Volume 21 - Number 3 - December 2014
Pages: 245 - 361

SYMPOSIUM: ARE WE MORE OR LESS CIVILIZED?

Stern, C. (2014). Enlightenment ideals in our present? Our future? Clio’s Psyche, 21(3), 295-298.

https://doi.org/10.70763/5b5e6cc50cefa5e9f1f5ca272b136475

Enlightenment Ideals in Our Present? Our Future?

response article

Abstract

In this response to the symposium “Are We More or Less Civilized?”, the author replies to Paul H. Elovitz’s “Reflections on Why Humans Are Better Off, More Civilized, and Possibly More Anxious” and Ken Fuchsman’s “The Complexities of Being Civilized.” She draws on a Psychohistory Forum meeting on the topic and on her experience teaching Western civilization and American history. She agrees with Elovitz and Steven Pinker that Enlightenment ideals have contributed to a civilizing process that has made life kinder and less violent for many people in the West, citing Thomas Paine’s The Age of Reason, Voltaire’s Treatise on Tolerance and Candide, and John Locke’s Some Thoughts Concerning Education. She then maintains that these ideals are unevenly held in the United States. As examples she names resistance to climate science, conservative efforts to declare the country Christian and to promote a triumphal account of its history, and news reports of violence against women and children by professional football players. She reports Henry A. Giroux’s argument in The Violence of Organized Forgetting that hostility to intellectual inquiry serves a small corporate elite. She also cites Thomas Homer-Dixon and Michael Klare on environmental scarcity and resource wars, and concludes that scarcity may make civilized choices harder even for civil people. She expresses concern that some people are uninterested in reflection.

Keywords:

American history, civilization, Clio’s Psyche, history, human civilization, Ken Fuchsman, Paul H. Elovitz, psychohistory, Psychohistory Forum, Thomas Paine, The Training Institute for Mental Health in New York City, Voltaire, Western Civilizations

I recently had the pleasure of attending the Psychohistory Forum meeting dedicated to the topic of “Are We More or Less Civilized?” The three and a half hour program, held at the offices of The Training Institute for Mental Health in New York City, featured a lively discussion of the perspectives offered by Paul H. Elovitz and Ken A. Fuchsman in their respective articles featured in this issue of Clio’s Psyche. The participants at the Forum included a mix of historians and psychoanalysts, and the resulting discussion was at all times informed, thoughtful, erudite, and highly engaging. The event was a genuine pleasure, one of the more intellectually rich experiences I’ve enjoyed in a 20 year academic career. As a trained Europeanist who regularly teaches courses in Western Civilizations and American History, I wish to contribute the following thoughts to the discussion.

Every semester I share with students the ideas of Thomas Paine, Voltaire, and Cesare Beccaria, among other Enlightenment thinkers, and I agree wholeheartedly with both Paul Elovitz and Steven Pinker that the Enlightenment-inspired ideals have played a role in the civilizing process to create a kinder, less violent, and more enjoyably productive life for many people within the Western world. Even after 20 years of teaching this history, I still feel a palpable sense of exhilaration as the students and I read from such classic Enlightenment texts as Paine’s The Age of Reason (1794) and John Locke’s Some Thoughts Concerning Education (1693). Particularly satisfying is Paine’s injunction to “make our fellow-creatures happy” by “doing justice” and “loving mercy.” His reference to “fellow-creatures,” rather than simply humans, is also intriguing as it seems that he may have included animals in his world view.

Other passages that prompt a similar response, both in me and often in many students, include Voltaire’s plea for religious tolerance in Treatise on Tolerance (1763), along with his critiques in Candide (1759) and elsewhere of battlefield carnage, and

Page 295

Locke’s recommendation to adults that they model the virtues of restraint, civility, and compassion so that children will develop into adults who are reasonable and even-tempered. These Enlightenment-based guidelines aimed at fostering a gentler interpersonal ethos were interwoven intricately, as noted by some historians, with a broader set of revolutionary political goals: to question absolutist authority; to challenge the persecuting regimes of European monarchies; and to create the framework of democratizing changes that benefit so many of us in the Western world.

Yet, as I write this, I am reminded with great sadness that even the Western world—and perhaps most particularly its visible superpower—is not uniformly a haven of shared Enlightenment values. Current debates over climate change (and especially resistance to scientific findings), along with continued conservative efforts to proclaim the United States a “Christian country” and to “sanitize” American history to uphold an idealized triumphalist narrative that downplays analysis or dissent, are just a few examples of a problematic tendency by some Americans to reject the importance of rational thought or serious reflection. These examples also underscore the extent to which some contemporary individuals outright assail, deny, or remain ignorant of various key Enlightenment precepts.

A proud embrace of “willful ignorance” is, I believe, a serious concern for both historians and psychoanalysts alike. Without a willingness to engage in sustained reflection, whether of society or self, there can be little hope for the prospect of civilized life or meaningful change in its direction. In a provocative new book titled The Violence of Organized Forgetting: Thinking Beyond America’s Disimagination Machine (2014) theorist Henry A. Giroux reminds us that the contemporary anti-intellectual stance found in many quarters of U.S. culture functions in a way that facilitates the goals of a tiny corporate elite at the expense of the general public and particularly its most vulnerable members. Violence-based entertainment, he posits, parallels an ethos of cruelty that manifests in contemporary political rhetoric to justify policies that deny such necessities as food, shelter, and medicine to our society’s elderly, indigent, unemployed, or chronically ill.

Material scarcities further exacerbate the conundrum. I be-

Page 296

come especially concerned as I think about the projections of such scholars as Thomas Homer-Dixon and Michael Klare, who remind us that environmental issues are matters of war and peace (see Homer-Dixon, Environmental Scarcity and Global Security, 1993) and that looming “resource wars” will likely mean that future populations will experience conflict over access to finite quantities of oil, water, and other physical items (Klare, Resource Wars: The New Landscape of Global Conflict, 2002). No matter how non-violent, reasonable, and “civil” one is, a lack of such necessities as potable water will create a pressurized context that may render it increasingly difficult for many humans to choose a civilized course of action.

To conclude on a very personal note, as a Manhattan woman with a PhD and a secular Catholic woman married for almost three decades to a secular Jewish man, I know and appreciate deeply the extent to which I am a beneficiary of the West’s most vital Enlightenment ideals. On a daily basis, I walk freely and without fear in a milieu that is progressive, creative, gay-friendly, religiously tolerant, art-filled, book laden, culturally dynamic, and, in my own personal privileged experience, free of interpersonal violence. Yet I also know that my little haven in New York City is not emblematic of a broader global or even national picture. I am reminded of this with great sadness as I follow the news reports of current events. As I write this in the last week of September 2014, I am particularly saddened by the absolutely sickening reports of National Football League players abusing women and viciously beating their children, along with vehement statements by some fellow football players in support of such actions as the brutal whipping of a four-year-old child. That any of these grown men may be a hero to other Americans is truly a sobering prospect. Most frightening to me is that there seem to be some humans, even in today’s Western world, who have little interest in either the process of reflection or in seeking the “better angels” of their nature.

Page 297

About the author

Christina Stern

Christina Stern, PhD, is a professor at SUNY Rockland. Her research interests include medieval European history, women, and Catholicism and the history of Jewish and Christian relationships in the West. She can be reached at .

How to cite this article

Stern, C. (2014). Enlightenment ideals in our present? Our future? Clio’s Psyche, 21(3), 295-298.

https://doi.org/10.70763/5b5e6cc50cefa5e9f1f5ca272b136475

PDF downloads