
Volume 13 - Number 1 - June 2006
Pages: 1 - 80
Marvick, E. W. (2006). A memorial tribute to Fawn McKay Brodie. Clio’s Psyche, 13(1), 61-62.
A Memorial Tribute to Fawn McKay Brodie
Abstract
In this article, the author offers a memorial tribute, written from personal friendship, to the historian and psychobiographer Fawn McKay Brodie (1915–1981). The author characterizes Brodie as a generous friend and a model of responsible citizenship, and considers how features of her history account for her qualities as a person and scholar. The author points to her upbringing in the Mormon community, where women’s influence was often exercised covertly and where, the author recalls Brodie saying, her mother privately held heretical views. The author proposes that this background shaped Brodie’s insistence on truthfulness and on bearing public witness, evident in No Man Knows My History, and her attention in Thaddeus Stevens and Thomas Jefferson to the unrecognized historical role of black women. The tribute recounts her partnership with her husband, Bernard Brodie, including their joint From Crossbow to H-Bomb (1962), and her devotion to raising her children. It links her turn to psychoanalysis after moving to California in 1951 to her dislike of self-deception, and notes its influence on her work on Richard Nixon. The author also recalls her generous reception of other writers’ work on Nixon and Sally Hemings, and concludes that her openness and delight in life gave her scholarship its distinctive character.
compassionate, contribution, Fawn McKay Brodie, friendship, humane, memorial, psychohistory, scholarship, virtuous
I will only be adding my voice to many when I say how generous, sensitive, and compassionate a friend Fawn Brodie was, how eager she was to help. On a public level, too, she was admirable. She set an example of humane and responsible citizenship. Her contribution to scholarship was remarkable. It was not only substantial, conscientious, and original; it also gave great pleasure to many because of its human interest, path-breaking scholarship, and admirable style. Fawn was an extraordinarily kind, virtuous, hard-working, and gifted woman. She lived life fully.
The world would be a better place if Fawn were still with us. It would also be better if many more could live like her. It seems right to consider, as she might do in another case, how some distinctive features of her history account for her exceptional qualities.
Fawn was, of course, a daughter. The conditions under which she grew up are surely important for the remarkable person she turned out to be. In the Mormon community, Fawn came from where men were allotted the larger share of power and authority. She used to say that in Mormon doctrine the status of blacks and of women was about the same. Everyone here is aware of her feeling of affinity with the deprivations of black people and her demand for justice on their behalf. Two of her major works—Thaddeus Stevens and Thomas Jefferson—show that she was especially alert to an unrecognized historical role played by black women. Both books concern powerful white men whose personal happiness—if not their public performance—was dependent on black women.
In Fawn’s home community, too, women were more likely to exercise their influence covertly. Some of these women were secretly skeptical of the men’s doctrine. I have heard Fawn say that she believed that one woman who was most important to her in childhood, her mother, was a closet heretic. Perhaps this was an influence on Fawn’s own hatred of deception and her desire to bear public witness to the truth, as she found it out. In her first book—No Man Knows My History: The Life of Joseph Smith—Fawn showed herself publicly as a heretic. She presented evidence that the man who was the source of divine authority in her home community was an ordinary mortal and, in many ways, representative of his time.
Fawn did reject some of the Mormon Church’s directives for conduct. But she remained appreciative of others. Bearing public witness to the truth as the individual sees it is a central ingredient in the American Protestant tradition, including the Mormon tradition. She gave the Church credit also for setting a high value on winning the free consent of its members. And, in particular, she shared the Mormons’ strong demand for community and family obligations. When a young mother whom she did not know was officially expelled from the Mormon Church, Fawn put herself in sympathetic touch with her.
Fawn’s personal and public legacy is not only individual; it is also the product of a partnership with her husband, Bernard. I remember her telling me of their first meeting—as students—at the University of Chicago student cafeteria. She had just taken a job serving there. He usually ate elsewhere. It was “a stroke of luck,” she told me, that he came to Hutchinson Commons that day. This was a joyful memory for her. Although for the most part Fawn’s and Bernard’s work resulted in separate, individual products, they did collaborate on a book on the history of military technology, From Crossbow to H-Bomb (1962). Few women scholars have devoted themselves to the
Page 61
arts of war, and Bernard’s interest in these matters sometimes led where Fawn felt herself not entirely at home. But her sensitivity and skills clearly contributed to the distinction of Bernard’s work, just as his criticism and insight, from a different perspective, contributed to hers.
I didn’t know Fawn as a young mother. When I met her, her youngest child, Pamela, was almost grown. I do know from talking with her after Thaddeus Stevens came out, that when her three children were little they were her principal occupation. If this had not been so, there might have been more books. I know that she would not have thought that exchange worthwhile. She loved her children and loved her part in their early development. Without this part, moreover, her books would have been different—lacking in some of the insights from this experience. Fawn put the highest value on continuity between generations and she knew how important was the support of the family and community that have raised you. In the last years of her own life, she loved having her children and grandchildren around her.
Fawn’s firm demand for truthfulness gave direction to her development as a scholar. She became attentive to psychoanalysis when she was already mature, after coming out to California in 1951. I believe this interest was related to her dislike of deception, because psychoanalytic method is a form of inquiry through which self-deception is systematically attacked. Once she had assimilated it, she began to use it in her work. It made her sensitive, for example, to the childhood origins of patterns of deception in Richard Nixon’s public behavior.
As an intellectual, she was open to a very wide range of topics. For example, I have found a passage from her work on Joseph Smith’s talents as a writer:
His book lacked subjectivity, wit and style … His characters were pale, humorless stereotypes; the prophets were always holy, and in three thousand years of history not a single harlot was made to speak. But he began the book with a first-class murder … and piled up battles by the score. There was plenty of bloodshed and slaughter to make up for the lack of gaiety and the stuff of humanity.
Smith’s style was not Fawn Brodie’s. The gaiety she brought to her own work let her treat with the stuff of humanity—with family life and childhood, with the words of harlots as well as chaste women and powerful men. Her human sympathy focused naturally not on the organization of destruction but on the hapless victims of war and politics. She was attuned to the human terror, misery, and loss portended by the failure of grand strategies.
To her friends, Fawn seemed to be free of such ordinary human failings as jealousy, spite, and envy. Those friends will remember how, during her long, slow progress on her last book, one new psychobiography of Nixon after another seemed to appear in print. She would greet each one with optimism and appraise them all generously for what they might contribute to her knowledge and insight. She was also warmly appreciative to the author of a fictionalized biography of Sally Hemings that owed a good deal to her own work on Jefferson. This welcoming behavior seemed linked to a quality of youthful receptivity to life and delight in it. It was a quality of ingenuous wonder that gave pleasure to those who were lucky enough to be her friends. It gave freshness and added interest to her work.
She was once asked if she had tried her hand at writing a novel. She replied that she had, but that she gave it up because she found she had no talent for fiction. I think perhaps, for Fawn, real life was romance enough.
Page 62
How to cite this article
Marvick, E. W. (2006). A memorial tribute to Fawn McKay Brodie. Clio’s Psyche, 13(1), 61-62.



