
Volume 23 - Number 3 - Spring 2017
Pages: 225 - 337
SYMPOSIUM
Mohl, A. (2017). Suicide: A psychosocial perspective. Clio’s Psyche, 23(3), 257-261.
Suicide: A Psychosocial Perspective
Abstract
This paper compares the studies on suicide made by Freud and Durkheim. The path of discovery and the limitations of each trailblazer are explored. Finally, advancements in the study of suicide since Freud’s and Durkheim’s contributions are enumerated, such as including elements of culture.
Beyond the Pleasure Principle, culture, death drive (Todestrieb), Emile Durkheim, The Introductory Lectures on Psycho-Analysis, meta-psychology, psychodynamic explanations, psychohistory, psychosocial, Sigmund Freud, suicide contagion
According to Sigmund Freud, the “goal of all life is death” (Beyond the Pleasure Principle, 1959). By 1916, in the middle of World War I, Freud must have felt that he had given to the world all that was in his power so that little remained beyond living out what was left of life. In an amazing, almost incredible burst of energy in the spring of 1915, he poured his deepest thoughts and his most far-reaching ideas into his theoretical series of essays on meta-psychology, as in the following year he brought his years of lecturing and exposition to an end by writing and publishing The Introductory Lectures on Psycho-Analysis.
Given the mixture of personal and social forces that contrib-
Page 257
ute to suicide, how is it that the study of suicide has been so lacking in a psychosocial perspective? Part of the answer lies in the limitations of the two men who contributed most to our understanding of suicide: Emile Durkheim and Sigmund Freud. Their work, important in and of itself, has a continuing and pervasive impact on subsequent work in the field.
Freud gave us our first important psychodynamic insight into suicide, although he did not deal directly with the problem of suicide and described in detail the suicide attempt of only one patient. What he did see in large numbers, however, were depressed patients (Freud, “Mourning and Melancholia,” S.E., 1976, 147-172). Freud stated that the self-hatred observed in depression originated in anger toward a loved one that the individual turned back on himself. He regarded suicide as the ultimate form of this phenomenon, and when he returned to the subject in a 1920 paper, Freud expressed doubt that suicide could take place without the express desire to kill someone else (“The Psycho-Genesis of a Case of Homosexuality in a Woman,” S.E., Vol. 18, 1955, 155-172). This concept of suicide as a kind of inverted murder was extremely important, although it was unfortunately overworked in an effort to explain all suicide.
Freud made his observations on depression long before he came to the conclusion that anger or aggression could be non-erotic in origin. At the time when he wrote “Mourning and Melancholia,” he held the view that all aggression had to have a sexual origin. Ten years later, Freud expressed surprise at his having “overlooked the universality of non-erotic aggression” (Freud, Civilization and Its Discontents, originally 1930, trans. J. Riviere, 1949, 99). Since he never rewrote his earlier report, the extraneous explanations for the existence of anger remained unaltered. The basic psychological truth contained in his 1917 paper (“Mourning and Melancholia”) also remains in reference to anger and its relationship to suicide. The point that was made by Freud, which remains a major factor in understanding suicide, is “that anger toward a lost loved object can become self-directed, which can lead to depression which can be a motivating force in suicide” (Herbert Hendin, Suicide in America, 1982, 15).
Freud also recognized that an ambivalent, narcissistic quality characterized relationships that terminated in severe depression. Because early psychoanalytic theory and interest were too instinct-oriented to focus on the role of such affective interactions, little was
Page 258
done with this observation. Contemporary psychoanalytic and psychodynamic therapy efforts to include the variations in the ways individuals relate effectively to each other are leading to a reemphasis on this aspect of Freud’s insight.
His instinctual frame of reference led Freud in 1920 to see aggression as the manifestation of a death instinct (Beyond the Pleasure Principle, 1975). The death instinct violates too many basic observations of biologists and psychologists for it to be accepted by them or by more than a small minority of psychoanalysts. Gregory Zilboorg probably spoke for a majority of psychoanalysts when he wrote in 1937, “To say that the death instinct gains the upper hand over the life instinct is merely an elaborate way of stating that men die or kill themselves” (“Considerations on Suicide: With Particular Reference to That of the Young,” American Journal of Orthopsychiatry, Vol. 7, 1937, 17).
Freud also saw little need for systematically considering the problems of social structure that we now see as an important determinant of behavior. His theoretical perspective stressed the immutable and universal context of human drives rather than the changing and culturally relative nature of institutions and practices. It is understandable that Freud’s orientation did not lead him to a concern with the psychological impact of the social institutions of particular cultures or such psychosocial questions, such as why suicide was very high in one country and very low in another; nor would his instinctual reference have enabled him to resolve adequately such questions even if they had arisen. Understandably under the influence of the evolutionary anthropology of his day, Freud saw the psychological life of primitive man as “a well preserved picture of an early stage of our own development” (Totem and Taboo, originally 1913, trans. and ed. J. Strachey, 1952, 1). This approach made study of the culture as a unit unnecessary and Freud had little interest in the comparative anthropology that developed during his lifetime.
In Suicide, first published in 1897, Durkheim defined the vulnerable population with regard to suicide and provided a theoretical framework to explain that vulnerability (Suicide: A Study in Sociology, trans. J. Spaulding and G. Simpson, 1951 [1897]). Durkheim saw rising suicide rates in the Western world as a function of the failure of state, church, and family to repair the forces of social integration that they had prior to the industrial revolution. Vulnerability to suicide, in his view, existed in people who were
Page 259
not integrated into any religious, communal, or family group. Even more vulnerable were individuals who had suffered a disruption in their previous pattern of social interaction. The single, widowed, or divorced, then as now, were observed to have higher suicide rates than married people. Why some who were single, widowed, or divorced were suicidal when most others were not was of little interest to Durkheim. His sense that “social facts must be studied as things, as realities external to the individual” made the psychology of suicide seem irrelevant (Suicide, 17).
Durkheim’s social categories were used to explain the variations in suicide from country to country. But he placed people into categories based on age, sex, religion, or marital status, which had no reference to culture per se and left no room for what it meant to be Austrian, Swedish, Japanese, French, etc.
Most work on suicide has been an unsynthesized mixture of Durkheim and Freud. Social statistical profiles of the vulnerable have substituted for psychological understanding of suicide. It has been evident for several decades that a truly psychosocial approach, not an amalgam of Freud and Durkheim but an approach that includes the examination of the psychodynamics of suicide of differing social groups, is required for obtaining any deeper understanding of the significance of suicide in a society.
I do not believe that there is a death instinct as Freud specified, but that culture, belief systems, and contagion do have an impact on people who are prone to suicide. My youngest son lost several friends to suicide during his adolescent years. In part, it may have been a contagion phenomenon in that during that period in the 60’s and early 70’s many young people, particularly adolescents, were committing suicide. According to Herbert Hendin, MD, “No single fact about suicide has aroused more attention than the dramatic rise in the suicide rate of young people over the past 25 years. In the United States, the increase has been over 250% among young women 15-24 and over 300% among young men 15-24 (H. Hendin, Suicide in America, New York: W.W. Norton and Company, 1982, 19). Young people of both sexes in this age group now constitute 1/5 of the 27,000 suicides in the United States each year (Hendin, Suicide in America, 19). But it is the older white population in the nation that has the highest suicide rate. White men between 50-65 years of age are responsible for 30% of all suicides. White males have a higher rate of suicide than females in this age group. This may be related to crises frequently related to
Page 260
growing old and how men feel about it. The variables relate to loss of loved ones, decline in physical, emotional, and mental capacity, as well as economic hardship. But it is interesting to note that during the bombing of London and other cities in the UK during WWII, the suicide rate dropped drastically among all ages within the British population.
Violence has a more direct connection with suicide, whether in the murderer who kills himself, the young man whose suicide is an attempt to control his violence, or in the mother who murders her child as part of her own suicide. Then there is the violence of suicide bombers who are of Muslim faith and are influenced by Imams who have strong negative feelings about Western societies and their foreign policies toward the people in the Middle Eastern countries. Many of these individuals who commit violence toward those in the West come from middle class families and are college educated; many are from poor families with little or no education. These are individuals who feel alienated. They are attracted to belief systems that are bigger than they are, which inspire them to commit suicide bombings against their alleged enemies. The causes, whatever they may be, resonate with alienated individuals, and they are therefore willing to die for them.
Suicide may be part of the possibilities of every culture and every individual. But the dominant psychodynamic patterns emerge, and the ways they are expressed are to a very significant extent molded by the culture in which the act takes place. Although the potential for the suicide act is universal, the particular nature of the act is to a large extent culturally determined and relative to the individual’s life experience.
Page 261
How to cite this article
Mohl, A. (2017). Suicide: A psychosocial perspective. Clio’s Psyche, 23(3), 257-261.



