
Volume 19 - Number 1 - June 2012
Pages: 1 - 125
Rosenberg, J. (2012). What is it about cats? Clio’s Psyche, 19(1), 27-31.
What Is It about Cats?
Abstract
In this article, the author considers why people own and love cats, or dislike them. The starting point is the negative image of cats in popular culture, which is attributed partly to anthropomorphizing, projection, and centuries of superstition, and set against the animal’s deification in ancient Egypt. Psychoanalytic ideas are offered as possible explanations and are illustrated with everyday experiences of cat owners. Invoking W.R.D. Fairbairn’s account of “good” and “bad” internalized objects, the article proposes that a cat’s unpredictable affection and rejection recall early caregiving, so that owners rework an unresolved childhood conflict, for instance in the satisfaction of winning over a finicky eater. It contends that cats appear as pure id, allowing owners to ease the restraints of their own superegos by living vicariously through their pets. On the preference for dogs, the article reports Nelson Antrim Crawford’s 1934 attribution of it to narcissism, accepting this only in part. It maintains that loving a cat means giving up control of the relationship, a form of moral masochism, though cats are described as benign in a way parents are not. It concludes that cats may also appeal as the most accessible form of the big wild cats, offering owners unconscious association with their power and aggression at little risk.
anthropomorphizing, cat worship, childhood, developmental approach, emotional development, human-animal relationships, “Object-Relations and Dynamic Structure,” projection, psychohistory, psychology of pets, W.R.D. Fairbairn
Popular culture is full of negative views of cats. They are seen as standoffish, conniving, impossible to negotiate with, and completely self-involved. Some of this is likely anthropomorphizing—or projection, if you will. It also is likely due to centuries of superstition about and vilification of cats, despite the fact they have also been deified through the ages, particularly in ancient Egypt.
In our culture, people, even many who own cats, believe
Page 27
they have the worst ulterior motives. They are seen as inherently evil. You don’t hear about a black dog bringing bad luck. You sometimes hear a cat owner happily saying, “She’s just like a dog!”
Then there is the reality about cats. They are indeed willful and difficult to control, even those who are friendly and demonstrative. They are predators, inflict damage on their surroundings (and sometimes on their owners), and are messy to clean up after. Their moods can be impossible for humans to decipher. (In the interest of full disclosure: I have had cats for most of my life after having been terrified of them until the age of eight. I currently have three.)
So what is it about cats that makes so many people own and love them? Or hate them? The answer of course varies from one person to the next and one cat to the next. But psychoanalytic theory offers some explanations.
W.R.D. Fairbairn (“Object-Relations and Dynamic Structure,” The International Journal of Psychoanalysis, 1946) taught us about the early experiences in life, when children try to make sense of a seeming conundrum: parents or other caregivers who gratify their needs and wishes and offer the possibility of more gratification, but who also frustrate them by saying “no” or showing anger. Fairbairn described the child as being excited by the prospect of getting a hug or approval. That same child feels rejected when she is denied what she wants or needs. Those rejections in the first years of life can seem unpredictable, which makes them shocking as well as painful.
A child must reconcile himself to and integrate these conflicting aspects of one person. It can be a difficult process, one that may never be truly complete—Fairbairn wrote that these aspects, which he called “good” objects and “bad” objects, end up being internalized in a child’s psyche and repressed. The never-quite resolved conflict gives most of us some pangs as we go through life. For many people, the answer is to try to work the conflict out in other relationships by trying to please a difficult partner or employer. Or a cat.
You can see it play out over and over in the course of caring for a cat. If a cat one moment seems affectionate toward its owner and then suddenly paws him or her and then runs off, there’s the
Page 28
unpredictable rejection in this situation reminiscent of childhood. You can see the dynamic also in the feeling of satisfaction, joy, maybe even triumph, that an owner gets when she has finally found something her finicky cat will eat. Of course, some of the owner’s reaction comes from relief that her cat, her baby, is eating. But there has to be an unconscious thrill at having won over the rejecting parent.
But this kind of love/hate relationship with cats can’t be the only reason why people are drawn to the furry felines. Owners will tell you that these are fascinating and entertaining creatures. Cats will stop at nothing to explore, satisfy their curiosity and find comfort, so they often end up in improbable situations: the top of a door or inside a clothes dryer. If there are two or more cats in a household, their owners often get to watch wrestling matches and feline farces as the animals try to dominate or merely play with one another. All of this can be very funny.
But there is more than comedy that makes an owner laugh at their pets. In these activities, cats appear to be pure id, the part of the psyche that if left unchecked would do whatever it wants. How we envy cats, but also joyfully identify with their freedom! Childhood, particularly in the first few years and then again in adolescence, can seem like one long “No” as we are socialized and pass through the stages of development that force us to control many of our wants and impulses. We develop superegos that for the most part prevent us from satisfying every impulse. One way to ease the pain of having to rein in our ids is to indulge someone else’s. Thus, cat owners live vicariously through their pets.
Still, many people report they prefer dogs over cats as pets. Nelson Antrim Crawford boils it down to narcissism: “The typical American, with his tremendous inferiority complex and his consequent tremendous need for external praise, has little admiration for cats” (“Cats Holy and Profane,” The Psychoanalytic Review, 1934).
That may be true—up to a point. Dogs are indeed more outgoing and demonstrative than most cats. Dogs give their owners and many other people instant validation. But cat owners will tell you their felines are also affectionate, although in a more muted way. Until you get to know a cat, the affection may seem more
Page 29
self-serving than a dog’s—but we also know that a dog’s continual attempts to please its owner is also a means to ensure that it gets food, shelter, and love.
Perhaps the real difference between loving a dog and loving a cat is that owners have to put up with cats’ more difficult nature in order to get that affection returned. To love and be loved by a cat, you have to be willing to give up control of the relationship. It takes some masochism. Consider that many cat owners are periodically scratched and woken up by meowing at 3 a.m. Cats knock over cups of coffee, scatter neatly sorted papers, and chew through electrical cords. Owners rant to their friends about the latest infractions, but they keep their cats.
Masochism, or moral masochism, as it’s called by psychoanalytic theorists, is the submission to someone else’s power in hopes of getting love. We all have some degree of masochism—as children, the balance of power was in our parents’ favor, and we had to submit. We all carry some residues of that time within us. Children who are continually forced to sacrifice their hopes, wishes, and sense of self in order to get love from a sadistic or withholding parent will struggle with a greater degree of masochism later in life. The masochistic love that a human may have toward a cat falls somewhere along this spectrum.
But there is a huge difference between parents, however controlling they are, and cats. The cats are benign dictators—their agenda is to get something they want, but it is not a psychic agenda that a parent might have, based, for example, on healing an old wound. Still, owners often don’t consciously realize that, and so you hear various projections: My cat hates me. My cat purposely knocks things off the night table to wake me. My cat won’t eat his food, just to screw with me.
But what happy masochists cat owners are! They put up with their cats, and get what they’re hoping for: their cats love them.
A final thought: Cats may also be appealing because they are the most accessible form of lions, tigers, and other big, wild, powerful cats. Although domesticated, they have many of the instincts of the big cats that are almost universally admired, feared,
Page 30
and identified with, even by people who say they’re cat haters. Who declared the lion to be the king of beasts? Humans. So, a cat owner may be unconsciously getting by association some of the power and aggression of the big cats—only much more safely.
Page 31
How to cite this article
Rosenberg, J. (2012). What is it about cats? Clio’s Psyche, 19(1), 27-31.



