Volume 08 - Number 1 - June 2001
Pages: 1 - 50

BOOK REVIEWS

Rosenberg, V. (2001). Abram de Swaan: Using sociology, history, and psychoanalysis [Interview]. Clio’s Psyche, 8(1), 43-47.

https://doi.org/10.70763/2475c20d9e9a1aaee80dcbc4e6316157

Abram de Swaan: Using Sociology, History, and Psychoanalysis

interview

Abstract

This interview, conducted by Vivian M. Rosenberg in Amsterdam in September 2000 and May 2001, features Abram de Swaan, sociologist at the University of Amsterdam and chair of the Amsterdam School for Social Science Research. He recounts his childhood as a hidden child in wartime Holland, his student activism in Amsterdam and Berkeley, and his Harkness Fellowship at Yale and Berkeley, where he says Charles Lindblom’s incrementalism made him more skeptical of rational choice theory. He describes moving from mathematical political science to psychoanalytic training at the Netherlands Institute for Psychoanalysis and to practice as a psychotherapist from 1973 to 1984. He reports that this training made him more accepting of emotion and informed his observation of a cancer ward, which he likens to the phenomenological suspension of judgment. He calls himself a sociologist rather than a psychohistorian, maintains that emotional experience is shaped by historical and cultural context, and names Norbert Elias, Nico Frijda, and Peter Stearns among his influences. He lists transference, countertransference, identification, projection, and fantasy as useful research concepts, and faults psychoanalysts as often ahistorical and asociological. He also discusses the decline of traditional analysis in the Netherlands, his books In Care of the State, The Management of Normality, and Words of the World, and his plan to return to identification and the civilizing process. He disputes Elias’s treatment of the Holocaust and proposes dyscivilized for Nazi Germany and the Soviet Union. He concludes that understanding individuals and societies requires sociology, psychoanalysis, and history together.

Keywords:

Abram de Swaan, Amsterdam School for Social Science Research, In Care of the State: Health Care, Education, and Welfare in Europe and the USA in the Modern Era, education, global language system, health care, interview, The Management of Normality: Critical Essays in Health and Welfare, psychoanalysis, psychohistory, social policy, sociology, transnational society, welfare, Words of the World: The Global Language System

Abram de Swaan is Chairman of the Amsterdam School for Social Science Research and holds the Chair of Sociology at the University of Amsterdam. He studied psychoanalysis at the Netherlands Institute for Psychoanalysis and practiced as a psychotherapist from 1973 to 1984. He headed a research project of social scientists and psychiatrists and has published a series of studies on subjects at the intersection of psychoanalysis and sociology. After the publication of In Care of the State: Health Care, Education, and Welfare in Europe and the USA in the Modern Era (1988) and The Management of Normality: Critical Essays in Health and Welfare (1990), de Swaan began a sociological study of transnational society, especially the prospects of transnational social policy and the emergent world language system. His book, Words of the World: The Global Language System, will be published this year. Vivian Rosenberg conducted the interview in Amsterdam in September, 2000, and May, 2001. Professor de Swaan may be contacted at .

Vivian Rosenberg (VR): Can we start with some information about your background?

Abram de Swaan (ADS): I’m not so comfortable with this. It can lead to linking a person’s ideas in a reductionist way to just a few details about his childhood.

VR: Would you be willing to provide just a framework? We won’t dwell on this.

ADS: I was born in 1942, during the war. My father was a businessman; my mother was not employed outside the home, but she was very active in the community.

VR: I know you are Jewish, but did your family identify strongly as Jews—or were you more or less assimilated?

ADS: We were not practicing Jews, not in any way religious. But that was irrelevant. We were Jewish—and others identified us as Jewish—and this changed our lives.

VR: Were you one of the “hidden children” in Holland?

ADS: Yes. I was sent to live with a family in the countryside.

VR: Do you have any siblings?

ADS: One sister, four years younger, born after the war.

VR: Are your parents still alive?

ADS: My father died when I was 15. My mother died just four years ago, when I was 53. She was very independent—a strong personality. I remember that during my teen years she was involved with the feminist movement and with groups protesting the Vietnam war, and, until her death, she continued to be active with political and community groups.

VR: Since your father died when you were so young, would you say that your mother had more of an influence on you than he did?

ADS: No, not at all. I still think about my father, and I’m absolutely sure that if he were alive today, he would be delighted with what I have accomplished and what I am doing.

VR: Looking over your curriculum vitae, I see that you followed your mother’s lead and became something of an activist yourself.

ADS: Yes. From 1963 to 1965, while I was working for my degree at the University of Amsterdam, I was an editor of a controversial student weekly and an outspoken critic of academic and party politics. Then, in 1967 and 1968, when I was at Berkeley, I, too, was part of the “Berserkely” scene, enormously involved in Vietnam protests. My weekly spoken letters describing the tensions during those years were broadcast in the Netherlands.

VR: It seems to me you that your academic work, too, has been shaped by sensitivity to the suffering in the world.

ADS: Well, I had a desire to study the world in a scientific, more objective way.

VR: But as I read your work, I could see that you have not simply an intellectual, or academic, interest –but also a strong commitment to social betterment and social change.

ADS: Yes, of course: that’s why one studies the world!

VR: I don’t think every researcher feels

Page 43

that way.

ADS: Then it’s no good. [laughter]

VR: Aside from your parents, were there other people who you might say changed your life or who at least influenced the way you viewed the world?

ADS: Oh, yes. While I was working on my PhD in political science, I was awarded a Harkness Fellowship and worked at Yale and Berkeley from 1966 to 1968. At Yale, Robert Dahl, Karl Deutsch, and Charles Lindblon all made a huge impression on me. In fact, one interchange completely changed my view.

VR: Can you say a few words about that?

ADS: Yes—I had written my master’s thesis on rational choice theory. Charles Lindblon had a very different view of decision-making; he was an “incrementalist.’’ His idea was that change is incremental, remedial, that it takes place within a framework of mutual adjustments. In the space of 10 minutes of dialogue in a class, he challenged what he called my “synoptic” worldview—my belief in all-encompassing systems. He believed people will not even bother to tackle something until there is an immediate problem and then they will remedy and try to repair it. He never believed in grand designs. He viewed change as incremental. And his ideas were so persuasive that I became much more skeptical about rational choice theory. But I still use it, in an eclectic manner, as a productive metaphor.

VR: Did you have other significant mentors?

ADS: At Berkeley, I would mention Sheldon Wolin; also, Hanna Fenichel Pitkin, the daughter of Otto Fenichel. You should read her book, Wittgenstein and Justice (1972).

VR: At Berkeley and Yale you were working in political science. But when you returned to the Netherlands, while still completing your dissertation, you began to study psychoanalysis at the Netherlands Institute for Psychoanalysis, and then you practiced as a psychotherapist from 1973 to 1984. How did you get into that?

ADS: While I was working on mathematical political science at Yale, I increasingly had the feeling that while this was very interesting, it kept me far removed from how people really function. I had the idea that if Stendhal, the French novelist, who I thought was a most perceptive “psychologist,” would be alive today, I would want to be his secretary. When I found out he was not alive [laughter], I decided that the next best people to learn from might be psychoanalysts. After I returned to Amsterdam, I went into psychoanalysis myself. That led me to learning analysis and I was admitted to the psychoanalytic institute.

VR: How did this affect your work?

ADS: I continued to work on what was a technical, mathematical dissertation, but at the same time I became more interested in specific environments. I wanted to observe and study real encounters. I got a commission to study a cancer ward, and this was very different from technical and mathematical research.

VR: Do you think you could have done the kind of work and research you did in the cancer ward without your own psychoanalysis and your immersion in psychoanalytic theory?

ADS: I find that hard to say.

VR: I suppose you were probably always something of a people-watcher.

ADS: Yes, and I’d have to say the psychoanalytic background certainly helped. I became a little more tolerant of human variety, a little less frightened of people’s emotional reactions. It didn’t open my eyes in any dramatic way; I knew, of course, that people were jealous or angry or scared—these are pervasive emotions. But I gradually learned to be more accepting of such emotions in myself and in others.

VR: Do you think psychoanalysis made you a more empathic person?

ADS: [laughter] Yes, but it’s something that you have to learn to turn on and off. I would certainly say that it helped me with my relationships with colleagues. I was a founder of the graduate school for social science. I managed to keep it all together despite the fact that I think I was the youngest in the group. One reason I could do that was that I had learned in group therapy that if someone flies into a rage—so what? Especially the Dutch, much more than the Americans, are terribly struck when someone gets angry. But I didn’t take it personally. I had learned in group therapy not to react immediately to other people’s defensive or aggressive outbursts. I was able to observe it and let it play out and see what happened.

VR: This immersion in the psychoanalytic world—did it change your vision of the world?

ADS: Yes. This is an education. It gives you more of a feel for the emotional quality of hu-

Page 44

man experience. There is always another layer behind what is happening—ambivalence, ambiguity. You’re not surprised when you see that. Also, psychoanalysis encourages introspection—and I increasingly got the idea that this is a great treasure for a sociologist, for where else can you find vice, if not from introspection? Maybe I was lucky to have a bad character—because this helps me understand others. [laughter] But to be serious for a moment, the psychoanalytic background taught me to take a more factual view of emotions.

VR: What do you mean by “factual”?

ADS: When I see that I am jealous or angry or frightened—or that others are—I can accept this as normal. I don’t see these feelings as shameful. They are normal, human. This was the heritage of psychoanalysis. I take this approach when I observe and study real human encounters.

VR: Can you explain how that approach plays out, for instance, in your research?

ADS: I’m thinking about the French photographer, Andre Bresson. He photographed artists in their studios. Many of them were working with naked women in their studios—by the way, very beautiful naked women. But there is no sexual excitement. Totally detached. The interest is in line and shadow—not the figure as an erotic object. That, of course, is the aesthetic “glance.” You look at the formal properties. There is very much an analogy in the psychotherapeutic encounter. Let’s say a patient is describing her latest sexual adventures. The patient may be ashamed or embarrassed, and the therapist observes this and may think how clever she was or how well she did this or he may try to figure out why she did such an outrageous thing or why she is so ashamed—but that is not the exciting quality; the exciting quality is somewhere else. Here there is the equivalent of the phenomenologist’s “epoche”: the suspension of acting upon desires; the suspension of emotions and of judgment and the concentration on observation. This is what happens in the psychotherapeutic setting and in the kind of research I did, for instance, in the cancer ward as I observed cancer patients and the people who took care of them.

VR: I particularly resonated to the essays in your book, The Management of Normality. You did work on the history of the family, jealousy, and agoraphobia, relating these to changing historical and cultural contexts. Considering these interests of yours, would you call yourself a psychohistorian?

ADS: I call myself a sociologist.

VR: Are you a sociologist doing psychohistory? Many psychohistorians emphasize that emotions drive history, but what you seem to be stressing is that we need to remember that history drives emotions; in other words, that our emotions are shaped by historical /sociological contexts. It’s a two-way street, isn’t it?

ADS: Yes. Emotional experience and emotional expression are shaped by culture as it exists in a specific time and place. I like the work of Peter Stearns because he sees this so clearly. You know, I have been very influenced by Norbert Elias. He called his major work The Civilizing Process: Sociogenetic and Psychogenetic Investigations. Those of us who call ourselves students of Norbert Elias think that the psychological and sociological are inseparable. You cannot talk about people as if they have no inner life, and you cannot talk about society as if it is not shaped through constant interaction among people.

VR: Aside from Elias’ work, can you name other books that were important to you?

ADS: Nico Frijda has been very important for my recent work. I’ve also drawn on the work of Harold Lasswell, Howard Stein, Vamik Volkan, Johan Goudsblom, and Thomas Haskell.

VR: Can you identify specific psychoanalytic tools you apply in your research?

ADS: Concepts like transference, counter-transference, identification, projection, and fantasies—I believe that all these are particularly important for anyone analyzing human interactions.

VR: Many readers of Clio’s Psyche would be interested in your assessment of the role of psychoanalysis in the Netherlands today.

ADS: I’d say that what is happening here is quite similar to what is going on the U.S. It’s very unusual today for people to go into traditional analysis, unless of course they aspire to become psychoanalysts themselves. It’s so expensive, and legislation is not so generous. Also, there is now more skepticism, even among the cognoscenti, about the efficacy of a “talking cure.” Therapists are more eclectic today, and many advocate therapy plus medication. Also, the different therapies—rational emotive, behavioral, gestalt, family—they are all coming out of their separate corners to see what they can do together. Psychoanalysts are part of this scene, of course, but they no longer dominate it. Nor do they insist that theirs is the

Page 45

only acceptable therapeutic approach. Still, I have no doubt that the insights of Freud and other psychoanalysts are invaluable for an understanding of individuals and societies. Freudian concepts of transference and counter-transference are absolutely germane to any research in sociology and anthropology. However, psychoanalysts have often been ahistorical and asociological. Like Elias, I, too, believe that it is essential to consider the sociological and historical contexts of human behavior.

VR: Your most recent work is on the globalization of language. How did you get into that?

ADS: It is a spin-off of something I dealt with in my book In Care of the State. I became interested in the dynamics of language groups. So I did what I have done before: I went into a new field about which I knew very little, and posed some obvious questions, but I could combine the answers with what I knew from more familiar disciplines such as psychoanalysis and the social sciences.

VR: Now that your book on language is finished, what are you going to do next?

ADS: I want to get back to what I did in my 1995 article on “Widening Circles of Identification: Emotional Concerns in Sociogenetic Perspective.” I want to explore the processes of identification and “disidentification” and see how these are related to the civilizing process.

VR: When you work with Elias’ material, do you see yourself as continuing his work, or amending or improving it?

ADS: Right now, I see myself in almost a head-on collision. I think Elias has never come to terms with the genocide of the Jews and the things he wrote on that topic are not satisfactory—but then that’s the most difficult topic one could possibly deal with.

VR: Perhaps one of the problems is that he did his major work when there was a great deal of optimism. We have now come to a time of pessimism, at least partly because we see too many pockets of “decivilization.”

ADS: I think Elias saw Nazi Germany as a society where the direction of the civilizing process was actually reversed with “the breakdown of civilization” as the final result. But I’m afraid that isn’t the whole story. I feel that one cannot understand the Soviet Union or Nazi Germany as “decivilized” societies. They were very well man-

Page 46

aged societies, and in many areas of life were very “civilized”—but they were destructive. That is why I use the word dyscivilized—as in dysfunctional. There is a problem in Elias’ work he couldn’t resolve; his own tragedies as a refugee colored his analysis. It is imperative today that we understand not only the civilizing process, but also why some societies are or become dysfunctional and dyscivilized.

VR: Many researchers today seem to be saying that divisions between disciplines are not only artificial, but also misleading.

ADS: That is very much the way I look at it. Many of the subjects I have been interested in are at the intersection of sociology, psychoanalysis, and history. I take a very strongly relational view of human nature. We are never alone, least of all when we are alone. We maintain, constantly, an inner dialogue with other people, people fantasized, people remembered. I have a very learned colleague, an anthropologist, who defends the idea of the primacy and the autonomy of fantasy. Yes, fantasies can get the better of people. Still, I am hesitant. I feel that there is always a material underpinning to those fantasies. Inner and real dialogues take place in specific cultural and historical frameworks. To understand individuals and societies, we need to draw on sociology, psychoanalysis, and history.

Page 47

About the author

Vivian M. Rosenberg

Vivian M. Rosenberg, PhD, is Professor of Humanities, Emeritaat Drexel University where she taught for 35 years after receiving her doctoral degree in the field of the History of Ideas at Brandeis University. Her paper, “Through a Kohutian Lens: William James and Josiah Royce,” received the William L. Langer Award for the best article published in the Psychohistory Review from 1992-1995. Dr. Rosenberg teaches in retiree programs in the Philadelphia area and may be contacted at .

How to cite this article

Rosenberg, V. (2001). Abram de Swaan: Using sociology, history, and psychoanalysis [Interview]. Clio’s Psyche, 8(1), 43-47.

https://doi.org/10.70763/2475c20d9e9a1aaee80dcbc4e6316157

PDF downloads