Volume 25 - Number 1 - Fall 2018
Pages: 1 - 125

BOOK AND MOVIE REVIEWS

Petschauer, P. W. (2018). The importance of The Making of Psychohistory [Review of the book The Making of Psychohistory: Origins, Controversies, and Pioneering Contributors by Paul H. Elovitz (2018)]. Clio’s Psyche, 25(1), 108-112.

https://doi.org/10.70763/bdd8817990ef209f0fb6b049f2d2ea0c

The Importance of The Making of Psychohistory

book review

Abstract

This book review by Peter W. Petschauer assesses Paul H. Elovitz’s The Making of Psychohistory: Origins, Controversies, and Pioneering Contributors (Routledge, 2018), which the reviewer characterizes as both a personal statement about Elovitz’s place in psychohistory and a history of the field. The review reports the Introduction’s demographic findings on psychohistorians, drawn from interviews conducted for Clio’s Psyche, covering religion, geographic concentration, and gender (84 percent male). The reviewer agrees that the field has not reached out enough to women and proposes a further reason: its lack of standing with the major history associations and departments made it a risky choice for young women professionals. The reviewer also attributes the field’s limited development to the International Psychohistorical Association’s reluctance to meet outside New York City, to the scarcity of historians in the field and so of cultural, environmental, women’s, and gender history, and to limited access to foreign-language scholarship. The review notes that the book concentrates on individual psychohistorians. It reports that Charles Strozier and Lawrence Friedman named Richard Hofstadter as overlooked and observes that group fantasy receives only passing mention. It lists the chapters, end-of-chapter notes, two appendices, and index. The reviewer credits Elovitz’s enthusiasm and his exposition of individual contributors’ work, and recommends the book to psychohistorians and others interested in the field.

Keywords:

book review, Charles Strozier, childhood, childrearing, Clio’s Psyche, David Beisel, female contributions, foreign languages scholarship, International Psychohistorical Association (IPhA), Lloyd DeMause, The Making of Psychohistory: Origins, Controversies, and Pioneering Contributors, Paul H. Elovitz, psychohistory

Review of Paul H. Elovitz, The Making of Psychohistory: Origins, Controversies, and Pioneering Contributors (New York and London: Routledge, 2018), ISBN 978-1-138-58749-6, 138 pages, paperback, $38.95, hardbound, $140.

Page 108

Professor Paul Elovitz’ The Making of Psychohistory is both a personal statement about his own place in psychohistory and a history of psychohistory. This is as it should be; as a psychohistorian, one must inform readers how to approach a particular historical topic. Let us consider a couple of important questions: Who are the psychohistorians? What do they do exactly?

In the Introduction (7) and based on the psychohistorians whom he and others in the field have interviewed over many years for Clio’s Psyche, the journal he has very successfully edited for 25 years, Elovitz tells the reader that 51% of today’s psychohistorians are Jewish and 43% Christian, and that there is one Muslim and one Hindu in the group. They are centered principally in the metropolitan areas of New York, Boston, Chicago, Toronto, Los Angeles, and San Francisco. He notes as well that 84% of the sample is male and 16% is female.

I agree with Elovitz that members of the field have not sufficiently reached out to women, but there may be a deeper reason for this gender imbalance. Young professional women, historians specifically but also psychologists, could not have risked their already frail career prospects to enter a field that has no cachet with the leading history association, history departments, and psychological organizations. Thus, psychohistory became a field filled with men, some of whom felt ostracized and who gradually grew older and became even less attractive as role models. Why should young women have joined a group of men whose leaders felt rejected by those who would have made their careers possible? Why join a group of men who could not place them in departments or other professional opportunities?

Elovitz, like many psychohistorians, recounts the lack of approval by “regular” historians, their associations, and departments (22). Professor David Beisel, at the 2018 International Psychohistorical Association (IPA) meeting in New York City (at the end of May/beginning of June), highlighted this failed quest and noted as well that as a group and as individuals psychohistorians have endeavored to gain their fathers’, that is, “regular” historians’, approval.

Elovitz mentions that location has been a determinant in the limited development of psychohistory. There has also been a pronounced reluctance of the members of the IPA—centered in New York and New Jersey—to meet in places other than New York City

Page 109

for its annual convention. There could have been places like Chicago and the west coast cities to meet in every so often. But shying away from this potential outreach hampered the organization’s ability to hear other scholars on their home turf, to appeal there to younger individuals and to women. For better or worse, psychohistory as embodied in the IPA became a field of scholars who meet annually in NYC and otherwise read each other’s papers, books, and blogs.

Elovitz’ approach is to concentrate on individuals who did and do psychohistory, even if they may not call themselves psychohistorians. He is, of course, fully aware that psychohistory depends very much on key individuals, especially those he highlights. The field is all about individuals and is not a movement.

Charles Strozier made an interesting comment about psychohistory at the IPA convention. He noted that as a group psychohistorians are not very interested in the more recent historical movements or social classes, like the working class—a topic dear to historians for at least the last five decades! Indeed, because there are so few historians left in psychohistory, it is missing some of the movements within history—cultural history, environmental history, women’s and gender studies—that have allowed “regular” historians to shed light on the past that psychoanalysts and psychologists would be unaware of by the nature of their fields.

Sadly, there is a lack of access to foreign language scholarship. Elovitz makes this point implicitly by highlighting some of the key individuals in psychohistory, namely those with a foreign language background. Among these researchers are Freud, Erikson, Binion, Volkan, Gay, Loewenberg, and Mitscherlich. I could add myself and several others who were born abroad, lived a wide range of past experiences, and were or are historians as well as psychologically trained scholars. That is not to say that historians, psychologists, or psychohistorians cannot learn a foreign language. Of course they can. But it is saying that most do not, and thus they lack access to broader understandings of the past. We were missing (until its publication in English in 1996), among many others, Arthur E. Imhof’s The Lost Worlds: Dealing with the Daily Life of Our Ancestors and Why We Are Having Such a Difficult Time Understanding It (C. H. Beck, 1984). Imhof takes apart traditional statistics and historical arguments using social, anthropological, psychological, and, yes, even historical insights into the past of a small German village. The point is that one cannot do psychohisto-

Page 110

ry without a deep and wide awareness of the past, and it may often require more than English.

Elovitz’ major contribution to the history of psychohistory is his inspiring enthusiasm for the field and the exposition of the work of the individuals who made major contributions to it. It is inevitable that some individuals are left out or feel underappreciated. According to both Strozier and Lawrence Friedman at the 2018 IPA, Richard Hofstadter is one of the overlooked scholars. Friedman also thought he was underappreciated as Elovitz discussed Erikson. But then maybe Friedman overlooked page 115 where Elovitz praises his contributions to the field.

While Elovitz speaks of childhood and childrearing in the past, he mentions only in passing group fantasy (47, 97), a topic dear to some psychohistorians, especially one of its towering figures, Lloyd deMause.

The reason for giving the following chapter headings of the book is so that The Making of Psychohistory’s overall thrust is not lost in the broader discussion of it. After the Introduction with opening thoughts, the aforementioned demographics, and chapter-by-chapter synopses, Professor Elovitz carefully elaborates his own approach in several chapters of his book. He entitled the second chapter, “My Exuberant Journey”; the fourth, “Resistance and Perseverance”; the ninth, “My Journey as Psychohistorical Teacher”; the tenth, “My Role in Creating and Nurturing Postgraduate Psychohistorical Education”; the 11th, “The Dilemmas of a Presidential Psychohistorian”; and the 12th, “Finding My Voice with Halpern, deMause, and Ullman.”

Other chapters of the book are chapter three, “The Early History of Psychohistory”; chapter five, “Comparing the Early Freudian and Psychohistorical Movements”; chapter six, “A Psychohistorian’s Approach to Childhood and Childrearing”; chapter seven, “Prominent Psychohistorians Lifton, deMause, and Volkan”; chapter eight, “Outstanding Psychohistorians Gay, Loewenberg and Binion”; and chapter 13, “Builders of Psychohistory.”

The notes are conveniently placed at the end of each chapter in the book; they are highly informative and worth reading. Elovitz also added two helpful appendices: one lists the names of scholars, editors, and authors he and other fellow contributors have interviewed for Clio’s Psyche, and the other is a list of the memorials that have appeared in Clio’s Psyche. There is an index as well.

Page 111

I highly recommend this book both to fellow psychohistorians and others interested in the field and related fields. It is well written, personal, engaging, thoughtful, and informative.

Page 112

About the author

Peter W. Petschauer

Peter W. Petschauer, PhD, New York University, taught at Appalachian State University, 1968-2006. (Now a writer and poet.) Initially courses in European and Russian History, later women and children.

Several administrative positions.

Also chair of Appalachian’s faculty senate and then chair of UNC-System’s faculty assembly.

Now on two arts-related boards at ASU and on two boards of psychohistorical journals.

Books: Faustina. Ein freies Mädchen und eine gefangene Fürstin. Das einzigartige Paar auf dem Römerhof bei Erlstätt (Faustina. A free girl and a captive duchess. The unique pair on the Roman farm near Erlstätt), 2025;Was man so Alles lernt, (All the Things one Learns) 2024; In Troubled Times Beauty. Listen to Rarely Heard Voices (poetry), 2022; An Immigrant in the 1960s. Finding Hope and Success in New York City; Hopes and Fears. Past and Present (poetry); A Perfect Portrait, about a young female artist in 18th-century Weimar; In the Face of Evil. The Sustenance of Traditions; The Father and the SS.

Articles, etc.: over 250 articles in journals and collections, several hundred presentations/ lectures.

; peterpetschauer.com

How to cite this article

Petschauer, P. W. (2018). The importance of The Making of Psychohistory [Review of the book The Making of Psychohistory: Origins, Controversies, and Pioneering Contributors by Paul H. Elovitz (2018)]. Clio’s Psyche, 25(1), 108-112.

https://doi.org/10.70763/bdd8817990ef209f0fb6b049f2d2ea0c

PDF downloads