Volume 05 - Number 3 - December 1998
Pages: 69 - 119

WASHINGTON’S OBSESSION WITH SEX AND CLINTON 23 AUTHORS LOOK AT CLINTON, LEWINSKY, STARR, AND THE IMPEACHMENT PROCESS

Rogers, H. J. (1998). Starr as Oliver Cromwell. Clio’s Psyche, 5(3), 81-82.

https://doi.org/10.70763/83dd3f9f97ef6533766c39d5b2e5e565

Starr as Oliver Cromwell

article

Abstract

H. John Rogers portrays Kenneth Starr as a Cromwell-like moral prosecutor whose stringent Church of Christ fundamentalism shaped the Clinton investigation. He argues that this religious-ideological lens, with its strong emphasis on sexual rectitude and repentance, helped inflate Clinton’s sexual misconduct and cover-up into offenses pursued with exceptional zeal, beyond what a less moralistic independent counsel might have treated as appropriate.

Keywords:

Bill Clinton, Kenneth Starr, Monica Lewinsky, Oliver Cromwell, psychoanalysis, psychohistory, religious ideology, sexual misconduct

Unfortunately, Clinton committed his sexual peccadilloes during the reign of a spiritual descendant of Oliver Cromwell. Judge Starr (as his proponents uniformly refer to him) is a lifelong member of a little-known fundamentalist Christian sect that makes Jerry Falwell look like a theological liberal. This is the Church of Christ, a 1.6-million-member denomination primarily based in the rural sections of the South and Appalachia.

Theirs is a fundamentalism so thorough and complete that, for example, no musical instruments are permitted in their churches solely because the Bible does not specifically mention music in conjunction with either Jewish or Christian worship. (They overlook David’s lyre and the frequent prefatory words to many of the Psalms. For example, Psalm 65 begins “Lamnatseach Mizmor,” which is, “For the conductor (or choir master) with musical accompaniment.”

They hold a closed communion service and no one other than members of the sect are permitted to participate in “the Lord’s Supper.” What this means theologically is that they make being a member of their church coextensive with being Christian. The unstated subtext is that everyone else—Baptists, Methodists, Roman Catholics (for them, the “great whore of Babylon” in the Book of Revelations)—is on their way to the everlasting bonfire. Being a member of the elect perforce produces a quantum of self-righteousness.

The only way to avoid damnation is to repent, be baptized, and join “and be accepted into” their denomination. The median educational level of the congregants is definitely below the 12th grade, so having an educated professional like Ken Starr in their midst is somewhat of an anomaly. In The Status Seekers, Vance Packard felicitously entitled the chapter about the economic stratification of the Protestant churches, “The Long Road from Pentecostal to Episcopalian.” Some four or five decades later, the fundamentalists in Judge Starr’s church still share the lower rungs with the charismatic Pentecostal. Their faith in their own rectitude, though, would place them at the top of the Protestant denominations.

A person like Judge Starr, affiliated by birth and by choice with such hard-core fundamentalism, may well harbor a deep and visceral loathing towards an avuncular, hedonistic “Bubba” like our President. Like other fundamentalist sects, the Church of Christ’s teaching focuses heavily upon sexual conduct. As a practical matter, this reaches fullest flower in the castigation of libertines outside the fold.

It is the President’s great misfortune that

Page 81

his Independent Counsel is a man who considered a little hanky-panky and its natural by-product, the covering lie, to be the equivalent of treason and bribery. Lawrence Walsh, the Independent Counsel in the Iran-Contra case, has generally given the impression in his published statements about l’affaire that he would have exhibited a bit more sangfroid than Judge Starr has if he had, say, received evidence that Ronald Reagan had been frolicking with the upstairs maid in Mrs. Reagan’s absence. And even if Reagan had denied his folly in a sexual harassment suit, I suspect that Judge Walsh, an Episcopalian as I recall, would have considered a sidebar investigation into this sort of thing beneath his dignity in addition to being outside of his charge.

Page 82

About the author

H. John Rogers

H. John Rogers, JD, is a Harvard-trained West Virginia attorney and minister with some psychoanalytic training and a profound interest in politics.

How to cite this article

Rogers, H. J. (1998). Starr as Oliver Cromwell. Clio’s Psyche, 5(3), 81-82.

https://doi.org/10.70763/83dd3f9f97ef6533766c39d5b2e5e565

PDF downloads