Volume 07 - Number 2 - September 2000
Pages: 53 - 99

BOOK REVIEWS

Rousselle, R. (2000). Applying Ullman’s dream methodology [Review of the book The variety of dream experience: Expanding our ways of working with dreams by Montague Ullman & Claire Limmer (1999)]. Clio’s Psyche, 7(2), 74-76.

https://doi.org/10.70763/f490d0af974fedf90cb0f1edce8e3dd5

Applying Ullman’s Dream Methodology

book review

Abstract

This book review of The Variety of Dream Experience: Expanding our Ways of Working with Dreams (second edition, 1999), by Montague Ullman and Claire Limmer, considers a collection built around Ullman’s experiential dream group process. The reviewer describes the method. A dreamer volunteers a dream, group members make it their own and relate its imagery to possible life concerns, and the dreamer, who may accept or disregard any interpretation, keeps control through a built-in Safety Factor. A Discovery Factor helps the dreamer learn about the dream and the self. The review outlines the book’s parts: dream groups for individuals and for a group of mothers new to America; classroom uses in anthropology, creative writing, computer and information science, and political science; ministerial and pastoral work; and psychology and psychiatry, including psychoanalytic group therapy and individual psychotherapy. It also covers Ullman’s closing proposal for a sociology of dreams, which it connects to his article “A Sociology of Dreams?” in Clio’s Psyche. The reviewer contrasts Ullman’s attention to the feelings of the manifest dream in a setting of safety with Freud’s movement toward latent content through free association. The reviewer finds the book lucid, conversational, and emotionally engaging, and regrets the publisher’s deletion of two historical dream chapters, by Don Hughes and Paul Elovitz, from the first edition. The reviewer concludes that the technique suits pedagogical, ministerial, and therapeutic settings and anyone interested in understanding their dreams.

Keywords:

book review, Claire Limmer, dream methodology, dreamwork, emotional response, intellectual interest, Montague Ullman, psychohistory, The Variety of Dream Experience: Expanding our Ways of Working with Dreams

Review of Montague Ullman and Claire Limmer, The Variety of Dream Experience: Expanding our Ways of Working with Dreams, Second Edition. Albany, New York: State University of New York Press, 1999. Paperback, ISBN 079144256X, pp. xiv & 280, $20.95.

Rare is the book that appeals both intellectually and emotionally to the reader, that generates reflection and excitement on successive pages. Most academic books (the kind I love to read and review) often stimulate the mind with new insights or approaches to a specific field, but they never emotionally grab the reader. Any thoughts or ideas applicable to the life or research of the reader are tangential to the book, and often one will become

Page 74

so lost in those thoughts that it will be several minutes before one realizes that he/she has read the last few pages uncomprehendingly. With Ullman and Limmer the “read” is different. The tone is conversational in many of the pieces; there is an almost total absence of jargon and a lucidity with which the process of dream work is explained. The book generates an intellectual interest in a useful technique for understanding dreams and the emotional response of considering participation in it. This is a revised, second edition of the 1987 book. The new edition includes some revised or expanded chapters, along with three new ones. Regrettably, a couple were dropped, about which I will write more below.

The basis of the book is the experiential dream group process, which is a group approach to dream work, devised by Ullman that enables people to better understand their dreams. Ullman recognizes the vulnerability of the dreamer sharing his/her dream with the group, and a Safety Factor is built into the process, which ensures that the dreamer maintains control of the dream. Also built into the process is the Discovery Factor, by which the group helps the dreamer learn about the dream and his/her self. The process begins with a person volunteering a dream, which members of the group then make their own and upon which they project their own moods and emotions. The group then relates the imagery of the dream to possible life concerns. The Safety Factor comes into play as the dreamer is free to accept or disregard any interpretation. The dreamer is then free to show the extent to which his/her understanding of the dream has been increased by the group’s suggestions. Further discussion elucidates recent events and emotions that underlie the dream, after which the dream is read back. Aspects of the dream that the dreamer does not understand can be the subject of further discussion.

Throughout this usually fascinating process, stress is on the Safety Factor. Feeling in control of the process frees the energies of the dreamer to probe more deeply into the dream. The process is not only intellectually intriguing, but also appears to be emotionally satisfying. Those who have never participated in any dream group, and who might be reluctant to relate much of a personal nature, would find this technique appealing.

The next two chapters of this part of the book relate other examples of how the group dream work helps the dreamer, illustrating further applications of the method. The chapter by Nan Zimmerman was especially moving. She dealt with issues such as the loss of a child by suicide and the dreams of an elderly woman as death approached. Most striking was Zimmerman’s own dream enabling her to face up to the sexual abuse perpetrated years before by a trusted minister, confiding the story to her husband and a few close friends, and eventually confronting the minister. Her narration of the dream and her struggle with it, and her courage in writing about it, exemplify her beautiful metaphor, that “(d)reams are seedpods in which the seeds of the past and the plantings of the future are encased. When we crack them open, reseeding of life can begin again.”

The third chapter, by Jenny Dodd, deals with a dream group of mothers, many with young children and all but one new to America. Dodd shows how the experiential dream group refreshed and healed, enabling them to face themselves and the world in which they lived.

The second and largest part of the book shows how the procedure has been successfully used in other disciplines. Its use in academia is explored by Deborah Jay Hillman for anthropology, Richard Jones for creative writing, Edward Storm in computer and information science, and John Wiske in political science. All demonstrate to varying degrees how talking about dreams in conjunction with their course work can help students better comprehend the subject, thereby enriching their understanding of it and themselves. Two chapters, by John Walsh and Sven Hedenrud, show the viability of the experiential dream group process in ministerial and pastoral duties. Especially touching is Walsh’s dream, which when explicated in its religious context reveals the sum of a life-time of faith and his struggle with his own darkness.

It is here that I must register a major disappointment. Two chapters from the first edition, dealing with historical dreams, one by Don Hughes on ancient dreams and the other by Paul Elovitz on more modern material, were deleted from the second edition by the publisher. As a historian I regret the decision, and considering the popularity of psychohistory one might have hoped that at least one of the chapters would have been retained.

The third part of the book discusses the application of the experiential dream group in psychology and psychiatry. Inge Widlund, trained in both traditional psychoanalytic group therapy as well as the experiential dream group, addresses the contrasting techniques and goals of each field. The

Page 75

author concludes that the appreciation of dreams and the way members of the experiential dream group “play” with dream images, symbols, and metaphors, could be usefully appropriated by the therapist leading a psychoanalytic group therapy session. It is followed by a very poignant account by Claire Limmer, relating feelings of youthful isolation and adult loss, plus the subsequent onset of cancer, and the healing properties of the dream work. It left her “stronger in the years that followed, more peaceful than I have ever been, and well.”

Ullman and Limmer join in a chapter concerning dreams and clinical work, how the group process can be applied to one-on-one psychotherapy. The seven premises of dream work which are applicable to the practice of psychotherapy are discussed by Ullman, after which Limmer documents their effectiveness with examples from her own practice. The final chapter by Ullman argues that although dreams are personal, they also have a social component. They comment not only on individual problems and concerns, but the societal area as well. At this point Dr. Ullman suggests the need for a sociology of dreams, which complements and expands on his remarks in a recent article in this journal, “A Sociology of Dreams?” (Clio’s Psyche, September, 1998, vol. 5, no. 2, pp. 41-43).

The observant reader will quickly note the difference between Freud’s and Ullman’s methods of dream work. For Freud, the dream was the road to reach the unconscious, to understand one’s neuroses. Through free association, Freud and his patient would go beyond the manifest content to the latent, no matter how harrowing or painful, even potentially alienating, to the dreamer. Ullman restored to importance the feelings and emotions of the manifest content of the dream, which reveals much of our fears and desires, relationships and animosities. Furthermore, it is done in a manner that ensures feelings of safety on the part of the dreamer. Rather than the doctor/patient relationship of one-on-one psychotherapy or the often confrontational nature of group therapy, the experiential dream group acts as a support system and focuses on helping the dreamer understand his dream in a safe, nurturing manner.

The authors and the dreamers whose dreams they relate resemble Freud in their courage, as they unreservedly share their dreams (some of a very personal and revealing nature) with the reader. Through this method, they document the beneficial and healing aspect of the experiential dream group. As the various chapters demonstrate, this technique is applicable to a wide variety of situations: pedagogical, ministerial, and therapeutic, as well as for anyone interested in understanding his or her dreams.

Page 76

About the author

Robert J. Rousselle

Robert J. Rouselle is an independent scholar with a doctoral degree from SUNY-Binghamton in ancient Greek and Roman history. His interests include ancient studies, Christian martyrs, dreams, and psychohistory, and he has published a dozen articles and 15-20 book reviews.

How to cite this article

Rousselle, R. (2000). Applying Ullman’s dream methodology [Review of the book The variety of dream experience: Expanding our ways of working with dreams by Montague Ullman & Claire Limmer (1999)]. Clio’s Psyche, 7(2), 74-76.

https://doi.org/10.70763/f490d0af974fedf90cb0f1edce8e3dd5

PDF downloads