Volume 26 - Number 3 - Spring 2020
Pages: 265 - 387

THE PSYCHOLOGY OF ALTRUISM, SERVICE, AND GENERATIVITY

Shafir, T. B. (2020). When giving never seems to be enough. Clio’s Psyche, 26(3), 300-304.

https://doi.org/10.70763/3569df159ec477451530c4455b2a9e86

When Giving Never Seems to Be Enough

article

Abstract

Viewing charity, philanthropy, and personal caregiving through the lens of Attachment Theory offers a novel perspective on the role defense processes play in a relationship. Drawing from individual case studies of attachment disruption and trauma, this across-the-lifespan weave examines the motivation for giving when satisfaction remains elusive. One may draw interesting parallels between how the needs of the individual and those of society as a whole seek to be met.

Keywords:

altruism, attachment, charity, compulsive caregiving, defense processes, generativity, Judith Kestenberg, philanthropy, psychohistory, psychological trauma, unconscious motivations

In the last few decades, much attention has been paid to the role of Attachment Theory in mainstream psychology. Those who deal with cutting-edge trauma therapies have begun to understand the connection between a secure base, unresolved attachment trauma, and early disruptions. What has this got to do with altruism, service, and generativity? Plenty. That first relationship and the average expectations it sets in a young child’s mind, not only from its caregivers but from the environment as a whole, establishes a history of give-and-take that either supports resilience and growth or creates bitterness and low self-esteem. The perspectives and behaviors that follow extend throughout life.

So what’s a human to do if what William Blatz referred to as a healthy dependency escaped one’s grasp? Enter the creativity of the perpetuation of the species: defense processes. We are predisposed to find a way to avoid abandonment and the terror that goes with it. Generally speaking, we either employ deactivation with a dismissing conclusion that if I can’t get what I need, I’ll just avoid the disappointment and no longer want/need it, or we choose cognitive disconnection by either removing what we perceive as the trigger from our environment or removing ourselves from the trigger.

Page 300

Compulsive Caregiving and the Case of Baby Joey    

Under these two broad umbrellas lie many variations of defense. Significantly prevalent is one called compulsive caregiving. This pattern can be seen very early in some instances, as in the case of two-month-old Joey. A healthy baby, Joey was the first child of a young couple whose mother was so obviously terrified to even be talking to a therapist (or anyone for that matter) that a meeting had to be arranged at a specific hour at a friend’s home. If you haven’t already surmised, Joey’s mother was a battered wife. She described a life nearly completely controlled by her husband and his mother. So much so that, although she wanted a natural childbirth, she was forced to have a medically unnecessary C-section on a date determined by her mother-in-law.

The new mother literally hovered over Joey as he attempted to nap during our session. Sitting a foot away from him, she frequently leaned over as he slept, eyes searching apprehensively for any sign of distress. For his part, Joey awoke every seven to 10 minutes, fussed, was immediately picked up, suckled briefly, and then returned to his seat to sleep. She explained that the baby was often hungry. Attempts to reassure her were unsuccessful.

Feeling mother’s anxiety, the baby responded with a level of hyperarousal, which was assuaged by interactive regulation. Instead of mutual regulation occurring as a result of the mother’s attunement to the baby, the baby actually learns to respond to the mother’s elevated level of anxiety with his own dysregulation. In this way, the baby calms the mother with interactive regulation, resolving his own distress in the process. This behavior evokes a pattern of disorganization that is likely to persist.

Somatic Components of a Secure Attachment System

From birth, in the non-verbal, somatic world of touch, tension-flow, and shape-flow, there is attunement and adjustment of mother to baby’s rhythms in service of both the functional and the emotional state. The baby also moves to align with the mother, shaping in service of early function in what may be described as a dance of give and take. The “good enough mother” (Winnicott, 1957)—not the perfect mother—projects empathy and fosters trust through muscle tension and breathing rhythms, promoting kinesthetic pattern memory through repetition. Dr. Judith Kestenberg, creator of the Kestenberg Movement Profile, asserts that through the repeated rhythm of breathing, for example, “…the infant develops an image of his or her own body” (The Meaning of

Page 301

Movement: Embodied Developmental, Clinical, and Cultural Perspectives of the Kestenberg Movement Profile, 2018, 146).

A baby exposed to tense holding patterns of bound flow and hyperaroused breathing rhythms over time develops internal working models of the self and self in relationship that reflect the mother’s emotional state and the immediate environment as a whole. Mutuality, instead of thriving in an evolving developmental state of encouraged exploration supported by an embodied sense of haven of safety, becomes one of unhealthy dependency. Moving from discomfort into comfort when the giver and receiver have switched roles colors the act of giving and causes mistrust in receiving. Is it a giving, generous environment to grow into, or is it unsafe to receive as well as easier, more familiar, and safer to give?

The Case of Susan and Becca

Giving to get one’s needs met through fulfilling the needs of another may on the surface be deemed selfless, considerate, even sensitive, and rewarded with approval of the authority figure. Compulsive caregiving is, however, transactional. The giver expects something in return, an affirmation of his/her/their value, an interactively regulating event, achieved through the satisfaction of knowing the object of one’s attention is pleased. Carried into adulthood, the compulsive giver’s pattern often becomes a source of anger and resentment for being ignored, unseen, and unacknowledged. A defense process of survival, sublimating one’s needs in deference to another’s, blocks intimacy. It is the ultimate detour on the road to self-realization. The compulsive caregiver is, by definition, poorly related to the recipient. The giving is palpable, but lasting satisfaction eludes both parties. There’s never enough—to give or to receive.

Susan, 28, and Becca, 23, are sisters. They are first-generation, born of immigrant parents who’d worked their way to a comfortable lifestyle. Susan describes her sister’s arrival as too much energy for mother to handle, so she took over as caregiver. Susan was bullied relentlessly throughout elementary and high school. Her attempts to alert her parents to the situation were met with little acknowledgment and decidedly failed protection. She stopped talking about it, employing a defense of deactivation, and endured. Her value derived from her role as her sister’s keeper and problem solver for the family.

Page 302

At their parents’ urging, Becca moved in with Susan after college. Susan, predictably accommodating, continued paying two-thirds of the rent and all utility bills, even after Becca found work. She insisted on maintaining her caretaker role while intense resentment built between the two. Susan’s quid pro quo was her tolerance for squashing her needs in exchange for not being alone and not having to leave “home.” Her caregiving focus allowed her to defensively exclude the unprocessed feelings of one prematurely and unfairly cast as mother’s and sister’s caregiver instead of being supported as the child who needed care. This emotional neglect was reactivated at school when she was bullied and ostracized by her peers with no effective protection or support from either parents or teachers.

She sought therapy to help resolve the trauma of a couple incidents of sexual abuse during college, which went unreported but resulted in a bout of anorexia and a year off from school. Compulsive caregiving was taking its toll in many areas, having effectively shielded Susan for most of her life from the anger and sadness from which she shielded herself, her family, and friends.

Her first major breakthrough came when she agreed to stop addressing her sister by her diminutive baby name, acknowledging in word and deed that Becca was now an adult. As she began to understand the concept of compulsive caregiving, Susan set boundaries and Becca agreed to pay half of everything. Now cognizant of the reverse attachment patterning of her mother, she cut their contact to one brief conversation a day, sometimes daring to skip a day. Instead of throwing money at the source of irritation, as she had learned to do, Susan dared to confront the system at the core, repatterning and reframing her part to elicit systemic change.

The Limiting Transactional Base of Compulsive Giving

When giving is linked to a perceived threat to life and limb, the sensory flashback of the moment of origin constantly drives the act of giving in the present. Accompanying thoughts emerge: “Be my friend, and I’ll take care of you. Stick with me, and I’ll give you something you can’t get on your own or from anyone else. Without me, you won’t survive.”

Transactional giving projects uncertainty and foments distrust. Unmet expectations arise for both those giving and receiving. Any immediate anxiety may resolve only to recharge and resurface when another trigger reappears. People trapped in the roles of this

Page 303

dynamic either need someone to rescue—someone helpless in need of attention, care, money, material goods, or power—or the recipients need to believe that they are incapable of taking care of themselves. Uninterrupted, this pattern results in the perception of the existence of perpetual victimhood.

Charity, giving of any kind, large and small, when motivated by an unconscious defensive strategy, serves as a constantly reenacting rescue from the giver’s own terrifying fear of abandonment. Since this external act misses the target of an internal need, the “never enough” feelings on both sides of the equation persist.

Page 304

About the author

Talia B. Shafir

Talia B. Shafir, PhD (Somatic and Spiritual Psychology), is a Registered Somatic Movement Educator and Therapist, Psychophysical Therapist, and Clinical Hypnotherapist in private practice in New York City. Dr. Shafir specializes in Trauma, PTSD, and Adult Attachment Issues. She can be contacted at .

How to cite this article

Shafir, T. B. (2020). When giving never seems to be enough. Clio’s Psyche, 26(3), 300-304.

https://doi.org/10.70763/3569df159ec477451530c4455b2a9e86

PDF downloads