Volume 12 - Number 2 - September 2005
Pages: 37 - 111

MISCELLANEOUS ARTICLES

Victor, G. (2005). The Sin Against the Blood, Hitler, and the Holocaust. Clio’s Psyche, 12(2), 37, 48-49.

https://doi.org/10.70763/ba3c736667394d5082f86f28aef38107

The Sin Against the Blood, Hitler, and the Holocaust

article

Abstract

This article concerns Artur Dinter (1876–1948), a German writer and Nazi Party official whom the author contends was the man who most influenced Adolf Hitler’s decision to exterminate the Jews. The author faults studies of that decision for citing Arthur de Gobineau, Houston Stewart Chamberlain, and Theodor Fritsch while omitting or barely mentioning Dinter. Because no full biography of Dinter exists, the author draws on a dozen articles and brief mentions in books, along with passages from Mein Kampf and Der Stürmer. The author recounts Dinter’s breakdown in 1917 and his unfounded suspicion, rejected by a court, that his wife had been unfaithful. The author then describes Dinter’s autobiographical novel The Sin Against the Blood, which held that an Aryan woman impregnated once by a Jew could never bear Aryan children. The author links this claim to telegony, an unverified late nineteenth-century belief reported by animal breeders. The article reports the novel’s popularity after World War I, Dinter’s leadership in Thuringia, and his expulsion from the Party in 1928 after disputes over religion. It also reports Julius Streicher’s promotion of the thesis in Der Stürmer. The author contends that Hitler implemented Dinter’s proposals after 1933 through marriage restrictions, the Nuremberg Laws of 1935, and sterilization programs, including failed secret methods aimed at part-Jews. The author concludes that the failure of legal control and sterilization led Hitler to decide to kill all Jews as the only way to prevent what he saw as the pollution of Aryan blood.

Keywords:

Adolf Hitler, Arthur de Gobineau, anti-Semitism, Artur Dinter, Charles Darwin, Holocaust, Houston Stewart Chamberlain, origins, psychohistory, The Sin Against the Blood, telegony, Theodor Fritsch

Many studies of the origins of Adolf Hitler’s decision to exterminate Jews cite internationally known books by the racists Arthur de Gobineau and Houston Stewart Chamberlain, and books by prominent German anti-Semites—notably Theodor Fritsch. However, they omit or barely mention the man who most influenced Hitler: Artur Dinter who, ironically, remains little-known in the United States.

Page 37

During the late nineteenth century, animal breeders reported an imagined phenomenon called telegony. If a superior mare, for example, was bred just once to an inferior stallion, she was biologically rendered permanently incapable of bearing superior foals. Anecdotal reports of telegony came to the attention of Charles Darwin and other scientists, who published them without verification.

Artur Dinter (1876-1948) was a scientist, fanatical theologian, novelist, playwright, and drama critic— probably a genius. There is no full biography of him; the following is based on a dozen articles and brief mentions in books, of which the most detailed is “Race and Spirituality: Arthur Dinter’s Theosophical Antisemitism” by George Kren and Rodler Morris (Holocaust and Genocide Studies, 1991, Vol. 6 #4) . In 1917, Dinter suffered a mental breakdown, prompted by a war injury, disease, and his belief that his wife had taken a Jewish lover, and had a child by him while he served at the front. Dinter regained a measure of sanity by hastily writing The Sin Against the Blood, an autobiographical novel in which his suspicions of his wife’s infidelity were a crucial element. After release from the hospital, he sued his wife for divorce, citing the alleged affair. The court found his accusations to be unwarranted and found for her, awarding her a divorce on the grounds of his marital infidelities.

His thesis, for which he claimed authority by virtue of his expertise in zoology and botany, was that an Aryan woman, once impregnated by a Jew, was rendered permanently incapable of bearing Aryan children. Dinter alleges that Jews were aware of this and therefore systematically tried to seduce and rape as many Aryan women and girls as they could and to impregnate them. By ruining them as breeders, Jews were wiping out the Aryan race. The “sin” was pollution of Aryan blood by mixed mating. To convince readers, Dinter devoted a fifth of his novel to scholarly notes.

During Germany’s fearful chaos after World War I, The Sin Against the Blood was an enormous bestseller with its erroneous thesis treated as scientific fact, especially by the Nazis. A few years after its publication, its author joined the newly founded Nazi Party. Hitler was impressed with Artur Dinter, making him the political leader of the large, important district of Thuringia. Hitler also made Dinter’s ideas a central thesis of Mein Kampf, as in, “The sin against the blood and the race is the hereditary sin of this world and the end of any race that yields to it” (Emphasis in original).

Seemingly, Dinter found his niche in the Nazi Party, but he was a provocative, litigious person whose zeal had gotten him into trouble before. As a Nazi leader, his religious statements offended not only Jews but also Catholics and Protestants, costing the Party votes. His disregard of Hitler’s orders to drop religion from his official speeches and pamphlets resulted in removal from his position. When he challenged Hitler over his removal, Hitler expelled him from the Party in 1928. From then until his death, except for publishing his own translation of the New Testament, Dinter withdrew from public life. Perhaps because Lamarckian theories of evolution became more popular at this time, his thesis that women were changed biologically by experience and they passed the change on through their children, grew in influence.

Julius Streicher, publisher of the Nazi newspaper Der Stürmer, was quite impressed with it. Week-after-week, Streicher featured “news” stories in support of Dinter’s warning. They consisted of unverified anecdotes sent in by readers and of items fabricated by staff writers, sometimes illustrated by retouched photos of deformed monsters produced by mixed matings. Streicher extended Dinter’s thesis in a Stürmer article, stating that “for those in the know, these are established facts… the seed of a man of another race is a ‘foreign protein.’ During copulation the seed is, in part or in whole, absorbed by the woman’s fertile body and thus passes into the blood.” Furthermore, “a single act of intercourse between a Jew and an Aryan woman is sufficient to pollute her forever. She can never again give birth to pure-blooded Aryan children.” Streicher added, “Now we know why the Jew uses every artifice of seduc-

Page 48

tion in order to ravish German girls at as early an age as possible, why the Jewish doctor rapes his female patients while they are under anesthesia” (Quoted from Der Stürmer [1935] in Randall Bytwerk, Julius Streicher [NY: Stein and Day, 1983], p. 148).

At the end of The Sin Against the Blood, Dinter had proposed government regulation of marital choices and sexual acts, and suggested that Jews who had affairs with Aryan women be killed. On becoming German chancellor in 1933, Hitler began to implement Dinter’s proposals. He immediately used his influence to have officials deny marriage licenses to Jewish-Aryan couples. He appointed geneticists to recommend policies as to who should be encouraged or allowed to have children, who should be discouraged, and who should be prevented. In addition, he had judges study legal controls to be enacted.

In 1935, Hitler was ready and announced The Law for the Protection of German Blood and German Honor (better-known as the Nuremberg Laws), which prohibited marriage between Jews and Aryans. It also stripped Jews of citizenship, thereby making them legally helpless against measures to come. The Nuremberg Laws were followed by a wave of regulations against marriage and intercourse between Jews and Aryans. Jewish men were prosecuted—and even executed—for only looking at Aryan women or girls.

Then Hitler went beyond prohibition and punishment to physical prevention. A largely secret program of involuntary sterilization, outwardly intended to control hereditary disease, was directed against Jews. Public discovery and protest of sterilization led to a fully secret project in which physicians experimented with methods of sterilizing people without their awareness. While Germany’s half million Jews had no legal recourse against sterilization, the intended targets of surreptitious sterilization were those who were part-Jews—an estimated three million citizens who still had legal protection.

The project failed because sterility-inducing X-rays left external lesions, risking exposure of surreptitious sterilization. Other methods such as an undetectable chemical (caladium seguinum) that caused sterility, derived from a South American plant, was unobtainable in sufficient quantity after the start of World War II. Also, efforts to synthesize caladium seguinum failed. In the end, failure of legal control of sex and marriage and of sterilization influenced Hitler’s decision to kill all Jews as the only way to prevent pollution of Aryan blood and consequent destruction of the Aryan race.

Page 49

About the author

George Victor

George Victor, PhD, was educated at Columbia, Harvard, and NY universities. He is a retired psychologist and Psychohistory Forum Research Associate who lives in West Orange, New Jersey. Among his publications are Invisible Men: Faces of Alienation and The Riddle of Autism. This article is based upon his book Hitler: the Pathology of Evil (1998) and on his research for a book in progress on religious fundamentalism and genocide. Dr. Victor may be contacted at .

How to cite this article

Victor, G. (2005). The Sin Against the Blood, Hitler, and the Holocaust. Clio’s Psyche, 12(2), 37, 48-49.

https://doi.org/10.70763/ba3c736667394d5082f86f28aef38107

PDF downloads