
Volume 21 - Number 3 - December 2014
Pages: 245 - 361
Rosenberg, J. M. (2014). British civility: Reality or reaction-formation? Clio’s Psyche, 21(3), 313-317.
British Civility: Reality or Reaction-Formation?
Abstract
This article takes up the popular image of Britain as a refined, civilized society and questions whether that image masks aggressive tendencies. The author proposes that British civility may be understood as a reaction-formation, a defense against aggressive impulses, in an ongoing conflict between a collective superego and id. Illustrations offered in support include the upper-class foxhunt, British rule in India, and tabloid reports of misbehavior among aristocrats and royals. Novels are cited as portraying strain beneath upper-class propriety: Brideshead Revisited, The Jewel in the Crown, and Pride and Prejudice. The piece acknowledges that Dickens, working-class musicians, and sitcoms about the lower and middle classes are also popular. It suggests that the idea of British civility functions as a superego and an ego ideal, and that Americans, who are seen as more brash, may hold to it because of their own superego and id conflicts. It concludes by maintaining that the same reaction-formation has existed among upper-class Americans, citing Henry James and Edith Wharton’s The House of Mirth.
British civilization, British literature, Charles Dickens, Downton Abbey, English sports, Jane Austen, Paul Scott, psychohistory, reaction-formation, soccer riots
For those who passionately read Jane Austen, watch Downton Abbey, or follow news of the royal family, Britain appears to be a refined society. Good manners, beautiful clothes, and speaking the King’s English are seen as evidence of how civilized the British are. Contrast that with slums and poor working class towns, Brit-
Page 313
ain’s subjugation of people around the world, and soccer riots and it raises the question of whether that refinement isn’t really a veneer that tries to mask a sadistic, violent, and uncivilized country and the existence of those characteristics in the very people who hold themselves out as civilized.
Britain may be one of the best examples of a nation that’s in an ongoing struggle between its collective superego and id, and that uses the defense known as reaction-formation—in the form of that very refined upper class image—to defend against the aggressive tendencies the British have along with the rest of humanity. Jean Laplanche and Jean-Bertrand Pontalis (The Language of Psycho-Analysis, 1973, 376-77) define this defense as the “Psychological attitude or habit diametrically opposed to a repressed wish, and constituted as a reaction against it (e.g. bashfulness countering exhibitionistic tendencies).” They go on to write “reaction-formations may be highly localized, manifesting themselves in specific behavior, or they may be generalized to the point of forming character-traits more or less integrated into the overall personality.”
Consider one of the most romanticized of upper class English sports, the foxhunt. One must wear all the right clothes, a hunting jacket, breeches, boots, and hat that can cost upwards of $2,000. The horses are finely bred, as are the foxhounds. The aim is to force the horses to run at a gallop, pursue and catch a small animal, and then celebrate as the dogs, egged on by the riders, tear it to pieces. I wonder how many of the riders understand that their attention to what they wear and the meals they’ll consume before and after the hunt are a reaction-formation against the murderous impulses they’re acting out.
This defense has played out on a global level, with Britain taking countries like India over by force and installing its own citizens as the upper class. They treated the people of the invaded countries as underlings. While there was squalor around them, the British lived well and, they believed, in a very civilized fashion, taking afternoon tea and going to parties.
British literature is testimony to the existence of this reaction-formation. Some of the most popular novels of the first half of the 20th century punctured myths about British civility and de-
Page 314
scribed the upper classes’ attempts to keep the veneer of their civility intact. Lord Sebastian Flyte in Evelyn Waugh’s Brideshead Revisited (1945) was the complete opposite of civility: drunk, dissolute, angry, and bitter. He rebelled against his mother, Lady Marchmain, and his brother, the Earl of Brideshead, who clung to family and religious traditions and observed all the social mores of the upper class. Underneath that façade they were emotionally suffocating Sebastian and his sister Julia.
Paul Scott’s The Jewel in the Crown (1966) detailed the paradox of British civility in a conquered land. The Britons who settled in India had lives of leisure, even luxury, with flower shows, equestrian games, and military parades. While they lived in denial of the poverty and racism they helped perpetuate, a major character and the district superintendent of the police in the book, Ronald Merrick, persecuted a young Indian man who had a relationship with an Englishwoman. Merrick wasn’t an anomaly. He was Scott’s symbol of British sadism toward Indians and any other people who were considered beneath the upper class.
Even Jane Austen’s novels had an undercurrent that revealed the misery behind the good manners and elegant parties. While many fans believe she wrote romantic drawing room comedies in which people followed the rules of British civility, her books were also social commentary on the plight of women who faced denigration and desperation if they were unable to find husbands, preferably ones with good breeding, income, and estates. The wealthy estate owner Mr. Darcy in Pride and Prejudice (1813) dissuades his friend from marrying Jane Bennet and his aunt, Lady Catherine de Bourgh, later tries to bully Elizabeth Bennet into a promise that she wouldn’t marry Mr. Darcy. The Bennet sisters spend much of the story facing an uncertain husbandless future until the happy ending finds the arrogant members of the upper class either softened or taken down a few pegs.
Of course, people know very well that the upper class is just one aspect of British society. Charles Dickens’ novels portraying the tribulations of the lower classes, including Oliver Twist (1838) and its thieving juvenile delinquents, are well-loved. So are the Beatles and Eric Clapton, who come from working class families. Sitcoms about the middle and lower classes are as popular as
Page 315
Downton Abbey (2010-) and its predecessor about upper class life, Upstairs, Downstairs (1971-1975, 2010-2012). Yet people persist in their embrace of the notion of British civility. One might argue that it’s not much different from the public’s fascination with movie stars and athletes and their apparently glamorous lives. However, many Anglophiles are people who don’t care about pop culture.
As I look at the question of British civility, I keep returning to the battle between the superego and the id. As children are socialized, or taught to be civilized, they learn consciously and unconsciously to keep their id in check. The superego, the internalized parent or authority figure, is the force that tries to contain the id. However, as we all find out to varying degrees, it can be a losing battle, and we all get in trouble throughout our lives for a wide range of vices: overeating and drinking, breaking the speed limit, and cheating on our spouses, to name a few.
The idea of British civility functions as a superego—someone who lives and behaves according to upper class mores is better and superior to everyone else. So that civility is something we aspire to, or at least admire. We’re looking for ego ideals to model ourselves after; if we could only be like the British, we’d be so good, so refined!
The truth is, the British are onto themselves. The newspapers, particularly the tabloids, are full of stories about the latest misbehavior by lords, ladies, and as we also know, Prince Harry and the former Duchess of York, Sarah Ferguson. Their ids tell their superegos to “get stuffed!”
Americans, though, may cling to the myth of British civility because of our own superego/id battles. The stereotypical American personality is seen as more brash and aggressive than the British. Many Americans see the British as far superior to us. It should be noted that the same reaction-formation has existed among upper class Americans. Henry James and Edith Wharton wrote about it. The wealthy in Edith Wharton’s The House of Mirth (1905) dressed well, observed all the right social customs, and turned like a pack of animals on Lily Bart, a young woman striving to be a member of that society.
Page 316
How to cite this article
Rosenberg, J. M. (2014). British civility: Reality or reaction-formation? Clio’s Psyche, 21(3), 313-317.



