
Volume 24 - Number 1 - Summer 2017
Pages: 1 - 133
Stecker, F. (2017). Donald Trump’s tweets. Clio’s Psyche, 24(1), 19-22.
Donald Trump’s Tweets
Abstract
What was once an innocuous method of modern social communication has evolved into a major tool for current tribal communications. While the Pope has 10 million Twitter followers, Donald Trump at one point registered 22 million followers. Trump, however, has not focused on aspects of the presidency, but rather on personal identity. While the use of this method of social communication may be responsible for his rise in popularity, his relentless messaging may be the key to his undoing.
Donald Trump, political rhetoric, psychobiography, psychohistory, social media, socio-political polarization, Twitter
Years ago, while I was travelling on business, I overheard a speech delivered by President Bush to the troops at Ft. Hood, Texas on January 3, 2003. He was addressing the build-up of forces due to Saddam Hussein’s possession of weapons of mass destruction. The president said, “We’re not going to forget that they [the terrorists] kill without regard for the rules of war. They don’t value inno-
Page 19
cent life like we do. In America we say that everyone is precious, everybody counts. Everybody is equal in the eyes of the Almighty.” However, he goes on to say, “they’re nothing but a bunch of cold-blooded killers, and that’s the way we’re going to treat them.”
I bristled to hear the violence of 9/11 cast in religious terms that incorrectly depicted Christianity and, by implication, Islam. I concluded that we were being manipulated by stealth hymnody, “Precious in the Eyes of the LORD” (Psalm 116:15), and cherry-picked Christian doctrine that sidestepped most of Christian teaching. This was an eye-opener. For the first time in three years of listening to Bush’s speeches, I heard nuances in the content of his rhetoric that had never before registered with me. I was mystified by the fact that I had been operating on autopilot, as it were, for years, without actually hearing the carefully scripted language in Bush’s speeches. I began a study of political rhetoric in earnest. Further study revealed that there are few improvisations in politics; the battle is always pitched in emotional terms for the undecided voter. It also is not unusual for the truth to be stretched or ignored.
Years later, and in much the same way (pondering an odd phrase of speech), I stumbled over Donald Trump’s use of Twitter. Shortly after the funeral of Justice Antonin Scalia, Trump tweeted “I wonder if President Obama would have attended the funeral of Justice Scalia if it were held in a Mosque? Very sad that he did not go!” ((Trump tweet, February 20, 2016). President Obama, however, had paid respects to Justice Scalia as he was lying in state at the Supreme Court the day before; he did not wish to have his security detail disrupt a public religious service. I wondered about the necessity of that off-hand statement by candidate Donald Trump. Remembering the speech addressed by President Bush to the troops at Ft. Hood, I began to see that such comments were not incidental, but part of a strategy to promote himself to the American voting public as he was seeking the Republican nomination and beyond. So I set about a study of Trump and his use of Twitter.
Much about Trump’s thought processes remain open to speculation. New York Times writer and researcher Kevin Quealy, along with his colleague Jasmine Lee, have read, tagged, and sorted over 14,000 of Trump’s tweets over an 11-month period in 2016 and concluded that he says anything he wants to say and genuinely does not care about the repercussions. They observed that he is a showman with a flamboyant style and his tweets function to both
Page 20
get him the attention of the press as well as to make an instant and personal connection to the individuals who make up his base. While deliberate in political strategy, it is applied with such callousness that it results in confusion.
Hoping that Trump would rise to a level of dignified behavior expected of all statespersons following his election, more than the majority of the American voting public are made anxious by almost each piece of reporting in his first 100 days as president. He continues with public behavior designed to offend; the content of what he has to say is unscripted and unpredictable. Trump has a need to humiliate; he has no regard for protocol, convention, or law. He contradicts his own statements and promises and exalts in his contentiousness toward the press. Trump uses Twitter to respond to anything that crosses his mind and has apologized for only one tweet: on April 18, 2014, he called on actress Kim Novak to sue her plastic surgeon for her face-lift—she felt bullied.
My first introduction to the phenomenon of Twitter being used for political gain was in Andre Nusselder’s “Twitter and the Personalization of Politics” (Psychoanalysis, Culture and Society, 18:1, 2012, 91-100). Nusselder described the tactics of populist Dutch politician Geert Wilders, who stood trial for “spreading hatred” by making statements regarding Islam. Wilders challenged the court by asserting through Twitter that the charges against him were politically motivated, calling The Hague “a place of backroom deals with no genuine interest in the people’s concerns.” The traditional route of the courts and allied institutions, including the press, he maintained, were not politically neutral. He succeeded in having his case retried by virtue of using social media to rouse public sentiment. What Nusselder discovered was that while the court system, television, and radio (the “old” media) controlled the ideological center of news making, the “new” social media, in turn, has become the perfect medium for “charismatic and populist leaders” tired of “traditional” and “elitist” methods of debate to solve disagreements.
Currently, 55% of Americans follow Twitter to gain access to current events and politics. With 140 characters, plus 20 to cover information regarding the author, a time and a response stamp, Twitter reflects our oral culture (versus writing sentences), which often focuses on small issues that reverberate with our emotions. On Twitter, style is expressed in spelling, punctuation, and an appeal mechanism that promotes fantasy, imitation, and identifica-
Page 21
tion. Twitter followers form tribes.
I believe that Trump’s tweeting is not just an idiosyncratic habit of his but an attempt (1) to establish the cult of the person and (2) to give himself and the voter the illusion of being able to participate in political discourse while not having to risk “face to face” discussion with a disagreeable opponent. Why does Trump continue to Tweet? Three possibilities, which are not mutually exclusive, cross my mind: (1) Trump must thrive on the confusion he creates, signified by the adaptation of a jagged signature which he proudly displays in executive orders; (2) Trump has realized that his use of social media embodies a break with the past by campaigning for people’s “real concerns,” the way Wilders used it in his own defense; and (3) Mr. Trump does not know what he does not know.
Looking at Donald Trump’s alarming behavior, it seems to me that he needs to continue battles pitched in emotional terms for an undecided voter and he seems to be obsessed with fixing aspects of victories that he has already won (like the issue of public attendance at his inauguration) by using what his counselor, Kellyanne Conway, called “alternative facts.” At the same time, he sets himself up for further unnecessary challenges so that his repetition compulsion might begin anew.
These tactics are symptomatic of Otto Kernberg’s observations that modern communications create a “mass psychology,” a tendency to sharply differentiate “what is good and what is bad; splitting the object world into idealized and persecutory figures, and creating a primitive morality […] with an intolerance for emotional depth.” He adds, “Mass psychology is a most powerful amplifier, both of paranoid ideologies and of leadership provided by narcissistic merchants of illusions or by the paranoid revolutionary” (Contemporary Controversies in Psychoanalytic Therapy Techniques and their Applications, 2004, 151-152). We need to pay attention to what is going on.
Page 22
How to cite this article
Stecker, F. (2017). Donald Trump’s tweets. Clio’s Psyche, 24(1), 19-22.



