Volume 13 - Number 4 - March 2007
Pages: 179 - 226

TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY PERSPECTIVES ON THE HOLOCAUST
SPECIAL ISSUE: SECTION IV LESSONS AND CONCLUSIONS

Zieman, I. (2007). Jewish and universal lessons from the Holocaust. Clio’s Psyche, 13(4), 197-199.

https://doi.org/10.70763/d9909824688daaad46d441eefd81eb38

Jewish and Universal Lessons from the Holocaust

article

Abstract

In this article, the author recounts a childhood in a Latvian town in the 1930s, including membership in the Socialist Zionist youth movement Gordonia, followed by forced labor in a Siberian coal mine in 1942 and postwar work with survivors in a displaced persons camp in Austria and in Munich. The author reports learning after 1945 that most of the family had been killed by local collaborators in 1941. Drawing on decades of reading and thought, the author sets out lessons for Jews and for humankind. The Jewish lessons are to remember the victims, to maintain a strong and democratic Israel, and to hold to the values of justice, compassion, and peace, since abandoning them or extreme assimilation would, in the author’s view, hand the Nazis a posthumous victory. The author is critical of right-wing Jews and attributes this stance to biographical roots: Nazi brutality, Socialist Zionist upbringing, and childhood experiences. The universal lessons include the danger of negative generalizations about ethnic or religious groups, with the current example of attitudes toward Muslims. The author also maintains that the Holocaust must be explained through economic, political, ideological, and psychological factors, citing Adorno and colleagues, The Authoritarian Personality, on child-rearing. The author proposes that it revealed human capacity for splitting and malleability, and concludes that Western education should be radically reoriented toward critical thinking, self-esteem, empathy, and cooperation to strengthen democracy and help prevent genocide.

Keywords:

childhood trauma, Displaced Persons (DP) camp, family dynamics, Holocaust, identity, immigration, Kibbutz, mental resilience, psychobiography, psychohistory, Socialist Zionist, survival, youth organization

My lessons from the Holocaust were naturally affected heavily by my childhood experiences in the 1930s and by my experiences as a young adult during the Holocaust and soon thereafter in the 1940s. My father was a rare specimen, an orthodox Jew who was also a Socialist Zionist. At the age of ten I joined Gordonia, a branch of the Socialist Zionist youth organization, in the small Latvian town in which I was growing up. I enjoyed it very much and became an ardent Socialist Zionist, visualizing my future: living in an agrarian Kibbutz in Palestine and participating in building a homeland for the Jewish people. This vision helped to sustain my mental health during World War II, particularly in the hell of my starving in the forced labor coal mine in Siberia in 1942. After the war ended in 1945 I immediately volunteered to work for the Social Zionist Youth group. I wound up leading a preparatory Kibbutz of young Holocaust survivors in a Displaced Persons (DP) camp in Austria, in Hitler’s birthplace of Braunau-am-Inn. A leader of Gordonia came to visit me in Braunau and told me that I and my people were needed in West Germany. So we left Austria for Germany; thus beginning for me a long history of life and work in Germany.

For the first three years, from 1945 to 1948, 1 worked in Munich in the central office of the United Pioneer Youth of which Gordonia was a part. In 1945, when I was in transit in Augsburg, I saw a woman who looked familiar to me. When we started talking, I found out that she was a woman I had known in my hometown. She told me that her husband and children were killed for being Jewish, and that she was able to survive in Germany because of her knowledge of Russian and her pretending to be a Russian Christian. She then told me what happened to the Jews of our hometown in the fall of 1941 while she was hiding. All Jews were assembled in the synagogues, then led to the forest and shot by local Latvian collaborators of the German army. Thus I lost my father Shlomo, my mother Golda, my younger brother Reuven, and my younger sister Miriam. Later in Munich I met a Latvian co-student of my sister Tsila who told me that Tsila had been in the Riga Ghetto. Since I have not been able to find any information about her life or death, I assume that she was one of the many thousands of Jews who were rounded up and shot near Riga by Latvian collaborators of the Nazis.

Since 1945 I have done some reading and much thinking about the Holocaust: how could it happen, that an educated, cultured people like the Germans gave up their democracy and gave the power to govern the country to a gang of criminal killers of innocents? What are the lessons to be learned from the Holocaust by the Jewish people and by all of humankind?

The first Jewish lesson seems to me to be: never to forget the victims of this heinous crime of mass murder of innocent people. I agree with the late leader of the council of Jews in Germany, Ignaz Bubis. He said: to forget the victims is like killing them again.

A second Jewish lesson is related to my Zionist background: Jews should have a Jewish country that would be able to rescue and absorb Jews who would be in danger or suffering anywhere in the world. Therefore, I believe that Israel should continue to exist as a Jewish country and it should be militarily, economically and socially strong and able to defend itself against any enemies. What makes Israel strong is not only its military and its economy, but also its democracy, pluralism, and the extent to which it is tolerant and fair toward its Arab minority and caring for its elderly and poor.

A third Jewish lesson from the Holocaust has to do with the fact that the Nazis’ goal was not only the physical destruction of the Jewish people, but also the destruction of the spirit and the values .of the Jewish people, such as the beliefs that God created all human beings and that people should endeavor to improve the world by practicing justice, compassion and peace. Even though most Jews nowadays, both in Israel and the Diaspora, are not religious, most secular Jews are still holding on to the originally religious values of justice, compassion and peace. I am proud of the fact that, as a group, Jews in the United States do not vote in accordance with their socio-

Page 197

economic status but rather on the basis of their social values.

The Nazis were endeavoring to substitute new values for the traditional Judeo-Christian values, like military strength, territorial expansion, racial purity, rule over weaker nations, and war. They viewed the traditional values as a nuisance that was weakening the belligerent Germanic spirit. From this it follows that abandoning the traditional Jewish values and adopting the socially Darwinian Nazi values of “might is right” would provide a posthumous victory to the Nazis. Similarly, extreme assimilation and abandonment of Jewish identity would serve the Nazi goal of the elimination of the Jewish people.

Holding on to the traditional Jewish values is not only a Jewish lesson of the Holocaust; it is also a universal lesson, since justice, compassion and peace are also universal values.

My adherence to the traditional values and my animosity to right wing Jews, who are flirting with Nazi values such as territorial expansion, military power, oppression and war, have powerful biographical roots. The first is the Nazis’ callous brutality toward my original family and toward my people. Another root is the Socialist Zionism which I may have inherited from my father and which was inculcated into me as a child in Gordonia. It also stems partially from my hatred of my father in my teens, when he was not able to accept my rebellion against Orthodox Judaism and when he endeavored brutally to bully me and to force me to become an orthodox copy of himself. I also remember being bullied and brutalized as a child by a bigger and stronger boy who was a member of the “Beitar,” a right wing, fascists Zionist youth organization.

What are other universal lessons to be learned from the Holocaust? The persecution of the Jews in Germany prior to the Holocaust was tolerated and accepted by the majority of the German people because they believed and accepted the Nazi propaganda, that the Jews as a group were morally inferior and harmful to the German society. Similar beliefs made it possible and easier for the perpetrators of the Holocaust to engage in mass murder of innocent people. This shows how dangerous negative generalizations about an ethnic or religious group are. Besides, such generalizations are usually untrue and they are very unfair to those members of a group whose values and behavior are the opposite of the generalization. A current example of the danger of negative generalization is the view that all Muslims are hateful and destructive to the West; expressions of such a negative generalization serve to antagonize most Muslims and to increase the popularity of extreme and violent Islamists.

Another universal lesson of the Holocaust is the importance of studying and teaching all the factors that made the Holocaust possible. If one wishes to make an event similar to the Holocaust impossible or at least unlikely to occur in the future, it is essential to acquire and to disseminate a thorough understanding of the various factors leading to the Holocaust. Some people feel so humbled by the enormity of the heinous crimes of the Holocaust that they don’t feel they have the right to study and to annunciate the causes of the Holocaust. Such people often claim that it is impossible to explain the Holocaust. Some also fear that explaining it means condoning or justifying it. I think that explaining is something very different from condoning or justifying.

To explain the Holocaust requires a multidisciplinary approach that encompasses economic, political, ideological and psychological factors. The tremendous inflation and large unemployment in Germany after World War I made many Germans desperate and open to new radical solutions to their problems. The Versailles Treaty added to Germany’s economic problems and humiliated the German people. The Nazis’ access to government power was furthered by a lack of experience with democracy in Germany, by the lack of commitment to democracy, by violent clashes between the forces of right and left and by the ruling classes’ fears of communism.

The perpetration of the Holocaust was also facilitated by the Nazis’ establishing a totalitarian system of government soon after their access to power in 1933, with full government control of the flow of information, with suppression and terrorizing of any dissent by the use of concentration camps and by their powerful and lying propaganda. For example, many Jews and many non-Jewish Germans believed the Nazi lie that the Jews were deported to the East to work there. In addition, the timidity and passivity of England and France in the face of Hitler’s disregard of the Versailles Treaty with his enlargement of his military and expansions of German territory contributed greatly to Germans’ enthusiasm about Hitler in the 1930s. Both the good conscience

Page 198

of the perpetrators of the Holocaust and the tolerance of the majority of Germans for the persecution of the Jews and for the brutal foreign policies of the Nazi government were facilitated by the belief in Nazi ideology. This ideology, containing an emphasis on the past victimization of the German people, on social Darwinism, racism, anti-Semitism and hostility toward other peoples, was partly fed by many centuries of anti-Judaism of the churches and by a tradition of anti-modernism in German writings.

Among the psychological factors that facilitated the growth of Nazism was the low self-esteem of many lower middle class and other Germans. This fact was successfully manipulated by the Nazis by claiming the racial superiority of Germans toward Jews and Slavs. Other psychological factors contributing to the Nazis’ success were mentioned by Theodor Adorno, et al., in The Authoritarian Personality (1950). In that book the authors describe a certain kind of oppressive, brutal child rearing in Germany contributing to the development of authoritarian personalities readily attracted to and seduced by the Nazis. It was a way of childrearing that stressed obedience, that discouraged thinking and self-expression by children and that punished brutally any attempts of disagreement by children with their parents. The results of such childrearing were low self-esteem, insufficient development of critical thinking, fears of hostility against the parents and instead the projection of one’s hostility toward the social out-group, for example the Jews or the Slavs.

Other universal lessons of the Holocaust pertain to the image of man. The Holocaust showed us that one can be a good husband, wife, a lover of animals, like Hoes, the commandant of Auschwitz, and at the same time, with a good conscience, order and supervise the murder of thousands of innocent human beings, including children. Thus the Holocaust demonstrated the human capacity for splitting. The Holocaust also showed the enormous malleability of human nature and the immense power of propaganda.

The Holocaust also disproved the enlightenment belief that science and technology would make people happy, because it showed that science and technology could also be used for heinous mass murder of innocents.

Finally, the Holocaust showed the lack of value of traditional education for the prevention of mass inhumanity to men, women and children. Some of the leaders of the mass murder were physicians and doctors of philosophy.

If education could help in the prevention of genocides, it has to be changed radically. There has to be an end to the Western educational system, which focuses nearly exclusively on competition and on the acquisition of knowledge. Instead the educational system must focus prominently on developing the abilities and inclinations for critical thinking, for adequate self-esteem, for empathy, compassion and cooperation.

The one-sided and inadequate Western educational system contributed to the fragility of democracy and to its defeat in several European countries in the twenties and thirties of the twentieth-century. It also contributed to the endangerment of democracy in some countries in the first decade of the twenty-first century. A different educational system that would emphasize the strengthening of the psychological foundations of democracy would go a long way to enhancing the safety and stability of democracy in the future and would thus also contribute to the prevention of more genocides.

Page 199

About the author

Isaac Zelig Zieman

Isacc Zelig Zieman trained in psychoanalysis in Germany and took a master’s degree in psychology from New School University in 1967. For two or three years he has worked with the One by One Reconciliation Group of people touched by the Holocaust. Zieman has retired from the practice of psychoanalysis and is close to finishing the manuscript of his memoir, From Victim to Peace Builder. He may be contacted at .

How to cite this article

Zieman, I. (2007). Jewish and universal lessons from the Holocaust. Clio’s Psyche, 13(4), 197-199.

https://doi.org/10.70763/d9909824688daaad46d441eefd81eb38

PDF downloads