
Volume 05 - Number 3 - December 1998
Pages: 69 - 119
Turken, H. (1998). The rescuer self in the Holocaust [Meeting Report]. Clio’s Psyche, 5(3), 114-115.
The Rescuer Self in the Holocaust
Abstract
This meeting report summarizes the Psychohistory Forum’s overflow meeting titled “Rescuer Self in the Holocaust” (September 19, 1998), featuring Dr. Eva Fogelman’s research on what enables individuals to undertake high-risk rescue during the German occupation. It distinguishes rescuing from resistance, describes the practical dangers and concealment demands (including effects on rescuers’ children), and outlines recurrent motives and traits associated with rescuers-moral conviction, identification with victims, tolerance for difference, and action-oriented fear management-illustrated through discussion of Raoul Wallenberg and postwar recognition and trauma.
Adolf Hitler, Eva Fogelman, German occupation, group efforts, Holocaust, meeting report, psychohistory, Psychohistory Forum, rescuer self, World War II (WWII)
The “Rescuer Self in the Holocaust” was the challenging subject of the overflow September 19, 1998 meeting of the Psychohistory Forum. Dr. Eva Fogelman shared with us her detailed research into the components of the rescuer’s self, and many participants asked intriguing questions on a subject that is important but often neglected.
The focus of Dr. Fogelman’s research was on the first act of rescuing and on the postwar effects on the surviving rescuers, particularly as it affected the children. A distinction was made between resistance and rescuing: rescuing implies activities to help another individual survive at great self-risk, acts of resistance imply group efforts to get rid of the German occupation.
Rescuers faced extreme dangers to themselves and to their families. People were turned in for a bag of sugar or a bottle of vodka. In Poland, death sentences were given to anyone seen talking to or aiding a Jew. Neighbors knew everyone living in every house; a flushed toilet in an apartment when people were known to be at work could give everyone away, as could sickness, babies born while in hiding, and ration cards. Rescuers’ children were no longer able to invite their friends over and became targets of physical abuse by other children.
How did rescuers manage to help without arousing suspicion? To maintain camouflage and concealment, everyone had to become an accomplished actor. Relatives were invented—cousins, aunts, and uncles. Children, who aroused less suspicion, were often used as transports. Being a rescuer became a full time occupation.
Rescuers were not the most religious, richest, or most educated, nor the ones with the most resources. Nor was gender a factor. The decision to be a rescuer was made at an emotional, cognitive, and religious level. It was based on 1) moral grounds, 2) identification with the victim and/or their Jewishness, or 3) professional and group concerns. One type, the moral rescuer, when asked to help, had a strong sense of right or wrong, a sense that another person would die if they did nothing. Those with a strong identification with the victim and their Jewishness had a very early awareness of the danger to the Jews and helped get them out of peril very early. They made use of group efforts that jointly had set up mechanisms that allowed them to move quickly into action. When needed, they supplied housing, identification cards, etc., for places like Spain and Switzerland.
The outstanding personality attribute of the rescuer involved their ability to figure out that they could do something about it, that it was their
Page 114
responsibility, and that they had resources they could put into action. Other factors were their spirituality, their greater capacity to manage their fear through action, their sense of independence (“I can do it without support”), and their tolerance for people who were different. Of the people interviewed, 80% had an altruistic role model for helping people in distress and 80% had a high tolerance for difference. They came from loving homes where they were disciplined through explanation of what they were doing wrong rather than by punishment. They did not fear authority. They were able to make decisions for themselves. Their sense of independence was praised as well as their sense of competence. Many had a loss or an illness in childhood and subsequently could empathize out of their own sense of vulnerability and experience of having been helped.
Raoul Wallenburg embodied many of these qualities. Wallenburg’s father died before he was born and his grandfather became his role model. In letters to Raoul, his grandfather wrote that he wished him to become a useful member of society, to be able to stand on his own two feet, and to be a leader. Raoul was to develop diligence and a familiarity with other people, always with diplomacy and tact. Other factors contributing to Wallenburg’s ability to carry out the task of rescuer were his sense of adventure and risk taking (e.g., hitchhiking), and his familiarity with Jewish culture and Hungary from his business trips to Israel and Hungary while working for a Jewish business man. In Switzerland he had first hand knowledge of what was going on in Germany from German Jews who escaped. Having been asked to go to Hungary, he accepted and showed no fear, even under dire circumstances. He was defiant of authority, even in the face of threats to his life by the German authorities and by the impending Russian advance into Hungary.
It was debated if Wallenburg, having been left out of the family’s banking business, saw this opportunity as a means to demonstrate to them that he could take on a big organizational operation and be successful at it. Dr. Fogelman reiterated that Wallenburg accepted the task out of altruism and out of his strong feelings for the plight of the Jews. His grandfather had groomed him to do great things and it was his identification with his grandfather that influenced him in the decision to get involved.
There were questions as to why rescuers were not given more recognition after the war and why it has taken so long to get it. (Holland did acknowledge and provide special welfare benefits to those known to have helped.) Rescuers did not want to be written about or maintain a connection with those they rescued because even after the war they continued to be in danger; some were even killed. In the case of rescued children, attachments had to be given up; the rescuers needed time to overcome the sense of loss. Jews and rescuers attempted to leave it all behind them. Rescuers suffered from post-traumatic stress syndrome, but it was not attributed to their role as rescuers since there were no groups or forums in which to speak about it.
Page 115
How to cite this article
Turken, H. (1998). The rescuer self in the Holocaust [Meeting Report]. Clio’s Psyche, 5(3), 114-115.



