
Volume 19 - Number 1 - June 2012
Pages: 1 - 125
Molofsky, M. (2012). Fear, shame, and animal aversion. Clio’s Psyche, 19(1), 19-23.
Fear, Shame, and Animal Aversion
Abstract
In this article, the author recounts her fear of animals, particularly dogs, and the shame it has caused her, as a contribution to an issue section on the psychology of human-animal relationships. She begins with a brief history of animal domestication, from bee-keeping and herding to companion animals. She also notes the images of devoted animals in fiction, film, and song, including Lassie Come Home and Black Beauty, and observes that people readily anthropomorphize animals and project wanted and unwanted traits onto them. She contrasts this with her own relationship to animals, which she associates with the Wolf Man rather than Lassie. She reports that after a long analysis she addressed her fear of heights and her fear of animals on her own, with help from friends and family members who keep animals. She interprets both fears as fear of her own drives, describing the biting dog as her own oral aggression and libido, and her aversion to animal hair as a fear of being unclean. She also attributes the aversion to frightening childhood encounters with dogs and to a cultural history among Eastern European Jews, citing attacks by dogs on Jews, the use of dogs in the Holocaust, and American films of dogs pursuing fugitives. She reports taking inspiration from accounts of service animals aiding disabled children, and concludes that she can live in peace with her animal self and with the animals around her.
animal aversion, companionship, domestication, fear, human-animal relationships, phobia, psychoanalysis, psychohistory, shame, trauma
I know people love and value animals as companions. Alas, I do not.
Humans and animals have lived together for millennia. Humans have established many sorts of relationships with animals, utilitarian and affectional. We domesticated animal life forms early. There is evidence of bee-keeping from 13,000 BCE, of domestic sheep herds as early as 11,000 BCE, of domesticated cats living with humans possibly as early as 9000 BCE, and of pig keeping from 9000 BCE. Dating of the first domestication of dogs is less evident, with speculation that dogs were domesticated somewhere between 3000 and 7000 BCE.
Animals were first domesticated for food and utility. Sheep, goats, and camels were used as food sources, for either meat or milk, and for their pelts. Donkeys, horses, and camels were used for field work and transportation. In Egypt, cats were trained to
Page 19
attack. Dogs were used as watchdogs, as sheep herders, and as assistant hunters.
In our contemporary world, in cities, suburbs, and rural areas, dogs and cats are companion animals, the objects of affection. We have many images of benign bonds between humans and other animals: novels, movies, fairy tales, and folklore. Lassie Come Home, first a short story by Eric Knight, then a novel published in 1940, a 1943 MGM film, and ultimately a TV series, beautifully delineates the affectionate and dedicated relationship between a boy and his dog. Black Beauty, an 1877 novel by Anna Sewell, delineates the affectionate and dedicated relationship between a girl and her horse. It proved so compelling that it was made into films in 1921, 1946, 1971, 1978, 1994, and was adapted as a TV series in 1972.
There are countless songs celebrating the relationship between a human and a dog. Elvis Presley sang “Old Shep,” written by Red Foley and Arthur Willis, “When I was a lad/ and Old Shep was a pup/ Over hills and meadows we’d stray….” When the boy fell into the “old swimming hole,” Old Shep, of course, jumped in and pulled him out. Peter, Paul, and Mary sang a children’s folk song about “Old Blue”, “I had me a dog and his name was Blue/ betcha five dollars he’s a good dog too….”
Animals are easy to anthropomorphize. We believe we recognize in animals characteristics we see in others and in ourselves. Aesop’s morality tales, children’s fairy tales, and folklore in general, are filled with images of talking animals. We recognize traits seemingly shared with us by other animals—and we project traits, both wanted and unwanted, on them as well. We seek loyalty and devotion from other human beings, and if we find other human beings unreliable, we are convinced we can depend on the loyalty and devotion of animals. Old Shep, Blue, Lassie, and Black Beauty— all are dependable in their love.
But there is a dark side. My relationship with animals is, to my regret, on the dark side. I am more apt to view the animal side of myself as difficult and dangerous, and I am afraid of animals. The literary and film images of animals that evoke my relationship to animals and myself are closer to the Wolf Man than to Lassie.
Page 20
Herein lays the shame. People who know me are shocked when they discover that I am afraid of animals. They think of me as warm, spontaneous, natural, loving, and affectionate—surely I would be an animal lover. Would that I were. I have tempered my fear of animals in the last 15 years, due to the efforts of an animal-loving friend and family members with animal companions. It has been not so much a matter of their saying, “Love me, love my dog,” but rather, “Get to know my dog, and you will not be afraid.” They are right.
Long after 14 years of a multiple-times-a-week analysis, I still had not understood my phobias—a fear of heights and a fear of animals. After the analysis ended, I addressed the phobias on my own—with a little help from my friends. I was successful enough. I, who once could not climb a step ladder to change a light bulb, have hiked along mountain ledges, done difficult rock scrambles, including the perilous “lemon squeeze” at Mohonk Mountain House, a 60-foot-high crevice climb using hand and footholds in the rocks and a ladder system. I, who once would cross the street to avoid a dog being led on a leash, have cuddled with dogs and taken them on walks on my own.
The two phobias have the same impulse—a fear of my own drives, of my own acting-out wishes. With heights, I realized I wanted to throw myself over, to fly, to let go. I was afraid I would become a “fallen woman.” With animals, dogs in particular, I was afraid of my own untamed wildness, my own aggression and libido. The biting dog was my own oral aggression. My aversion to the shedding by dogs and cats, my dislike of picking up animal hairs just by sitting on a sofa or chair where the animal once had lain, was my fear that I myself was a “dirty girl.”
Once I learned to accept and love my own drives, my impulses, once I began to believe that I was civilized enough not to bite, not with my teeth nor with biting words, my fears markedly decreased. The word sarcasm is derived from an ancient Greek word meaning to strip off flesh with the teeth. Thus, even verbal oral aggression has canine, lupine, and feline roots.
I have been ashamed of my fear of animals—so not commensurate with my self-image and my image in the eyes of oth-
Page 21
ers—and of the inner impulses that I have projected onto the animals.
Beyond personal internal conflict over the drives is trauma—personal trauma, to be sure, but also a history of cultural trauma. The personal trauma is easy to understand—and yet, not so easy. When I was six years old, a nearby neighbor asked me to walk her two collies, and they ran off, leashes wrapped around my wrists, dragging me along the sidewalk. I suffered painful scrapes and bruises, and, of course, I felt terror. Our neighbor next door had a succession of vicious Doberman Pinschers that would bark ferociously at my brother and me when we used the common alleyway between our houses to get to our own backyard. When I was seven, a rabid dog bit my brother, and he had to endure a painful series of rabies shots. Yet, my brother loves animals, lives with animals, and has no residual trauma-induced fear. But I do.
Cultural trauma goes back generations, centuries. I am Jewish-American, born here. Both of my parents were from poor, shtetl-Jewish backgrounds. My father’s family was from Belarus, and he was the first child born here, and my mother was born in a small shtetl outside of Warsaw, in Poland. Obviously not all Jews, even Jews from backgrounds similar to mine, are afraid of dogs. But there is a history of aversion to dogs among Eastern European Jews. There were gentiles in Eastern Europe, particularly in Poland and in Russia, particularly landowners, who used to set their dogs on Jews, often for sport, as a joke, sometimes to control them, or even with intent to injure them. During the Holocaust, dogs were used in Treblinka and other death camps to chase down and punish inmates, and to detect Jews who were hiding.
Detecting Jews in hiding using dogs is parallel to the use of dogs to track down escapees from chain gangs. A series of American movies depicts this: I Am a Fugitive from a Chain Gang (1932), The Defiant Ones (1958), and Cool Hand Luke (1967).
Thus, my personal trauma and my internal conflicts over what I perceived to be my dangerous drives intersect with a background of exposure to American movies in which dogs pose a great danger to people trying to escape, and a family history that is linked to being members of an oppressed, persecuted group that was sub-
Page 22
ject to deliberately induced attacks by dogs. My aversion to animals, particularly dogs, is over determined.
I am equally determined to further overcome my aversion, my fear, and my shame, and make friends with what other humans often describe as their “best friends.” A particular inspiration for me is the accounts of animals that offer healing functions, particularly with disabled children. “Wonder Dog” describes the healing relationship established between a service dog, Chancer, and Iyal, a Russian-born child with fetal alcohol syndrome, who had been adopted. The last paragraph of the article offers such a beautiful image: “Chancer does not know that Iyal is cognitively impaired. What he knows is that Iyal is his boy” (February 5, 2012, New York Times Magazine).
I am inspired to believe that I can live in peace with my animal self, that my animal self is my self, and thus I can live in harmony with the animals who live with us, and who sometimes share our homes, and our love.
Page 23
How to cite this article
Molofsky, M. (2012). Fear, shame, and animal aversion. Clio’s Psyche, 19(1), 19-23.



