Volume 26 - Number 3 - Spring 2020
Pages: 265 - 387

THE MANY ROADS OF THE BUILDERS OF PSYCHOHISTORY: PART III BIOGRAPHICAL STUDIES

West, M. I. (2020). Lawrence J. Friedman’s art of fusing history and psychology. Clio’s Psyche, 26(3), 376-380.

https://doi.org/10.70763/c82836ed448c41094025b4a872c5341e

Lawrence J. Friedman’s Art of Fusing History and Psychology

article

Abstract

This article surveys Lawrence J. Friedman’s published scholarship with an emphasis on the various ways in which he has combined the disciplines of history and psychology over the course of his career as a historian. In his first books, he draws on psychological concepts in order to better understand the behavior of people from the past, but in his more recent work, he shows how historical events can shape the formulation of psychological concepts.

Keywords:

Erich Fromm, Erik H. Erikson, history career, identity formation, interdisciplinary, Karl Menninger, Lawrence J. Friedman, projection, psychohistory, psychological concepts, psychology

I first met Lawrence J. Friedman 40 years ago when I entered the American Culture PhD Program at Bowling Green State University where he taught as a professor in the History Department. I was interested in studying the history and culture of American childhood, and he was leading a seminar based on Robert Coles’ Children of Crisis (1967). I signed up for the seminar, and I have been learning from Larry ever since. Although I ended up pursuing a career as an English professor with a specialty in children’s literature, I have continuously followed Larry’s career as a historian. I have taken a particular interest in how he combines the

Page 376

disciplines of history and psychology. Larry generally does not use the term psychohistory, but he has shown through his published scholarship some of the many ways in which history and psychology can speak to each other.

Any survey of Larry’s scholarship in which he combines history and psychology should start with his first book, The White Savage: Racial Fantasies in the Postbellum South (1970). Written while he was an assistant professor at Arizona State University, the book has connections to his experiences as a young Freedom Rider in the American South during the early 1960s. These experiences left an indelible mark on him and caused him to ponder the reasons behind racism. In The White Savage, he delves into the psychological motivations of the white Southerners who were invested in suppressing African Americans in the initial decades after the Civil War. Although he does not make many specific references to the psychoanalytic theorists, he draws on psychoanalytic concepts, such as projection. As he thoroughly documents in the book, some white Southerners projected their own aggressive and libidinal impulses onto African Americans, and this response influenced their racist attitudes toward African Americans.

Larry’s interest in combining history and psychology is also reflected in Gregarious Saints: Self and Community in American Abolitionism, 1830-1870, which Cambridge University Press published in 1982. Larry was completing this book when I first met him, so I heard him talk about it on several occasions before it actually saw print. When Larry discussed this book, he often mentioned that he drew on theories related to social psychology, the psychology of the self, and group psychology when writing it. I specifically remember him mentioning Heinz Kohut’s The Analysis of the Self (1971) during one of these discussions. In this book, Larry shows that for some abolitionists, their sense of self was tied to their interactions as members of the abolitionist community. He shows, for example, how the dynamics of social psychology played a role in the willingness of some abolitionists to advocate violence as a tool to end slavery.

Around the same period that Larry was completing Gregarious Saints, he developed a more focused interest in psychological theorists. This interest led him to study psychoanalytic theory at the Menninger Foundation in Topeka, Kansas. In August 1981, he took a sabbatical leave and signed up for the Menninger Interdisciplinary Studies Program. While he was there, he met Karl Men-

Page 377

ninger, and they often engaged in long conversations about history, literature, and the evolution of the Menninger Foundation. Larry ended up co-dedicating Gregarious Saints to Karl Menninger. Larry’s experiences at the Menninger Foundation and his relationship with Karl Menninger resulted in a significant shift in Larry’s career as an historian. Up until this point, he focused most of his scholarship on 19th century American history, but he decided to focus his next book on the history of the Menninger Foundation.

This decision rippled through to me. At this point, I was completing my dissertation under Larry’s direction, and I was looking for full-time employment. The archivist position at the Menninger Foundation was vacant at the time, and Larry suggested that I apply for it. I did, and I got the position. From 1983 until June of 1984, I served as the Menninger Foundation’s official archivist, and in this capacity, I helped Larry while he was conducting some of the archival research for his book Menninger: The Family and the Clinic, which Knopf published in 1990. Even though I had already taken courses from Larry and had read some of his scholarship, this was the first time that I saw his research process up close. I remember being very impressed with the thoroughness of his research. When Larry was critiquing the chapters of my dissertation, he often asked, “Where’s your evidence?” Watching him do the research for his Menninger book, I came to understand how much he values evidence-based claims. He read thousands of letters written by Karl Menninger and other people associated with the place, and he examined the records from meetings going back to the very beginnings of the Menninger Clinic. If he could not find a letter or a document, he sent me on a mission to locate it. In the end, he spent years collecting and analyzing evidence.

In researching and writing Menninger: The Family and the Clinic, Larry moved in a new direction in terms of combining history and psychology. Instead of using psychological concepts and theories to help explain the behavior of people from the past, he decided to use his skills and insights as an historian to shed light on the evolution of a psychiatric hospital and the family behind it. In the process, he showed how psychological concepts and theories are shaped in part by historical events. One of my favorite examples of this in Menninger: The Family and the Clinic is the chapter titled “Karl Menninger and the Émigrés.” In this chapter, Larry discusses the relationship between Menninger and a group of most Jewish psychoanalysts who were fleeing Europe as a result of the

Page 378

rise of Nazism. Menninger recruited a number of these European émigrés and offered them positions in Topeka. These émigrés brought with them psychoanalytic concepts that were not yet widely accepted in America. As Larry documents, this page from the history of the Menninger Foundation helps explain why Topeka became a center for the promulgation of psychoanalytic theories in America.

Larry’s ongoing interest in the relationship between European and American psychoanalytic communities led him to Erik H. Erikson, the topic of his next book project. Taking the same thorough research approach that he did with his Menninger book, Larry spent ten years traveling between Europe and America, investigating how Erikson made the transition from being a young psychoanalyst from Vienna named Erik Homburger to becoming Erik Erikson, America’s preeminent psychoanalytic theorist and writer. The result of this research is Identity’s Architect: A Biography of Erik H. Erikson, which Harvard University Press published in 1999.

Given my interest in the history and culture of childhood, I particularly like Larry’s two chapters that deal with the writing and impact of Erikson’s Childhood and Society (1950). It was Larry who first introduced me to Childhood and Society when I was a graduate student, and I have shared it with many of my graduate students over the course of my career. Larry explains how this book grew out of Erikson’s experiences in Boston and New Haven during the late 1930s. Larry shows the connections between Erikson’s efforts to establish a new identity as an American and his thoughts about identity formation. In other words, Larry explains how the formulation of a psychological concept of identity formation is rooted historical events, but he does not stop there. He goes on to discuss how the concept of identity formation took root in American psychological circles.

Toward the end of Identity’s Architect, Larry discusses Erikson’s role as a public intellectual during the 1960s. As Larry points out, Erikson regularly spoke out during this period on pressing political issues, such as the Vietnam War. Erikson drew on his background in psychology in his work as a public intellectual, and this intrigued Larry. Larry’s interest in how psychoanalysts and psychologists sometimes function as public intellectuals is reflected in his most recent book, The Lives of Erich Fromm: Love’s Prophet, which Columbia University Press published in 2013. In many ways, Identity’s Architect and The Lives of Erich Fromm are sister

Page 379

volumes. Both are biographies of prominent psychoanalysts who grew up in Europe and then moved to America as young men. In both of these biographies, Larry delves into the social forces that shaped these men and discusses the lasting impact of their writings. However, in The Lives of Erich Fromm, Larry shows how Fromm embraced the role of public intellectual.

Larry’s biography of Fromm includes several chapters that deal with Fromm’s interest in political issues. As Larry points out, Fromm set out to shape political discourse by writing overtly political works such as Escape from Freedom and The Sane Society. Larry also demonstrates that Fromm drew on his psychological insights when advising political leaders, such as President John F. Kennedy. In writing The Lives of Erich Fromm, Larry shows yet another way in which history and psychology can speak to each other. Through his scholarship on Fromm, Larry provides an intriguing example of how psychoanalysts and psychologists can shape the course of history through direct involvement in the political sphere.

One of the many lessons I have learned from Larry about the connections between the disciplines of history and psychology is that it cannot be reduced to a simple formula. Through his published scholarship, Larry provides diverse examples of how these two disciplines can inform each other. In his earlier work, he shows how psychological concepts can be used to better understand the behavior of people from the past, while in his more recent work he shows how historical events can shape the formulation of psychological concepts. However, in all of these works, he bases his arguments on primary research and avoids mechanistic approaches to interpreting the behavior of the people he covers in his scholarship. For Larry, the fusing of history and psychology is as much an art as it is a scholarly approach.

Page 380

About the author

Mark I. West

Mark I. West, PhD, is Professor of English, as well as the recent Chair of the Department of English at the University of North Carolina at Charlotte, where he has taught since 1984. In addition to performing administrative duties, he regularly teaches courses on children’s and young adult literature. He has written or edited 19 books, the most recent of which is Theodore Roosevelt and His Library at Sagamore Hill (2022). Before entering academia, he worked as an early childhood educator and professional puppeteer. His email address is .

How to cite this article

West, M. I. (2020). Lawrence J. Friedman’s art of fusing history and psychology. Clio’s Psyche, 26(3), 376-380.

https://doi.org/10.70763/c82836ed448c41094025b4a872c5341e

PDF downloads