Volume 15 - Number 1 - June 2008
Pages: 1 - 54

LETTERS TO THE EDITOR

Unger, N. C. (2008). Gender, race, and money in the election [Letter to the Editor]. Clio’s Psyche, 15(1), 47-48.

https://doi.org/10.70763/f900afc719d7d86bd7d17b9d3be0aafe

Gender, Race, and Money in the Election

letter to the editor

Abstract

In this letter to the editor, the author replies to an e-mail discussion with the editor about gender in the primary season, agreeing that the media shows little interest in the question of gender. She objects to debates over whether people of color or women are more oppressed and criticizes a remark that sexism has never killed anyone while racism has. She cites the heckling of Hillary Clinton with a demand to iron a shirt, and John McCain’s amused response to a question about how to beat Clinton. She contends that comparable remarks aimed at Barack Obama would have drawn outrage, and she maintains that the United States is more willing to discuss racism than sexism. In a second part, responding to an exchange between the editor and another correspondent, she disputes the argument that the side spending most wins California initiatives and referendums. She cites her essay with Marie Bolton on environmental propositions in La Californie: Périphérie ou laboratoire?, “The Case for Cautious Optimism: California Environmental Propositions in the Late Twentieth Century,” in which oil interests outspent environmental groups.

Keywords:

election, gender, letter to the editor, media, oppression, politics, psychohistory, race, racism, sexism

Dear Editor,

In our e-mail discussion of gender unfolding in this primary season, I think you were exactly right when you said that, “The media has almost no interest in the question of gender.” I have heard, however, a few “who’s more oppressed, people of color or women?” debates. I didn’t even realize we were in a contest! The remark I found most

Page 47

ignorant—and irritating—was “sexism has never killed anyone, but racism has.”

I agree with the pundits who pointed out that when Clinton was heckled with “Iron my shirt!” there was none of the outrage that would have followed someone shouting at Obama, “Shine my shoes!” Similarly, when McCain was asked, “How do we beat the bitch?” he chuckled before answering, something he would not have done if someone had asked, “How do we beat the nigger?”

The media’s far greater attention to gender greatly annoys, but does not surprise me. This nation is far more willing to own up to (or at least discuss) its racism than its sexism.

Speaking of politics, I enjoyed your exchange with David Lotto, especially your very candid final assessment. I fight this “money is political power” argument all the time here in California, where people frequently claim that initiatives and referendums always favor whichever campaign spent the most money. My French colleague Marie Bolton and I did a study of environmental initiatives in which Big Oil dramatically outspent various Green groups. The results are suggested by the title of our essay: “The Case for Cautious Optimism: California Environmental Propositions in the Late Twentieth Century,” La Californie: Périphérie ou laboratoire?, Annick Foucrier and Antoine Coppolani, eds., 2004, pp. 81-102. I wish David Lotto would read it.

Sincerely yours,

Nancy C. Unger

Page 48

About the author

Nancy C. Unger

Nancy C. Unger, PhD, is Professor of History at Santa Clara University, specializing in the Gilded Age and Progressive Era. She is the author of many scholarly articles and essays as well as two award-winning biographies. Her Beyond Nature’s Housekeepers: American Women in Environmental History (2012) was short-listed for the California Book Award. She served on the editorial board of this journal and has been featured on C-SPAN and PBS, and her op-eds have appeared in venues including CNN, Time, and the Washington Post. She can be contacted at .

How to cite this article

Unger, N. C. (2008). Gender, race, and money in the election [Letter to the Editor]. Clio’s Psyche, 15(1), 47-48.

https://doi.org/10.70763/f900afc719d7d86bd7d17b9d3be0aafe

PDF downloads