Volume 13 - Number 4 - March 2007
Pages: 179 - 226

TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY PERSPECTIVES ON THE HOLOCAUST
SPECIAL ISSUE: SECTION III EXPLORING WHY AND THE PROSPECTS FOR THE FUTURE

Rappoport, L. (2007). Some reflections on the Holocaust. Clio’s Psyche, 13(4), 193-194.

https://doi.org/10.70763/1c208ee88299e7d6d6eff86e6879384e

Some Reflections on the Holocaust

article

Abstract

In this article, the author, a psychologist who co-wrote The Holocaust and the Crisis of Human Behavior (1980; revised 1994) with George Kren, sets out three observations on the Holocaust today. He is critical of the accumulated literature, museums, films, and curricula, which he describes as a cultural artifact resembling a tourist destination. He asks what to make of appeals to the Holocaust by causes ranging from Israeli settlements in Palestinian areas to antiabortion campaigns in the United States, and he does not accept that public awareness justifies such vulgarity. He contends that representations gloss over victims’ conduct, including conflict among prisoners, collaboration by some Judenrat members, and internal resistance to revolt, and he notes that Frankl, Bettelheim, and Arendt raised such questions. He concludes that Western institutions, the United Nations, and systems of law, religion, and science cannot be relied on to prevent genocide, and that knowing how genocide is possible has not stopped it.

Keywords:

cultural artifact, George Kren, Holocaust, human behavior, memorialization, psychoanalytic theory, psychohistory, racism, reification, socio-political agendas

When my late colleague George Kren (1926-2000) and I began our study of the Holocaust around 1969, we had no idea it would become the main focus of our lives for the next ten years, or that while applying academic psychology and psychoanalytic theory to analyze the historical events we would be led to question many of the assumptions guiding modem understandings of human behavior. The results of our work, The Holocaust and the Crisis of Human Behavior, was published in 1980, revised and updated in 1994. As I think of the Holocaust today, three things stand out. One that seems fairly obvious is that, taken together, the vast scholarly and popular literature about it that has accumulated, as well as museums, films, and academic curricula, has facilitated its reification into a monumental cultural artifact. Presumably constructed in order to memorialize the victims, celebrate survivors and rescuers, and show the horrors that can follow from racism, prejudice, and crackpot ideologies, this multifaceted artifact seems to me to have become something like a metaphysical tourist destination, including optional visits to the sites of Nazi death camps. Then there are the various socio-political agendas, everything from Israeli settlements in Palestinian areas to antiabortion campaigns in America, that appeal to the Holocaust for their justification.

What is one to make of this? Is it a gross exploitation, a way of stimulating guilt feelings among gentiles, assuaging guilt feelings among Jews, and scaring kids in general? Or is it an important warning against what can happen when national interests and policies become detached from fundamental moral values? Or both? I think that some Holocaust scholars might acknowledge these issues, but argue that whatever vulgarity may have set in is a small price to pay for the raising of public awareness. But as a former little boy who was given a tin can emblazoned with Jewish stars and sent out to collect nickels and dimes for the Jewish National Fund, the last is not my position.

Another, less obvious impression I have about representations of the Holocaust today concerns a general tendency to gloss over the darker side of the victims’ behavior. Thus, George Kren and I were not the only ones to identify many of the shameful, occasionally vicious behaviors between prisoners in the camps, the collaboration between some Judenrat (Jewish council) personnel and the Nazis, nor the fact that those who rebelled in the camps and fought in the ghettos typically had to first

Page 193

resist powerful internal arguments against taking forceful action. But the idea that such issues deserve attention (we discussed them under the heading of “the fallacy of innocence,”) is only occasionally noted and rarely pursued in the literature. Nor is the better known work of those like Viktor Frankl, Bruno Bettelheim, and Hannah Arendt, who have raised critical questions about the victims’, behavior.

Finally, I think that on the evidence of what has been going on in the twenty-first century, it is all too clear that, despite pretensions to the contrary, the primary institutions of Western Civilization, the United Nations, and our systems of law, religion, and science cannot be relied upon to prevent genocidal actions today any more than they could during the Holocaust. It seemed reasonable, in the sixties and seventies, to believe that if careful psychohistorical studies could reveal “how such things are possible,” this might help prevent genocides in the future. Well, now we know how those things are possible, but they are still happening.

Page 194

About the author

Leon Rappoport

Leon Rappoport completed doctoral work in psychology at the University of Colorado in 1963. Following a one year NSF postdoctoral fellowship for study at Oslo University, he joined the faculty at Kansas State University, and was named Professor Emeritus upon his retirement in 2003. Author of numerous research papers in social psychology and psychohistory, his books include: Personality Development (1972), The Holocaust and the Crisis of Human Behavior (1980:1994) co-authored with George Kren, How We Eat: Appetite. Culture, and the Psychology of Food (2003), and Punchlines: the Case for Racial, Ethnic and Gender Humor (2005). He may be contacted at .

How to cite this article

Rappoport, L. (2007). Some reflections on the Holocaust. Clio’s Psyche, 13(4), 193-194.

https://doi.org/10.70763/1c208ee88299e7d6d6eff86e6879384e

PDF downloads