Volume 33 - Number 1 - Winter 2026
Pages: 1 - 129

SPECIAL ISSUE ON PSYCHOHISTORICAL INSIGHTS ON ANGER, ANXIETY, AND FEAR IN OUR FRIGHTENED WORLD

Wood, R. (2026). Canadian responses to Trump’s 51st state threats viewed through a psychoanalytic lens. Clio’s Psyche, 33(1), 89-94.

https://doi.org/10.70763/eefc7bfe8fd6e2c8c01aa6ca7b1aab1a

Canadian Responses to Trump’s 51st State Threats Viewed Through a Psychoanalytic Lens

article

Abstract

This article offers a subjective reflection by a Canadian psychoanalyst on Canadian emotional responses to Donald Trump’s threats to make Canada the 51st state. Drawing on his own experience, conversations with eight friends whom he describes as liberal, and impressions from patients and neighbors, the author acknowledges that his material is anecdotal and shaped by the circles in which he moves. Viewed through a psychoanalytic lens, he interprets Canadian rage as reflecting despair and an effort to assert power against a vastly outsized aggressor. He suggests that outrage insulates against threat but also reminds Canadians of their relative smallness. He identifies fear of losing sovereignty and a quieter Canadian identity, which he contrasts with American nationalism, as central to this fear. He describes grief over the loss of a cherished friendship with the United States, replaced by mistrust and a need to diversify partnerships, and he anticipates permanently damaged trust. He reports growing hopelessness, especially among younger people, in the face of looming chaos south of the border, along with what he perceives as rising mental health distress. He also fears that American populism will inspire similarly exploitative politicians in Canada who seek to consolidate authority.

Keywords:

Canadian politics, Donald Trump, despair, fear, hatred, hypervigilance, identity, mental health, National Identity, outrage, populism, prejudice, psychoanalysis, psychohistory, punitive, rage, vindictive

This article is currently unavailable to the public due to its recent publication.

To access it, please become a member of the Psychohistory Forum.

Membership page

About the author

Richard Wood

Richard Wood, PhD, was acting Director of the Department of Psychology at Mount Sinai Hospital from 1974 through 1982 and, mostly concurrently, associate professor in the Department of Behavioural Science, which was affiliated with the University of Toronto Medical School. From 1982 up to the present time, he has worked exclusively in private practice. In 1989, he was president of the Ontario Psychological Association. He also started and headed a multidisciplinary clinic to assess and resolve motor vehicle accident claims for the Ontario government. In 2022, he published his first book, A Study of Malignant Narcissism: Personal and Professional Insights (Routledge). He’s currently working on a book that Routledge has requested summarizing psychoanalytic thought on narcissism. He can be emailed at .

How to cite this article

Wood, R. (2026). Canadian responses to Trump’s 51st state threats viewed through a psychoanalytic lens. Clio’s Psyche, 33(1), 89-94.

https://doi.org/10.70763/eefc7bfe8fd6e2c8c01aa6ca7b1aab1a