
Volume 17 - Number 4 - March 2011
Pages: 275 - 371
Petschauer, P. (2011). All war deaths and suffering are memorable. Clio’s Psyche, 17(4), 339-343.
All War Deaths and Suffering Are Memorable
Abstract
In this article, the author reflects from his own background on two points he takes from Rudolf Kreis’s Die Toten sind immer die Anderen: Eine Jugend zwischen den Kriegen (2009). The first is that treating the Jewish victims of the Holocaust as uniquely deserving of attention narrows awareness of other Europeans who died and suffered before, during, and after World War II. The second is that emphasizing uniqueness does not deter future harm to ethnic or religious groups. He recounts how he came to his view: studying Russian and Soviet history at New York University, including the Siberian exile and camp systems; later studying Soviet, German, and American military commanders; his German-speaking childhood and American citizenship; conversations with Jewish fellow psychohistorians from the late 1970s and with a colleague who was a hidden Jewish child; and coming to terms with his own family’s wartime history. He maintains that commemorating one group’s deaths above others’ makes it easier to demean other groups, and that it overlooks soldiers who fought Nazi Germany, conscripted German soldiers, survivors who suffered lifelong physical and psychological harm, and civilians who endured bombing and hunger. Citing Martin Niemöller’s account of failing to act as successive groups were attacked, he argues that honoring all the dead and all survivors would guard against the abuse of Jews, Muslims, Roma, and, in the United States, American Indians, African Americans, and Mexicans. He contends that the European Union arose from this awareness.
Dead are Always the Others: A Childhood between the Wars (Die Toten sind immer die Anderen: Eine Jugend zwischen den Kriegen), Holocaust, psychohistory, Rudolf Kreis, war death toll, war trauma, World War II (WWII)
Rudolf Kreis makes two unique points about the Holocaust in Die Toten sind immer die Anderen: Eine Jugend zwischen den Kriegen (The Dead are Always the Others: A Childhood between the Wars, 2009). Neither is new, but the second encouraged the following reflections.
His first point is that the exclusive assignment of the murders and suffering perpetrated on Jews closes the opportunity to address the murders and suffering of other Europeans before, during, and after the Second World War (WWII). Indeed, an emphasis on one group, be it Jews, Poles, Russians, or Germans, lessens our awareness of others who also died and suffered. The suffering of others is ignored or diminished.
Kreis maintains as his second point that emphasizing uniqueness does nothing to discourage future harm to ethnic or religious groups. Ironically, by elevating one group over others, we encourage others to follow suit and proceed to diminish other groups. Experience tells us that diminishing groups other than our own can and does lead to unwelcome consequences.
Page 339
A psychohistorian must always ask: “How did I arrive at this certain point of view?” I first learned of the major atrocities of the 20th century at New York University, in connection with studies of Russian and Soviet History. I read and wrote about the imperial government’s exiles (the famous Decembrists of 1825) and the first camps it created in Siberia in the later 19th century. With my interest sparked, the later Soviet camps and their economic impact became one of my areas of concentration. Sending generals and technocrats to Siberia made no sense to me; just as little as murdering hundreds of thousands of productive farmers in Ukraine to fulfill the Soviet leadership’s ideological dreams.
Quite naturally, I next discovered WWII. I was torn between focusing on the Soviet/German side and the American/ German side. The Soviet side intrigued me because I had studied Russian and Soviet history, economics, and government. The German side intrigued me because of my German parents and my childhood in German-speaking parts of Europe. The American side intrigued me because I had become an American citizen and a patriotic immigrant. So, I studied Georgy Zhukov and Konstantin Rokossovsky, Erwin Rommel and Hans Speidel, and Dwight Eisenhower and George Patton, initially overlooking the human and other costs of war. Only with time did the so-called casualties of the war become dead and maimed human beings.
The reality of the Holocaust first entered my understanding when I met fellow psychohistorians in New York City in the late 1970s; the ones with whom I enjoyed long conversations happened to be Jewish. The second contribution to my understanding was dealing with my father’s position in the SS (the German Schutzstaffel unit most devoted to Hitler and associated with crimes against humanity) and therefore possibly having committed war crimes. The third was speaking many times with one of my colleagues, a hidden child from Poland, at educational and religious settings about our different experiences of the early 1940s in Europe. In the case of the first, most members of the families of some of these New York Jews had been killed in Eastern Europe. In the case of the second, my father turned out to be a loyal diplomat whose unit was taken over by Himmler’s extensive machinery, but who committed no crimes. In the case of the third, I realized that being Jew-
Page 340
ish in Europe meant not only concentration camps, but also having to emigrate, having to hide, and being shot in the middle of or near one’s town.
The early exposure to the millions murdered and abused in the Soviet Union, the other millions in WWII, and the later recognition of the killing of civilians by the Nazis and their supporters led me to seriously reconsider Kreis’ points. As my colleague Zohara Boyd (a hidden Jewish child during the Holocaust) and I spoke to various groups, I had already begun to realize that talking about the murdered six million Jews to the exclusion of others who were murdered does nothing to prevent other national or ethnic groups from engaging in similar activities again. Indeed, we must never forget, but finding a way to prevent such slaughter had become a key concern.
Exclusivity elevates the deaths of a selected group above all others. The dead would probably ask us, and we must say for them: Is my death less meaningful than that of another person’s? Is the death of the Russian soldier who was shot upon arrival in a German prison camp less meaningful than that of a German prisoner who slowly starved to death in a Siberian camp? Or, asked more immediately: is the death of an Italian Jew in a truck from Milan to Bozen-Bolzano less meaningful than that of an American soldier who gave his life liberating a concentration camp in Germany?
Indeed, all Europeans who were killed in the name of fanatics and adherents to inhumane ideologies deserve to be honored; their deaths, and the suffering of all survivors, must be seen as a warning against extremists and others who would readily perpetrate similar mayhem. If they are not, then we allow them to abuse or kill this or that person or group because they are less “valuable.” Unfortunately, as soon as the offenders have demeaned a person or group as “vermin” or “obstacles,” that is exactly what happens. Thus, a German demeaned a Jew or Pole, and vice versa, a Frenchman demeaned a German or Italian; in each case, the “other” was portrayed as less than human and subject to prison, torture and death. As we know so well, almost all of those who died and suffered abuse were innocent.
In elevating the death of some, however well intended or
Page 341
deemed necessary, one also tends to ignore the deaths of the soldiers and fighters who struggled against the Nazi regime and its assistants. While the Soviet soldiers committed all too many crimes and abuses in Eastern and Central Europe, the ten million of them who fell should not be pushed aside, nor should the deaths of the other soldiers who fought against the Nazi regime. We can argue against Kreis and not include the mostly draftees in the regular German Army and the SS tankers to whom he belonged as a 17-year old, but the death of these six million men was caused by the same fanaticism that enabled the deaths of civilians.
Something else is difficult with elevating the deaths of some individuals over those of others. In the process, we all too often ignore those who suffered as they did but survived. Many of these persons anguished all their lives, and some have said that they would have preferred to have been killed rather than live through the hell that followed from their exposure to the consequences of the evildoers. To live with the wounds that the perpetrators inflicted, physical and mental, was enough to have driven many to an early death through suicide and the familiar diseases of cancer, high blood pressure, and diabetes. Can we ever imagine the fear of being on a death march in Austria in the winter of 1945, as fellow prisoners were being shot for no reason or being trampled to death? This is the trauma that lingers for a lifetime.
Such a stance also ignores the suffering of all other contemporaries. Those individuals who lived in cities like London, Kiev, Warsaw, Nuremberg and Dresden would never be “the same.” The bombing raids alone were horrific. One dramatic example is a woman in Düsseldorf, whom my mother and I knew reasonably well, whose featherbed caught a fire bomb and thus prevented it from exploding—but who saw her entire street burn down in a firestorm. Indeed she was never the same again, and we sensed her confusion in every conversation. Hunger, cold, exposure to the elements, unspeakable behaviors of occupational troops as well as other atrocities are imbedded in the souls of so many who survived.
Yes, the politics of death are offensive. Unless we honor all of the dead and the survivors, we give excuses in this country and others to say that this or that group deserves to be shunned, pushed aside, and maybe, given the “right” circumstances, put in prison,
Page 342
reservation, camp, and even murdered.
In an odd way, the exclusive assignment of value to one death over another makes it easier to abuse Jews, Muslims, Roma, and even more relevantly here in the U.S., American Indians, African Americans and Mexicans. That is, we continue to argue, in vain, that “my” group is more important than “your” group and “my” group deserves to thrive more than “your” group. As Martin Niemöller told a professor in Kronenberg between 1950-1954, who related the conversation this way:
When the Nazis attacked the Communists, he [Niemöller] was a little uneasy, but, after all, he was not a Communist, and so he did nothing; and then they attacked the Socialists, and he was a little uneasier, but, still, he was not a Socialist, and he did nothing; and then the schools, the press, the Jews, and so on, and he was always uneasier, but still he did nothing. And then they attacked the Church, and he was a Churchman, and he did something—but then it was too late. (http://www.history.ucsb.edu/ faculty/marcuse/niem.htm).
Exclusivity made Niemöller ignore the commonality of plight. His later endeavor to pin down his reactions allowed Europeans to gain the lesson of the arbitrariness of abuse. The European Union exists as an outcome of this awareness.
Page 343
How to cite this article
Petschauer, P. (2011). All war deaths and suffering are memorable. Clio’s Psyche, 17(4), 339-343.



