Volume 28 - Number 1 - Fall 2021
Pages: 1 - 129

DAVID BEISEL FESTSCHRIFT ESSAYS IN HONOR OF DAVID R. BEISEL

Stein, H. F. (2021). David Beisel: A scholar’s scholar in psychohistory. In P. H. Elovitz, & N. D’Andria (Eds.), David Beisel festschrift. Clio’s Psyche, 28(1), 17-23.

https://doi.org/10.70763/25ef0d887bc7a2b30089a025618e1c62

David Beisel: A Scholar’s Scholar in Psychohistory

festschrift article

Abstract

This festschrift article is an appreciation of the psychohistorian David R. Beisel, written by a colleague who has known him since 1978 and is admiring of him as a historical scholar. The author characterizes Beisel’s work by its thoroughness, attention to detail, and insistence on exhaustive historical evidence before psychodynamic interpretation, and describes him as wary of psychohistorians who impose preferred clinical theory on a topic. As illustration, the author discusses Beisel’s research on the causes of World War II, presented at International Psychohistorical Association conventions through the 1990s and published as The Suicidal Embrace: Hitler, the Allies, and the Origins of the Second World War (2004). The author reports that Beisel examined nations, their leaders, citizens, the press, and political cartoons, and contends that he demonstrated unconscious fantasy and strong emotion, rather than rational self-interest, driving the path to war. The author situates this work within Lloyd deMause’s fantasy analysis, Kleinian and Bionian object relations theory, and family systems theory, and recounts Beisel’s treatment of Europe’s nations as a family acting out unconscious collusion, including the fate of Czechoslovakia. The author also mentions Beisel’s advocacy of poetry panels at IPA conventions and his editing of Wounded Centuries (2015). The author concludes that the integrity of Beisel’s scholarship gives his psychodynamic interpretations broad foundations, and expresses gratitude for his work and friendship.

Keywords:

David R. Beisel, festschrift, historical detective, International Psychohistorical Association (IPhA), political cartoons, psychodynamics, psychohistory, scholarship, teaching psychohistory, unconscious, World War II (WWII)

This brief essay honors the eminent psychohistorian David Beisel in one of his numerous major areas of contribution to the field of psychohistory: scholar. I have known him since 1978, first as a respected colleague, soon also as a cherished friend. As a founding member of the International Psychohistorical Association (IPA) and a renowned teacher of psychohistory to thousands of students, he has established and is an exemplar of standards of historical scholarship that inspire gratitude, awe, and emulation. To me, he is first and foremost a scholar’s scholar.

Note that I did not include the adjective “psychohistorical” in that descriptive phrase. Although Dr. Beisel is a widely-published and outstanding psychohistorian and has made innumerable presentations at psychohistorical conferences, psychohistory is the subject matter in which he is nonpareil. Yet my greater admiration is for his thoroughness, meticulousness, breadth and depth, integrity, respect for fact and perspective, keen eye and ear, and attentiveness to the tiniest (often overlooked or repressed by others) detail and to the large canvas as a scholar. His essence of style and stature would have been the same had he been an astronomer.

For him, there is no room in psychohistory or any other area of inquiry for sloppy thinking, cursory research, or those who prize hypothesis and theory over an exhaustive search for fact. To put it a different way: I believe that, for Dr. Beisel, one must first be a historical detective, then more broadly and deeply a psychohistorian—that is, a scholar who wonders and explores possible unconscious dimensions to historical processes and eras. In his distinguished company are George Kren, Rudolph Binion, Peter Loewenberg, Robert Jay Lifton, Jacques Szaluta, and Peter Petschauer, who are also renowned psychohistorical scholars of Nazi Germany and World War II as well as longtime IPA members.

I do not remember whether Dr. Beisel ever directly posed the question to fellow psychohistorians, “Where is the history in psychohistory?”, but he lived and worked as if that were implicitly always on his mind and directed his inquiry. I learned in part from him to ask: Where is your data? Dr. Beisel was as painstaking in questioning his own use of psychodynamic interpretation of history as he was (and remains) open to new historical data and perspectives. As long as I have known him, he has been wary of psychohistorians who are quick to apply (in the sense of imposing) pre-

Page 18

ferred clinical theory to any topic.

If psychohistory is defined as the inquiry into “the why of history,” that exploration of the “why” must be thoroughgoing both in historical research and in the judicious use of psychodynamic (or any other, such as Marxist or anthropological) interpretive framework. I illustrate this with the example of Beisel’s longitudinal psychohistorical study of the causes of World War II.

David Beisel has contributed to numerous topics within psychohistory. Here I address one in which his work is both distinguished and singular: the causes of World War II. Dr. Beisel had long realized that something essential was missing from earlier outstanding scholarship that had explored long-term historical, economic, political, leader-follower, demographic, and leadership personality accounts. He did not dismiss these but found their interpretations and explanations to be incomplete.

In developing his realization and painstaking demonstration of the enormous contribution of unconscious process in the inexorable—not accidental—cascading path to “the suicidal embrace” of World War II, he presented papers at the annual IPA convention year after year throughout the 1990s. Methodically, he discussed his research on one nation after another, their leaders and their life stories, their citizens, the press and its political cartoons, and the relationships between leaders, followers, and the peoples of other nations. From having attended these presentations, I can attest to their breadth and depth, the meticulousness of Beisel’s research, the clarity of his writing, and the logic of his rationale for including psychodynamic dimensions, without which any explanation of how and why World War II occurred would be incomplete.

Gifted in exploring language and visual art for cues to the work of the unconscious in history, Beisel paid close attention to metaphor and political cartoons (e.g., David Low) as a “royal road to group unconscious processes” in the cascade to World War II, just as Freud had first used the image of the “royal road” to reveal the unconscious in dreams. For Beisel, political metaphors and cartoons are no mere turn of phrase, gratuitous, or inconsequential, but should be taken seriously, if not urgently, as keys to what life is really about. I wonder whether Beisel’s attunement to the depths of language at least in part underlays his advocacy of poetry-of-history presentations and panels at IPA conventions in the 2010s and his editing a book of psychohistorical poetry, Wounded Centuries: A

Page 19

 Selection of Poems (2015).

Beisel has spent his entire professional life working within an American cultural climate long steeped in the “rational man”-based decision-making model that permeates academia (from economics to history), business, and even international relations and diplomacy. This cognitive, intellectual(-ized) model has no place for unruly fantasy or emotion, which wreaks havoc on algorithmic logic. Yet Beisel found these essential to understanding how and why history is “made.” In The Suicidal Embrace: Hitler, the Allies, and the Origins of the Second World War (2004), he demonstrated how conscious and unconscious fantasy and strong emotion heavily influenced the political and cultural life of large groups such as nations, leader-follower relationships, and international relations. Passions, not reason, drove the fateful cascade into World War II. The Pied Piper of Nazi Germany lured his frightened people into unquestioning loyalty and obedience because they desperately wished to believe in him.

Before going further into Beisel’s study of the causes of World War II, I must take a moment here to locate Dr. Beisel’s thoughts and works on World War II within the historical ambiance of the early and subsequent years of people and thinking in the International Psychohistorical Association (founded in 1977 by Lloyd deMause, David Beisel, Paul Elovitz, and Henry Lawton, among others); its predecessor and for a while parallel group, The Institute for Psychohistory; the scholarly and theoretical contributions of Lloyd deMause, who founded and led both groups and their journal, The History of Childhood Quarterly (later changed to The Journal of Psychohistory); and the emergence of The Psychohistory Forum and its journal, Clio’s Psyche. This foray into his milieu is not a detour from Beisel and his enormous contributions but rather locates him in space and time.

From the outset, Lloyd deMause recognized, documented, and emphasized the central role of infanticide and child abuse in human history and its interplay with unconscious dimensions in caregiver-baby relationships, the child’s personality development, and their influence on all aspects of the adult’s life. That is to say, the enactment of the parental unconscious in childrearing. Much of his interest and writing were on the parent-child relationship, specifically the process and consequences of parents’ unconscious projection of hateful, murderous wishes fantasized onto and into their baby. One fatal form this took was the widespread killing of one’s

Page 20

baby/child (infanticide), that is, killing one’s own intolerable “bad” parts of self by first thrusting them onto the baby and then killing the baby to magically erase one’s badness.

As a closely related methodological and empirical instrument for discovering psychohistorical data of child abuse and murder, deMause and others developed a technique he called “fantasy analysis” to explore metaphors of these in ordinary political processes. It was used to analyze political cartoons and politicians’ speeches to reveal unconscious levels embedded in conscious language and images. In deMause’s work, then, the “direction” of the projection was from the parenting caregiver to the infant and, later, onto society. The baby was the original container for the projections of terror and rage. Beisel cautiously, effectively, and sparingly applied fantasy analysis.

Lloyd deMause and many fellow psychohistorians were also influenced by the theories of Melanie Klein and by what became known as the “object relations” school of psychoanalysis for their potential interpretive and explanatory value for psychohistorians. Klein’s concept of “projective identification” recognized how human relationships are intersubjective (unconscious to another unconscious). Bion took Klein’s work further, arguing that three types of ad hoc therapy group dynamics were driven not by reality or ostensible tasks but rather by unconscious “basic assumptions” that became the “reality” that shaped their members’ decisions and actions.

A third and complementary psychodynamic framework emerged among psychohistorians, like Beisel, who were influenced by certain family systems theorists and therapists. These theorists and clinicians explored unconscious influences in nuclear and extended family relationships, including parent-infant/childrearing and their consequences for personality development and adult life—and in turn, for the making of culture and history. One such person was Helm Stierlin, who wrote Psychoanalysis and Family Therapy (1977) as well as an influential book on Hitler in the context of his early family life, Adolf Hitler: A Family Perspective (1976). Obviously, Bion’s ad hoc therapy groups of strangers differed greatly from the intimacy and seething cauldron of lived daily family life. Yet, both frameworks included the central role of such defensive processes as denial, splitting, projection, projective identification, and introjection in regulating human relationships, useful instruments in psychohistorical research into large groups such as

Page 21

ethnic groups, religions, and nations.

David Beisel was steeped in this atmosphere in the psychohistorical institutions he became closely affiliated with and in the journals that published the work of psychohistorians, including many of his own papers. Early in his work on understanding the origins of World War II, he took seriously the metaphorical phrase “the family of nations,” long used in describing European history. Soon followed his interest in seeing what psychodynamically-informed family systems theory and family therapy might contribute to understanding how World War II came about.

Nothing was what it seemed. In Europe during the 1920s and 1930s, nations and their leaders did not lead and make decisions based on rational self-interest and reality but instead based on emotion, fantasy, and life plans shaped by repressed childhood experiences. Nations became human bodies that embodied members of an extended family who acted out unconsciously intentional “mistakes” in international relations. Reciprocal projections governed policy-making.

Just as in families in which members unconsciously collude in, say, the targeting of a family member who became a drug addict and eventually committed suicide through an overdose of medicine (e.g., John Zinner and Roger Shapiro, “Projective Identification as a Mode of Perception and Behaviour in Families of Adolescents,” International Journal of Psycho-Analysis, Vol. 53, 1972, 523-530), leaders and nations’ members unconsciously colluded to bring about inexorable war. Paradoxically and tragically, while all the nations in this “family” consciously prided themselves on their distinctness and idealized history, at the unconscious level they were inseparably fused in a magical matrix of denial, splitting, projective identification, fantasy, and acting out.

With unconscious fantasy serving as much of his lived reality, Hitler repeatedly overruled his generals’ advice and military strategies, governed less by reality than by grandiose fantasies that would restage old humiliations and defeats (e.g., beatings from his father), avenge them, and reverse them. Hitler was a catastrophic military strategist and unconsciously sent his beloved German youth to their death on military missions his generals dared not defy. “Hitler is Germany! And Germany is Hitler,” his propagandists shrieked. Hitler’s will was theirs, and his followers identified with him through the prism of their own lives, following him to self-

Page 22

destruction, convinced that victory was theirs.

The fate of Czechoslovakia was perhaps the tragic “masterpiece” of this irrational family therapy. A newborn nation created out of the rubble of the Austro-Hungarian Empire at the end of World War I, the family of nations, with Hitler presiding, performed a ritual infanticide of Czechoslovakia. The baby nation was killed as a sacrifice to “cure” and “save” Europe—but only temporarily. While the mask of this process was considered rational decision-making, the true, underlying face was irrational, unconscious acting out.

In this brief essay, I have focused on one dimension of David Beisel’s many contributions to psychohistory, including his helping to found the field. For me, Beisel’s scholarship—in any topic he chooses—is second to none. Because of the integrity of his scholarship, his psychodynamic interpretations of historical processes and eras are edifices built on broad and deep foundations. I am beyond grateful for his thinking and his enduring friendship.

Page 23

About the author

Howard F. Stein

Howard F. Stein, PhD, Professor Emeritus in the Department of Family and Preventive Medicine and University of Oklahoma Health Sciences Center, has contributed many poems and articles to the Journal of Psychohistory, Clio’s Psyche, and many other print and online literary journals/magazines over many years. He authored 32 books, including recently two of poetry, as well as The Psychodynamics of Toxic Organizations: Poetry, Stories, Analysis (2020), which he co-authored with Seth Allcorn. Dr. Stein may be contacted at .

How to cite this article

Stein, H. F. (2021). David Beisel: A scholar’s scholar in psychohistory. In P. H. Elovitz, & N. D’Andria (Eds.), David Beisel festschrift. Clio’s Psyche, 28(1), 17-23.

https://doi.org/10.70763/25ef0d887bc7a2b30089a025618e1c62

PDF downloads