Volume 23 - Number 1 - Fall 2016
Pages: 1 - 101

PSYCHOBIOGRAPHY AND PSYCHOHISTORY IN A GLOBAL CONTEXT

Ponterotto, J. G. (2016). Bobby Fischer, the Cold War, and the global reach of psychobiography. Clio’s Psyche, 23(1), 51-59.

https://doi.org/10.70763/14678db82874f1456031fcc05a3afaf6

Bobby Fischer, the Cold War, and the Global Reach of Psychobiography

article

Abstract

The author examines Bobby Fischer’s life through psychobiographical analysis, addressing four central questions: how Fischer achieved chess mastery, the origins of his anti-Semitism, his growing hostility toward the United States, and his forfeiture of the world title to Anatoly Karpov in 1975. The author traces these outcomes to Fischer’s unstable childhood, FBI surveillance of his mother, feelings of abandonment, and a personal identity fused with his chess identity. The piece concludes by reflecting on the need for mental health support for gifted children.

Keywords:

antisemitism, Bobby Fischer, Boris Spassky, Cold War, Erik Erikson, Giorgio Vasari, individualism, psychobiography, psychohistory, Sigmund Freud, Zoltan Kőváry

This special feature of Clio’s Psyche focuses on psychobiography in a global context. Interest in psychobiography transcends time, place, and culture. From Vasari’s (1550) study of the lives of great artists, to Freud’s (1910) psychoanalytic profile of

Page 51

Leonardo Da Vinci, to Erikson’s (1969) Pulitzer Prize-winning psychobiography of Mahatma Gandhi, humans have been fascinated with the lives and psyches of significant personalities throughout history. Psychobiography is, in and of itself, a global phenomenon, and as emphasized by Hungarian psychobiographer Zoltan Kőváry, we are in the midst of a “renaissance in psychobiography” (Europe’s Journal of Psychology, 2011, 7 [4], 739-777).

My work in psychobiography over the last eight years has focused on one person: Robert “Bobby” James Fischer (1943-2008), former Chess Champion of the World (1972-1975). Fischer was an iconic and enigmatic figure who, for a short time during the height of Cold War tensions between the Soviet Union and the U.S., may have been the most famous person on earth. Fischer’s epic battle over the chessboard against the then-reigning World Champion, Soviet Grandmaster Boris Spassky, captured the attention of the world. Fischer was a global phenomenon, and he helped make chess the world’s most popular board game.

Bobby Fischer has been the subject of multiple biographies—the best researched among these are those by Professor Frank Brady (St. John’s University), which include Bobby Fischer: Profile of a Prodigy (2nd ed., 1973) and, more recently, Endgame: The Spectacular Rise and Fall of Bobby Fischer (2011). There have also been two book-length psychobiographies of Fischer. The first was a strictly Freudian analysis by noted psychoanalyst and Chess Grandmaster Reuben Fine, titled Bobby Fischer’s Conquest of the World’s Championship (1973); the second, by myself, was the multi-theoretically anchored A Psychobiography of Bobby Fischer (2012). While these book-length treatments of Fischer had a comprehensive lifespan focus, oftentimes psychobiographers narrow their research to specific mysteries in the lives of historic figures.

In the short space I have to describe the psychology of Fischer, I will focus on four mysteries surrounding the legacy of the USA’s only world chess champion: How did Bobby Fischer get so good at chess? What are the origins of his vitriolic anti-Semitism? Why did he come to despise the United States, his country of birth? Finally, why did Fischer forfeit his title to the Soviet challenger Anatoly Karpov during the apex of his chess brilliance at the age of 32? To address these questions, it is important to first understand, at least in part, the historic and political circumstances of Fischer’s early life. The context and researched facts in the summary below

Page 52

stem from the works cited above, particularly A Psychobiography of Bobby Fischer (2012; hereafter Fischer).

Disadvantaged Childhood, the Cold War, and FBI Surveillance

Bobby Fischer was born in 1943 in Chicago to a single mother, Regina Fischer. Regina, who had been born in Switzerland in 1913, immigrated to the U.S. with her mother, father, and older brother Max in 1914. The family was of Polish-Jewish heritage. Bobby had a sister Joan, who was five years older and born in Moscow in 1937 where Regina was studying medicine (1933-1938). Prior to moving to the Soviet Union, Regina was visiting Berlin where she met her future husband Hans Gerhardt Fischer, a highly respected physicist. Escaping the Nazis, the couple moved to Moscow where Gerhardt found employment at the Moscow Brain Institute and where Regina started studies at the First Moscow Medical Institute. In 1939, Regina returned to the United States with her daughter Joan; Gerhardt never joined them and the couple divorced in 1945.

In the early 1940’s, Regina was studying at Boulder, Colorado, where she met the math instructor Paul Nemenyi, a Hungarian-Jewish mathematician and engineer who fled the Nazi rise in 1939. Most Fischer biographers believe Paul Nemenyi to be Bobby’s biological father, and while he helped support Regina, Joan, and Bobby financially to some degree, he and Regina never married. Researchers believe that Regina never told Bobby of his true paternity, given the stigma in the early 1940s of being born out of wedlock. In fact, Regina instructed the birth physician to list Gerhardt Fischer as Bobby’s father on his birth certificate. Family secrets such as these can promote feelings of mistrust and lack of safety in one’s life; feelings that stayed with Bobby throughout his life.

In the U.S., Regina Fischer had joined the American Communist Party in 1945. Given her long sojourn and medical training in Moscow, along with her linguistic skills (she was fluent in Russian and other languages), she soon came under the scrutiny of J. Edgar Hoover and the FBI. Though she was never arrested or deemed to be a Soviet spy, Regina was surveilled by the FBI for almost three decades (from shortly before Bobby’s birth in 1943 through 1972). The FBI amassed a 994-page dossier on Regina Fischer, which I have closely studied and discuss at length in my psychobiography of her son. Bobby was told as a young boy not to talk to strange men who were asking questions about his mother. In this case, Bobby had good reason to be cautious and mistrustful of

Page 53

others—a “healthy paranoia”—as indeed the family was being followed.

During Bobby’s early years, Regina travelled across many cities looking for employment. FBI surveillance and interviews with Regina’s friends, associates, and employers made it difficult for her to keep a job. Fischer biographer Frank Brady documented that Regina, Joan, and Bobby moved residences across multiple cities, ten times before Bobby reached seven years of age. Furthermore, by the fourth grade, Bobby had been in and out of six different schools. Clearly, stability was not a characteristic of Bobby and Joan’s childhoods.

Regina had few financial resources and her family struggled economically. When Regina could find employment, she often worked long hours and Bobby was often in the care of his older sister. Bobby also spent considerable time alone, even as a child. After being introduced to the game of chess at six years of age by his sister, chess became his constant companion. He remarked as a child, “All I want to do, ever, is play chess” (Ponterotto, Fischer, 3). Chess was a stabilizing, familiar, and reliable factor in his life; he could even play against himself, and take his little chess set wherever he went. With chess he was never fully alone. Unfortunately, by living primarily in his “chess world,” Bobby was at-risk of losing contact with a broader social environment, which would be important to healthy childhood and adolescent development.

How Did Fischer Get So Good at Chess?  

Bobby’s brilliance at chess resulted from a confluence of factors. First, his mother Regina Fischer and his biological father Paul Nemenyi were both highly intelligent. Dr. Nemenyi was a renowned mathematician whose “Nemenyi’s Theorem” deals with isothermal curves and fluid dynamics (reviewed in Truesdell, 1952, Paul Felix Nemenyi: 1895-1952 [Obituary], Science, 116 [3009], 215-216). Second, Bobby loved playing chess and studied or played for hours each day. As he became very good at chess, his skill level increased, as did his self-esteem. His personal sense of identity, more and more, became fused with his chess identity. This drove him further to full dedication to chess and he quit Erasmus High School in Brooklyn in his junior year to be able to play chess full time. Malcolm Gladwell, in his popular book Outliers: The Story of Success (2008), integrates research evidence that supports the position that world class and elite status in a defined field (e.g., chess, violin, mathematics) requires roughly 10,000 hours of

Page 54

deliberate study. Estimating the number of hours Fischer studied chess each day, it is believed he had reached this 10,000 hour mark around the age of 15, which is indeed the age he was when awarded the International Grandmaster Title, the youngest person in history up until that point in time to be so honored.

A third factor in Bobby’s chess development was his social environment. Though at first Bobby’s mother encouraged him to broaden his interest beyond chess, she eventually acquiesced to his chess obsession and worked hard to raise funds for his travel and support his career. She also found chess teachers and mentors for her son. Thus Bobby got great at chess due to A) some genetic predispositions for spatial visualization, memory, and intense focus; B) a childhood and youth environment that, for good or bad, encouraged the singular pursuit of his talent; and most of all C) by studying and working at the game constantly for decades.

Why Was Bobby So Anti-Semitic?

Bobby Fischer’s mother and biological father were Jewish. However, Regina Fischer was more communist-aligned and culturally Jewish than she was religiously Jewish. Though biographer Frank Brady presents evidence that Bobby was Bar Mitzvahed as a child, Bobby later disavowed any Jewish identity (Endgame: The Spectacular Rise and Fall of Bobby Fischer, 2011). Bobby had no relationship with his sister’s biological father, Gerhardt Fischer (who was Protestant).

Bobby showed few if any signs of anti-Semitism in his youth and early adulthood; however, after he became World Champion at the age of 29 and moved to the Los Angeles area, his expressions of anti-Semitism grew continually. These were fueled by his reading of anti-Semitic literature and listening to radio broadcasts by Herbert W. Armstrong, head of the Worldwide Church of God. The seeds of his anti-Semitism, however, were sown earlier in life through his sense of abandonment. Fischer researchers noted that Bobby’s mother spent a good amount of time with Jewish intellectual friends, which Bobby resented because it took her away from him. Bobby’s biological father, Paul Nemenyi, was Jewish and lived apart from the family; he died in 1952, when Bobby was nine years old.

When Bobby was 17 years of age, his mother left their Brooklyn apartment for good to prepare for the year-long “San Francisco to Moscow March for Peace” (1960-1961). In an often-

Page 55

cited interview with journalist Ralph Ginzburg around this time, Bobby discussed his mother leaving their apartment: “She and I just don’t see eye-to-eye together. She’s a square…she keeps in my hair and I don’t like people in my hair, you know, so I had to get rid of her” (Ginzburg, 1962, “Portrait of a Genius as a Young Chess Master,” Harper’s Magazine, 224, 1340, January, 49-55). Though Bobby on one level wanted his independence so he could play and study chess uninterrupted, on some level, living without any parent at the age of 17 may have elicited feelings of abandonment.

Bobby also clashed with Jewish members of the chess community. The leading American player before Bobby was an Orthodox Jewish-American player, Samuel Reshevsky. Bobby felt that the American Chess Foundation was favoring Reshevsky with financial and travel support to tournaments. Thus, in my psychobiography of Fischer, I hypothesize that on some level, Bobby paired, or associated, Jewishness with his feelings of abandonment from his mother, biological father, and the U.S. chess establishment. In the 1940’s and 1950’s, there was also a nationally pervasive feeling of anti-Semitism. During this period, American Jews Julius and Ethel Rosenberg were convicted (1951) and executed (1953) for conspiracy to commit espionage. In the minds of many Americans, being Jewish and communist were associated. It is believed that once Bobby abandoned competitive chess and the structure of tournament life, his isolation grew, as did his own internalized anti-Semitism. Unfortunately, for the last decade or so of his life, Bobby was known more for his vitriolic anti-Semitism than he was for his chess achievements. Bobby represented the “self-loathing Jew” as conceptualized by David Mamet (The Wicked Son, 2006) in discussing the existential emptiness that can lead to self-hatred. From a more modern psychological perspective, one might say that Bobby developed an internalized anti-Semitism, absorbing the broader social prejudice toward the Jewish people.

Why did Bobby Grow to Hate America?

In 1972, as Bobby was wavering about whether to play the championship match against Boris Spassky, he received a personal call from Henry Kissinger, then President Nixon’s National Security Advisor, urging him to play and represent the U.S. in this epic battle over the chess board. Bobby apparently was honored by the call, and Kissinger’s encouragement did contribute to Bobby playing the match. When Bobby returned to the U.S. in the early fall of

Page 56

1972 as the new World Chess Champion, President Nixon wrote him a letter of congratulations. In time, however, Bobby became more and more disillusioned with the United States. He believed he was not supported enough during his chess career given all he was doing for the U.S. in terms of world chess recognition. He believed he should have been personally invited to the White House to meet with President Nixon after he won the title. As his anti-Semitism grew during his “wilderness years” in the 1980s, Bobby accused the U.S. of conspiring with Israel to control the world.

The most significant factor in Bobby’s revulsion toward the U.S. was, however, when he came out of his California seclusion to play in a privately sponsored rematch with Boris Spassky during 1992 in war-torn Yugoslavia. The U.S. Department of the Treasury forbade any American citizen from doing business in Yugoslavia. Bobby defied the order in playing the rematch against Spassky (which he won again, winning over $3 million). An arrest warrant was issued for Bobby and he could not return to the U.S. without risk of immediate arrest. Bobby would never return to the U.S. and died in Reykjavik, Iceland, where he had been granted citizenship on humanitarian grounds. On a Philippine radio station immediately following the September 2001 attack on the U.S., Bobby praised the attack, stating: “This is all wonderful news. It’s time for the [expletive] U.S. to get their heads kicked in. Finish off the U.S. once and for all…. This just shows you that what goes around, comes around, even for the United States.” In Bobby’s mind the U.S. had abandoned him, as had his mother and father. At the root of Bobby’s rage was a deep sense of hurt from this felt abandonment.

Why Did Bobby Resign (Forfeit) the World Chess Title in 1975?

The chess world was very excited about the World Championship match between Bobby and the new Soviet challenger, Anatoly Karpov. Fischer made numerous demands to change the rules of FIDE’s (Fédération Internationale des Echecs) match, and though Karpov and the FIDE agreed to most, they did not agree to every one. This was the rationale Bobby gave for resigning his world title. Fischer himself, and most chess experts at the time, believed that Fischer would have defeated Karpov, so why did Fischer sabotage the match? My hypothesis, explored fully in my psychobiography of Fischer, was that Fischer’s quest for the world title became the defining aspect of his search for identity; that is, his

Page 57

personal identity was fused with his chess identity. Once he defeated Spassky for the world title, his two identities coalesced into one. If he were to lose the match against Karpov, he would in essence lose his personal identity and that realization was too risky for Bobby. Better to resign the title as World Champion (and still believe one is the best player in the word) than to risk losing one’s sense of self.

Psychobiography in Cultural and Political Context

Bobby Fischer represented the American cultural emphasis on individualism. He developed his talent mainly through individual effort and was representing himself, more than the U.S., in the 1972 “chess match of the century.” Spassky, on the other hand, was a symbol and chosen representative of the Soviet intellectual “collective.” The Soviet system had nourished, cared for, bankrolled, and prepared him for chess greatness since his childhood. Fischer’s loss would have been devastating for him and disappointing for Americans. Spassky’s loss would be devastating to the Soviet Union and hazardous for himself (in fact, after losing the match, many restrictions were put on his travel). Interestingly, as portrayed in the new film, Pawn Sacrifice (2015), both Fischer and Spassky were used as pawns in their country’s efforts to engage an acceptable Cold War battle over the chessboard rather than an unacceptable battle of military conflict.

In terms of mental health, the Fischer story highlights the need for school counselors, administrators, and other mental health professionals to intervene early in the lives of child prodigies. Many parents of prodigies, whether the talent is in chess, tennis, violin, computer design, and so on, struggle with how to balance nurturing their children’s special gifts while also promoting healthy and balanced lives. What more could school counselors, administrators, and psychologists have done for a young Bobby Fischer and his financially struggling family? Clearly, there are more social, financial, and academic support structures in place now than there were during Bobby’s formative years in the 1940s and 1950s. It is important that the mental health and education systems devote more research and resources to studying the challenges and needs of the extremely gifted.

Page 58

About the author

Joseph G. Ponterotto

Joseph G. Ponterotto, PhD, is a Professor of Counseling Psychology in Fordham University’s Graduate School of Education, Lincoln Center Campus.  His primary research interests are in psychobiography, multicultural psychology, and research methods. He has published book length psychobiographies on chess champion Bobby Fischer (2012) and John F. Kennedy, Jr. (2019), both published by Charles C Thomas, Publisher.  His latest book is The Psychobiographer’s Handbook:  A Practical Guide to Research and Ethics (2025, American Psychological Association).  Email address:

How to cite this article

Ponterotto, J. G. (2016). Bobby Fischer, the Cold War, and the global reach of psychobiography. Clio’s Psyche, 23(1), 51-59.

https://doi.org/10.70763/14678db82874f1456031fcc05a3afaf6

PDF downloads