Volume 23 - Number 2 - Winter 2017
Pages: 103 - 223

HOW PEOPLE AND SOCIETY CHANGE
SYMPOSIUM

Molofsky, M. (2017). Transformational change to repair the world. Clio’s Psyche, 23(2), 134-138.

https://doi.org/10.70763/aba18772fc70c8cbf79a79f413ef102b

Transformational Change to Repair the World

response article

Abstract

In this article, a response in the “How People and Society Change” symposium to Paul H. Elovitz’s lead essay “Reflections on How People and Society Change,” the author reflects on psychoanalysis as a source of transformational change. Across its theoretical orientations, from classical drive theory to relational psychology, the author maintains that making the unconscious conscious loosens old narratives and lets analyst and analysand co-create new ones, and identifies freedom as the greatest change psychoanalysis offers. The author proposes Talmudic roots for this focus on one life, citing the precept of tikkun olam, “to repair the world,” and explains self and object representations through examples of infant-caretaker exchanges re-enacted in adulthood. Drawing on Elovitz’s treatment of Andrew Jackson and Abraham Lincoln, the author reads Lincoln’s 1856 remark about having been a slave to his father as bearing on his opposition to slavery, and links historical freedom movements to social, economic, and intrapsychic sources. The author then surveys American social movements and setbacks from the 1960s to 2016, alongside the Beatles’ “Revolution” and “Eve of Destruction,” and describes continuing racism, misogyny, xenophobia, and anti-Semitism. The piece closes by asking whether the gains will last, whether tikkun olam is possible, and who defines repair.

Keywords:

drive theory, ego psychology, intersubjectivity, neo-Freudianism, object relations, Paul H. Elovitz, psychic change, psychoanalysis, psychohistory, relational psychology, self-psychology, Sigmund Freud, Talmud

Psychoanalysis offers the potential for transformational change, that a person’s psyche can undergo restructuring, resulting in a personal transformation. Whatever the theoretical psychoanalytic orientation—classical drive theory, ego psychology, neo-Freudianism, object relations, self-psychology, intersubjectivity, relational psychology—the assumption is that the internal balance of aspects of the psyche will change.

These theoretical assumptions could be that conflict and undue inhibition can be dissolved, defenses that no longer are useful can be significantly lessened, social and cultural influences can be identified, self and object representations can alter, modes of conceptualizing relationships of self and others in the world can evolve because the unconscious has been made conscious, and the relation-

Page 134

ship between analyst and analysand itself has a therapeutic effect. As the unconscious becomes conscious, the old assumptions and narratives no longer continue to control the person’s mind, and new life-enhancing narratives can be co-created in the analytic dyad. The analysand gains freedom and can make choices unencumbered by the unproductive, limiting narratives that were revealed and analyzed.

Certainly, the evolving emphasis on culture and society in mid-century American psychoanalysis provides an intersection for psychohistory and psychoanalysis. In addition, the recognition of personality formation of individuals during early childhood that psychohistory offers gives insight into the currents in adulthood. These may then contribute to the creation of major historical events.

Between 200 CE and 500 CE, the Talmud, a major form of instruction in Judaism codifying an oral rabbinic tradition, was developed. One well-known precept from the Talmud is the concept of tikkun olam “to repair the world”—which has been interpreted in many ways, often as a way to preserve the best features of society and culture. Another related precept, appearing as early as the Yerushalmi (Jerusalem) Talmud, and later, in the Babylonian Talmud, is “to destroy a life, destroys a world. To save a life is to save a world.”

Thus, the work of psychoanalysis could be considered to have Talmudic roots, as the focus in the analytic dyad is on one life, the life of an analysand, who then finds a wholeness and a freedom. The emphasis is on the individual, though it may have a ripple effect on other people, society, culture, perhaps even the world. This also might be understood as personal redemption, a refining of character. The concept of redemption, of course, can be found in many religious traditions, but it also has secular resonance.

The greatest change psychoanalysis offers is freedom. With freedom, the individual has a much broader range of options and can make informed choices. The individual is no longer a prisoner of the past, a prisoner of unconscious forces. The individual is empowered.

Where might this lead? Here, Paul Elovitz’ essay has a particular resonance. Elovitz examines historical change reflecting the psyches of key historical figures, such as Andrew Jackson and Abraham Lincoln. His statement that “Abraham Lincoln in 1856

Page 135

declared ‘I used to be a slave’ referring to when his uneducated and domineering pioneer father virtually rented him out to neighbors” (Elovitz cites Sidney Blumenthal, A Self-Made Man: The Political Life of Abraham Lincoln: 1809-1849, 2016, 3, as the source) is particularly poignant. Of course we see in this statement Lincoln’s boyhood, and emancipation from the dictates of his father, as essential to his ethical foundation opposing slavery, resulting in the Emancipation Proclamation.

So many historical events are freedom movements, some basically philosophical, activist, actively rebellious, or revolutionary. There seems to be a great drive for people to emancipate themselves from the rigors and hardships of everyday life, oppression, imposed limits, and authoritarianism. Some of that drive toward emancipation may be primarily based on social/economic circumstances. Some may also be derived from personal intrapsychic events.

The drive toward emancipation based on personal intrapsychic events may be based on internalizations of particular interactions with early figures in an infant and child’s life. Those interactions result in a wide range of self-representations and psychic representations (objects in psychoanalytic terminology). The psychoanalytic use of the term “self” is fairly consistent with everyday language. The term “object” is derived from Freud’s concept that an id impulse, an instinctual drive and aim, is toward an object. The object of the aim is usually the primary caretaker in an infant’s life, usually the mother. Object relations theory inherited the term. Thus the object representation is an aspect of that caretaker. Here are examples of self and object representations: “Mommy is mad at me. Mommy is a screaming witch. I am a bad baby.” “Daddy laughs at me when I cry for my bankie. I need my bankie. Daddy is mean. I am stupid. I am foolish.” “Mommy smiles at me, her eyes are dancing. Mommy is wonderful. I am a wonderful baby.” “Mommy is always tired. She never wants to play. I am not important to her. I am a dull, boring baby.”

In the analytic process, the analyst examines with the analysand behaviors that turn out to be recapitulations of those earlier moments of baby and caretaker relating, those earlier self and object representations that are unconsciously re-enacted in adulthood. The analysand learns from recognizing those recapitulations, often in transferential fantasies about how the analyst will respond to whatever the analysand feels, thinks, or does. The haunting and

Page 136

limiting unconscious narrative is modified by the analysand, as he or she learns to create new narratives and possibilities.

A life has been changed. Therefore, the world may be changed as a result. We each are a world within ourselves, and we each have an impact on the greater world in various ways. Those ways may be limited in time, space, and range and, in some instances, those ways may extend vastly.

In 1968, the Beatles released a record, a single, with “Hey Jude” as the A side, and “Revolution” as the B side, and an album, “The White Album,” with a longer version of “Revolution,” written by John Lennon. The lyrics begin, “You say you want a revolution,/ Well, you know/ We all want to change the world,” and end with, “Don’t you know it’s gonna be all right, all right, all right….” The 1960’s were a time of social ferment, of great social movements. Was it “gonna be all right”? Have the great social movements resulted in lasting change?

In 1964, P. F. Sloan wrote a song, “Eve of Destruction,” which eventually was recorded by several rock groups. The chorus is, “And you tell me/ Over and over and over again, my friend/ Ah, you don’t believe/ We’re on the eve of destruction.”

Historical transformation may have a lasting impact, but does it really last? In the United States, we saw great social movements, with great social change: the Civil Rights Movement, for racial equality and justice; the Women’s Liberation Movement, using consciousness-raising groups as a tool; the anti-Vietnam War movement. There were terrible losses and meaningful victories. The Civil Rights Act was passed in 1964. Martin Luther King Jr. was assassinated in 1968. Roe v. Wade was decided in 1973. The Equal Rights Amendment (ERA) was defeated after a long series of states withdrew their original support. Change happened.

In 2008, the United States elected the first biracial president, and reelected him again in 2012. In 2016, the Democratic Party has a female nominee for president. Change happened. Yet the United States also has Donald Trump as the Republican nominee for president. Manifestations of racism, misogyny, xenophobia, and anti-Semitism are rampant. The Color of Change has sponsored and publicized #BlackLivesMatter to protest police shootings and killings of African-American men, women, and children. Sexual assaults of women on college campuses have been trivialized. The

Page 137

Boycott, Divestment and Sanctions (BDS) movement has manifested with anti-Semitic commentary on college campuses.

Change happened. Transformation happened. Will the positive aspects of that transformation last, or will a so-called “correction” distort the ongoing potential of that significant transformation? Is tikkun olam possible? Can the world be repaired? Who defines the nature of that repair?

Page 138

About the author

Merle Heidi Molofsky

Merle Heidi Molofsky, MFA, NCPsyA, LP, is a licensed psychoanalyst in private practice in New York State and a writer. Her writings include articles in professional journals and chapters in psychoanalytic books, fiction, and poetry. Her play, Grail Green (1971), was performed at Lincoln Center. International Psychoanalytic Books has published a volume of her poetry, Sh’Ma, I Hear Voices (2024); her novel, Streets 1970 (2015); her collection of short fiction, Necessary Voices (2018); and a volume she edited, Jew-Hating: The Black Milk of Civilization (2023). She serves on the Editorial Boards of The Psychoanalytic Review and The Journal of Controversial Discussions, the Advisory Board and Faculty of Harlem Family Institute, and the faculty of the Training Institute of NPAP. She can be contacted at .

How to cite this article

Molofsky, M. (2017). Transformational change to repair the world. Clio’s Psyche, 23(2), 134-138.

https://doi.org/10.70763/aba18772fc70c8cbf79a79f413ef102b

PDF downloads