
Volume 17 - Number 4 - March 2011
Pages: 275 - 371
Pomper, P. (2011). The revolutionary Russian origins of modern terrorism [Review of the book Death Orders: The Vanguard of Modern Terrorism in Revolutionary Russia by Anna Geifman (2010)]. Clio’s Psyche, 17(4), 346-348.
The Revolutionary Russian Origins of Modern Terrorism
Abstract
This book review essay considers Anna Geifman’s Death Orders: The Vanguard of Modern Terrorism in Revolutionary Russia (Praeger, 2010), which the reviewer describes as a contrapuntal history alternating between the Russian Empire and the modern Middle East. The reviewer reports that Geifman treats the revolution of 1905 and its aftermath as the point at which earlier, more targeted terrorism gave way to forms closer to contemporary practice, and that she draws on Robert Jay Lifton’s concept of historical dislocations, linked to modernization, totalistic thinking, and thanatophilia. The reviewer judges the portrayals of hostages at Ma’alot and Beslan and of attacks in Moscow and Tel Aviv to be effective. The reviewer questions whether thanatophilia can account for more than some terrorists and identifies a tension between the breadth of Geifman’s examples and her stated focus. The reviewer also notes that she gives altruistic suicidal terrorists only brief attention. Discussing Sergei Nechaev and the “Catechism of a Revolutionary,” the reviewer proposes that dehumanizing enemies and constructing modes of immortality are widespread human tendencies. The reviewer concludes that terrorism’s fires may burn out historically but that technology and weapons of mass destruction enlarge the potential danger, and that although Geifman hopes for a collective choice of life, her account prepares readers for the worst.
Anna Geifman, book review, contemporary terrorism, Death Orders: The Vanguard of Modern Terrorism in Revolutionary Russia, hostages, Middle East, modern terrorism, Moscow, psychohistory, revolution of 1905, Russian Empire, terrorism origins, Tsarist officials
Review essay of Anna Geifman, Death Orders: The Vanguard of Modern Terrorism in Revolutionary Russia (Santa Barbara, CA: Praeger, 2010) 229 pages, ISBN 978-0275997526 Hardcover, $34.95.
Anna Geifman has written a contrapuntal history of modern terrorism. She provides a late 20th and early 21st century counterpoint to the bloody deeds of parties and individuals of the Russian Empire. The method involves scene-shifting and time-travel, from sites in the Russian Empire to the modern Middle East and back. She effectively portrays the misery and hopelessness of hostages and the single-mindedness of terrorists; for example, at Ma’alot in Israel, Beslan in North Ossetia, and the dreadful carnage in Moscow and Tel Aviv in places where people go to enjoy life—a theater, a disco. The treatment of hostages—of innocent women and children—especially brings home the mercilessness of contemporary terrorism. These extreme variations of terrorism differ from that practiced against Tsarist officials by some Russian terrorists in the late 19th and early 20th centuries, although those often had “collateral damage.” Geifman believes that the previous forms of terrorism were quickly replaced by something more akin to contemporary terrorism during the revolution of 1905 and its aftermath.
Page 346
Geifman avers that the historical causes of 20th century forms of terrorism are what Robert Jay Lifton calls “historical dislocations,” which entail threats to a community’s symbolic immortality. Historical dislocations attend wars, civil wars, genocide, and mass traumas due to natural catastrophes; but the modernization process itself is an ongoing problem for all cultures. Modernization can be fertile soil for totalistic thinking, which in its denial of death sometimes paradoxically produces the thanatophilia and apocalyptic cults of Geifman’s narrative. Contemporary media spreads the pathology far beyond the actual sites of trauma to those susceptible to death imagery, and to anomic individuals vulnerable to recruitment into groups that perform murder-suicide missions. However, now the terrorists have been mobilized not only in service of secular socialist or communist doctrines but in the name of Islam.
One encounters in the literature on terrorism sympathetic portrayals of altruistic suicidal terrorists, but Geifman gives the category only a glance and focuses on “‘adventuristic, annihilatory’ terror that originated in the first decade of the 20th century” (3). At the very base of “death orders” she finds thanatophilia, but surely this drives only some terrorists. Geifman throws out a large net and brings in a great many practitioners of terrorism, so there is a tension between the wealth of Geifman’s illustrations and her theoretical statement of focus. Geifman intensely studied the early 20th century in an earlier book, Thou Shalt Kill: Revolutionary Terrorism in Russia, 1894-1917 (1995). However, she also studied certain Russian precursors. Sergei Nechaev, the inspiration for Dostoevsky’s Devils, stands out as someone who dehumanized his targets and helped create the “death culture” of the 20th century. Ruthless creeds like the “Catechism of a Revolutionary” (1869) dramatized the notion that any means might be used in the service of secular and religious totalisms.
We recognize in this process something stubborn and pervasive in our species. We casually denigrate out-groups in the banal competitions of ordinary social life. Dehumanization of the enemy is a standard move in more serious struggles. Those readying themselves to kill often transform their enemies into grotesque caricatures, demons, vermin—pseudo species—and elevate themselves into heroes and martyrs. The ideologues set very high stakes: the
Page 347
survival of one’s community in a hostile world, the rewards of martyrdom. All of this seems to exist in human psychology, ready to be activated, as does the tendency to construct modes of immortality as rewards for our actions. Less totalistic forms of terrorism do exist, but Geifman argues that the totalistic variant dominates contemporary Islamic terrorism. Historical evidence suggests that the fires will burn themselves out; that cultures of death and destruction cannot be sustained indefinitely. But the population base for contemporary terrorism is potentially quite large because technology expands the reach of ideologues and practitioners of terrorism. Even if we know terrorism’s typical patterns, the conjunction of non-state terrorist networks with easily deliverable weapons of mass destruction creates new nightmare scenarios. As of now, all of the casualties of this new era of terrorism are still miniscule compared to the concentrated slaughter of state-sponsored modern wars and genocides, but we do not know the end of the story. Although Geifman presents the hope that collectively we choose life in the ongoing dialectic of death and life imagery, her contrapuntal history of terrorist atrocities prepares us for the worst.
Page 348
How to cite this article
Pomper, P. (2011). The revolutionary Russian origins of modern terrorism [Review of the book Death Orders: The Vanguard of Modern Terrorism in Revolutionary Russia by Anna Geifman (2010)]. Clio’s Psyche, 17(4), 346-348.



