
Volume 31 - Number 1 - Fall 2024 Part I
Pages: 1 - 133
Messina, K. (2024). Donald Trump and the fascism question. Clio’s Psyche, 31(1), 18-27.
Donald Trump and the Fascism Question
Abstract
This paper explores whether Donald Trump has become a fascist. In this context, his brand of leadership will be examined to determine if it is reminiscent of fascism exhibited by strongmen of the past or if it fell short of that type of leadership until he incited citizens to rise against our democracy during the insurrection of 2021. As the parallels between Trump and historical strongmen become more apparent, we must understand the implications of such a power shift, which we also need to consider within a larger conversation about the threat to global democracies within the framework of the 2024 U.S. presidential election.
democracy, Donald Trump, fascism, global politics, January 6th insurrection, presidential elections, Project 2025, psychohistory, toxic leadership
This paper examines whether Donald Trump’s actions are steering us toward a form of government reminiscent of fascism—a crucial exploration since our democracy is at risk. As the parallels between Trump and historical as well as current strongmen become more apparent, we must understand the implications of such a power shift.
“Strongman” Donald Trump and the Implications of Project 2025
In a speech on Veteran’s Day in 2023, Trump’s language
Page 18
took a dark turn, describing political foes as “vermin” who needed to be “rooted out.” Trump added that “the threat from outside forces is far less sinister, dangerous and grave than the threat from within” (Bender & Gold, 2023). New York University professor and author of Strongmen: Mussolini to the Present (2020), Ruth Ben-Ghiat, believes Trump’s Veteran’s Day speech is “echoes of fascist rhetoric, and they’re very precise” (Bender & Gold, 2023). Trump’s bombast reveals his capacity to dehumanize people in a way that can leave others in a state where they find they don’t have much of a voice. You might think, “This is America. Fascism can’t happen here.” However, the new handwriting on the wall may be telling a different story since it appears as though the former president and his aides seem to be moving in that direction.
In addition to what has happened in the past, many of Trump’s statements sound more like words that were spoken by Hitler and Mussolini, especially in his current presidential bid. This could mean it’s only a matter of time before America loses its standing as a democratic nation, which seems particularly likely when one considers “Project 2025” and its accompanying “180-Day Playbook.” The latter is a plan developed by conservative billionaires who have created an anti-democratic blueprint for the United States that Trump intends to implement.
Barrington Salmon (2024) suggests that Project 2025 is a “sweeping rightwing blueprint for the next Republican president, Trump or not, to run the country for the foreseeable future” (para 1). If the document were merely advocating for lower taxes and greater state autonomy, we wouldn’t be discussing it. Instead, Project 2025 calls for conservative “warriors” to “defund the Department of Justice, dismantle the FBI, break up the Department of Homeland Security and eliminate the Departments of Education and Commerce” (Salmon, 2024, para 2). This is not a blueprint for a democratically-elected leader—it is a roadmap for a fascist’s first 100 days. Importantly, “Project 2025 offers proposals to deregulate targeted industries, privatize government functions and help American corporations to make more money at the expense of American workers, the middle class and everyone except the oligarchs and the 1%” (Salmon, 2024, para 4).
People around the globe are surprised that many Americans seem unconcerned about the 2024 presidential election. This is particularly curious since many people in the world community think the American presidential election is the most important issue to-
Page 19
day. It’s hard for them to understand why some people in our country are so blasé since many global citizens wait with bated breath to see if Trump will return to the White House. They appear to fear he could spearhead a movement that might greatly affect or perhaps even end democracies in other countries.
The juxtaposition between these different attitudes is striking. It may be related to the fact that some Americans think our form of government is a given. However, others are worried about the former president’s disdain for the underpinnings of liberty and justice for all as well as his disregard for the outcome of elections. His way of pandering to autocratic leaders, including Viktor Orbán, Vladimir Putin, and Chinese President Xi Jinping, among others, seems to be characteristic of an attitude he learned from his authoritarian father, which is also quite alarming.
These new, anti-American plans Trump and his team are preparing are important because the former president’s foray into authoritarianism is supported by certain primitive mechanisms of defense that divide and conquer by figuratively separating people into categories of good and bad. This mental maneuver, known in the world of psychoanalysis as “splitting,” has been illustrated in the way he treats immigrants who, in his book, are unworthy of decent treatment. This is discussed in detail in my book, Resurgence of Global Populism: A Psychological Study of Projective Identification, Blame-shifting and the Corruption of Democracy (2022).
There is the question of whether or not Trump is exploring a new, darker path, or if he is simply being Trump, spinning yarns that may sound different but are being put forth to save himself from his political entanglements. Is he projecting aspects of himself he can’t tolerate onto others—as he has always done—or is his more punitive rhetoric different and a harbinger of a new phase in our country? These are the questions we need to consider within a larger conversation about the threat to global democracies around the world. We don’t yet know the answer, but the months that precede the 2024 U.S. presidential election are an important time in history that may very well set a different tone in world politics.
Another essential factor to consider is Trump’s apparent contempt for representative government. When a leader undermines the political framework of his country for personal gain, we hope the system has enough safeguards to prevail. However, that system is at risk when a leader dismantles those protections and un-
Page 20
dermines the functioning of a stable democracy without serious repercussions.
An additional problem arises from Trump’s demanding total loyalty from his advisors—no Lincoln-inspired team of rivals here—and that fealty mandate can actually hurt his own goals. Consider his criminal hush money trial in New York City. Experts say he has assembled one of the finest legal teams he’s ever hired, all hailing from Manhattan law firms, but it appears this legal team is pursuing a flawed and potentially risky strategy. Why? Trump is their client, and they must oblige his wishes. Ankush Khadori (2024) suggested that Trump’s lawyers were unable to manage their client, whose preferred defense tactic is to “attack, attack, attack,” even when that strategy doesn’t work. We could see this kind of treatment as a precursor for what Trump would do in a second presidency—if you don’t do what Trump wants, you’re out.
The unwinding of democracy begins with undermining the self-government, wherein the first step toward this disruption affects those tasked with upholding the rule of law. When these civil servants come under fire for doing their jobs, it will be hard, if not impossible, to carry on without feeling deflated. Eventually, some public servants will say, “Why am I doing this?” While some may stay to try to uphold the pillars of democracy, others can’t bear the burden or strain of a government for the people, led by the people, in the throes of being unraveled.
Let’s consider the cult-like, charismatic characteristics of populist leaders who dictate what their base should say and do. These leaders are so effective because of their ability to convince their followers that they are special and have been maltreated by their shared oppressors. While there has been much speculation about Donald Trump’s leadership style, reliable information has come from Mary Trump, Donald Trump’s niece and a clinical psychologist, who has observed him for many years.
In an interview with Christiane Amanpour, Dr. Trump said her uncle acts like a young child because he was never allowed to grow up. Describing Trump’s childhood as one that was strongly influenced by a tyrannical, authoritarian father, she also said this man, her grandfather, was “a straight-up sociopath” (Esperanza, 2024). Since Donald was the favorite son of Fred Trump, Sr., during this timeframe, he knew what he had to do to stay on his father’s good side. From this vantage point, it makes sense that Don-
Page 21
ald Trump seems comfortable seeking approval from authoritarian strongmen because he did that for his entire childhood.
Could the Former President be as Dangerous as Hitler and Mussolini?
It’s hard to imagine that anyone could entertain the possibility that Trump might be more heinous than two of the modern world’s most brutal dictators. However, this claim has been made by a former U.S. Senator, Claire McCaskill, who said, “A lot of people have tried to draw similarities between [Benito] Mussolini and [Adolf] Hitler and the use of the terminology like ‘vermin’ and the drive that those men had towards autocracy and dictatorship” (Mastrangelo, 2023, para 2). She goes on to say, “The difference, though, I think makes Donald Trump even more dangerous, and that is he has no philosophy he believes in” (Mastrangelo, 2023, para 2).
The writer of this article, Domnick Mastrangelo, who shares McCaskill’s words, is another critic who fears that Trump’s lack of a philosophy makes him so dangerous. Trump also has an insatiable need to “fill himself up with praise,” according to Mary Trump, who also said his “deep-seated insecurity” formed “a black hole of need that constantly requires the light of compliments that disappear as soon as he soaked them in” (Trump, 2020, pp. 197-198).
What would the United States look like without a democratic form of government? What would “decline” look like? According to the Brookings Institute, democracies rarely fall because of a coup—not in today’s world. Instead, in 2024, there is a subtle, steady decline. It is an erosion that occurs over time. Two major indications of a shift in democratic principles seem to be occurring at present: election manipulation and the lack of equal authority shared by the three branches of government. Vilification of political opponents has also increased in recent years, weakening democratic ideals. These types of issues reflect an inability to communicate effectively. When people are polarized in this way, there is little or no respect for the opinions or rights of others. From a psychological perspective, people in this category are in a world where everyone is out for him or herself.
Given the precarious state of our government, the vulnerabilities we are seeing are particularly troublesome. This may partly be because the United States only guaranteed that all Americans could vote as recently as 1965. Despite this fact, some people in
Page 22
our country seem to feel as though our way of governing has “been around forever,” but that notion is only a fantasy. We are a new democracy with no guarantee of longevity.
The Many Faces of Fascism
When reading Roger Griffin’s theories on this topic, it is easy to see why the concepts associated with the word “fascism” are not easy to understand. This is due to the fact that, while authoritarian governments may seem similar, they usually have a number of different goals. Even though the destruction and devastation that is caused may look similar, at the end of the day, the means of getting to the final outcome usually vary quite a bit. To add to the complexity of this issue, Griffin says that people who are educated in the West believe they know what fascism means until they try to explain it, at which time, the topic becomes increasingly less clear. That observation makes it even more important to wrestle with the topics associated with this word since groups within our country believe they or others are following in the footsteps of European autocratic leaders from the early 1930s—leaders who were operating within authoritarian and nationalistic Right-wing systems of government.
Donald Trump, unlike most world leaders, had no political experience before entering the political arena in the summer of 2015. Since he changed political affiliations several times before entering the race, his political position seemed to be based on the viewpoints of former presidents. His platform appeared to consist of a little bit of this and a little bit of that cobbled together to make it appear as though he had a strong position that the average American could identify with while not changing their views in radical ways. Rather than believing in Trump’s ever-changing ideas, what appealed to people was the fact that he promised his followers they could become a part of something big, something great again.
While many policies he espoused seem original, Trump’s “Make American Great Again” (MAGA) tagline harkens back to the post-WWII days. Both Reagan and Clinton used similar slogans. However, Trump, who had long specialized in branding, made the slogan and its acronym, MAGA, synonymous with his argument that the country had lost something vital, and he was ready to fight to regain it. Trump’s ignorance of history prevented him from being labeled a fascist. He was a former Democrat who became a Republican and then changed his party affiliation at least two more times. He lied incessantly. But lying and having no po-
Page 23
litical ideology did not make him a fascist at that point.
Is There a New Brand of Toxic Leadership Emerging across the Globe Peppered with Claims of Victimization?
America isn’t used to fascist leaders, so it’s a difficult issue to fully understand now that Trump may be reelected. One person who thinks the former president is moving in that direction, as mentioned earlier, is Ruth Ben-Ghiat from New York University. She believes that a common trait among authoritarian leaders is their need to play the role of a victim. As an example, she says Silvio Berlusconi played the victim card in Italy, similar to how Trump plays it in the United States.
Another interesting question emerges with the use of the term “witch hunt” as an allegory to describe political persecution. It suggests that Trump and Berlusconi tried to paint the most negative image possible of their accusers. In the 21st century, claiming to be a victim of a witch hunt also implies someone is suffering from extreme paranoia; to think people are after you to the point of burning you at the stake or hanging you is beyond hyperbole. We can only hope that Trump is unaware of how misogynistic his references to witch hunts can be since it was reported that millions of women have been killed because of these atrocities (Cassese, 2018).
Mussolini and Erdoğan have also said they have been victims of witch hunts. Whether the use of these words was meant to be literal or figurative, the references illustrate very poor taste because of the suffering women had to endure. Unfortunately, it is still practiced in some areas of the world, including Africa, Southeast Asia, and Latin America.
The connecting thread among these leaders is the way they bond with people by giving them basic information about how they are mistreated. Then, when the audience nibbles, they feed them a meal of paranoid stories and the persecution they have had to endure. By that point, their followers have been taken in by their narratives. The hooks were set, so to speak; followers were there for the taking.
Did a New Type of Fascism Emerge After the Insurrection?
Americans don’t want to think we are moving toward a fascist government. It’s uncomfortable and doesn’t make a lot of sense to people who have only lived in a democracy. Yet more and more political analysts are wondering if the term is appropriate.
Page 24
This shift seemed to come about because of the insurrection and the findings of the January 6th Commission.
Though some people who have been writing about Trump seem to be thinking more about the possibility that he is just now transforming into a fascist, one person who has resisted using that term in recent years, despite his serious questioning of the former president’s behavior, is Christopher R. Browning, the Frank Porter Graham Professor of History Emeritus at the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill. Now, because of Trump’s more aggressive behavior, he has reconsidered the use of the word. Currently, he uses the term “isolationist fascism,” a concept he considers to be an oxymoron, but “Trump continues to break every mold” (Browning, 2023).
Browning comes close to saying Trump is an outright fascist but seems to stop short by adding that other leaders have done far worse things, such as putting a hold on elections, throwing people in jail without giving them a chance to face their accusers, and turning countries into one-party systems. Even with his own term, “isolationist fascism,” he seems to be saying Trump is close to being an outright fascist, but he isn’t quite there yet. However, he suspects a second Trump presidency with a far more organized campaign will seal the deal, especially since we have been told that retribution will be carried out against Trump’s perceived enemies while total devotion of his team will be required.
Robert Paxton, a historian of fascism at Columbia University, also changed how he viewed Trump after the insurrection. He said, “I have been reluctant to use the F word for Trumpism, but yesterday’s use of violence against a democratic institution crosses the red line” (Matthews, 2021, para 3).
Ruth Ben-Ghiat shifted her thinking as well, saying in October 2020 that she preferred using the word “authoritarian” instead of “fascist” when referring to Trump (Matthews, 2021, para 4). However, by February 23, 2024, she had heard enough of a shift in Trump’s rhetoric and underlying message that she feels we have entered a new, dangerous zone: “It [fascism] can happen anywhere. And indeed, nowadays, they tell you what they’re going to do ahead of time. And that’s what Trump and his enablers are doing” (McNamara, 2023, last para).
After reviewing many articles about Donald Trump’s presidency, in many ways, his administration didn’t seem organized
Page 25
enough to be categorized by any concept that has been used in the past because there weren’t organizing principles that held it together as a consistent political philosophy. However, as fascism experts and other people with expertise in democracy have said, inciting citizens to overturn our American government crossed a line. Trump is no longer an aggressive bully or a contrarian. I think he is a fascist, a view that is underscored by his plans for the future, as spelled out in Project 2025, which is also known as The 2025 Presidential Transition Project.
Page 26
References
- Bender, Michael C., & Gold, Michael (2023, November 20). Trump’s dire words raise new fears about his authoritarian bent. The New York Times. https://www.nytimes.com/2023/11/20/us/politics/trump-rhetoric-fascism.html
- Browning, Christopher R. (2023, July 28). A new kind of fascism. The Atlantic. https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2023/07/trump-second-term-isolationist-fascism/674791/
- Cassese, Erin (2018, October 31). A political history of the term “witch hunt.” Vox. https://www.vox.com/mischiefs-of-faction/2018/10/31/18047208/trump-witch-hunt
- Esperanza, Rosalita (2024, March 2). CNN 03 02 2024 11 17 13 [Video]. YouTube. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Dzvzf6RRQgo
- Khadori, Ankush (2024, May 14). Trump’s lawyers are making major mistakes. Politico. https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/politics/trump-s-lawyers-are-making-major-mistakes/ar-BB1mlYcv?ocid=BingNewsSerp
- Mastrangelo, Domnick (2023, November 22). Trump “more dangerous” than Hitler, Mussolini: McCaskill. The Hill. https://thehill.com/homenews/media/4322886-trump-hitler-mussolini-mccaskill/
- Matthews, Dylan (2021, January 14). The F word. Vox. https://www.vox.com/22225472/fascism-definition-trump-fascist-examples
- McNamara, Russ (2024, February 23). Is Trump a fascist? A fascism scholar says he certainly sounds like one. WDET 101.9 FM. https://wdet.org/2024/02/23/is-donald-trump-a-fascist-a-fascism-scholar-says-he-certainly-sounds-like-one/
- Moran, Lee (2024, March 4). Mary Trump pinpoints childhood reason for uncle’s “crush” on dictators. Yahoo! News. https://www.yahoo.com/news/mary-trump-pinpoints-childhood-reason-083152954.html?guccounter=1#:~:text=The%20former%20president%20
- Müller, Charlotte, & Sanderson, Sertan (2020, August 10). Witch hunts: A global problem in the 21st century. DW. https://www.dw.com/en/witch-hunts-a-global-problem-in-the-21st-century/a-54495289
- Patten, Chris (2024, January 8). Another trump presidency is the biggest threat to liberal democracy. Project Syndicate. https://www.project-syndicate.org/commentary/trump-victory-in-2024-poses-grave-threat-to-postwar-international-order-by-chris-patten-2024-01?barrier=accesspaylog
- Salmon, Barrington (2024, January 16). Project 2025, if allowed, will cement America as a rightwing authoritarian state. Michigan Advance. https://michiganadvance.com/2024/01/16/project-2025-if-allowed-will-cement-america-as-a-rightwing-authoritarian-state/
- Trump, Mary L. (2020). Too much and never enough: How my family created the world’s most dangerous man. Simon & Schuster.
How to cite this article
Messina, K. (2024). Donald Trump and the fascism question. Clio’s Psyche, 31(1), 18-27.



