
Volume 32 - Number 1 - Winter 2025
Pages: 1 - 129
SPECIAL ISSUE PART II
Rubin, J. B. (2025). White supremacy and childhood trauma: The case of David Lane. Clio’s Psyche, 32(1), 102-106.
White Supremacy and Childhood Trauma: The Case of David Lane
Abstract
Drawing on a psychoanalytically informed psychobiography of David Lane, one of the ideological architects of the White supremacist movement, the author aims to illuminate the link between David Lane’s White supremacist ideology and his emotional experience in childhood with a brutalizing father.
autobiography, childhood trauma, culture war, David Lane, father-son relationship, Heart of Darkness, Joseph Conrad, neo-Nazism, psychoanalysis, psychobiography, psychohistory, Robert Stolorow, White supremacist movement
White Supremacy and Childhood Trauma: The Case of David Lane
Drawing on a psychoanalytically informed psychobiography of David Lane, one of the ideological architects of the White supremacist movement, I aim to illuminate the link between his White supremacist ideology and his emotional experience in childhood with a brutalizing father. The most significant threat to America may lie within. When COVID-19 becomes a nightmarish memory of a ghastly cultural plague, I fear the social virus infecting America from White supremacists will continue to haunt, bewilder, and assault us. It is easy to miss the mark when thinking about White supremacists and homegrown extremists. Amid a raging culture war, people tend to be divided between White supremacist sympathizers who condone recent racism and violence and opponents who abhor it. When a significant segment of the population is viewed by some democrats as “deplorable,” it is tempting to advocate that we “exterminate the brutes,” as Kurtz said in Joseph Conrad’s (1950, p. 123) Heart of Darkness.
“Nothing is easier than to denounce the evil-doer; nothing more difficult than to understand him,” wrote Norman Cousins (1981, p. 39), summarizing Dostoevsky. White supremacy, like madness, has a story to tell. Understanding where people are com-
Page 102
ing from who identify as White supremacists—which doesn’t preclude holding them morally accountable for racism and violence—is more constructive and important than denunciation. We can’t address malevolence we don’t comprehend, such as White supremacy.
The best theories we have about the causes of White supremacists don’t get to the source of the problem. The Chicago Project on Security and Threats (CPOST) has studied the demographics of the “377 Americans, from 250 counties in 44 states, arrested or charged in the Capitol attack” (Pierce, 2021, para 2). Based on two additional independent surveys in February and March, including a National Opinion Research Council survey, CPOST concluded that fear of the “Great Replacement,” rather than economic insecurity, was at the root of the rage. The “Great Replacement” theory—the notion that Whites are being displaced and replaced because of mass immigration and low birth rates resulting in rapidly rising non-White populations—certainly sheds light on some elements of fury among White people. Yet, although the “Great Replacement” theory has “achieved iconic status” (Pierce, 2021, para 5), it also hides a deeper source of resentment.
A unifying thread and rallying cry of White supremacists is a belief in the threat of “White genocide.” It is hard for those who don’t share this belief to understand how neo-Nazis, Ku Klux Klanners, militias, and Aryan survivalists came to assume that White people are threatened with extinction by mass immigration, intermarriage, and “forced assimilation.” In the case of David Lane, who popularized this belief, fears of extinction seem based on an unconscious fear from the past, instilled by a White father who terrorized and endangered his child.
Lane, a neo-Nazi and convicted felon, was the poster child for 20th century White nationalism. He was best known on the Right for penning “14 Words,” arguably the most renowned White supremacist slogan: “We must secure the existence of our people and a future for White children” (Lane, 2015, p. 211). Racial survival was the single greatest issue of our time, according to Lane, and America was the murderer of the White race.
White people living in fear of “extermination” is an old story in American history. In reference to Lothrop Stoddard’s The Rising Tide of Color: The Threat Against White World-Supremacy (1920), F. Scott Fitzgerald’s (1925) character Tom Buchanan in The
Page 103
Great Gatsby favorably embraced Stoddard’s view: “Well, it’s a fine book, and everybody ought to read it. The idea is if we don’t look out the white race will be—will be utterly submerged. It’s all scientific stuff; it’s been proved” (p. 13). It was David Lane who took these views and brought them to a wider audience.
David Lane was born on November 2, 1938, in Woten, Iowa. “My only memory of my mother is as a tall, severe woman who never smiled,” he writes in his autobiography (Lane, n.d.). Lane (n.d.) wrote in his autobiography that his father
seems to have been a drunk, a scoundrel, and a low-life of the worst kind… particularly when drunk, a truly despicable creature. He sold my mother to his buddies and to strangers for booze money. He beat the entire family, often with a razor strap.
Then, he continued with this heartbreaking recollection:
In 1942, the family was living in a room over a hardware store in Woten, Iowa. With no wood for the stove, which provided the only heat during cold northern Iowa winters, my brother Roger [two years David’s senior] started a fire in the stove with available materials, including the razor strap. For this my father beat him so badly that he broke Roger’s eardrums and he was deaf for the rest of his life. For this reason, he was never adopted from the orphanage where we all ended up. (Lane, n.d.)
After David’s father left his family in 1942, he mistreated another young wife, and “a brother of the new victim smashed his head in with a hammer, and Gerd went to wherever trash goes after death” (Lane, n.d.). In 1943, David was “adopted out of the orphanage” by a “doctrinaire, fundamentalist, Lutheran minister from the old school. He had a personality which practically no one could bear” (Lane, n.d.). His new mother “was an enigma. … To this day I cannot fathom how she could abandon her own talents and ego to traipse about the country with someone I considered an obnoxious buffoon” (Lane, n.d.).
Something murderous and unspeakable was done to David Lane and his family—by his father, not people of color. When your father beats you and abandons you, you feel annihilated and erased, worthless and unlovable. What makes dreadful events traumatic, notes psychoanalyst Robert Stolorow in Trauma and Human Exis-
Page 104
tence (2007), is not the incident alone but the absence of an emotional home for one’s feelings. Not only did David Lane go through a devastating experience, but he also had to face it by himself, which intensified the psychological damage.
The nightmare his father put David through gave him a life mission—save White children from being extinguished. But in some ways, the extinction David feared in the future—“The Death of The White Race is neither imaginary nor far off in the distant future”—already happened, but in his past: the emotional “murder” he had undergone at home. The British psychoanalyst D. W. Winnicott found that a fear of breakdown—and death (I’d add soul murder)—was a breakdown that happened in the person’s past but was not remembered; the unremembered memory was preserved in the fear projected into the future.
“The future for White children” David Lane yearned to “secure”—and that has inspired thousands of White supremacists—was one his father annihilated in him. By blaming Blacks, immigrants, Jews, and women for the “extermination,” he didn’t realize what he had experienced at the hands of his father. Aligning himself with a community of embittered men who stoked his anger rather than empathized with his pain, David distanced himself from the real source of his agony by scapegoating innocent people, letting his father off the hook. Racializing emotional extinction—attributing fears of obliteration to nameless people of color David Lane never met—warded off the unspeakable and unbearable nightmare that his father had psychologically obliterated him. In doing so, Lane unwittingly ensured that his trauma would never be addressed; instead, he foisted his trauma on the world.
Not everyone who is traumatized becomes an extremist. Some torched souls respond to their agony by becoming psychotherapists or nurses, martial artists or teachers, rather than perpetrators of violence or abuse. It’s likely impossible to claim that all White supremacists were once traumatized or that authoritarianism is only learned at home. But I think we can reasonably speculate that some kind of ghastly unconscious trauma may live in some, and possibly many, White supremacists.
Since the topic of authoritarianism and White supremacy is overdetermined, with historical, psychological, and sociological facets, we need to utilize the wisdom of historians and sociologists, mental health professionals and anthropologists, economists and
Page 105
students of the brain, and novelists and artists in addressing these troubling and ever-escalating cultural cancers. Combating homegrown extremists is a complex problem demanding multi-pronged strategies. It’s crucial to understand the emotional sources of White supremacists’ fear and alienation, which the example of David Lane suggests is emotional trauma close to home. It’s also important to understand their feeling culturally and financially marginalized, supplanted, and losing the world they knew and not being able to mourn it. Getting in touch with the emotional horrors we undergo can be devastating, even shattering. But it also affords a powerful resource for lessening the possibility that such traumas are so frequently revisited on innocent people in the world.
Page 106
References
- Conrad, Joseph (1950). Heart of darkness. W. W. Norton & Company. (Originally published in 1899).
- Cousins, Norman (1981). Human options. W. W. Norton & Company.
- Fitzgerald, F. Scott (1925). The great Gatsby. Charles Scribner’s Sons.
- Lane, David (2015). 14 words. In Cathie Carmichael & Richard C. Maguire (Eds.), The Routledge history of genocide. Routledge.
- Lane, David (n.d.). Collection of works of David Lane. https://www.scribd.com/document/73195517/Collection-of-Works-of-David-Lane
- Pierce, Charles P. (2021, April 6). A new study draws a line from January 6 to Charlottesville. Esquire. https://www.esquire.com/news-politics/politics/a36040222/robert-pape-cpost-report-january-6-insurrection/
How to cite this article
Rubin, J. B. (2025). White supremacy and childhood trauma: The case of David Lane. Clio’s Psyche, 32(1), 102-106.



