
Volume 06 - Number 2 - September 1999
Pages: 41 - 88
Reynolds, E. (1999). E-mail: Anonymous or revealing? Clio’s Psyche, 6(2), 47-49.
E-mail: Anonymous or Revealing?
Abstract
In this article, the author reflects from personal experience on writing and reading e-mail, contrasting it with the process of composing and posting a paper letter. The author reports that sending messages to mailing lists and chat rooms is fast and that errors are visible to many recipients at once. The author attributes “flame wars” to the speed with which participants interpret one another’s behavior, likens them to road rage, and observes that the distance of cyberspace seems to release energy that face-to-face contact might not. The author describes writing more often and more freely online, closer to stream of consciousness, and believes that experience of flame wars has improved this writing by teaching clarity and the value of asking clarifying questions. The author notes that on mailing lists participants are faceless, that level of knowledge appears to matter most, and that credentials appended to messages can act as messages themselves. The author suggests that anonymity may allow ageism, sexism, and racism to recede, and that the medium can join people across countries. The author reports that easier access to information has altered work life and reduced time spent biking. The author concludes that online interaction cannot replace face-to-face or voice contact, though added pictures and voices might help, and expects eventual accommodation to the medium.
cyberspace, email, flame war, letters, mailing lists, online communication, psychohistory
When I write a letter, I go through a process. I sit at a keyboard until I have finished my thoughts to the person or organization, then I take the printed output and fold it, put it in an envelope, place a stamp or two on the envelope, and add a return address. Then I post my letter. Enter e-mail: I cut out all this except the keyboarding! I can sit at my keyboard, type my thoughts as they come to me, and CLICK! The message zips out into cyberspace to the recipient(s).
On mailing lists and in chat rooms, that message will appear on the screens of many recipients, so if I make a spelling, punctuation, or grammatical mistake, it shows up on all those screens. Someone reading my message may interpret my words other than I intended, and may respond quickly and with sharp-sounding words; most e-mailers write directly and to the point. If I read into this response a negative intent, I may retaliate with a negative message, and we get into a “flame war.” Others on the list may get involved, and it can last for days. So a flame war, like road rage, results from the speed of interpreting the behavior of others. Flame wars get humorous, especially from the sidelines, because the misinterpretations seem clear to bystanders. The participants, however, sometimes call each other names, put each other down, demand that others get banned from the list, and generally just bash each other. If they were face-to-face, would they do that? Flame wars on the Internet seem very different; the cyber distance seems to unleash energy.
Knowing I am only a click away from sending, I think I write more often and more freely, closer to stream of consciousness. It feels like I am writing a note, even when what I write covers several pages. It feels temporary, like talking with my fingers instead of my voice. The same keyboard I use to create e-mail seems to produce different material than when I write a letter.
I believe my writing has improved, as I try to make my words carry the full meaning of my message. I have learned from e-mail experience the importance of writing clearly. This learning came from the flame wars I have experienced. I can easily misinterpret, but more importantly, I can fail to ask clarifying questions. Sometimes a simple question could clear things up right away! Why don’t we take the time to do that?
Mailing list participants have no faces and we know nothing about each other except the words that appear; age, race, and gender may not enter the picture. A participant’s level of knowledge appears to have the most significance in these exchanges. Sometimes a flame war occurs over “facts.” At a time like that, the level of knowledge becomes the most important aspect of each individual involved. Usually, no one stops the clicking long enough to verify the facts that zip by. It’s easier to “flame” back with more demeaning and judgmental words.
Some people put their credentials at the end of every message. That in itself constitutes a message, and sometimes it seems to mean, “Don’t respond to me unless you have comparable credentials.” The scholarly writers clearly identify themselves by their writing style, even if they omit their credentials.
Being able to respond to someone in Australia or Sweden or China shows the breakdown of geographical barriers. Because of the anonymity, ageism, sexism, and racism can easily disappear. This medium can bring us together in our common humanity, in spite of posturing and flaming.
I do not yet have my own Web site. My professional/personal/work life has been affected by giving me easier and quicker access to information I seek. A secondary effect has been that I no longer bike several times a week! The lure of information and/or exchanging ideas seems to draw me more than biking!
Online interaction abounds, but it cannot take the place of face-to-face interaction, or even voice-to-voice interaction. Perhaps the addition of pictures and voices to e-mail will give these added dimensions. Eventually, we will accustom ourselves to this medium of communicating, and I’ll get back to bike riding!
Page 48
How to cite this article
Reynolds, E. (1999). E-mail: Anonymous or revealing? Clio’s Psyche, 6(2), 47-49.



