Volume 06 - Number 4 - March 2000
Pages: 133 - 184

THE FUTURE OF PSYCHOHISTORY

Simonton, D. K. (2000). Psychohistory from a historiometric perspective. Clio’s Psyche, 6(4), 146-148.

https://doi.org/10.70763/475cc020a2dc98e1bd061ddfdf162fdc

Psychohistory from a Historiometric Perspective

article

Abstract

In this article, a contribution to the symposium “The Future of Psychohistory,” whose first essay is Paul H. Elovitz’s “The Partial Success and Bright Prospects of Psychohistory,” the author contends that psychohistory would benefit from adopting the quantitative methods of scientific psychology. He characterizes psychohistory as resting on psychoanalytic theory and a qualitative, quasi-clinical method. He describes historiometry as the content analysis of documents, correspondence, and creative products, combined with statistical analysis of biographical and historical variables, and distinguishes it from cliometrics. He surveys his own research on eminent scientists, artists, philosophers, U.S. presidents, and European monarchs, and lists other researchers who have used the approach, among them Winter, Suedfeld, and Tetlock on political leaders. He cites Colin Martindale’s The Clockwork Muse as a historiometric study of a psychoanalytic concept, primary process. He acknowledges that historiometry tends toward general principles while psychohistory more often pursues particular cases. As examples, he cites Winter and Carlson’s motive-score study of Richard Nixon and his own time-series study of King George III. He reports that the study found the king’s illness episodes followed periods of personal and political stress, and proposes that earlier accounts overlooked this. He refers readers to his book Psychology, Science, and History: An Introduction to Historiometry and concludes that wider use of historiometric methods could revitalize psychohistory, since both fields hold that history cannot be understood without the psychology of its actors.

Keywords:

clinical analysis, historical events, historiometric perspective, methodological approach, personalities, psychoanalytic theory, psychobiography, psychohistory, psychological interpretation, qualitative terms

Historically speaking, the term psychohistory has acquired a somewhat narrow meaning. For the most part, psychohistory has been taken to mean the psychological interpretation of historical events and personalities. Initially, these psychological interpretations relied almost exclusively on psychoanalytic theory. Even when the theoretical orientation is not psychoanalytic, the methodological approach remains so. That is, the interpretation proceeds in a manner very similar to that of a clinical analysis. The raw facts of history and biography are discussed in qualitative rather than quantitative terms.

Yet I would argue that psychohistory might benefit immensely if it were to do more than confine itself just to the theoretical findings of psychological science. After all, scientific psychology prides itself as much or more on its methodological sophistication, especially its quantitative techniques. Significantly, these techniques include methods for (a) the content analysis of official documents, private correspondence, and creative products (whether scientific, literary, musical, or visual) and (b) the causal analysis of correlational data regarding content analytical, biographical, and historical variables. Collectively, this collection of measurement and statistical techniques has been styled “historiometry.” This term not only distinguishes these methods from psychohistory, but also from cliometrics which, while clearly quantitative, does not examine psychological processes, as do both historiometry and psychohistory.

Historiometric inquiries have already shed a tremendous amount of light on the psychological processes that underlie historical manifestations of genius, creativity, leadership, and aesthetics. In my own research program, for example, I have studied eminent scientists and inventors, great philosophers, literary giants, illustrious artists, classical composers, the Presidents of the United States, absolute monarchs of Europe, and other distinguished achievers in almost every domain of accomplishment. In these studies, moreover, I have examined such factors as intelligence, precocity, personality, values, motivation, family environment, education, political circumstances, and the broad sociocultural milieu. Others who have successfully applied quantitative techniques to historical data include Herbert Barry, III, R. B. Cattell, Wayne Dennis, Francis Galton, Aubrey Immelman, Harvey C. Lehman, Colin Martindale, David C. McClelland, Robert R. Sears, Peter Suedfeld, Lewis M. Terman, Philip Tetlock, Edward L. Thorndike, and David Winter. The method has been extensively utilized in the psychological analysis of political leaders, most notably in Winter’s studies of Presidential motivation and in studies by Suedfeld and Tetlock regarding the historical repercussions of a political leader’s cognitive complexity.

Furthermore, some historiometric investi-

Page 146

gations have actually addressed issues that have roots in psychoanalytic theory. A particularly remarkable example can be found in Colin Martindale’s The Clockwork Muse: The Predictability of Artistic Styles (1990). Beginning with the concept of creativity as entailing regression into primary process, Martindale then devised content analytical measures of primary process in literature, music, and the visual arts. Fluctuations in primary process imagery were then shown to predict the origination of new aesthetic styles.

Admittedly, many historiometric investigations are more oriented toward testing nomothetic principles than engaging in idiographic explanations. That is, the historiometrician usually strives to learn about the general processes and functional relations that govern human behavior, thought, and feeling. The psychohistorian, in contrast, is more often interested in a specific historical or biographical question in which the “names, dates, and places” are an integral part of the interpretation. This approach appears more compatible to the quasi-clinical method favored in most psychohistory. Nonetheless, there are many examples of historiometric studies that attempt to grapple with issues that psychohistorians should find inherently valuable. Two examples may suffice.

Many psychohistorians have tried to understand the personality and behavior of Richard M. Nixon, certainly among the most puzzling of all modern Presidents. Some of Nixon’s peculiarities were explicated in terms of his distinctive motivational profile by Winter and Carlson (“Using Motive Scores in the Psychobiographical Study of an Individual: The Case of Richard Nixon,” Journal of Personality, 56 1988, pp. 75-103). After determining Nixon’s power, achievement, and affiliation needs using content analytical procedures, the investigators were able to compare his profile against what would be expected from the vast psychological literature on the correlates of these three motives. In a sense, Nixon represents a fairly typical example of how persons tend to behave who have the same motivational constitution.

Another historic figure who has received considerable psychohistorical attention is King George III of Great Britain. His sporadic bouts with mental illness have attracted many interpretations, some psychodynamic and others medical (e.g., the porphyria hypothesis). Although this literature has been explicitly identified as an example where psychobiographers have exhibited scientific progress in the adequacy of their explanations, I have published a historiometric investigation that shows that these accounts may have overlooked a crucial psychological process (“Mad King George: The Impact of Personal and Political Stress on Mental and Physical Health,” Journal of Personality, 66, 1998, pp. 443-466). By adapting biographical measures from instruments used in health psychology, and by applying time-series statistical analyses, I was able to show that his mental and physical illness followed shortly after periods of exceptional stress in his personal and political life. Hence, King George was exhibiting a phenomenon far more commonplace than most psychobiographers had suspected.

Psychohistorians interested in obtaining a better understanding of this quantitative methodology may consult my book, Psychology, Science, and History: An Introduction to Historiometry (1990). In addition, representative examples of my historiometric articles regarding creative genius have been published in a recent anthology, Simonton, Genius and Creativity: Selected Papers, (1997). Finally, I should mention my most recent review article, “Significant Samples: The Psychological Study of Eminent Individuals” (Psychological Methods, 4, 1999, pp. 425-451). The article systematically compares historiometry with other methodological approaches, including psychometrics, psychobiography, and comparative studies. My hope is that the more extensive use of historiometric methods can help revitalize psychohistory as a respected and creative discipline. After all, historiometricians and psychohistorians share one critical value: The persons and events of history cannot be fully understood without understanding the psychology of the actors who make history.

Page 147

About the author

Dean Keith Simonton

Dean Keith Simonton, PhD, received his Harvard doctorate in Social Psychology and retired as a Distinguished Professor Emeritus of Psychology at the University of California, Davis. His more than 500 publications, including over a dozen books, treat various aspects of genius, creativity, and leadership. In 2023, he served as President of the Society for the History of Psychology (Division 26 of the American Psychological Association). Simonton may be contacted at .

How to cite this article

Simonton, D. K. (2000). Psychohistory from a historiometric perspective. Clio’s Psyche, 6(4), 146-148.

https://doi.org/10.70763/475cc020a2dc98e1bd061ddfdf162fdc

PDF downloads