Volume 24 - Number 3 - Spring 2018
Pages: 253 - 371

THE PSYCHOHISTORY OF DEPENDENCY AND AUTONOMY
SYMPOSIUM

West, M. I. (2018). Infant depravity in children’s literature in Puritan America. Clio’s Psyche, 24(3), 339-345.

https://doi.org/10.70763/577fd60255d4bb0f466464849ffe6d8e

Infant Depravity in Children’s Literature in Puritan America

article

Abstract

Early American education by Puritans was based on the concept of infant depravity, or the innate sinfulness of humanity. The texts created for education reflected this, as seen in The New England Primer and The Prodigal Daughter. The New England Primer was the first American text created exclusively to educate children and The Prodigal Daughter was the first work of fiction created for American children. In contrast, today’s education is based on the concept of innocent childhood, which came to popularity in the 19th century.

Keywords:

childhood, cultural influences, infant depravity, John Calvin, The New England Primer, pedagogical approaches, The Prodigal Daughter, psychohistory, Puritan America, Puritan education, religious beliefs

Childhood is as much a social construction, or a set of related ideas, as it is a span of years in the life of a human being. Some of these ideas stem from religious beliefs, while some grow out of political or economic developments. Others reflect cultural or scientific movements. Often ideas about childhood are so deeply embedded within particular cultures that they are simply taken for granted by them. Philosophies of education and pedagogical approaches are, at their foundation, often premised on commonly held ideas about childhood.

Page 339

Researchers working within the field of education may not be consciously aware that the social construction of childhood influences their research, but in reality researching nearly any topic related to education is inextricably bound to the ideas that frame our thinking about childhood and the place of children in society. Studying the history of childhood can provide education researchers with insights into how concepts related to childhood often influence educational systems and approaches. It is often easier to understand such dynamics when we focus on historical ideas about childhood for the simple reason that we can take a more distant and perhaps more objective view of such dynamics when we do not feel obligated to uphold current paradigms related to childhood. The Puritan concept of infant depravity is an example of an idea from the past that, while no longer accepted, can still help us understand how such concepts influence educational systems and philosophies.

The Puritans played a dominant role in America from the 1630s, when the first wave of Puritans moved to New England, until the mid-1700s, when other immigrant groups began outnumbering the Puritans. During the Puritan period in American history, many of the leading figures in New England believed in the concept of infant depravity, and this belief strongly influenced their approach to education. Drawing on the writings of John Calvin, these Puritan leaders believed that all people, including newborn infants, were innately sinful. They maintained that it was the duty of parents and teachers to suppress children’s sinful inclinations. They also believed that everyone within their community needed to have a one-to-one relationship with God by reading the Bible. The Puritans’ concept of infant depravity and their emphasis on promoting literacy can be seen in their approach to education. It not only led them to create a school system, but it also resulted in the writing and publishing of didactic children’s literature (Michael Zuckerman, Peaceable Kingdom: New England in the Eighteenth Century, 1970).

Initially, the Puritan leaders in America assumed that parents would take on the responsibility of teaching their children how to read the Bible, but it soon became evident that this assumption was misguided. For many Puritan parents, the simple struggle to survive in the New World consumed so much time and energy that they were unable to devote the time necessary to teach their children basic literacy skills. In response to this situation, the General Court of the Massachusetts Bay Colony decreed in 1647 that every

Page 340

town of 50 families or more should build and support a school where all of the children in the town would be taught how to read the Bible and receive basic information about their Calvinist religion.

The development of the Puritan school system led to the creation of curricular materials to be used in these schools. The most important of these textbooks was The New England Primer. First published in Boston around 1687, The New England Primer was used in American schools until the late 1700s. The earliest surviving edition was published in 1727, but it is clear that the book went through countless editions over the years. The contents of the book changed somewhat from one edition to another, but it always included a picture alphabet with simple rhymes that children were expected to memorize. In addition to teaching the alphabet, these rhymes also conveyed religious lessons. As the first two rhymes demonstrate, these lessons reflected the Puritans’ preoccupation with original sin:

In Adam’s fall
We sinned all.
Thy life to mend
God’s Book attend (Virginia Haviland and Margaret N. Coughlan, eds., Yankee Doodle’s Literary Sampler of Prose, Poetry, and Pictures, 1974, 21).

The New England Primer also included a catechism, religious maxims, prayers, and religious verses. In his scholarly analysis of the existing editions of The New England Primer, David H. Watters argues that Calvinistic theology permeates the entire contents of this textbook. As Watters makes clear, the concept of infant depravity is at the core of The New England Primer:

The root metaphors of Calvinist theology operate in the Primer to define the child’s being in terms of human disobedience to God’s authority, God is an angry father whose “children,” Adam and Eve, have disobeyed him; all children are guilty of and deserve punishment for desires that run contrary to parental or divine will. The child learns that one’s self is bounded by creators who gave life but also restrict freedom, even to the point of threatening life itself. By the time the child has memorized the Primer, he or she knows the religious metaphors com-

Page 341

munally used to interpret those experiences that are limits or boundaries to the self, such as birth, death, grace and guilt (David H. Watters, “I Spake as a Child: Authority, Metaphor and The New-England Primer,” Early American Literature, 20.3, 1985, 194).

The New England Primer was undoubtedly the most widely circulated children’s book in Puritan America. By some estimates, between six and eight million copies of the book were printed and sold over the many years that it was used in American schools. However, The New England Primer was not a work of fiction. It alluded to Biblical stories, but the various creators of this book did not set out to tell a story to children. The first fictional book for children to be written and published in Puritan America was likely The Prodigal Daughter. First published anonymously in Boston around 1737, this Puritan children’s book went through 29 separate editions in America and was later published in England. The book remained in print in America well into the 19th century (d’Alte A. Welch, A Bibliography of American Children’s Books Printed Prior to 1827, 1972). In his article titled “Early American Children’s Literature: A Bibliographic Primer” (1983), Jerome Griswold argues that The Prodigal Daughter “may have been the most popular early American children’s book” (Early American Literature, 18.2, 1983, 124).

Written in rhymed verse, The Prodigal Daughter was a cautionary tale intended for children, but it also included a message for those parents who indulged their children. The author of The Prodigal Daughter fully embraced the concept of infant depravity and set out to show what happens when parents allow their children’s sinful natures to go unchecked. Like all children’s books from the Puritan period, it served a didactic purpose, but it was the first to use fiction as a teaching tool.

The central character in The Prodigal Daughter is a teenage girl who is described as a “proud and disobedient daughter.” Her parents had indulged her tastes for beautiful clothes and had not required her to study the “holy scriptures.”  In the beginning of the story, the girl’s parents “begin to see their tender kindness would her ruin be.”  In order to save the girl from her evil ways, the “father stript her of her rich array, and then he cloath’d her in russet gray” (4). The parents then confine their daughter to her chamber. While the girl is sulking in her room, a visitor mysteriously ap-

Page 342

pears:

On night as in her room she musing were
The Devil in her room did then appear,
And seemingly he took her by the hand,
In shape and person like a gentleman (5).

The girl and the Devil hatch up a plan to poison the parents. Satan advises the girl to pretend to be repentant, and then when the opportunity presents itself, slip poison into her parents’ food. She prepares to implement this plan, but the night before she intends to poison them, an Angel visits the parents and warns them of their daughter’s intentions. Unaware that her parents have been alerted to her scheme, the girl tells her parents that she is now repentant and that she is going to make breakfast for them:

Next morning she rose early, as we hear,
And for her parents breakfast did prepare,
And in the same she put poison strong,
And brought it unto them when she had done,
Her father took the victuals which she had brought.
And down the same unto the dog he set,
Who ate the food and instantly did die,
The case was plain she could not it deny (8-9).

After the girl’s murderous plot is revealed, she collapses and remains unconscious for four days. Her parents conclude that their daughter has died, but actually she is in a deep trance. While she is in her trance, her soul takes flight. At first she visits hell, where she cries for “mercy” but “could find none” (12). Then she sees a light and follows it to the gates of heaven. There she converses with the keeper of the gates who tells her that only truly repentant sinners who have read the scriptures are permitted past the gates. The girl then regains consciousness. However, her parents, thinking that their daughter has died, are in the process of burying her at the very moment that she comes back to life:

At length they did observe the dismal sound
Come from the body just laid in the ground,
The coffin then they did draw up again,
And in a fright they opened the same,
When soon they found that she was yet live,
Her mother seeing that she did survive,
Did praise the LORD, in hopes she would have time,
And would repent of all her heinous crimes (10-11).

Page 343

The girl is then carried home, where she tells her parents and the local minister what happened to her during her trance. The story concludes with the girl’s sincere repentance: “And now she is a Christian just and true, no more her wicked vices does pursue.” In the final lines of the story, the author addressed the child readers directly:

I hope this will a good example be,
Children your parents honour and obey,
And the LORD will bless you here on earth,
And give you a crown of glory after death (14).

The New England Primer and The Prodigal Daughter were both didactic children’s books intended to teach Puritan children key tenants of the Puritans’ religious beliefs. Although the concept of infant depravity runs through both of these books, this concept is treated somewhat differently. In The New England Primer, the concept of infant depravity is embedded in the book’s many Biblical references, and it is explicitly tied to the belief in original sin. The child readers of The New England Primer are told that they are sinners, but the book does not include detailed depictions of depraved children. In The Prodigal Daughter, the concept of infant depravity is presented in a much more sensational manner. The book conveys a melodramatic story in which the central character is presented as a depraved girl, and the implication is that the girl’s tendency toward depravity started when she was very young. Although the story refers to the parents as being kind, the text suggests that the parents were at fault for not attempting to thwart their daughter’s sinful impulses while she was still a little girl.

The New England Primer came out 50 years before The Prodigal Daughter first saw print, and this half-century interval may well help explain the differences in how infant depravity is treated in these two texts. When The New England Primer first appeared in 1687, the Puritans were by far the dominant group in New England. Other groups, such as the Quakers, were present in New England at the time, but the Puritans were firmly in control. When The Prodigal Daughter came out in 1737, the Puritans’ dominance over New England was beginning to weaken. Other immigrants who did not share the Puritans’ religious beliefs were settling in New England in increasing numbers, and this change caused some Puritans to become more defensive about their beliefs, including their belief in infant depravity. In some ways, the author of The Prodigal Daughter reflects this change. The parents in The Prodi-

Page 344

gal Daughter initially ignore the Puritans’ concerns about infant depravity, and as a result, they are nearly murdered by their daughter.

Eventually, the Puritans’ concept of infant depravity fell out of favor in America. New ideas related to childhood gradually took root instead. By the beginning of the 19th century, the idea of childhood innocence started gaining acceptance. This change gradually resulted in new approaches to education. For example, the Puritans’ widespread use of corporal punishment in the schools began coming under question. The Puritans saw the use of corporal punishment as a fitting response to the depraved nature of children. In fact, the alphabet in The New England Primer includes the line “The idle Fool is whipt at school.” By the mid-19th century, educational leaders such as Bronson Alcott (the father of author Louisa May Alcott) openly denounced the use of corporal punishment in the schools, arguing that corporal punishment was inconsistent with the concept of childhood innocence (Bernard Wishy, The Child and the Republic: The Dawn of Modern American Child Nurture, 1968).

By today’s standards, Puritan children’s literature seems very heavy-handed and overly moralistic, but this literature was a natural outgrowth of the Puritans’ beliefs about childhood. The literature that we now provide to our children and the curricular materials we now use in our schools are vastly different from what Puritan children read. However, not everything has changed. The reading material we provide our children today reflects the ideas that we now associate with childhood, just as the reading material that Puritans provided their children with reflected their ideas about infant depravity.

Page 345

About the author

Mark I. West

Mark I. West, PhD, is Professor of English, as well as the recent Chair of the Department of English at the University of North Carolina at Charlotte, where he has taught since 1984. In addition to performing administrative duties, he regularly teaches courses on children’s and young adult literature. He has written or edited 19 books, the most recent of which is Theodore Roosevelt and His Library at Sagamore Hill (2022). Before entering academia, he worked as an early childhood educator and professional puppeteer. His email address is .

How to cite this article

West, M. I. (2018). Infant depravity in children’s literature in Puritan America. Clio’s Psyche, 24(3), 339-345.

https://doi.org/10.70763/577fd60255d4bb0f466464849ffe6d8e

PDF downloads