DAVID BEISEL FESTSCHRIFT ESSAYS IN HONOR OF DAVID R. BEISEL

David R. Beisel: Extraordinary Psychohistorian and Colleague (leading festschrift article)

Keywords:

David R. Beisel, editor, festschrift, Henry Lawton, International Psychohistorical Association (IPhA), Institute of Psychohistory, “Mr. Psychohistory,” Journal of Psychohistory (JOP), organizer, psychohistory, psychological history, psychology, scholar, teacher

Abstract:

This festschrift article by Paul H. Elovitz opens the festschrift in honor of David R. Beisel and is an appreciation of his career as a psychohistorian. Under the headings Leadership, Scholarship, Editorship, Pedagogy, and Honors and Awards, followed by a closing portrait of the man, the author is admiring of Beisel throughout. The author recounts his graduate training in history at Clark University and New York University, his entry into psychohistory through the Institute for Psychohistory in the 1970s, and his service as convention chair and second president of the International Psychohistorical Association, including the 1978 inaugural conference and a 1983 Manhattan convention. Surveying the scholarship, it lists publications on German history, diplomacy, early German nationalism, Jimmy Carter, and the Holocaust. It singles out The Suicidal Embrace (2004) as his most significant single work, along with the 2011 Clio’s Psyche symposium on military and diplomatic blind spots and the edited volume Wounded Centuries: A Selection of Poems (2015). It credits him with introducing refereeing and raising standards as editor of the Journal of Psychohistory, and with teaching psychohistory to about 8,000 students at Rockland Community College, including a classroom method developed after the Columbine shootings. It lists his teaching awards and invited addresses and notes three unfinished manuscripts whose completion it regards as uncertain. It concludes by describing him as a humorous and loyal friend, committed to scholarly standards and to psychohistory.

How to Cite This: Elovitz, P. H. (2021). David R. Beisel: Extraordinary psychohistorian and colleague. In P. H. Elovitz, & N. D’Andria (Eds.), David Beisel festschrift. Clio’s Psyche, 28(1), 1-7.
https://doi.org/10.70763/6b8b8e3bd6ad94b985c1b1f1b7a94cb2

The Unique Approaches of Two Authoritarians: In Search of Power in Germany and the U.S. (festschrift article)

Keywords:

Adolf Hitler, authoritarian personality, childhood abuse, David R. Beisel, democracy, dictatorship, Donald Trump, festschrift, German motherhood, psychohistory, public appeal, Weimar

Abstract:

This festschrift article in honor of David R. Beisel compares conditions in Germany during the Weimar years and early 1930s with those in the United States in the 2010s. It considers Adolf Hitler and Donald Trump as authoritarian figures seeking, holding, and (in Trump’s case) losing national power. Following Beisel’s argument in The Suicidal Embrace that governmental abuse and war are made or permitted by individuals, the author maintains that leaders’ backgrounds, psychological needs, and aspirations must be examined alongside the societies that accept them. The comparison is limited to the two men’s aspirations and methods. The author contends that both societies experienced real or perceived loss, resentment, nostalgia for an idealized past, and projection of fear onto minority groups, and that authoritarian family patterns and difficult childhoods made such leaders’ appeals resonate. Hitler is portrayed as a “master teacher” of political self-presentation, symbolism, media use, and attacks on the press, from whom Trump drew in some aspirations and behaviors. The author notes that Trump has shown no intention of mass murder or war on Hitler’s scale. The article suggests that authoritarians act from weakness, rarely retain power in the long run, and concludes that Trump’s bid for power failed.

How to Cite This: Petschauer, P. W. (2021). The unique approaches of two authoritarians. In P. H. Elovitz, & N. D’Andria (Eds.), David Beisel festschrift. Clio’s Psyche, 28(1), 8-16.
https://doi.org/10.70763/e8f2779682fd11fa2067beffc27a9192

David Beisel: A Scholar’s Scholar in Psychohistory (festschrift article)

Keywords:

David R. Beisel, festschrift, historical detective, International Psychohistorical Association (IPhA), political cartoons, psychodynamics, psychohistory, scholarship, teaching psychohistory, unconscious, World War II (WWII)

Abstract:

This festschrift article is an appreciation of the psychohistorian David R. Beisel, written by a colleague who has known him since 1978 and is admiring of him as a historical scholar. The author characterizes Beisel’s work by its thoroughness, attention to detail, and insistence on exhaustive historical evidence before psychodynamic interpretation, and describes him as wary of psychohistorians who impose preferred clinical theory on a topic. As illustration, the author discusses Beisel’s research on the causes of World War II, presented at International Psychohistorical Association conventions through the 1990s and published as The Suicidal Embrace: Hitler, the Allies, and the Origins of the Second World War (2004). The author reports that Beisel examined nations, their leaders, citizens, the press, and political cartoons, and contends that he demonstrated unconscious fantasy and strong emotion, rather than rational self-interest, driving the path to war. The author situates this work within Lloyd deMause’s fantasy analysis, Kleinian and Bionian object relations theory, and family systems theory, and recounts Beisel’s treatment of Europe’s nations as a family acting out unconscious collusion, including the fate of Czechoslovakia. The author also mentions Beisel’s advocacy of poetry panels at IPA conventions and his editing of Wounded Centuries (2015). The author concludes that the integrity of Beisel’s scholarship gives his psychodynamic interpretations broad foundations, and expresses gratitude for his work and friendship.

How to Cite This: Stein, H. F. (2021). David Beisel: A scholar’s scholar in psychohistory. In P. H. Elovitz, & N. D’Andria (Eds.), David Beisel festschrift. Clio’s Psyche, 28(1), 17-23.
https://doi.org/10.70763/25ef0d887bc7a2b30089a025618e1c62

Resistance and Transformation in Psychohistory (festschrift article)

Keywords:

Bob Lentz, Clio’s Psyche, counter-resistance, David R. Beisel, festschrift, group dynamics, infantile attractors, multidisciplinary, poetic psychohistory, psychohistory, psychological resistance, unconscious defenses

Abstract:

In this article, written for the festschrift honoring David R. Beisel, the author recalls first meeting Beisel’s work through a 1994 interview in the inaugural issue of Clio’s Psyche. The author is admiring of Beisel as a psychohistorian who kept researching, teaching, and editing despite resistance from other scholars. The article sets Beisel’s writing on resistance beside earlier remarks by Lloyd deMause and James M. Glass on the reluctance of social scientists and political theorists to engage with psychology. It reports the five sources of resistance to psychological approaches that Beisel identifies in “Resistance to Holocaust Scholarship,” along with John Fanton’s regrouping of them in “The Logic of Psychohistorical Destiny,” and it cites Beisel’s “Psychohistory and the Historians: 1970-2015.” Drawing on Beisel, the author contends that resistance also operates among psychohistorians themselves. The author proposes the term counter-resistance for psychohistorians’ attacks on other fields, characterizing it as a form of scholarly countertransference that can undermine collaboration. Citing Christopher Bollas and Stanley Palombo, the author maintains that recognizing these dynamics would make multidisciplinary exchange more open and would move psychohistorians from a constricted toward a more open sense of the future. The article closes with Beisel’s recent work on poetry as a psychohistorical source, including his edited collection Wounded Centuries and John Allman’s Clio’s Children. It characterizes poetic psychohistory as an area between the arts and science that can bridge knowledge and emotion.

How to Cite This: Ihanus, J. (2021). Resistance and transformation in psychohistory. In P. H. Elovitz, & N. D’Andria (Eds.), David Beisel festschrift. Clio’s Psyche, 28(1), 23-28.
https://doi.org/10.70763/332647f433a1c10fa2e2ae04abfdf83e

David Beisel is Also a Psychohistorian of the Arts (festschrift article)

Keywords:

David R. Beisel, festschrift, film, International Psychohistorical Association (IPhA), jazz, The Journal of Psychohistory (JOP), music, psychohistory, SUNY-Rockland, The Third Man, writer

Abstract:

In this festschrift article honoring David R. Beisel, the author is admiring of his career in psychohistory and concentrates on a lesser-known side of it, his writing on music and film. The author recounts that Beisel twice served as president of the International Psychohistorical Association, edited The Journal of Psychohistory for ten years, wrote The Suicidal Embrace (2004), taught psychohistory courses at SUNY-Rockland, and edited the 2016 poetry volume Wounded Centuries. Drawing mainly on Beisel’s Genres of the Imagination (2021), the author reports Beisel’s account of jazz, which he came to as a teenage outsider sneaking into Birdland. Beisel describes jazz as healing, and he finds in its after-hours cutting contests sibling rivalry, mentoring of newcomers, and the stresses of creativity, including self-destruction among some musicians. The author connects these themes to Beisel’s view of the historian’s creative task. The author also summarizes Beisel’s discussion of the film The Third Man (1949), which Beisel links to disillusionment after the Second World War, the bombing of Vienna, and distress in postwar America. The author maintains that Beisel brings to the arts the same illumination found in his psychohistorical writing, and that his career reflects a distinctive sensibility.

How to Cite This: Fuchsman, K. (2021). David Beisel is also a psychohistorian of the arts. In P. H. Elovitz, & N. D’Andria (Eds.), David Beisel festschrift. Clio’s Psyche, 28(1), 28-31.
https://doi.org/10.70763/f9fd2624beefbc7808e4e405d73f57ab

BEISEL APPRECIATIONS

Passionate Journeys to Psychohistory: Honoring the Brilliant Psychohistorian (festschrift article)

Keywords:

Belarus, David R. Beisel, Europe, festschrift, history, Lloyd deMause, psychohistory, psychology, Soviet Union, students, The Suicidal Embrace: Hitler, the Allies, and the Origins of the Second World War

Abstract:

In this article, written as an appreciation for the festschrift honoring David R. Beisel, the author recounts her path into psychohistory as his student and describes her admiration for him. She recalls beginning as a post-Soviet postgraduate in historiography in Belarus, where she encountered 1970s issues of The Journal of Psychohistory at the National Library of Belarus in 1994. She reports that Beisel’s articles offered an alternative to the Marxist-Leninist historiography in which she had been trained. She describes writing to Lloyd deMause, joining the International Psychohistorical Association, winning a grant to study in the United States, and taking Beisel’s course at Rockland Community College, State University of New York. She sorts his students into three groups, including skeptics who she says often became committed supporters. She credits his book The Suicidal Embrace: Hitler, the Allies, and the Origins of the Second World War (2004) with creating a new paradigm for the origins of the Second World War, and says she used its account of Czechoslovakia at Munich in her own courses at Belarusian State University. She proposes that the book bears on Belarus after August 2020 and asks whether Belarusians resemble the prewar Czechs. She concludes that his approach lives on through his students.

How to Cite This: Shutova, O. (2021). Passionate journeys to psychohistory: Honoring the brilliant psychohistorian. In P. H. Elovitz, & N. D’Andria (Eds.), David Beisel festschrift. Clio’s Psyche, 28(1), 31-33.
https://doi.org/10.70763/a57e8915461b83adefb011530b711704

Collaborating With Dave: New Perspectives/New Directions (festschrift article)

Keywords:

COVID-19 pandemic, creative collaboration, David R. Beisel, festschrift, Google, historical data, psychohistorical writing, psychohistory, unconscious processes, writing

Abstract:

In this festschrift article honoring David R. Beisel, the author recounts her collaboration with him. She recalls meeting him as a colleague at professional meetings and conferences, contributing poems to Wounded Centuries (2015), which he edited, and discovering a shared interest in jazz and film noir that led to a joint panel at the International Psychohistorical Conference in New York City. She reports that the papers grew into a book, written during the 2020 COVID-19 lockdown and later joined by a third collaborator. She describes the project as an effort to write psychohistory in everyday language, without jargon, drawing on personal experience and unconscious imaginal processes. Citing Irving Louis Horowitz, she regards a festschrift as a call to further work as well as a retrospective. She concludes that the resulting Genres of The Imagination: Essays by David Beisel and Irene Javors (2021) opens new directions for psychohistorical writing.

How to Cite This: Javors, I. (2021). Collaborating with Dave: New perspectives/new direction. In P. H. Elovitz, & N. D’Andria (Eds.), David Beisel festschrift. Clio’s Psyche, 28(1), 34-35.
https://doi.org/10.70763/379a7ba015d8bf1c70b8add2c287c6fa

Celebrating My Friendship with a Splendid Human Being: David Beisel (festschrift article)

Keywords:

David Beisel, festschrift, jazz enthusiast, Mark Brunswick, music, The New York Review of Books, politics, psychohistory, Rockland Community College (RCC), Sigmund Freud, World Wars

Abstract:

In this article, written for the festschrift honoring David R. Beisel, the author recounts his friendship with Beisel, a colleague at Rockland Community College, where both began teaching in 1972, Beisel in the Social Sciences Department and the author in the English Department. He reports that the two knew each other only slightly at first, despite shared politics and a shared enthusiasm for jazz, the author favoring Dixieland and swing and Beisel more modern styles. They became close after their offices were moved to the Rockland Field House. The author describes their weekly coffee meetings, where they discuss current politics, their health, articles in The New York Review of Books, and Germany, Beisel’s major field of interest. He notes that Beisel’s book The Suicidal Embrace: Hitler, the Allies, and the Origins of the Second World War (2004) often anchors their conversations about the two World Wars, an interest he connects to his family’s emigration from Germany to the United States in 1937. The author closes by expressing admiration for Beisel as a person and pleasure at contributing to the festschrift.

How to Cite This: Artin, T. (2021). Celebrating my friendship with a splendid human being: David Beisel. In P. H. Elovitz, & N. D’Andria (Eds.), David Beisel festschrift. Clio’s Psyche, 28(1), 35-37.
https://doi.org/10.70763/3c333aadfc3ee8ecb8d77ee31197d96a

Doing Psychohistory with David Beisel (festschrift article)

Keywords:

1979 Annual Convention, Alec Simos, Alien, annihilation anxieties, applied psychoanalysis, David R. Beisel, festschrift, group fantasies, Henry Ebel, Henry Lawton, Howard F. Stein, Jay Y. Gonen, The Journal of Psychohistory (JOP), Lloyd deMause, Mel Goldstein, political leaders, psychohistory

Abstract:

In this article, the author recalls attending the 1979 annual psychohistory convention in New York, his first, and his later friendship with David R. Beisel. The author recounts the convention’s welcoming atmosphere, conversations with Lloyd deMause, Henry Ebel and others, and seeing Ridley Scott’s Alien on Ebel’s recommendation and Ebel’s idea that science-fiction films explore inner worlds. He reports that the convention introduced him to ideas about group fantasies of destruction connected to political leaders, and that he found it hard to convey these ideas to people outside psychohistorical circles in West Germany. He describes Beisel as generous, skeptical, and attentive to verification, mentions Beisel’s essay “Toward a Psychohistory of Jimmy Carter” (1977), and credits him with proposing the author for the editorial board of The Journal of Psychohistory. The author refers to Beisel’s study of the origins of World War II, The Suicidal Embrace (2004), and closes with good wishes to Beisel and his family.

How to Cite This: Bliersbach, G. (2021). Doing psychohistory with David Beisel. In P. H. Elovitz, & N. D’Andria (Eds.), David Beisel festschrift. Clio’s Psyche, 28(1), 37-38.
https://doi.org/10.70763/b8b9c74ac526fffbeb2d39ab038d1cd7

Toasting Dave Beisel (festschrift article)

Keywords:

David R. Beisel, Decoding the Past, festschrift, Foundation of Psychohistory, Genres of Imagination, Lloyd deMause, Peter Loewenberg, psychohistory, The Suicidal Embrace: Hitler, the Allies, and the Origins of the Second World War

Abstract:

This festschrift article is a brief appreciation of David R. Beisel, written by a colleague as a toast. The author congratulates Beisel on his book Genres of Imagination (2021) and says he will shelve it between Beisel’s The Suicidal Embrace (2004) and Loewenberg’s Decoding the Past (1985). He recalls that Beisel, as editor of The Journal of Psychohistory, gave him his first major assignment, a review essay on Lloyd deMause’s Foundations of Psychohistory (1982). He describes feeling both honored and apprehensive as a newcomer, and says that Beisel’s request for a more critical review made him feel welcome. He notes that he has not seen Beisel in many years and recalls drinks together at a New York City jazz bar. The piece closes by raising a glass to Beisel’s friendship, intelligence, encouragement, and contributions to psychohistory, history, his students, and the psychohistory community.

How to Cite This: Adams, K. A. (2021). Toasting Dave Beisel. In P. H. Elovitz, & N. D’Andria (Eds.), David Beisel festschrift. Clio’s Psyche, 28(1), 38-39.
https://doi.org/10.70763/314450613369e0ee72d0da7f6fee773c

COPING IN OUR ANXIOUS WORLD

Coping with Anxiety in Our Fearful Digital World (article)

Keywords:

anxiety, coping mechanisms, digital communication, Donald Trump, modern technology, psychohistory, Sigmund Freud, threats to democracy, The United States of Anxiety

Abstract:

In this article, Paul H. Elovitz argues that anxiety is intensified in contemporary society by digital connectedness, which brings the dangers and problems of the entire world into daily awareness, and by a long-standing human inclination to scan the environment for danger. He treats anxiety as universal, pointing to the Garden of Eden myth, the possibility of prenatal anxiety, and Freud’s contention in Civilization and Its Discontents that renouncing instinctual impulses is part of civilization’s cost. He distinguishes realistic fear from anxiety as the anticipation of fear. Writing as a self-described Eriksonian participant observer, and drawing on his experience as a therapist, a teacher, and himself, he explores how people cope with the anxieties generated by the COVID-19 pandemic, its economic and social dislocation, and the Trump presidency. The coping methods he considers include therapy, love and work, absorption in activities, self-medication, mindfulness, humor, and immersion in political movements. He suggests that the Make America Great Again movement offers its followers purpose and identification with a leader amid fears of lost identity and economic security. He also reflects on his own coping and his heightened concern about threats to American democracy after January 6. He concludes that anxiety cannot be eliminated, though responsible government makes coping less formidable.

How to Cite This: Elovitz, P. H. (2021). Coping with anxiety in our fearful digital world. Clio’s Psyche, 28(1), 40-46.
https://doi.org/10.70763/c7558e9d1f956b016d1fdba7ea132378

Anxiety, Help, and Helplessness (article)

Keywords:

anxiety, autonomy, childhood templates, helplessness, internal environment, psychic survivalism, psychohistory, security, self-sufficiency, self-worth

Abstract:

This article argues that helplessness is the root of anxiety and that anxiety can be understood only by understanding “help” as a relation both between persons and within the self. Drawing on attachment theory and on Winnicott, Bion, Klein, and Laub, it proposes that reliable caregiving contains overwhelming emotion and allows the child to internalize helpers, building a benign internal world and feelings of worth, security, and autonomy. Failures of help are inevitable and necessary for development. The article maintains that when such failures are severe or inconsistent, helplessness is discovered too early and traumatically, leaving a harsh internal environment, splitting, and a sense of worthlessness. Later in life, it contends, both the prospect of help, which may imply that the self is not self-sufficient, and the failure of help can trigger intense anxiety. The self defends against this anxiety through a grandiose psychic survivalism that is hostile to providing help to oneself and others. The article suggests that this hostility may be organized in groups identified with helplessness and enacted in attacks on helping institutions, including governmental ones.

How to Cite This: Bowker, M. H. (2021). Anxiety, help, and helplessness. Clio’s Psyche, 28(1), 46-51.
https://doi.org/10.70763/73b817090081cef1bca77232f4532c5d

Virtual Anxiety (article)

Keywords:

anxiety, consumption culture, coping with anxiety, Frederich Nietzsche, information overload, psychic defenses, psychohistory, repression, Sigmund Freud, Søren Kierkegaard, survival mentality, technocultural, technology, trauma, virtual anxiety, virtual reality

Abstract:

This article traces the psychoanalytic understanding of anxiety, including Freud’s three forms (real, neurotic, and moral anxiety) and his view that anxiety causes repression. It argues that present-day anxiety differs from the traditional traumatic situations of birth, separation, castration, and loss of love in its global scale and its orientation toward the future. The author proposes “virtual anxiety,” a continuous background “noise” of which people are usually unaware but which repeatedly emerges as a conscious, distressing feeling. He situates it within contemporary technoculture, including digital surveillance, media entertainment, virtual reality, and the pandemic. He contends that it is no longer a return of the repressed but an overwhelming, many-faced anxiety arising within information overload and compulsive consumption. Death anxiety is presented as the basis of all anxieties, which the author suggests can be softened by media images of virtual death. Drawing on Richard Lazarus’s stress appraisal theory and later work by Susan Folkman, the article distinguishes problem-focused, emotion-focused, meaning-focused, and future-oriented coping and notes their limits. It concludes that growth may follow extreme stress, that a sense of coherence may induce relational compassion, and that anticipating humankind’s challenges requires large-group negotiation and planning for future generations.

How to Cite This: Ihanus, J. (2021). Virtual anxiety. Clio’s Psyche, 28(1), 51-56.
https://doi.org/10.70763/b5b03f06271f8917685d14cea7c6c50a

Coping In Our Anxious World: Implementing Mentalization to Address Racism (article)

Keywords:

American culture, anxiety, collective anxiety, coping, healing, mental health, mentalization, pandemic, patience, polarization, progress, projective identification, psychohistory, racism

Abstract:

Writing in 2021, the author describes a climate of extreme anxiety and polarization that she argues is damaging collective mental health, and she considers how mentalization can help people communicate across opposing viewpoints. She defines mentalization as the capacity to recognize and understand one’s own thoughts and feelings as well as those of others, usually learned in childhood, and presents it as a more profound cousin of empathy. Turning to racism in America, she proposes that racism, including microaggressions, is sustained by projective identification: hatred, fear, and envy are expelled onto a group deemed an acceptable vessel, while the perpetrator remains aligned with the dominant group. She cites a July 2020 statement on racism by the American Psychoanalytic Association as context for psychoanalytic attention to trauma and for practitioners’ role in opening difficult conversations. Mentalization, she maintains, allows people to hold their own view and an opposing one in mind at once without necessarily agreeing. She argues that it can therefore help victims and even perpetrators take back racist projections and dismantle racist beliefs. She concludes that this repair is incremental, and that aiming for progress rather than perfection helps keep anxiety manageable.

How to Cite This: Messina, K. E. (2021). Coping in our anxious world: Implementing mentalization to address racism. Clio’s Psyche, 28(1), 56-60.
https://doi.org/10.70763/dba31bb5c75992690f20c2d3b370ec7c

Our Anxieties (article)

Keywords:

anxietatem, anxiety, child abuse, hunger, Jews, Longin Pastushek, medical care, Poland, political uncertainty, psychohistory, technology, weaponry

Abstract:

This article argues that little can be done to alleviate anxiety in U.S. society unless its many sources are brought into view, and it aims to begin a conversation about them. The author proposes that these sources are partly of American making and partly brought to the United States. He first considers Europe east of the Elbe River, where, citing a Polish historian and politician, he locates the most anxious populations, shaped by centuries of invasion, occupation, and unfree peasantry. For Jews in this region he adds a further layer of anxiety: religious blame, persecution, ghettoization, and ultimately the concentration camps. He suggests that survivors carried this inheritance to the United States. The article then turns to American sources of anxiety: abusive childrearing, for which it recommends prohibiting corporal punishment in all states; neighborhood danger and poverty; hunger; a profit-oriented health care system, including the response to COVID-19; fear of others, expressed in gun ownership and military spending; fear of falling behind amid competition and job insecurity; political infighting; and technology. The author contends that recent policymakers have done little to reduce these fears, and that some have encouraged them to consolidate power. He closes by asking what society can do.

How to Cite This: Petschauer, P. W. (2021). Our anxieties. Clio’s Psyche, 28(1), 61-65.
https://doi.org/10.70763/c68c9c8258ea7d85472dd6fd0015f047

Our Anxiety Can be Reduced by Addressing the World’s Problems (article)

Keywords:

anxiety, Armenians, Azerbaijan, climate change, Donald Trump, election, environmental deterioration, helplessness, nuclear war, politics, psychohistory, Silent Spring, Turkey

Abstract:

In this article, the author, writing from personal experience, argues that anxiety should be considered in terms of major societal issues as well as intrapsychic causes, naming climate change, nuclear accidents, and deliberate nuclear war. She recalls school air-attack drills in childhood, dates her environmental concern to the 1950s construction of the Interstate Highway System and to Rachel Carson’s Silent Spring (1962), and reports hearing anxiety and helplessness from nearly everyone with whom she raises the subject. She states that concern about a threat to U.S. democracy from Trump and about racism now stands alongside this earlier priority. She then turns to Armenia after the 2020 war in which Azerbaijan, backed by Turkey, took Armenian-held lands. She reports that Armenians are frightened, sad, and angry, and that Turkey has not disavowed the Ottoman Empire’s policy toward Armenians, which she characterizes as genocidal. She concludes that Armenians need to evaluate threats and respond productively, and that people with psychological knowledge could help them manage emotional dysregulation and distinguish projection from real danger amid political and media manipulation.

How to Cite This: Steiner, P. (2021). Our anxiety can be reduced by addressing the world’s problems. Clio’s Psyche, 28(1), 65-66.
https://doi.org/10.70763/b31df16a88ce00fed951f24b46e08649

Music as a Powerful Reducer of Anxiety (article)

Keywords:

coping, COVID-19 pandemic, healing music, herd immunity, mental life, primal anxiety, psychoanalysis, psychoanalysis, psychohistory, psychology, YouTube, Zoom

Abstract:

In this article from the “Coping in Our Anxious World” section, Julie Jaffee Nagel offers a psychoanalytic and interdisciplinary perspective on the relevance of music in mental life, drawing on her experience as a classically trained musician, psychologist, and psychoanalyst. Writing during the COVID-19 pandemic, which she describes as having intensified primal anxieties, she asks what resonates in the mind when words have limited value. She proposes that music is integral to the emotional healing of psychohistorical pain and current trauma, and that the formal qualities of Western music (pitch, rhythm, dynamics, tempo) allow elevating and disquieting feelings to be experienced simultaneously. Citing Erikson, Anzieu, Feder, and Langer, she links music to the earliest sound exchanges between mother and infant and to the idea of music as a reflection of emotional life. As in her book Melodies of the Mind (2013), she suggests that music travels an aural “royal road” to the unconscious parallel to Freud’s route through dreams. She argues that childhood coping strategies, intellect, and reason are often inadequate against unconscious feelings reawakened by stress and loss. Brief clinical and personal vignettes illustrate music’s effects. She concludes by recommending that music of all genres be used in treatment and in social and educational programs to address lasting pandemic-related emotional suffering.

How to Cite This: Nagel, J. J. (2021). Music as a powerful reducer of anxiety. Clio’s Psyche, 28(1), 66-70.
https://doi.org/10.70763/17eb7ecc4c38e4705361cccd903ad8c6

THE PSYCHOLOGY OF TEACHING: PART II

Psychoanalytic and Psychohistorical Pedagogy (article)

Keywords:

COVID-19 pandemic, educator, empathy, identity, psychoanalysis, psychoanalytic pedagogy, psychohistory, psychology student, teaching, therapeutic approaches, trauma, virtual classroom

Abstract:

In this introduction to Part II of the special issue on the psychology of teaching in Clio’s Psyche, Judith Harris argues that psychoanalytic insight illuminates teaching and learning. She maintains that transference and countertransference operate in the classroom as in psychotherapy, and that both enterprises use talk to bring conscious and unconscious desire into view. Whereas Part I emphasized practice, Part II turns to the theoretical underpinnings of psychologically informed teaching. Harris introduces contributions that compare education and psychoanalysis, consider therapeutic imagination in clinical training, treat literary study as a means of identity development and social justice, describe a teaching approach built on introspective student projects, and trace the history of psychoanalytic pedagogy. She also describes her own article on three scholars of psychoanalytically informed pedagogy. Harris suggests that these pieces converge on empathy, compassion, and supportive classroom containment, especially when discussion surfaces trauma, resistance, and painful conflict. She contends that such pedagogy treats learning as self-development and agency rather than the accumulation of facts. She observes that psychoanalytic pedagogy has met resistance in academic settings and that the educational literature says little about what psychoanalysts themselves say about teaching. She concludes that these qualities matter all the more in a period of collective grief.

How to Cite This: Harris, J. (2021). Psychoanalytic and psychohistorical pedagogy. Clio’s Psyche, 28(1), 70-75.
https://doi.org/10.70763/e924517087669cf201ea91bd737a4ff4

Psychoanalysis and Education: A Developmental Proposal (article)

Keywords:

childhood, developmental growth, educator, gender, human psychological growth, Sigmund Freud, stereotypes, teaching, psychoanalysis, psychohistory, psychology, stereotypes

Abstract:

This article examines how education and psychoanalysis affect society and the individual. The author argues that education carries out the will of society, transmitting and maintaining the status quo, while psychoanalysis seeks to free the individual to develop fully and sometimes disrupts the way things stand. Drawing on Freud, Siegfried Bernfeld’s Sisyphus, or the Limits of Education, and Bruno Bettelheim, he maintains that the two disciplines share an interest in children’s optimal development and, ultimately, a more humane society. He contends that their methods diverge because schools organize learning by age gradation, whereas psychoanalysis attends to a child’s achieved level of ego development. Using differences between boys’ and girls’ motor development as an illustration, he argues that age-based curricula produce frustration, stigma, and overrepresentation of boys in special education classes. He suggests that the misreading of psychoanalysis as permissive has aroused unconscious anxieties about loss of control and a reaction formation favoring quick behavioral fixes. Each discipline has virtues and shortcomings, and simplistic stereotypes have dismissively maligned both. The author proposes reorganizing education around developmental progression, citing Montessori schools, the Khan Academy, and therapeutic teaching as precedents.

How to Cite This: Seitler, B. N. (2021). Psychoanalysis and education: A developmental proposal. Clio’s Psyche, 28(1), 75-80.
https://doi.org/10.70763/340a39045c40d50dda207bcfdece883a

Psychoanalytic Pedagogy in the Works of Bracher, Berman, and Alcorn (article)

Keywords:

creative writing, empathy, identity formation, intrapsychic processes, Jeff Berman, Mark Bracher, Marshall Alcorn, psychoanalysis, psychoanalytic pedagogy, psychoanalytic writing, psychohistory, psychology, self-disclosure, unconscious

Abstract:

This article examines how Mark Bracher, Jeff Berman, and Marshall Alcorn bring psychoanalytic understanding to pedagogy in the college writing classroom. The author sets their work against post-structuralist and cultural-critical doubts about psychoanalytic interpretation. Although none of the three identifies as a psychohistorian, she argues that each links social behavior and individual consciousness to the intrapsychic processes that inform learning, an approach she considers especially useful with resistant learners. She presents Bracher as bringing history into the present moment so that social and cultural change becomes possible. She also presents him as turning to social psychology and a literature-based pedagogy that supports students’ identity formation. In Berman’s work, she emphasizes empathy as a safeguard for self-disclosing writing, the teacher’s attention to transference and countertransference, and writing pedagogy as a route to personal transformation. For Alcorn, she discusses resistance understood as a desire not to know, and the labor of mourning that change in students’ ideological assumptions may require. She concludes that, although not self-consciously psychohistorical, these approaches offer a framework for education that extends beyond the classroom to learning about life itself.

How to Cite This: Harris, J. (2021). Psychoanalytic pedagogy in the works of Bracher, Berman, and Alcorn. Clio’s Psyche, 28(1), 80-85.
https://doi.org/10.70763/dfb84a11f431c62436cfb760e30a34fe

Teaching Therapeutic Imagination: A Neglected Competency in Psychology (article)

Keywords:

art, competency, creativity, imagination, John Dewey, John Kaag, poetry, psychoanalysis, psychohistory, psychology, Rank, Sigmund Freud, teaching, The Therapeutic Imagination, Theo Dorpat

Abstract:

This article argues that the imagination is a neglected but vital component of psychology education and clinical training. Drawing on the philosophers John Kaag and John Dewey, the author contends that attending to the nature of imagination can help integrate the humanities and human sciences with the natural sciences in psychology curricula. Turning to psychoanalytic writers including Theo Dorpat, Lawrence Josephs, Stephen Seligman, and Farhad Dalal, he maintains that institutionalized training attitudes, prescriptive pedagogical rules, and manualized, algorithmic, managerial approaches function as defenses against uncertainty. In his account, these defenses close down analytic space and eclipse imaginative work. He presents Otto Rank’s criticism of Freud’s pedagogy as an earlier instance of this problem. Following Jeremy Holmes’s concept of the therapeutic imagination, the author proposes adding a therapeutic imagination competency to current professional competencies. Its components include reverie, language as metaphor and symbolism, action meaning, play, and reflection. He suggests practical training approaches: poems, literary narratives, and films as models for listening and mentalizing, participation in the arts and crafts, and expressive methods drawn from play therapy. He concludes that this emphasis counters binary thinking and keeps spontaneity, contingency, and creativity central to clinical understanding.

How to Cite This: Barbre, C. (2021). Teaching therapeutic imagination: A neglected competency in psychology. Clio’s Psyche, 28(1), 85-90.
https://doi.org/10.70763/f6c9dc70ecfd8f90ba8598aa2401cd1a

A Psychoanalytic Literary Pedagogy: Practices for Identity Development (article)

Keywords:

compassion, education, identity development, literary study, mental health, psychoanalysis, psychoanalytic literary pedagogy, psychohistory, sense of self, self-examination

Abstract:

In this article, the author argues that a basic function of education, like the fundamental task of psychoanalysis, is to promote more secure, multifaceted, resilient, and prosocial identities. He maintains that insecure, rigid, or narrow identities contribute to learning difficulties, anxiety, and harmful behavior among students, and to broader social problems such as prejudice, ethnocentrism, and violence, citing empirical research on identity threat. He proposes that literary study can foster identity development through self-examination processes parallel to those of psychoanalysis, helping students encounter, own, and take responsibility for aspects of themselves, including love and aggression, that were not previously part of their operational identity. Drawing on his own teaching, he describes moving from journal writing about students’ personal histories, aligned with the Lacanian aim of putting desire into language, to an approach that begins with literary characters and human nature before students turn to themselves. He contends that this indirect approach, though less intense than psychoanalysis, reduces identity threat. He suggests that literature can offer recognition, support prosocial identity contents, reveal the consequences of identities, and strengthen identity structure through inclusive identities, integrative self-schemas, and narrative identities.

How to Cite This: Bracher, M. (2021). A psychoanalytic literary pedagogy: Practices for identity development. Clio’s Psyche, 28(1), 91-96.
https://doi.org/10.70763/6271faadeedd7626d661856b7a004e27

Learning and Helping People Learn (article)

Keywords:

education, learning, liberal arts, listening, mental blocks, pedagogy, psychohistory, psychology, teaching psychohistory

Abstract:

In this article, the author reflects on his experience teaching at the college and postgraduate levels, proposing that education depends on teachers structuring an environment in which students, who are the ones who do the learning, can work through emotional blocks to particular subjects. He describes the classroom, virtual or physical, as a safe place for speaking freely, and presents himself as a role model of open-minded, nondefensive learning. Drawing on his psychoanalytic training, he maintains that psychoanalytic principles underpin his interdisciplinary teaching, which combines history and psychoanalysis with other fields. He follows emotion, treats student resistance as something to understand rather than suppress, and uses transference and countertransference, including caution toward student idealization, to interpret classroom dynamics. He outlines what he understands by psychohistory and describes the Institute of Psychohistory and Psychohistory Forum seminars, in which historians and clinicians critique one another’s work-in-progress papers. He also considers analysts and analysands as learners. Discussing students’ political idealization, he suggests, following Marshall Alcorn, that people must mourn one ideological position before assuming another. He concludes that he is a participant observer in learning and that everyone is both learner and teacher.

How to Cite This: Elovitz, P. H. (2021). Learning and helping people learn. Clio’s Psyche, 28(1), 96-100.
https://doi.org/10.70763/465636eb4a7ff4b267f3b765d07a02da

Education and Learning: Strangers to Psychoanalysis? A Historical Overview (article)

Keywords:

Anna Freud, applied psychoanalysis, authoritarian personality, educational reform, interdisciplinary, learning theory, psychoanalysis, psychoanalytic pedagogy, psychoanalytic training, psychohistory, Siegfried Bernfeld, Sigmund Freud, supervision, World War II (WWII)

Abstract:

This article offers a historical overview of psychoanalytic pedagogy and its applications to children’s homes, formal education, and psychoanalytic training in Europe before World War II. It describes how psychoanalytic training became organized only in the 1920s, when Max Eitingon and others established the tripartite model of seminars, training analysis, and supervised practical work. The author argues that psychoanalysis and academic developmental and educational psychology shared little common ground. Psychoanalysis held to its own cornerstones, such as the dynamic unconscious, infantile sexuality, transference, and resistance, while academic psychology relied on a “learning” paradigm that most psychoanalysts found strange. Psychoanalytic pedagogy concentrated on the upbringing of children and on school difficulties linked to unconscious processes, and it rarely addressed adult learning. The article discusses Siegfried Bernfeld’s Baumgarten Children’s Home in Vienna and Vera Schmidt’s Moscow Children’s Home-Laboratory as short-lived applications, and it contrasts Bernfeld’s “pessimistic pedagogy” with Anna Freud’s more optimistic view. The author concludes that psychoanalytic insights now add to interdisciplinary and transformative learning processes. The author proposes that psychoanalytic training move toward creative, dialogical, and self-reflective learning, and asks whether transformative learning remains strange to psychoanalysis.

How to Cite This: Ihanus, J. (2021). Education and learning: Strangers to psychoanalysis? A historical overview. Clio’s Psyche, 28(1), 101-106.
https://doi.org/10.70763/17d8da815fa21c57af9829fb0a869602

Danielle Knafo: The Psychology of Creativity and Perversion (interview)

Keywords:

art, creativity, Danielle Knafo, mental health, perversion, psychoanalytic institutes, psychohistory, psychology, psychosis, technology, trauma, unconscious fantasies

Abstract:

This interview with Danielle Knafo, a psychoanalyst and professor of clinical psychology at Long Island University’s Post Campus, is conducted by Paul H. Elovitz and Peter W. Petschauer. It covers her early life in French Morocco, Israel, and the United States, and her work on creativity and art, including studies of Egon Schiele and women artists. She defines psychohistory as the use of psychological and psychoanalytic theory to understand historical events and individual lives. She says her multicultural background sensitized her to competing historical narratives and to the erasure of Sephardic Jewish history. She describes The Age of Perversion: Desire and Technology in Psychoanalysis and Culture, co-written with Rocco Lo Bosco, which argues that perversion and technology both arise from dissatisfaction and the wish to transcend limits. She also describes her current project on the psychoanalytic treatment of psychosis, which she understands as a creative response to unbearable circumstances. She emphasizes childhood, three-generation family history, intergenerational trauma, and parental loss in Schiele’s life. She characterizes fundamentalism as a reaction to insecurity resembling Melanie Klein’s paranoid-schizoid position, links violence to dehumanization, and applies Freud’s two theories of anxiety to terrorism. She maintains that psychohistory’s future depends on politics, with authoritarianism narrowing historical narratives. She recommends reading biographies, collecting family oral histories, and using social media to recruit newcomers. She names her mentors and five major contributors to psychohistory: Freud, Robert J. Lifton, Erik Erikson, Vamık Volkan, and Philip Cushman.

How to Cite This: Elovitz, P. H., & Petschauer, P. W. (2021). Danielle Knafo: The psychology of creativity and perversion [Interview]. Clio’s Psyche, 28(1), 106-117.
https://doi.org/10.70763/6d19c113404cee55b4036fce1a37c058

Our Virtual Psychohistory Forum Meeting on Paranoid Politics (article)

Keywords:

American politics, Donald Trump, Ken Fuchsman, Joe McCarthy, paranoid culture, The Paranoid Style in American Politics and Other Essays, psychohistory, Psychohistory Forum, Richard Hofstadter, Sigmund Freud

Abstract:

This article reports on a virtual Psychohistory Forum meeting held May 1 on paranoid politics, at which Ken Fuchsman presented and Inna Rozentsvit moderated. The author recalls Richard Hofstadter’s concept of the paranoid style in American politics, developed in a 1964 essay in Harper’s Magazine and in The Paranoid Style in American Politics and Other Essays in response to Senator Joseph McCarthy’s anti-communism, and notes that Hofstadter and Fuchsman use the term politically rather than clinically. The report relays Fuchsman’s comparison of early-2021 Google hit counts for the paranoid style, Freud, and psychohistory. It also cites a February 2021 poll in The Hill in which 67 percent of Republicans said the 2020 election was invalid, which the author takes as a sign of declining belief in trust and truth. The author commends the presenter and moderator and describes the 31 participants’ national and occupational backgrounds, with therapists the largest group and at least four historians. The author maintains that virtual meetings widen participation but forgo informal contact, and notes a technical delay. Discussion points included the radical right’s possible rejection of democracy, Senator Chris Murphy’s statement that most House Republicans treat a Democratic election victory as illegitimate, a psychoanalyst’s emphasis on lost safety and trust, and an Ohio professor’s observation that conspiracy theories also occur on the left.

How to Cite This: Elovitz, P. H. (2021). Our virtual Psychohistory Forum meeting on paranoid politics. Clio’s Psyche, 28(1), 117-118.
https://doi.org/10.70763/a4666cd9e1ab0e4abf05a0fb232f4ad3

BOOK REVIEWS

The Armenian Genocide: Can Conciliation Replace Denial? (book review)

Keywords:

Armenian genocide, Azerbaijan, book review, Collective Trauma and the Armenian Genocide: Armenian, Turkish, and Azerbaijani Relations Since 1839, conciliation, genocide denial, intergenerational trauma, Pamela Steiner, Turkey

Abstract:

This book review considers Pamela Steiner’s Collective Trauma and the Armenian Genocide: Armenian, Turkish, and Azerbaijani Relations Since 1839 (2021), a psychohistorical study by a mediator and clinical psychologist who is U.S. Ambassador Henry Morgenthau’s great-granddaughter. The reviewer reports that its 18 chapters cover individual and collective trauma, with examples from Rwanda, Hungary, Israel/Palestine, and Indonesia; Ottoman history over two centuries, including a psychobiographical chapter on five Young Turk leaders and the genocide beginning April 24, 1915; Azeri–Armenian relations in the Transcaucasus after 1900; and meaning-making, with a proposed way forward over Nagorno-Karabakh. He judges the book even-handed and multidisciplinary, notes a bibliography of over 300 sources, and is admiring of its approach. Drawing on his own family’s history, he raises four issues for reconciliation: whether speaking of ghosts of 1915 respects ancestors’ memory; the distinction between the Turkish people and their government, including Turks who protected Armenians; DNA testing through which some Turks discover Armenian ancestry; and forgiveness, which he contends becomes possible as denial declines among Turkish citizens, though he says the Turkish government still denies the genocide. Citing the 2020 Azerbaijani military operation in Nagorno-Karabakh and President Biden’s April 2021 use of the word genocide, he says the stakes are higher and recommends the book to those involved in the region.

How to Cite This: Takooshian, H. (2021). The Armenian genocide: Can conciliation replace denial [Review of the book Collective Trauma and the Armenian Genocide: Armenian, Turkish, and Azerbaijani Relations Since 1839 by Pamela Steiner (2021)]? Clio’s Psyche, 28(1), 121-125.
https://doi.org/10.70763/ac34ae1fda29b8fe781ac8d6d32a6bc7

MEMORIALS

Remembering Richard L. Rubenstein (memorial)

Keywords:

After Auschwitz, International Psychohistorical Association (IPhA), memorial, psychoanalysis, psychodynamic interpretation, psychohistory, psychology, Richard L. Rubenstein

Abstract:

This memorial tribute marks the death on May 16, 2021, at age 97, of Richard L. Rubenstein (1924-2021), rabbi, university professor, theologian, philosopher, and president of the University of Bridgeport. The author notes that Rubenstein did not identify himself as a psychohistorian, attended the International Psychohistorical Association conference once, in 1978, and may not have been claimed by the field. The author recounts being his student at the University of Pittsburgh from 1963 to 1967, where Rubenstein directed the Hillel and served as guest rabbi, and recalls a lecture on Hegel’s Phenomenology of Spirit. The author describes After Auschwitz (1966) as addressing Jewish life, divine election, and theodicy, and lists later books, including The Cunning of History, The Age of Triage, and Jihad and Genocide. The author contends that Rubenstein used psychoanalytic perspectives throughout his writing and that, as an implicit psychohistorian, he deserves to be read widely as psychohistory.

How to Cite This: Stein, H. F. (2021). Remembering Richard L. Rubenstein [Memorial]. Clio’s Psyche, 28(1), 126-127.
https://doi.org/10.70763/56c82ccd658e09e829f16bb99457bcbc

BULLETIN BOARD

CONFERENCES: The Psychohistory Forum Work-In-Progress Seminar’s virtual meeting on May 1, 2021, featured Ken Fuchsman (University of Connecticut and past International Psychohistorical Association [IPA] president) on “The Paranoid Tradition in American History and Politics.” Inna Rozentsvit handled the technical aspects of the meeting. “Accomplishments and the Next Assignments of Psychohistory: The Impact of COVID-19 and the Need for Research on Childrearing, Psychobiography, and the Breakdown of Trust” is the tentative title of the seminar being scheduled for September online. Jim Anderson is now confident that he can present in person his pandemic delayed talk, “Heinz Kohut’s Vulnerable Self,” in the early spring. Additional meetings will be scheduled when proposal papers are received and a committee has reviewed them.

The International Psychohistorical Association’s 44th Annual conference held virtually on May 19-21, 2021, included presentations by our members, Peter Loewenberg (keynote speaker), Theresa Aiello, Marc-André Cotton, Paul H. Elovitz, Ken Fuchsman, Hannah Hahn, Susan Kavaler-Adler, Doris Leicher, Ruth Lijtmaer, Karyne E. Messina, Denis O’Keefe, Peter W. Petschauer, Ken Rasmussen, Howard F. Stein, and Duke Wagner. The International Society for Political Psychology’s (ISPP) virtual meeting will be on July 11-13, 2021; and the Interdisciplinary Conference of the Forum for Psychoanalytic Education (IFPE) conference will be held in Fall 2021.

APPRECIATION: We wish to thank Judith Harris for several years of service as Associate Editor of Clio’s Psyche as she now turns her attention to writing The Poetry of Loss: Romantic and Contemporary Elegies for Routledge.

CONGRATULATIONS: To David R. Beisel and Irene Javors on the publication of Genres of the Imagination (2021); Tomasz Pawelec on History and the Unconscious: The Theoretical Assumptions and Research Practices of Psychohistory (this 2004 book is now translated into English from Polish); Paul Salstrom on his upcoming book Appalachia’s Alternative to Mainstream America: A Personal Education (University of Tennessee Press, December 2021 release); Vamık D. Volkan on the publication of Sexual Addiction: Psychoanalytic

Page 127

Concepts and the Art of Supervision; and Bob Samuels on the publication of Generation X and the Rise of the Entertainment Subject, part of the Generation X: Studies in Culture, Demographics, and Media Representation series (2021). Congratulations to the staff of the IPA who have upgraded their online newsletter into a valuable psychohistorical source, which may be found at: https://www.psychohistory.us/archive.php.

DEATHS: Our condolences to Margery Quackenbush on the death of her husband Robert: artist, children’s book author, psychoanalyst, and past member of the Psychohistory Forum who died at age 91 of leukemia.

WORK IN PROGRESS: To Larry Friedman on the near completion of A World Without Nations: Pragmatic Visionaries and the Quest for Global Peace that he has worked on for many years.

WELCOME NEW MEMBERS: Karyne E. Messina, Bob Samuels, Pamela Steiner, and Benjamin Wegner.

THANKS: To Benefactors Fred C. Alford, Peter Barglow, Herbert Barry, David Beisel, Eva Fogelman, Peter Loewenberg, David Lotto, Jamshid Marvasti, Candace Orcutt, Peter W. Petschauer, Billie Pivnick, and Jacques Szaluta; Patrons Theresa Aiello, Ken Fuchsman, and Joyce Rosenberg; Sustaining Members Arnold Richards and Talia Shafir; and Supporting Members James W. Anderson, Sue Erikson Bloland, Barbara Bloom, James R. Booth, Michael Britton, Marilyn Charles, Lawrence J. Friedman, Karyne E. Messina, Susan Nimmanheminda, Joseph G. Ponterotto, and Jack Schwartz. Our special thanks for thought-provoking materials to Kenneth Alan Adams, Tom Artin, Claude Barbre, Gerhard Bliersbach, Matthew H. Bowker, Mark Bracher, Howard H. Covitz, Paul H. Elovitz, Ken Fuchsman, Judith Harris, Juhani Ihanus, Irene Javors, Karyne E. Messina, Julie Jaffee Nagel, Peter W. Petschauer, Martin Quitt, Burton Norman Seitler, Olga Shutova, Howard F. Stein, Pamela Steiner, and Harold Takooshian. To Nicole D’Andria for editing, proofing, and Publisher 2016 software application and Professor Paul Salstrom for proofing. Our special thanks to our authors, editors, and numerous overworked referees who must remain anonymous.

Page 128

Call for Papers

Clio’s Psyche Call for Papers on

Personal Space in our Modern & Virtual World

The Winter 2022 Special Issue (Papers due 10/01/2022)

Some possible psychological/psychoanalytic approaches include:

  • Case studies of severe anxiety and depression brought on or intensified by social distancing and fear of the pandemic
  • Familial spatial rearrangements during the pandemic and the impact on relationships
  • The invasion of women’s space including by bosses and politicians
  • Online space and its meaning to the young who can be bullied on it
  • Personal vs. public space: What are the safe spaces of your life?
  • Cultural comparisons of the use of space and their implications
  • The space of our homes, imposing exterior-mansions
  • How the space we create in our homes reflects our psychic reality
  • Space for public display or personal enjoyment
  • Owning, controlling space as an expression of one’s power
  • The sacred space of the nation state worth fighting and dying for
  • The invasion of workspace into the home sanctuary
  • Royal space and the space of the rich and powerful vs. others
  • Space for quiet and reflection in a noisy, intrusive world
  • Religious spaces, including comparisons of religious usage of space
  • Conflicts over holy space, case studies, such as in Jerusalem
  • Imagined space: heaven, hell, utopias, and dystopias
  • The medical invasion of the body: X-rays, MRI, mammograms
  • Digital business, government, and personal computer space, invaded by hackers
  • Fantasies & realities of outer space, space in the wild, etc.
  • Technology and space
  • Reviews of relevant books, broadcasts, games, movies, music, or plays

We seek articles from 1,000-2,000 words—including a 25-word abstract, 7-10 keywords, and your brief biography ending in your e-mail address—by 10/01/2021. One or two 3,000-3,500 word symposium submissions must be submitted by 08/15/21. Send articles as attached Microsoft Word documents (*.docx) or rich text format (*.rtf) files to .

Page 129