schnauzer whose expected life span was no more than 12 to 15 years. I reflect on why I felt immensely underprepared to accept her death while also reevaluating my subsequent guilt from having to “let her go.”

Ashes for Beauty

When I learned that my dog’s diagnosis was fatal and inevitable, I grabbed my chest in pain. My heart literally and metaphorically hurt in a way that I determined was a result of it breaking. Medically, takotsubo cardiomyopathy (broken heart syndrome) feels like a heart attack, although it is a temporary condition. It causes your heart muscle to weaken rapidly. A stressful event, like grief, can trigger it. This embodied reaction is another powerful testament to how our bodies and emotions are intertwined. Although devastated by the news and medicated to digest it, I was and still am angry. I feel cheated by life, god, and even the veterinarian who delivered the news of Bailey’s fate.

Incredibly, after eight years together, I have never felt such a strong connection with another living being outside the son I birthed.

Page 272

Bailey and I shared many morning rituals, which included coffee, cuddles, and cartoons. She was so attuned to me that if I experienced foreboding symptoms of a panic attack, she immediately jumped on my lap to soothe me, consistently offering the emotional support I lacked throughout most of my childhood and alleviating many of the mental health symptoms I struggled with daily. As a child abuse survivor, human relationships can (still) feel unsafe and anxiety-inducing. I am painfully awkward around new people and environments, but this mattered less to me with her. I suffered from clinical depression when she came into my family. Her unabashed joy became infectious. We joked that she turned me into a “morning person” since I notoriously woke up most days with a scowl. Over time, she became more than just a service dog; she was and will always be the closest friend I have ever had. Bailey mirrored many attributes that enriched my adult life: patience, kindness, and unconditionality. Losing her felt like the newly discovered parts of me that I had learned to love through and with her were also going to die.

Our social support determines how we move forward from the intense pain of losing a pet. My family’s support during this time was invaluable. I found solace in the shared memories of Bailey, and the understanding nods were like a balm to my wounded heart. However, I could not help but ask myself: Can this type of pain be transient? After all, no one can refill the void left by the departed. Since death is definitive, it felt unbearable. I stayed in bed for days, inconsolable, when she died. The juxtaposition of grief with the immense love I felt from my husband and son, who stayed by my side, feeding me and holding my hand so our hearts could syncopate, was breathtaking. It also compelled me to confront what “letting go” meant in the context of living. Bailey and I had to learn to trust each other, strengthening our connection and attachment. Studies suggest that pet loss is hard on children because it is usually their first experience with death and grief. Weirdly, this loss felt like a first. As I write this, my eyes still well up with tears.

As adults, the advent of sudden death forces us to seriously reevaluate our time on earth, especially when we know that our systems of technological medical care cannot meet our needs and desires to prolong life indefinitely. This powerlessness can make us feel vulnerable and desperate, as seen in Netflix’s documentary Bad Vegan: Fame, Fraud, Fugitives (2022). It centers on chef Sarma Melngailis, who embezzled over a million dollars from her restaurant because she was promised immortality for her dog. She suspended her common sense in favor of the fantastic and impossible. I have never felt such

Page 273

empathy for someone as I did for her in her pursuit of the same thing I wanted more than anything: my dog to have eternal life.

Due to the pressures of everyday life, the countless deadlines and hustle, and our collective aspirations for “more,” we tend to carry on as if there is an endless supply of time to spend on earth and our loved ones will be perpetually available. This purposeful misguidedness obstructs our perspective and causes us to take so much for granted, especially the little things that enhance our lives. I wish I had taken longer walks with Bailey and shared more steaks, lazy days, and weekends. I regret the hours I spent doing anything and everything that did not involve my loyal confidante. I resent my choices despite knowing I spent nearly every hour I could with her by my side. It will never feel as if we had enough time together. I will always feel bitter about what I perceive as a cruel and unjust fate for such a loyal and devoted friend. This grief is homed in the adage that life is not always fair.

All Animals Grieve

The emotional connection between humans and animals is unsurprisingly similar to the emotional bond between humans. Humans grieve because we are “social animals.” Like elephants, cows, ducks, and dogs, we display “evident distress” and “profound emotions” upon losing a loved one. However, despite knowing how unexceptional grief is within the animal kingdom, losing Bailey still feels extraordinary.

The stages of grief are disorganized and can be passive or active. Passive grief can accentuate the feeling of victimization, while active grief empowers and enables a path forward where you can healthily express the grief. Fittingly, when you choose active grief, you are choosing life. Because of my social environment growing up, I developed “extraordinary” creative and destructive capacities in order to function. But when I got my emotional support animal, daily life felt more effortless and lighter. I did not have to mask the idiosyncrasies of my condition; with her, I was able to experience radical acceptance despite my traumas.

My upbringing forced me to rely on myself, even as a child, so the need and desire to become involved with others as an adult did not feel compulsory. This disconnect is typical of survivors of chronic trauma who must balance trust with self-protectiveness. Keeping most people at a safe distance was essential to my survival, which made me an incredibly lonely and isolated child. One Christmas, I received a stuffed animal from the local church. I took it everywhere and had

Page 274

long conversations with it, too. I remember praying it would come to life. Eventually, my sister threw it out, and although I missed it, I was not allowed to complain about a thrown-away toy. Over 30 years later, I let Bailey’s fur grow out overly long, as she had missed a grooming appointment. I realized she looked exactly like the childhood toy I loved so much. I remember holding her close with gratitude that she had come into my life. My inner child felt heard by a higher power who often made me feel forgotten.

After eight years with no health issues, Bailey’s unknown illness and rapid decline were unexpected. I carried her in my arms to the vet, never thinking that she would not return home. After teaching medical ethics for more than a decade, the concept of euthanasia (a good death) became no longer abstract or theoretical. The veterinarian ran tests, and when she returned with “bad news,” I felt like I was in a movie; I could hear her, but nothing made sense. While our collective goal for Bailey’s care was to prevent suffering, it felt like we were also de facto “executioners.” Since quality of life is not an objective discernment, my decision to let her go in peace came down to me not wanting her to suffer, even if it meant that I was going to have to as a result. The vet observed my distress and tried to let me know that what I was doing was humane, ethical, and loving. I did not make it easy for her because she, too, started to cry and hugged me as I crumbled, sobbing in her office.

People who feel discounted because of disregarded grief can also feel deprived of the right to share their feelings or to receive acknowledgment and sympathy. I tend to power through most things like a workhorse. Still, with Bailey’s loss, I experienced myself as “passive and helpless,” which felt foreign and infuriating. However, as “choiceless” as her death felt, I decided to let her go because I loved her so much. My immediate reaction was to blame myself, which I know is an all too familiar trauma response. While self-blame is an acceptable response from a child who conceives themselves as the center of the world, it also aligns with the thought processes of traumatized people of all ages who blame themselves in order to make sense of what has happened to them. The truth is that even when a death is foreseen or welcomed, it still hurts. I could not withstand extending Bailey’s suffering because of my selfish desire to keep her with me for as long as I could. It was the sacrifice I had to make.

Grieving is a process, not an event. It must be active for the recovery to bring the mourning person back to their original state. My default setting before Bailey was sad and anxious, which is the lived

Page 275

reality of patients like me diagnosed with complex post-traumatic disorder. Scholars note that conceiving the grieving process as active is preferable because it promotes self-understanding and helps chart a path forward. Accordingly, successful grieving makes it possible for the bereaved to remember without intense pain and anguish and to “cherish” remembrances rather than being “overwhelmed” by them. I know I need to hold on to the memories of Bailey and me running on the beach without breaking down. I should be uplifted by our time together.

As Bailey transitioned to the unknown, I sang to her through tears and held her tightly. The sparkle in her eye dimmed; she was tired, and I wanted her to rest. I had an entire repertoire of songs I made up and would sing to her as she would smile and sigh, communicating her content. Amid my suffering, I recalled how singing guides the deceased’s journey to the afterlife within many death rituals. I have always found this idea encouraging. So I sang to her through tears, while my husband expressed his gratitude and cheered her on, like she had scored the winning penalty goal against France.

As she took her last breath, I thanked her. We surrounded her with the love she gave us and promised to remember her fondly forever. I hold on to the childhood belief that all dogs must go to heaven because if not, there is nothing to look forward to. Bailey taught me that the only way to mend a broken heart is to open it up to more love. As I actively grieve, I will continue to remember her in song, with love, and I am eternally grateful for the life she gave me. I will memorialize her by choosing kindness, no matter my circumstance, and by telling our story…this story.

Page 276

About the author

Melissa Maldonado-Salcedo

Melissa Maldonado-Salcedo, PhD, is an artist, anthropologist, and adjunct assistant professor in the Department of Technology, Culture, and Society at the Tandon School of Engineering at New York University since 2013. She can be contacted at or www.melthestorydoc.com.

How to cite this article

Maldonado-Salcedo, M. (2025). Losing my best friend: The perils of animal bereavement and grief. Clio’s Psyche, 32(3), 271-276.

https://doi.org/10.70763/342285bb2a8cadef22f667eeb6a63732

PDF downloads