
Volume 22 - Number 4 - March 2016
Pages: 225 - 337
Rosenberg, J., & Cifelli, D. (2016). Remembering Arno Gruen [Memorial]. Clio’s Psyche, 22(4), 332-333.
Remembering Arno Gruen
Abstract
This memorial tribute to the psychoanalyst, psychologist, and psychohistorian Arno Gruen (1923–2015) recounts his life and work. The authors report that he was born to a Jewish family in Berlin, that the family left Germany in 1936 for the United States, and that he studied at City College of New York and New York University. He trained in psychoanalysis under Theodor Reik at the National Psychological Association for Psychoanalysts. The tribute notes his private practice, his 17 years teaching at Rutgers University until he moved to Switzerland in 1979, and his publications. These include The Betrayal of the Self (1988), his first book in English, Der Fremde in uns (2001), which received Germany’s Geschwister-Scholl-Preis, and Against Terrorism, published shortly before his death. The authors describe his central position: evil is not an innate human trait but results from betrayal and self-hatred in early childhood, with self-hatred then projected onto others. They present this as a challenge to Freud’s view of inherent human aggression. They connect this outlook to his 2010 Loviisa Peace Prize in Finland and suggest that his early experience of Nazi-era anti-Semitism contributed to his search for the sources of violence and hatred. The tribute also covers his fifty-year friendship and collaboration with Montague Ullman, including joint work on the effects of stroke on patients’ behavior. It closes with the hope that his calls for empathy and peace will continue to be heard.
Arno Gruen, The Betrayal of the Self, Loviisa Peace Prize, memorial, psychobiography, psychohistory, psychology, self-hatred
Arno Gruen (March 26, 1923–October 20, 2015) was a distinguished psychoanalyst, psychologist, psychohistorian, and researcher who has given much to the field. His work was centered on the fundamental belief that evil is not an innate character trait of humans, but rather the result of betrayal and self-hatred from an early age. His research and many books and papers worked to apply this theory to help explain events and people throughout history. This view of the world and work to understand and ultimately fight the suffering, inequality, and violence of the world led to him being awarded the Loviisa Peace Prize in Finland in 2010. He ended his acceptance speech with “It is empathy and cooperation – not profit, selfishness, and the drive for ever more bigness – that will lead us toward a more humane civilization than our present one.”
The seeds of Arno Gruen’s humanity that led to his receiving the peace prize, were sown early in life; as a Jewish child born in Berlin and growing up in Germany, his view of the world was open-minded and accepting. When his father told him that one should distinguish between Jews, Christians, atheists, and often between the Germans and the French, the young Arno was surprised: “I thought we are all human beings.” This was in 1930, before Hitler came to power, unleashed anti-Semitism in Gruen’s homeland and likely contributed to Gruen’s search for the reasons behind the violence and hatred that swept across Europe in his youth.
The Peace Prize was one of many accomplishments in Gruen’s long career. Notably, he also won Germany’s Geschwister-Scholl-Preis for his 2001 book, Der Fremde in uns (The Stranger Within Us). His family had fled Germany and the Nazis in 1936, eventually making their way to the United States. He received his undergraduate degree from the City College of New York before going on to New York University to study psychology. Seeking to become a psychoanalyst, he studied at the National Psychological Association for Psychoanalysts under Theodor Reik. He worked in private practice and also had many professorships. His longest tenure was 17 years at Rutgers University, teaching there until he moved to Switzerland in 1979. The Betrayal of the Self (1988) was his first book to be published in English and an excellent example of his scholarship. He published countless more articles and books; most recently he published Against Terrorism shortly before his death in 2015.
Arno Gruen’s work and research countered Freud’s belief that human beings are inherently aggressive or violent. Instead, Gruen be-
Page 332
lieved that hatred and violence are the result of the mistreatment and punishment of children that feeds self-hatred, which is in turn projected and acted out on others. In his acceptance speech for the Loviisa Peace Prize, he crystallized and lamented what he saw as the collective and inevitable loss of self that human beings suffer beginning at a very young age, laying the foundation for the hatred and violence in the world:
What is reality if we are constrained from birth to see the world not as we experience it ourselves but as others tell us it is? Before and directly after birth our perceptions are shaped by empathy, not by cognitive intellectual processes. Our early empathic perceptions are direct and immediate, uninfluenced by society’s expectations, and for that reason are true to reality. But from the very first day of life, the way we ought to see the world is communicated to us by others, along with the message that our own perceptions have no validity. Thus, our cognitive perception, based on the expectations of those who raise us, never develops without distortion. This is especially true if these expectations are not in accord with a child’s needs but rather meet with the parents’ need for self-esteem.
As news of his passing spread, Arno Gruen’s friends and colleagues recalled his great compassion and kindness to those he knew, and his large presence in their lives. Many remembered his longtime close friendship and collaboration with dream worker, psychoanalyst, psychiatrist, and researcher, Montague Ullman (1916-2008). In 2008, Gruen sat by Ullman’s bedside the night before he died from a stroke, giving comfort to Ullman’s partner and colleague Judith Gardiner. Gruen and Ullman had known and worked together for 50 years, since the time Gruen sent Ullman an article he wrote on the interaction between organic states and functions and they began collaborating on a study of the effects of stroke on patients’ behavior. These two men shared more than an ongoing interest in science; they were both humanitarians who were concerned for the future of mankind.
Arno Gruen will be missed, but his scholarship will live on through his library of publications. It is hoped that his calls for peace and empathy in the world will echo on, long after his departure from this world. We wish to express our condolences to his wife Simone Gruen- Müller and his daughters Connie, Margaret, and Zoey.
Page 333
How to cite this article
Rosenberg, J., & Cifelli, D. (2016). Remembering Arno Gruen [Memorial]. Clio’s Psyche, 22(4), 332-333.



